Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Yep. It's a word! Meredith Levine studies why people becomes fans of characters, entertainment, and brands and has a masters in Critical Studies. 

Leave questions for her below!

(And yes I definitely plan to ask where the line between fan and stan is, because we all need to know. )

Your fan,

Ol Pops

Comments

Jessie Dragon

What are some of the most toxic fandoms they’ve seen? What’s your favorite? Are there any specific ones they find fascinating?

Alyssa Marchand

WHY DO TEEN GIRLS HEARTS CRUSH SO HARD ON BOYBANDS. THERE HAS TO BE A SCIence

Reuben Clamzo

What's the origin of toxic Fandom, and what can other fans do about it?

Anna Thompson

Thank you! Stan has become such a part of the vocabulary and I have no clue what it really means!

Hadley

Have you seen the tiktok trend of shifting ?and aside from the physics questions if it’s actually real, what do you think about it?

Elle McCall

Is it healthy to be part of a fandom? I get VERY obsessive about my favorite band and I think it drives people crazy..but like...I could be obsessed with worse things right?

Elle McCall

It comes from an Eminem song and...isn’t great.

Kelly Semon

Please explain what the hickity heck was happening on Tumblr in the 2010s (if you were there you remember but I doubt you could explain or justify it either....)

bailey sperling

pleaaasssseeeee talk about the one direction fandom. thank u.

Celeste Elric

Has there been an effect on the media being produced in order to please the fans due to the react of social media? How do you think this has changed the way fans interact with said media?

Hannah

Sports fanatics vs. comic con nerds. Who is more passionate?

Budd

Why do some fandom’s/fans become so toxic? Why don’t others? And what can we do as fans of people/characters/franchises etc to have a health fandom community?

Jen A.

Is there as equal a compulsion to NOT be a fan of somethings? For as many people who love a sports team, musician or pop culture trend, there are as many that hate it. What's up with that? Plus, why do we all fan over Dad Ward? 💜

L. Wink

Are there certain age groups that are more, for lack of a better term, “susceptible” to joining fandoms? For example: teenage girls going crazy for boy bands.

Vlad Bathory

What do you believe is the reason for the strong emotional bonds people form to not just characters but particular storylines?

RJ Doidge

Has anyone ever done a study on how the subject of the fandom deals with this?

Anna Thompson

Can a toxic fandom come back and become good again?

Elle McCall

Please ask them to address SuperWhoLock. They’re what I immediately think of when I hear the word Fandom.

OJ Carrasco

Why do people always say to me “YOU’RE a wrestling fan?!” Have fandoms always been such specific types?

Schmitty Thompson

What role did women in the early Star Trek fandom have in the development of fan culture as we know it today?

Lee Katherine Ayerhart

Are there known characteristics that media have in common which tend to drive obsessive fandom?

Forrest Stotts

Okay but why are you the bestestest? But seriously, what causes us to feel so connected to a celebrity or personality? Even cartoon fandoms where the creators aren’t well known.

bailey sperling

how do you think the evolution of social media has affected fandom culture? i feel like the underlying principles of the beatles and one direction fandoms are the same, but has existed in different forms because of the internet

Felix Lasselle

FTQA here. Are there any historical records of Fandoms in history? Did Plato have a fans obsessing about his work. Would there have been a Shakespeare-con back in the day?

Maria Jouravleva

Is there anything you've studied in fandoms that have led to better understanding of human psychology and sociology?

Toni Jane

Is fandom just a cult type thing?

Anna Thompson

What are your thoughts on "death of the author" within entertainment? Specifically the "death of an author" of books about a certain boy wizard? Can people still be fans of a work written by bad people?

Jade Tollis

Do you find it ironic that fandoms surrounding modern books, movies, TV shows, and culture are dismissed as frivolous; while a majority of the pop culture from the Renaissance can be categorized as fan art and fan fics featuring biblical characters or the monarchy?

Florence Yuan

Where did the concept of "fandom" as we know it today originate? When I hear "fandom" I think about media and entertainment, but I suppose it started with sports... or did it start with something else? (my last name is pronounced "you-en"!)

bailey sperling

what do you think are the benefits of fandoms? i had a super great experience making friends and having a community, are there studies to back anything like that up?

Heather Densmore

Is fandom a new phenomenon or did Mozart have young girls swooning over him?

Gianna McClain

Do you have an opinion on events like Dashcon or the Homestuck fandom spitting in buckets or cases when fandoms take things too far?

MissKitti

YES! This question because my child is new to HP and loves them and I can't decide what to say about the author.

Noah Sullivan

Can we please talk about what and why My Immortal is the way that it is?

Lynn and Dori

how does the average age of fandoms contribute to how they interact?

Steph

What is it about scifi and fantasy shows/movies that lead them to develop more of a fandom? I've noticed that shows I love (*cough* Supernatural) have massive, active fandoms despite not being as widely watched as crime procedurals, etc.

Anna Thompson

Do people typically connect more with podcasts then other types of media because listening is more intimate?

Sneaky Hamster

Why did I, and probably many others, have a potentially unhealthy obsession with a certain celebrity during high school? Does being a fan of something help us cope with the reality of life?

Erica L Hinders

I’d love to know her thoughts/insight on when the creator of a work does something that makes the fans unwilling to support the creator anymore, but still have strong ties to the fandom. JKR and Harry Potter for example.

Kelly Semon

This is SUCH a good and interesting question! I remember being a fan of Supernatural and knowing characters were killed off literally as fanservice. Meanwhile the Orphan Black team had the most mind blowing social media strategy on Tumblr in my memory. Like the official show was interacting with fans meaningfully as it aired but I never felt like the show was compromised. Such contrast.

Chris Brewer

How far back in history does fandom go?

Saint Kendra

ive seen some fanatics on tumblr that make me wish i were a more passionate person. not a Q, just sort of in awe of people's deep wells of love

Angela Clark

What is it about a bunch of 14 year old girls on Tumblr dot com that creates an echo chamber that makes a conspiracy like Harry Styles being in a secret gay relationship with his band mate something totally believable to one's young brain? Hive mind? Asking for a friend....

McKenna Rinta

Is there a reason why teenagers are the best at fanning? I don’t think I could ever fan as hard as I did when I was a teenager. Just thinking about my level of fangirling over certain things and people that I will not mention here makes me so embarrassed I could die.

Hannah

How does the ologist feel about fan fiction?

Chell

Oh finally a topic I actually studied in school! Psychologically, what's up with the playful aggression fans use when discussing their faves (i.e. "HE'S SO HOT I HATE HIS FACE" etc)? It's a curious kind of familiarity that you see across fandoms where fans discuss the objects of their affection in an exaggeratedly negative way.

Angie King

*FTQA* How does cosplay/roleplay factor in? People seem to dress as characters that they already slightly resemble, I'm wondering if this is just the psychology of representation - being able to see yourself in the character and relating to or being interested in them for those reasons.

Taryn

Why have shipper wars always been so prominent in every fandom? I mean, we even have Stacey Abrams weighing in on the Buffy/Angel vs. Buffy/Spike debate.

Hilary Larson

At what point does Fandom cross the line from simply enjoying something to forging your identity around it, almost like subscribing to a cult? Does it have to do with a sense of community? Think H.P. Lovecraft fans, for example.

Samantha Heinicke

How can a republican be a fan of the StarTrek universe?

Kelly Semon

To quote John Green (who many people have their feelings about but I’m still a fan of his work especially Vlogbrothers) : “Books belong to their readers”

Lee Katherine Ayerhart

I feel like fandom for me tends to coincide with periods of poor mental health or general dissatisfaction with life. What are some things to look out for to tell if it's crossing into unhealthy behavior?

Taryn

I don’t know, there were just so many Misha Collins gifs???

Rena Dez

First time asker! What are her thoughts on fanfiction? When does it cross the line from creative expression to privacy invasion? From, someone who isn’t a reader but has seen some pretty scary things on tik tok. P.S. my best friend and I can’t wait for this episode!

Anne Simonen

What are the social/mental impacts on finding or being part of a fandom? It felt so good when I recently found the fandom of books I have loved since I was a kid (shout out to other Tamora Pierce fans!). Knowing others were profoundly impacted by the books as I was and still loved talking about them was so exciting!

Kelly Semon

I’m sorry we have WHAT?

Bonnie Flint

Who is the greatest female character ever written and why is Dana Scully?

Pandora II

That is my question too

Ashley Scrivner

When does a fandom become a cult? Is it like a square/rectangle thing like all cults are fandom but not all fandom are cults?

Chris Brewer

Is there a certain age range where a person is more inclined to fall into fandom of someone or something?

Samantha Steelman

Can we talk about the trend of re-imagining long beloved characters as minorities? Thinking of the Miles Morales as Spiderman, the push for a black James Bond, Halle Bailey cast as Ariel in The Little Mermaid and Captain Marvel as a woman in the 80s and much much more. Does this influence changes in society's image of a hero or is it reflecting the already current ideal?

Rebekah Landry

The whole series has been ruined for me because of her. I feel like I’ve wasted my life on it.

Jade Tollis

What are your thoughts on the use of fandom iconography in protest art; such as Women’s March posters featuring General Organa (the rebel formally known as Princess Leia).

Lee Katherine Ayerhart

Why is it so hard to draw a line between fandom of a show and its characters, and the actors IRL? Some of it gets very creepy, what is the psychology that gets a person to that point?

Kelly Semon

I would LOVE to hear some thoughts about the Twilight fandom. I feel like that was the first piece of media I totally LOST myself in and had OPINIONS about and then of course it has the wild distinction of its own fan fiction spawning an entire new fandom and apparently it’s making a come back now and I’m just fascinated.

Toni Jane

Two of my fandoms have all but imploded recently, because of comments, posts or lack of acknowledgment and the tv series for another one is about to end (Supernatural). This year sucks for my fandoms. Here’s my question- Should I feel guilty for still being a fan of the band and still a fan of the authors work? Even though their true, horrible, dark colours have come out and don’t align with my beliefs? Or is it just a matter of learning to appreciate the art and not the artist?

Kyle Leonard

How does a fandom keep its members? Is it top-down or self-regulating?

Taryn

RPF (Real Person Fanfic) has always felt very invasive to me! I’m curious about this, too.

Meghan

Are the bonds that celebrities claim to have with their fans real? I know celebrities like Taylor Swift go above and beyond for their fans, even Paul McCartney was inspired by Taylor’s relationship with fans and wrote a song about it! Also, that leads me to wonder about para-social relationships and how those figure into celebrity-fan relationships!

Steph

Does fandom ever have much influence on the story being told, particularly in series?

Davis Born

Please explain Nicolas Cage

Laura M

Fanfiction. There's such a stigma that it's all weird porn written by obsessive fans (some of it is and that's great! Yay erotica!) but some of the best writing and stories I've ever read have been fanfiction works. Can you talk about why we like fanfic? *I've seen people talking about it before and have realized some of this myself, especially this year, that fic can be a good stepping stone for beginner writers since you don't have to develop a while universe and characters to start with. It's also a new story, maybe one that fills in gaps in canon, but with characters and situations you're already familiar and comfortable with. I had a lot of trouble this year committing to new shows and books, but fanfic was easy and safe because I already knew these people and how this universe works. (if it helps I mainly read Supernatural fics, which has the most popular ships on Archive of Our Own, including the one that just became canonical on the show)

Kelly Semon

I just want to ask the group if I was the only person who genuinely Harry and the other 1D guy were in an open and totally UNQUESTIONED gay relationship because everything I knew about the band was 2nd hand info that came across my tumblr dashboard. It was literal years before I found out those dudes weren’t dating. Years. It was just presented to me as fact and I didn’t question it 😂😂

Bethany

What is the etymology of the word fan? Is there any relation to the devices that keep our spaces cool and breezy?

Claudia Dimick

Do you consider Trump supporters part of his fandom? If so, what about the trump administration, and his role as a celebrity prior to taking office, play a role in the level of loyalty, passion, and general behavior of his supporters now? (Also, sorry to go political.)

MissKitti

At what point does fan-fiction become its own thing or remain derivative?

Will Plewa

The law and order SVU main actress said in an interview that ppl would contact her about actual crimes (I think often unreported DV). Are there other occurrences where undertaking a role has proceeded to a real world opportunity to make a positive difference?

Lee Katherine Ayerhart

How has fandom changed with social media and the ability of creators to interact with the fans more directly?

Argonautilus

Why do you think there's still a "cringiness" associated with fandom culture? Why are fans mocked and made to feel immature for obsessing over a boy band or TV show, compared to people who worship sports teams with equal ferocity?

Steph

I remember reading Twist & Shout in high school, and I'll be damned if that wasn't some of the best writing I've read

Samantha Steelman

Let's talk about fans working to flesh out fictional worlds more extensively than the author ever did. For Harry Potter, fans took bits and snips of lines from the books and used that to really organize what cultures and rules of magic look like in the Wizarding World. It's seems to be fandom rules that have become almost universally agreed upon.

Toni Jane

As Halsey sung on the track “929” - “Don’t meet your heroes, they’re all fucking weirdos”

Malorie Albee

Why do people OUTSIDE of fandoms so often disparage people INSIDE of fandoms, as if they are superior for having avoided being swept up in the craze?

Laura M

I cried forever reading Twist and Shout

Alia Myers

Why do people feel like they "understand" celebrities on an intimate, personal level? I get the connection to fictional characters bc they can be idealistic and are just fantasies, or even youtubers and podcasters (hi dadward) who you have pseudo-social relationships with, but celebrities are real people with whom you have no interactions or connection????

Lexi Reitz

Why am I in love with Jamie Fraser from outlander? More importantly, why do some obsessions with celebrities turn dangerous when someone is so attached to someone they don't know. For example stalking said person or physically harming someone that talks smack on said person.

Kelly Semon

Okay I’m sorry because I’m getting out of hand with my questions but I have so many thoughts and feelings anyway: I’d love to here the ologist’s thoughts on how social media and new media had shifted the nature of fandom. Some of my most passionate fan communities in my early teens were around Youtubers. This was of course followed by devastation when a bunch of the youtubers I really liked were all implicated in one of the first YouTuber sexual harassment scandals. (The mike Lombardo arrest and resulting dominos). It completely shook me and I’ve seen it repeat. So yeah, How has the potential to connect meaningfully and personally with idols impacted modern fandom?

Molly

Is there any research on the influence fandoms have on the media they appreciate? I feel like it’s more of a mutual relationship than we think.

Christine

Why do hardcore sports fans get so crazy when their team loses (or wins if you're an Eagles fan)?

Francesca Huggins

What is it about people who consider themselves part of a fandom that makes them retain a sense of childlike enthusiasm well into full blown adulthood?

Kelowna Ostwald

~FTQA~ When did the word “fandom” come to have it’s modern usage? Are there any historical examples of what we would now consider to be a fandom?

Steph

What helps fandoms last even after the show/band/etc is over?

Emily Okerlund

All media (movies, books, TV, etc) have fans, but not all have dedicated fandoms. Is there anything about a piece of media art that makes it more susceptible to having a large fandom other than exposure?

Monica

What is the academic discussion surrounding fanfiction writing? Are they taken seriously in an academic context? What are some issues that pop up when an author admits to reading fanfiction? Why do so many authors deny that they've ever read any? What makes something an Author's Universe vs in canon? Are their any dark corners of archiveofourown that you fear to tread? Any personal squicks? ABO? Dubcon/Noncon? How do you reconcile the mission statement of archiveofourown with possibly providing a haven for, say, pedophilic art and works celebrating immoral/illegal/terrible things? Where does creative license to write what you want meet social issues about giving a pass to anti-social or amoral behavior? Can you give a brief history of the fanworks scene? Where did it start? When did zines rise? What about fanfiction.net? Tumblr? (What is a zine?) How as the word "fan" changed in the cultural consciousness? What did it used to mean, and what does it mean today? Are we seeing more acceptance now, or less? Is Dante's Inferno a fanwork of the Book of Genesis?

Emily Okerlund

Something that the Harry Potter fandom is really grappling with right now is the idea of who owns this magical world - the author who we now know to be hateful or the fans who have made it their own. Where do we draw the line between art and creator when it comes to fandoms?

Chani Adams

From your grandfan, my 13 year old, Alem: "When looking at theories across different fandoms, would you say that they are reasonable, messy, don’t even make sense or otherwise?" And form me: "what are your thoughts in general about fan enthusiasm that takes on a life of it's own, like theories about characters or plot elements that aren't represented in the original?"

Steph

I almost never read AU works but that one was incredible, I can see why it's still so popular after all these years.

Kelly Semon

I honestly feel a little bit how I felt a few years after I was deeply committed to twilight. JKRs trash opinions didn’t change the books and I do think they still have value. But I’ve grown enough to be able to look at them with a critical eye and see they were pretty problematic in and of themselves. That’s kind of why there’s so much good fan fiction though. Fans have been noticing the major flaws in the books for a while. Even if I hold no love for the books I still love all the wizard rock and fanfiction and work of groups like the Harry Potter alliance. JKR can shove it.

Kelly Semon

Omg the mishapocalypse #NeverForget

Caitlyn Powell

Is there a point where fandom can become a detriment to real life? Any unhealthy side effects-- i.e. is it a sign of infantilization like some of my family members think it is?

Diane

Why is shipping such a huge thing? Why do I feel compelled to gush over my favorite couples and fawn over the idea of two fictional characters being in love?

Sylvia Scharf

I am not a sports person, but I am fascinated by sports fans who will be a fan of a team forever, even through 100%+ turnover of players/managers/coaches. What, exactly, are they a fan of at that point?

Elle McCall

I am 32 and probably more intense as a fan than I was before because I have ✨adult money✨

Caitlyn Powell

What is the draw of writing fanfiction instead of coming up with original fiction?

Skeletor the Crested Gecko

Why are some fans very interested in the private lives of the people behind a show/movie/whatever, while others are only interested in the content being produced? I am a fan of many things, but get turned off by celebrity drama, tabloids, etc.

Sylvia Scharf

This! Yes this question! Like, are there fandoms for random sitcoms, or really just sci-fi/fantasy?

Kelly Semon

Okay in the interest of contributing a question about brands because I just noticed that in the OP- WHY AM I A FAN OF SOME BRANDS EVEN THOUGH IM SUPER NOT A FAN OF CAPITALISM?! Why Are brands able to do this to me even when I know I’m being manipulated???

Alicia Penney

i used to be really interested in getting autographs of musicians i like, but then i realized that what i really wanted was to meet them and have a memory of being in close proximity to someone i admired. since then, i keep thinking about people buying autographed memorabilia and i just don't get it! why would people pay for something like that without even getting to have the memory of being near the famous person?

Elle McCall

This is such a good question!!! Brand loyalty could be a whole episode of it’s own.

Calvin Dowling

What is it about soap operas that they're able to survive endlessly, even when the content feels like same story different time and not even necessarily different people. Why are people so invested is seeing people like Erica Kane or Asa Buchanan get married and split 50 bazillion times?

Ellen Silva

Is anyone looking at the weird dynamic of fans of podcasts and the hosts? How fans sometimes believe they are actual friends of the hose with all sorts of intimate details, while the host may not even recognize the social media name of the fan, and certainly not their face, let alone anything about their life. Add to that the actual limited view into a host's life and it creates a very awkward situation when a real-life meeting happens. I've been a podcast host in a niche-y area and have experienced this, and I can only imagine it is many times more relevant to nationally known podcast hosts.

Bobbi Minard

What is an instance of a fandom universally rejecting the "cannon" content? How does this affect both groups?

Heidi Wright

When did modern fandoms start to effect the production of the media they were fans of? Was it Figwit with Lord of the Rings?

Sylvia Scharf

Oh also also also - people talk about fangirling or fanboying over a person - what is the gender-neutral term for this behavior? It isn't fanning... (Signed, agender person who definitely does this thing but is neither a girl nor a boy...)

AL

I've heard of writers on big shows with huge production teams creating aliases on fan fiction sites to write the episodes they're not allowed to write for the network. To me, this blurs the line between FAN fiction and actual writing, since they are the WRITERS. Is there a special name for this? Can a writer be their own fan?

Stefanie

First-time question asker! When I think of "fandom", I specifically think of social media fandoms like we see on Tumblr. What did fandom look like before the internet? Also, in my experience, there are many fandoms that start out good and wholesome, and end up imploding into a dumpster fire after either a certain amount of time passes, or the thing starts to reach a larger, more mainstream audience, inviting trolls. Is this inevitable with every fandom or have I just been unlucky with the fandoms I have been in?

Cat Lindsay

Can a fandom be comparable to a cult in a sense? What draws people psychological to fandoms?

Anna Guzman

What do you think it is that draws adults to fandoms of shows intended for children such as My Little Pony, Adventure Time, etc.?

Sharika Elahi

Hardcore fans can get pretty intense, in a way that often feels very cultish. Are fandoms a sort of cult, or are they similar to cult culture? In other words, are fandoms and cults in any way related?

Jean Chapin

I am a home care nurse. It blows my mind when I am in a home if I see Star Wars items, or anything that would trigger fandom, and I start talking Star Wars with them (or Harry Potter, Star Trek, Grateful Dead , Horror Genre, model cars/classic cars, X-Fliles, etc...), if you see that and you engage them in that you can crack so many barriers and not just find out about their fandom but their entire life. It establishes a trust greater than anything else I’ve ever encountered and has allowed me to delve so deep with some patients. What takes a patient from fandom talk to that level of trust to just unbelievable openness?

Nicole Howley

What are some of the qualities of something that attracts a ton of fans and leads to the creation of a fandom? There are a lot of popular movies, books, etc that are high quality but that don't inspire the same degree of fan engagement as Harry Potter, soccer and football teams, etc. Are there any characteristics in individuals that make us more or less likely to engage with a fandom? Or that make us more likely to engage with a fandom to a greater or lesser degree? There are people who live, breathe, eat, sleep, their fandom and then there are people who like things without engaging beyond consuming the origional content, and I've found myself at various points on the spectrum at different points in my life.

Onyx Cassiel

I am a HUGE Buffy the Vampire Slayer fan! It's 23 years old now! What makes a TV show like BTVS so beloved by old fans and is still gaining new fans 23 years later?

Kelly King

This! As the parent of a trans teen it totally stinks. We no longer by licensed merchandise, but the HP books were the first big kid books my kids and I read together. How do we separate them without feeling bad....or can we?

AL

Why do some fandoms and brands survive and evolve (ie. Star Trek and Levi jeans) and some are only popular during a limited era (i.e. Buffy the Vampire Slayer and Jordache jeans)?

Alyx

I'm a huge consumer of kdramas and have noticed how fandom in South Korea seems to be on another level than the US. Kpop Idol fans have gone so far as to harass/assault rumored romantic partners of their idols and idols have even mobilized their fan base to troll Trump. I'm curious how fandom is expressed in other countries?

Kelly King

Is there a term for the feeling of awkwardness that comes from *not* being a fan of some very popular thing? 🤣 cause there should be. I'm looking at you Star Wars.

Thomas N Wyndham

Great topic! I really want to know why fan, myself included I must admit, feel criticism of their fandom as a personal slight or attack? I was just remembering the other day in high school a girl said to me, “Actually Tom, I don’t really like Star Wars.” and rather silly looking back, I felt very shocked, and upset. I hope I’m older and wiser, but I still would love some insight into we take things so personally about our interests.

Meghan McLean

I worked for many years in the tabletop role playing industry, and at conventions some seemingly shy folks became more socially extroverted when immersing themselves in their preferred favorite show/movie/game. Why is this?

Deli Dames

Are there any patterns that make people more susceptible to being a fan? Like attaching an identity to a character or something?

Malorie Albee

Why is it more socially acceptable to be a sports fan than book/tv show fan?

Bennett Vanderbosch

Is there any difference between being a fan of things like cartoons and games (often considered nerdy) versus sports and the like (more mainstream)?

Tristyn Vaughan

Why do teenage girls get ALLLLLL THE CRAP for being fans of boy bands/young male singers? Why is it such a terrible thing to be a fan of a group of boys that sings? Is it the group itself? Is it the demographic of fans? What is it about these groups and fans in particular that causes people to go "OMG you like them?!? Ew" Need to know for my One Direction loving, heavily teased, teenage self, thanks Dad!

Sara Neilson

I feel like fandom far too often crosses the line from fun/entertaining to exploitative. Can we make people more discerning and logical about who they are fans of and just how hard they go about it?

Mandii Smith

Why can so many people watch The Office over and over and over again without it getting old verses other shows with fandoms where rewatching is less common?

Bonnie

What’s the line between between being healthily a fan of something and obsession? How does one stay a healthy fan?

Sarah

Is there anything that makes you more psychologically susceptible to joining a fandom or becoming obsessed with a certain character? I know neurodiverse folx tend to have 'special interests' but is that the only predictor? What fandoms in your studies are the most voracious or obsessive? Is there a notable decline in a fandom or fans' passion if the creator turns out to be problematic (looking at you, J.K. Rowling)? And does this have a ripple effect on the lives of the fans? Is being a die-hard fan of a sports team similar to being in a fandom? Is there any notable difference in the communities formed in fandoms as compared to other passions? (ex: being part of the Supernatural fandom vs. being part of a birding club) Thanks, pops!

Taylor Dumaine

Not a question, but if you're interested in this topic there is a really awesome spoken word poem by Olivia Gatwood called "When I say we are all teen girl"

SUTTON TAGGART

Does being a fan help you define your tribe?

Earl of Greymalkin

What does the history of fandom structure look like? What was fandom like hundreds of years ago? Did people orient to particular stories in the past quite the same way that we do now? And how have intellectual property laws shaped how we interact with various fandoms today?

Marc Chavez

Which fandom is the most liked, which is the least?

Janna Wisniewski

Yes! Seeing how I had absolutely no bearing on the outcome of the game, why do I feel good when my team wins?

Janna Wisniewski

Is fandom a relatively new phenomenon, or were people fans of things before movies, TV, and the internet? How was it expressed?

Hannah Lowe

Why do you think older generations that enjoy kid fandoms are more aggressive about their desired fandom?

David M Williams

Are there elements of fandom that are predictive of negative behaviors? Or characteristics of fans that may lead them to negative behaviors?

Kristina Meyers

Is it just me, or is the rise in the popularity of social media personalities and their increasingly zealous fans concerning. In other celebrity fan followings the connection between the idolized individual and the fan seems a little more distant and impersonal, while social media stars tend to thrive on developing an intimate relationship with their fans.

Bailey Jones

What is the most interesting fandom group you have seen?

Bailey Jones

Do you participate in fandoms?

Keri

Where is the clinical boundary between fandom and unhealthy obsession?

Jack Brownfield

why do fandoms gatekeep? Is it that tribal instinct keeping outsiders out or is it just groups of people being mean?

Bailey Jones

How long do most fandoms last?

Fi Cameron

First time question asker. Why do we imagine ourselves in the world of certain shows? For instance daydream about being friends with the cops from Brooklyn Nine Nine? Fantasise about what life would be like in The Good Place with the soul squad? Also why do we form such strong bonds with certain works of fiction/characters that we can watch/read these stories over and over again?

Tanner Harrold

Why would I take a bullet for Harry Styles? Why would I be willing to sacrifice my life for this man who I have never met?

Tanner Harrold

Why do I feel a deep loss when I finish a great book or tv show? Does that indicate something is missing in my real life or is it totally fine and normal?

Seth Suchy

Why do fandoms sometimes verbally attack and even threaten the creators of the show/book/music etc. ? Looking at you Steven Universe fandom (most are great, some of fans are rabid and mean)

Camille Young

Why do so many fans feel like it's their personal responsibility to defend their faves from any negativity whatsoever?? Also, have you noticed any differences in friend groups formed via fandoms vs friend groups formed via more traditional ways (work, school, etc)? And how common were those friend groups before the internet made them so easy?

Euan Munro

This is great question! I definitely have the cognitive dissonance in my head where I think brand loyalty is stupid, but also only by a certain brand of tea.

Kata Zarándy

Are there fans from all sorts of life? I mean is it more common to become a fan e.g. when your young? Is belonging to a fandom a privilege of any social/age/ethnic/etc group? Can anyone become a fan? Are there personality types that are immune to it?

Moth

Kathleen Sachs

What is the most moving thing you have seen a group of fans do for someone else?

Kathleen Sachs

Fandoms and cults. How easily can a fandom turn into a cult / exhibit cult-like behaviors? Which fandoms have the most cult-like behaviors?

Paulina Krasińska-Sroka

I love this topic! That was supposed to be my final paper in college, back when I still thought I'll finish it (about 10 years ago) <3 My question is: Is there any explanation why so many fanfics are sex-related, pure porn or at least have elaborate sex scenes? Is this some sort of compensation for the lack of sex-positive representation in media they fan over? I'm actually part of few fandoms (Frostiron, Cherik) and I can't wait for the episode!!

Paulina Krasińska-Sroka

Also, on the related note: How prominent in fandoms is homosexuality and other non-cis representation? For whatever reason, almost everyone I know that's into some fandom, is shipping gay or non-binary relationships. That's also something I'm into (aforementioned Frostiron - Loki & Tony Stark, Cherik - Charles Xavier & Erik Lehnsherr) and I'm bisexual. Is it just my bubble, or there's really a LOT more of non-heterosexual pairings in fandoms than in books/movies/other media?

Douglas W. Genet

So what is happening in the brain 🧠 when we are exposed to the things we are fans of?

lettersfromeleanorrigby

What is the state of legal challenges to fanworks since AO3 started? Did the challenges die off before or after OTW's legal arm was developed? Or was there a dropoff due to an understanding of social media and the utility in engaging with fandom?

lettersfromeleanorrigby

Can you talk about shows' queerbaiting, fridging, and burying their gays and whether fan backlash has an actual impact in viewer stats, ratings, sponsorship, etc.?

lettersfromeleanorrigby

Thoughts on the most interesting "new" fandom channels? i.e. Discord is just an improved IRC chatroom, is there anything really new and improved in fandom right now?

lettersfromeleanorrigby

What do you think the most creative tools/platforms/prompt sources for fandom? (Yuletide? Kink memes on LJ/DW? Discord chats? Something else?)

lettersfromeleanorrigby

Can you talk about sports as fandom, and how the people who do get criticized for being "bad" sports fans are the same people who get criticized for partaking in other fandoms? (i.e., sexism, racism, and homophobia aimed at nonwhite, nonmale, nonstraight sports fans is the same set of "critiques" used to denigrate nonsports fandoms?

Tamara Mann

Why are some people such fans that they'll go to any extent to 'become' their idol? I've seen people change their names, hair color, dress etc!

Tamara Mann

When does fandom cross the line to inappropriate or unhealthy?

JENN 'Benthopelagic squirrel' ALVAREZ

Why do ppl try to prove that they're a bigger or the biggest fan of *xyz*? Also, im totally Ologies biggest fan! *why am I like this? *😂

colleeneebee

It seems like a lot of fandoms are toxic, and I've even seen fans turn on the creators. Why is that? Is it something about perceived ownership, identity, etc?

Charlotte Fjelkegård

Did the fact that both Harry Potter and Twilight were written and published in modern time contribute a lot to the fandom. I'm thinking that it was a special experience to NOT KNOW THE ENDING in advance, but to be able to share the excitement with all the other fans when a new book came out. Did that happen with Austen, Dickens and Dumas as well when their stories were first published as serials in the papers?

Natalie Rhoades

Are there any particular fandoms that jump out to you as excelling at being super welcoming and inclusive to all folks?

Danae DeJournett

Where did the word “fan” in this context originate? When did fan behavior start? I’m assuming back sometime in the days of the royals, but at that point in time it was more political. Are fans just another form of divisiveness we use outside of political parties? Can fandom be expected/guessed depending on a person’s characteristics? Like for instance, can one assume that a lot of fans of Luke Bryan, the country singer, might be white people from more rural areas and Lil Wayne in turn, more black people from urban areas? When does someone’s star shine so brightly (like Beyoncé) that it eclipses those boundaries?

Mark Reid

What are some factors that lead to particularly intense fandoms?

Carrie Cimo

What benefits does fandom have on society? Ie. Bringing people together over a sports team (recognizing that this same phenomenon creates divides too...)? What amount of influence does fandom have in creating community?

Carrie Cimo

How would society be different if fandom wasn’t a thing?

Kim Bonacker

What has been the most wholesome or world / vuew changing thing you've seen come out of the Fandom culture, or any particular Fandom?

Logan M

Historically, have fans been able to separate the creator of the work from the work itself when the creator become problematic over time... eg. the transphobe JK R*wling and her life’s work.

Matt Ceccato

What are the healthiest and unhealthiest behaviors in fandom?

Jess Swann

I once read an interesting theory that distinguished 'collective' fandom - people who buy official merch and memorize all the facts about a fandom - from 'transformative' fandom - fanfiction, vidding, cosplay, etc. Do you think that's a meaningful distinction? One of the other points in the theory was that collective fandom was traditionally primarily male while transformative fandom was traditionally primarily female. It drew some connections to men being mostly in charge of the media industry and so providing more of 'what men want' whereas women had to take control to make things more like what they want. How do you feel about that argument?

Jess Swann

How do we remove the stigma against fandom, especially traditionally female fandoms like bands?

Logan M

Also I don’t know if I’m the only one but I’m only on Personality Psychology (2/19/19) and I became a patron because duh. But I get a bit of excitement thinking that weeks from now when I catch up, I might hear one of my questions being answered. Feels like I’m putting a message in a bottle for myself. 🤣

Megan

Yes this! Why is something like Captain Marvel a "fandom" but sports aren't (for many people)?

Jess Swann

Similar to the question about fandoms with awful creators (like JK Rowling), how are people dealing with being fans of shows where the subject is problematic? Many people I know have been fans of Brooklyn 99, for example, but given the current world of police violence, they are struggling.

Liz

Do you think COVID-19 has had any impact on the Fandom world? (lack of concerts, live events, new movies/shows)

Michelle L. Pegram

I don't know if you also study sports fandom, but I have often wondered why I feel such intense emotions around my sports teams. I feel crushed when they lose and elation when they win. Why???

Ella Thompson

How come sometimes we fangirl (fanperson) out with someone not famous? I 100% fangirled out over someone in the last few months, and I'm not even sure why. Then I found out someone else was fangirling over me! (We are both women) I am a normal person! It's confusing. Maybe it's a crush? But I don't think so.

PixieMuffin

Why am I more invested in other people than myself? For example: I was *destroyed* when two twitch streamers I watched had a messy breakup. I'm still not completely over it ~3 years later

Laura Stacey

I'm not sure if Meredith's studies would cover this, but I'm curious about the ethics of creating ads and playing into the psychology of branding. Is this something that is being studied? How far is too far? Should we be better educating people about their psychological vulnerabilities that advertisers take advantage of?

Mr_Wizard_Merlin

What is the first ever recorded case of a fandom?

Amber-Leigh Noelle

i was so heavily invested in my fandom of choice that when i began to fall out of love with it, i felt like i was being deprogrammed from a cult. i don't want to compare cults to fandoms because one is severe and serious and one should be a fun and safe place, but for me, i felt like i had to re-wire my brain to think about things in a normal way and not base all of my thinking around my particular hyper-fixation. am i alone in feeling this way, or is this something that many people experience?

Soph Cousineau

This might be a bit of an "evolutionary psychology"-esque question, but why do we become fans of people (or characters or sports teams)? Do you think there's an adaptive reason why people become fans, or do you think it's a side effect of having mass media to tell us about people we've never met but have parasocial relationships with?

Jolanta Benal

As a writer of fanfic, I'd like to know why fanworks and the people who make them are so often regarded with condescension or outright contempt by those outside our subculture. I'd really like your insights here -- especially because anthropology hasn't historically taken the most, uh, generous views of the people under study.

Hope

how does the fandom mentality (people who religiously keep up with new material/make fanart/theories/rambling posts on tumblr) Work? Is it at all similar to hyperfixation with ADHD?

Jolanta Benal

re your last question: i think you're basically asking why people have kinks

Jolanta Benal

I write fanfiction and am friends with a number of other fanfic writers. The draw is that you're struck by a lacuna of some kind in the source material and a way to address it presents itself to you as a story idea. Or some dynamic between characters has broader implications than the source material addresses. Or it strikes you as fun to see what certain characters might be like in a noncanonical setting. Or, of course, you just like it when two cute guys bang (I'm looking at you, Bucky Barnes and Steve Rogers).

Jolanta Benal

Also see Jean Rhys's "Wide Sargasso Sea," which is LITERATURE and therefore definitely not fanfic of "Jane Eyre."

Jay Ryan

Why do I hate Disney fandom so much?

Sadie

Can we talk about Game of Thrones yet or are we still mourning? I’m just still shocked how quickly (regardless of how deserved or not) the fans abandoned a seemingly giant, culturally changing phenomenon! Or is this like, par for the course with anything that gets too big for its britches?

lettersfromeleanorrigby

Gonna guess it's the toxic white masculinity, but I too would like a professional opinion.

Levi Bourke

What’s with some people (me included) getting hyper fixated on certain fandoms? I know for me it’s part of OCD and ADHD but why does it happen more with fictional characters than anything else? Just trying to validate my obsession with 40 year old men🤷🏻‍♂️

Deborah Baudoin

What is your opinion on fanfiction? Does it deserve the disdain it gets in some circles or is a good place for writers to learn their craft with a built-in circle of critics? Has the stigma of fanfiction been lifted since the 70s and 80s? From what I've seen lately, quality still varies from atrocious to absolutely fantastic.

Kai Kishimoto

Have you done any studies on the phenomenon of queer baiting and how it creates die-hard fandoms of shippers but never delivers a happy queer ending?

David Phelps

First time question asker with SO MANY questions! Do academics rank levels of fandom? Like someone who has seen every Star Wars movie is a casual fan, and someone who saw every movie on opening night is a big fan, and someone who has seen every movie, has read every book, and also has Jedi robes and a lightsaber are super fans? Also, I often see Marvel movies with my brother. Invariably, after the movie I say I like it and he says, well it's not like the comic. Is this dynamic a fandom bias or a desire for consistency or something else? I feel like the root of toxic fandom is when someone's mental image of a universe is not aligned with what they are experiencing. For example, Toxic Star Wars fans are mad about basically every part of the sequel trilogy because they wanted a story that played in the old rules not invented some new ones. Is a fair understanding? And if so, could you explain other things in our world as toxic fandoms? One example I can't stop thinking about is Trumpism. It would be a toxic fandom of America, which is more multi-cultural than a Trumpers' perception of America, and less upwardly mobile than they (and we) were told. Is that too weird of a take? Finally, how do you engage with someone who's fandom has become toxic? As you can tell from my examples, I love Star Wars, but there are a lot of toxic fans out there. How do bring them back to the light side, as it were? And if you can't, how do still talk about something you love without letting them corrupt it for you?

Will Johnston

What in your opinion is the most toxic fandom? Also what is the best fandom and why is it Terry Pratchett's Discworld?

Diana Hsu

How do you think fandom intersects with parasocial relationships? I'm thinking both of fandoms around fictional properties but also "Real person fandom" like the Bon Appetit Test Kitchen crew. Relatedly, how do you feel about "Real Person Fandom"? Creepy, or just a variant of celebrity culture?

Will Johnston

When I saw that tweet it made me so happy!

Anya

Is being an obsessive fan of something a form of addiction or related to addiction?

Mardee Goodwin

YES! And why is my hatred of said Fandom so poorly received? People look at me like I kicked a puppy when I tell them my feelings about Disney. It's fun to learn about murderers but don't fuck with Mickey mouse. *barf*

Yuri

First time question asker! Why does Fandom seem to happen with a mob mentality, a critical mass of enough others liking it, instead of what a person truly likes? Or put another way, does what we think are our own individual likes and tastes, actually are implanted subconsciously by what everyone around us is doing? And if so, how do we get out of that hall of mirrors? For instance, years ago on my birthday at a club the dj played me my favorite song by a very well known and popular hip hop artist, but the song wasn't released yet - there were other songs on the album that were huge hits (and the people in the club thronged to the dance floor for), but this wasn't out yet. The dance floor almost completely emptied out for the duration of the song (of course I still danced! It was a fantastic song on my birthday!). A month later, after the song was released and was a huge hit, bigger than the others on the album, when the dj played it the dance floor was completely packed with delighted happy enthusiastic people, many of whom were the same people from a month before (the club had a lot of regulars). What gives? Either you like a song, or you don't. Why does how popular the song is make such a huge difference to how popular the song is?

Veronica Blair

What happens when you stan a book and then find out that the author tweeted vile things that hurt the lgbtq+ community? Stop buying the books and merch? Stop consuming altogether? What do you think?

Jason Miller

I think you can separate the world and the characters from the writer- though it is probably very tough to do

Kelly Roberson

First time question asker here! Why do I rewatch the same cartoon over and over for comfort? I've literally seen Avatar the last air bender and the legend of Korra 40+ times. WHHHYYYYY

Lynn

Is there a common personality trait among those who are intense fans? I'm thinking of the screaming girls in front of The Beatles or people who go all out on the costumes for Comic Con.

Jess Bauzá de García

I have to do academic writing for work and will sometimes have a fanfic plot bunny that won’t leave me alone and I can’t do work writing until I get the fanfic writing out of my head. I’d be interested to hear about this too

Ava Schaefer

As a teenager I’ve noticed that fandoms have become more popular as I grow older. Is there an age group that is specifically drawn to fandoms? If it is the teens do you think that would be a developmental thing? Can fandoms be developmental? What’s the neuroscience behind this? I know we tend to go with the group is that why fandoms are so popular?

Ava Schaefer

How are fandoms even started in the first place?

Emily Branigan

What is the best fandom, and why is it Avatar the Last Airbender?

Emily FW

What's the connection between adolescence and all-consuming, crying-because-my-favourite-Backstreet-boy-had-a-girlfriend (who wasn't me) fandom? I mean, hypothetically...

Salem

Why do we feel the need to get lost in these worlds? Like what is the psychology of wanting to get so lost in a fandom or world?

Kethry Warren

These questions come from my fellow nerds and good friends: What impact has fandom had on language? What is the impact of shipping (relationships, not goods being transported to customers) on media?

Pascal Perron

What about the hipster cliché: someone ''discovers'' an incredible underground artist and is disappointed when they go mainstream, and they might feel like they're favorite thing is ''spoiled''. Do we not want our favorite artists to achieve the level of success they deserve and are capable of?

BENJAMIN

Have you seen people being fans of characters that resemble themselves in some way or more-so being fans of characters like someone they want to become (if that makes sense)?

Pascal Perron

At what point does a fandom get a name like the Trekkies or Juggalos or Beyhive? Is this a recent phenomenon or did fans of Beethoven called themselves Beethofans? I've been a huge fan of Tori Amos my whole life, yet I don't feel the need to call myself a Toriphile. Why don't I want to be part of the group? Am I a jerk? Side note: Some of those names get pretty creative: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_fandom_names And also: should Ologies have one?

Helena

Hellooo from a first time question asker! Is there a gender neutral term for fangirl or fangirling? Why is it gendered in the first place? I'm nonbinary but saying I'm fanpersoning over ologies sounds a bit weird...

Yuri

Wow, I had no idea there were so many! I think I've only heard of four or five of these

Aubrey Nelson

Do you think people rewatch their favorite shows because it is a known comfort? There are no surprises, therefore no anxiety over what will happen, so it’s just the comfort of the known?

Sam Correia

Wow, how exciting! I've recently realized about myself that, when I'm really into a show or book or something, it takes up like 50% of my brain space for approximately 4-6 months. I become obsessed with it, and then almost snap out of it and become obsessed with something else for a long period of time. Is this how a lot of people experience fandom? Like, really strong obsession for a period of months, and then it switches over to something else almost overnight?

Susanne Krause

Which factors make it more likely for a show/book series etc. to get a really dedicated fan crowd, such as, for example Star Trek or the Harry Potter books?

Susanne Krause

Which psychological/emotional need does being a fan of something fulfil?

Meryl

What about not really being a fan of anything? I don't really get super into shows/bands/etc.

Katie Yu

Does being a fan of something satisfy the desire to be benevolent to others?

Spencer Parks

What's the strangest (most unique) group of fans you've encountered? Why study fandom?

Garrett Robinson

What makes a fandom Go Bad, as has happened with such fandoms as Star Wars or My Hero Academia?

Colin

Why do some fandoms seem to handle change well and other seem to rip apart of anything new is introduced? Looking at you Star Wars!

Diane

I guess you could call it stanning? Freaking out? I feel like "fangirling" comes from a need to poke fun of stereotypical teenage girls who are hysterical and super-obsessed with fandom stuff like their favorite band or movie. I mean, boys aren't made fun of for going ALL OUT with stereotypical "guy fandoms" like science fiction or sports.

Susan G

How do you reconcile when you are in a fandom that is wholesome and supportive and amazing and it turns out the creator of the thing you are fandoming about is a total douche. Is it becoming more common to see fandoms disconnecting from problematic creators because the communities grow beyond that?

Fwaeldling

can someone please add Ologites to this list? no taxation without representation!

lishka arata

What's the relationship between fandom and religious/spiritual figures? How is the fandom/worshipping different or similar for the fan/worshiper?

Helena

Yes!! I need a tshirt that says I am freaking out about ologies!

Michelle Jacobs

What is your opinion about authors not allowing/wanting fans to create fanfiction?

Michelle Jacobs

In your opinion, can we truly be a fan of a novel (or anything really) if we do not agree with its creator (e.g. Harry Potter and J.K. Rowling)?

Wendy Miles

Are those that become mega fans more susceptible to brainwashing, cults, megalomaniacs, spousal abuse or general subservience? Is there a scale of fandom, where 1 is "I want to wear his t-shirt for a week" and 10 is "I want to have his face tattooed onto my face."

Kristen

Why are some Fandoms so gendered? Like seeing generally a majority of one Fandom being towards one gender, how does that happen?

Nikki DeMarco

Joining the fandom late in the game is overwhelming and it's hard to know where to start. Is there a strategy to join and not be a total noob?

Nikki DeMarco

Why are fandom relationship bonds so strong? It seems like people who become friends through fandoms become closer more quickly.

Sarah Sutcliffe

Why do fans often become "apologists" or try to romanticise or excuse toxic characters? Is there a line where exploring "what ifs" of characters backgrounds and histories and potential redemption arcs and recognising complexity in people etc turns into a perpetuation/romanticization/normalisation of problematic relationship dynamics, particularly abusive ones? Thinking particularly of Snape and the Always fandom as one on the edge of problematic, but I'm also aware of much more problematic and borderline rapey/stalkerish/abusive ships and romanticisation of characters who are constructed as objectively bad people.