Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

New episode: Dasyurology (TASMANIAN DEVILS) is up! And tomorrow, I hop on an interview about.... carob? 

What even is carob and why do we eat it instead of chocolate and what's up with shrubs vs. trees vs. bushes? If you have ever in your life had a question about carob, well: good news. We know a Carobologist. 

Bring it on, below. 

Comments

Megan Lynch

Yes. In fact, it's this association with hard times which for years made carob sink in popularity until just the last decade or so. Europe was torn apart by repeated wars during the Modern Era, but the period from WWI - WWII, including the Great Depression and the Spanish Civil War was a time when those who lived in places where carob grew increased their reliance on carob. Just as most people grow tired of eating the same meal and like to switch it up even in regular times, people not only grew tired of eating so much carob, but associated it with the many traumas of this period. An interest in local culture and folk traditions that had grown more distant or rare in the 20th century as well as an interest in exploring more sustainable ways of growing like agroforestry have contributed to a renaissance of interest in carob in its home regions.

GenusByGenus

FTQA! Which is more environmentally sustainable/environmentally preferable to consume— chocolate or carob?

Adam Weaver

What an unexpected ology but I love it. My only experience with carob is in dog treats (That I've definitely tasted shamelessly). What even is it? Is it a bean? A root? A seed?

taylor

FTQA: so like what even is it?? I have no clue at all. Is there a big flavor difference between chocolate and carob? (Now that I’ve learned we eat it)

Meghan McLean

When buying carob, how does one pick out the quality carob from the crap carob? Are there different types, as found in chocolate?

Emily A

Should I eat carob instead of chocolate? Is it healthier? Does it taste like chocolate on its own, opposed to cocoa beans that are processed into chocolate? Basically what is it and why

Ethan Bottone

I only ever heard of carob from an episode of "Hey Arnold!". Do you know about this pop culture reference/are there others?

Scott Sheldon

Is it true that Rome used carob seeds to weigh against gold which is how we got the unit of measure a carat? That’s a factoid that has always been in my head but have zero clue if it’s real

Molly

Is there a cultural/geographical trend regarding where carob is used as a chocolate alternative? Which came first as far as yummy treats go?

RJ Doidge

A friend makes homemade dog treats and uses carob chips in place of chocolate so they like, don't die. What's the difference between the two that makes it doggie safe?

Michelle Dempsey

I've seen articles suggesting chocolate has nifty qualities such as it contains antioxidants, or has blood pressure lowering abilities, and even that it is used as an aphrodisiac. What sorts of nifty qualities does carob have?

Mandii Smith

Does carob taste like chocolate to dogs? Does it taste like chocolate to people? Are their any health benefits to eating it?

Laura Springer

Can I grow my own carob plant and make my own carob?

Maria

I have no specific question as I barely know anything about carob, so please tell me everything!

Moth

Tamara Mann

I've been eating carob on and off since I was 5. I have never found it to taste like chocolate. Sometimes it's a enjoyable but most of the time I don't like it. What am I doing wrong? Also is carob related to chocolate?

Jolliebean

FTQA- does carob have the same orac as chocolate? Also, same as Samantha, what's the sustainability like for carob?

Wells Howe

What the heck even is a Carob and why have I never learned that those dried brown snake bananas hanging in the trees are edible!?

Wendy Lockhart

How does carob differ structurally from chocolate? Does it contain theobromine? And why does it taste gross?

Molly

That’s so interesting! Is Milo carob or chocolate? Growing up (rural American Midwest) the only reason I knew about carob was the local homesteader and Amish population.

Jennasis

What else besides chocolate can it be used for?

Zoltán Szászi

Hi I just wanted to ask what's this business with "St. John's Bread" because that's how we call it in Hungarian too (literally St. John's Bread Tree) and why do we (mostly) know this as a chocolate replacement and animal feed if bread is right there in the (alternate) name?

Hannah Quist

Why are some carob tree cultivars hermaphroditic? I understand that they’re typically dioecious. Does this relate to climate/scarcity/population ecology? (This doesn’t matter but I am a huge plant nerd)

Jennasis

High sugar content always makes my face break out. Does carob cause the same acne issues that chocolate does?

Ruby Johnstone

Are carob allergies common? Also, any thoughts about the Hey Arnold episode where Chocolate Boy is forced to transition his diet to carob?

Jennasis

How old is it?

Monica

How many carob puns do you know off the top of your head?

Morgan Jennison

FTQA -Does the carob industry have less of the ethical issues that standard non-fair trade chocolate has?

Monica

What's your favorite way to actually enjoy carob, as opposed to hating it for not being chocolate?

Nicklas Zemp

This is a solid question!! I vote for this one!

Nicklas Zemp

**I've read that the processing involves using and acid or roasting to remove the skin of the seed. Has the same effect been historically achieved through fermentation?

Michelle Neer

Who first decided "hey let me eat this plant!"?

Michelle Neer

Does it have a complicated process to prepare it to be eaten like chocolate from cacao?

Kale Levin

Who was carob originally intended for? What animal(s) evolved along side carob trees as their seed dispersers?

MissKitti

What are the nutrient takeaways from carob? Also, what plant grouping does carob fit into?

Debra Pekin

I know carob as a substitute for chocolate and always thought, um .. nooo, and why even? But I do have a real question- what is the best use if carob as itself? I don’t need a substitute fir chocolate- but I am very interested in learning about ingredients that have good nutritional purpose and in trying new foods.

Buhbrie

FTQA What evidence is there of ancient cultures using carob? What did they use it for? Any medicinal uses? Oldest found evidence of carob use for anything?

Catalina Ibarburu

**As well as chocolate, carob takes a lot of processing for it to have a nice flavor. How did people realize that they should do all that stuff to beans and if it was a coincidence does that mean that there may be something incredibly delicious in nature that we havent found out about cause we didnt process it in a determined way?? Like what if PINECONES soaked for 21 days and roasted over deer skin during a half moon is super delicious and we dont know it cause we havent tried the method yet

Mara Rosenbloom

Why can I not find carob bars like I can find chocolate bars? It seems like ever since the “good news” about dark chocolate, carob is much harder to find!

Shanna Mandell

Why does no one in my family but my dad (RIP) and his siblings like carob?

Skeletor the Crested Gecko

Carob does not replace chocolate and health foods are a lie. Okay, strong feeling aside, I think carob had a very interesting fruity-ish taste and once had an amazing carob brownie recipe that paired carob with raisins and cream cheese. What other flavors does carob pair well with?

bailey sperling

do you ever get confused for being a carboologist and if so what would that be the study of

Rayden Marcum

There's a Jewish folk tale about an old man being scorned for planting a carob tree because they supposedly take 70 years to fruit and he won't be around to enjoy it by then (because he's already old). Is there any truth to that, or does it just make a good story? When/where was the first recorded use of carob as food? ps the story ends with the man saying it's to be his legacy for his grand/children

Rayden Marcum

How do you tell if a carob pod is good to eat or full of bugs?

Justin Darr

Why do humans find beans/bean pastes/bean juices so appealing?

Corrie Navis

Have humans been eating carob for as long as cocoa, or is it something a bunch of hippies scrounged up in the 60s?

Arica Starlinger

So I’ve googled FTQA and just keep getting answers for what FTA means... what’s does FTQA mean? Am I that old I can’t find an answer on google??

Arica Starlinger

What’s their favorite thing to eat carob in?

Alan Kerr

I first discovered carob in health food stores in the 1970’s along with whole wheat pasta. Fifty years later, whole wheat pasta, when cooked, has the taste and texture of cooked pasta, not hot soggy cardboard like the 70’s health food product. Fifty years later, why does carob still not taste like chocolate and still not taste good, even when not compared to chocolate? 1970’s health food stores were a result of Hippies needing to make a living. I have always blamed carob on the Hippies since, back in the day, carob didn’t seem to exist outside of their stores. When the Last Hippie dies, will society finally be free of the scourge of carob?

Patrick Shaw

This. Chocolate milk is hyped as a recovery drink (I totally buy the hype). Are there similar benefits to carob?

SUTTON TAGGART

Where is from? I'm guessing it didn't start out being "replacement" for chocolate. Is it a fruit? Does it need bees and such? Can I plant one in my back yard? (Austin, TX)

Kathryn Jordan

Can I grow carob in my backyard (Saint Paul, MN)? How would someone harvest and prepare carob? What’s your favorite way to prepare carob?

Charlotte Fjelkegård

THIS! I've always been fascinated by the art of "ancient" food processing. When 19 people have died from eating X, what motivates you to try yet another way to prepare X and then eat it? (Besides starvation of course.)

Kata Zarándy

Wow, there are some strong feelings about carob... Until now I was just barely aware it existed but now I want to try it. Any tips for a first time carob consumer?

Elizabeth McKeighen

Is carob environmentally friendlier, and lets call it ethically and human rights friendlier, than chocolate? Or anything else?

Monika Blue (they)

FTQA Why do you eat the pod not the bean? (Do you eat the pod not the bean like tamarind???)

Lynn and Dori

FTQA are there any positive health effects from carob? If so, are they outweighed by the negative effects?

Euan Munro

I only had time for a quick google, but according to Wikipedia carob is "the last source of [human] food in hard times". Is there any particular hard time where the carob plant has helped people?

Helen Langille

It means ‘first time question asker’

Mortify

What is it in carob that makes it a chocolate substitute? How does it grow? What are some other uses for it? Does it have any other significance (culturally, practically, etc.) outside of commerce based chocolate-wannabe?

Mortify

I guess I'm asking, "who really IS carob?"

Shannon Sartain

FTQA, if carob was a different color or texture, would we still compare it to chocolate?

Alyssa DeForest

Whose idea was it to use carob as a substitute for chocolate?!?!? Whose idea!!!!

Anya

I think carob is disgusting especially when used as a chocolate substitute. Are there any recipes (maybe in other cultures) where it is used in its own right (and actually tastes nice?)

BolognaShoes

Why... just why? Who was the asshole that first said, "hmmm, yeah, this is just like chocolate! Let's traumatize an entire generation of children who thought the cookies were safe after coming to the conclusion that the dark spots were not in fact raisins"

Maria Jouravleva

(Asking for my partner, who is a FTQA) Do they have to ferment carob beans like they do with chocolate beans? Asking for myself: Are carob plants more or less sustainable in terms of growing operations than cacao plants?

Ava Schaefer

What properties in the plant make it a good chocolate substitute? Also, is it a good option for people on a paleo and keto diet? (Asking for my non Alie dad)

Heather Nannette

Does carob produce endorphins in humans when eaten, like chocolate does?

Kahtya Cherney

How many ways can we consume it? What is the best?

Carolyn Armitage

What is it about carob that makes it safe for AIP and other elimination diets vs chocolate?

Frankie Parker

Why is carob safe for dogs and not chocolate?

Tyler Duggan

What cheese and wine would you pair with carob "chocolate?" Specifically a dessert.

Amy M Goshe

I have brown hair so I use carob powder in my dry shampoo. It smells lovely when I exercise, and it blends in a lot better than using arrowroot powder.

Teagen Andrews

This Does matter, please ask this! Yayy plant nerds!

Sadie Baker

FTQA! Is carob farmed more sustainably than chocolate - also why is it called a carob? and why haven’t I heard of this before??

Natalie Matz

Can one use "cacao" and "cocoa" interchangeably? FTQA.

Hope

Are carob pods edible too? If so, who eats them/how/what are they use in?

Hope

Also a question from my brother: how many families of mammals are there (extinct and extant)

Evie Smith

What part of the carob plant are we eating? And what does the fruit look like? And what kind of plant is it?

Evie Smith

Also, where is it grown? And are there similar kinds of social justice/inequity concerns in the carob value chain as there are in the coffee and cacao value chains?

Courtney Bainbridge

so do the male flowers... really smell like.. semen? also if yes, did you find out the hard way? 🤣

Mardee Goodwin

FTQA was carob ever used as currency like the Aztec used chocolate to trade for goods?

Celia LaBonte

Whats with all the slave labor in chocolate?

Leighanne Gray

Why does carob taste like if I made chocolate while my depression was in full gear?

Biminy Cricket

Why try to substitute chocolate with carob? My mom tried it once and even as a young child, I wasn't buying it! The two do not taste the same. Are there other uses for carob apart from attempting (unsuccessfully) to pass it off as chocolate?