Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Content warning: comments will contain questions about the study and phenomenon of suicide. 

Suicidology is very much a real -ology, and an important one. I've been wanting to cover it for years and as September is an awareness month for the issue, I'm tracking down a good guest for it. I've considered many different people and really want to make sure I choose wisely. Leave your questions below, fam -- and any suggestions for guests in case that weighs the choice for me. 

ALSO LANGUAGE HEADS UP: the term "committed suicide" is no longer used because it implies a crime.  "Died by suicide" is what experts, mental health advocates and health care providers use. 

Hearts & hugs to everyone impacted by this issue. ❤️

- Dadward

Comments

Yuri

Why are neurodivergent people 9x more likely to die by suicide, and how can we help our neurosibs?

Christa Dixon

Why do we have existential dread?

Paige

Is there a region in the United States where suicide rates are disproportionately higher than others?

Preston

How can I change my language when talking to someone who is considering suicide to be more compassionate but also serious?

gumi

are help lines actually helpful? what’s the process of calling one like

mary l

How does Durkheim’s Suicide hold up in 2021?

Anna Thompson

How can you best help if you see a stranger on the edge of a bridge or in other such situation?

Kiera Faye

Dese’Rae L. Stage of Live Through This (dot com) would be a great guest.

Ashley Oki

Trigger warning: suicide attempt I tried to commit suicide a year ago. I’m in therapy and a much better place, but I still feel the urge to commit suicide whenever something is slightly inconvenient. (For context I’ve been suicidal for most of my life). Why do I still get the urge to commit suicide even though I’m ‘better’? What can I do to get rid of these urges?

Joe Porfido

Are suicidal ideation and self-harm behaviors related?

Jessica Kleist

Dr. Kristin Kosyluk at the University of South Florida is a great expert in mental health stigma. I'm currently in a Master's program of Gerontology. Older adults make up about 12% of the US population, but account for 18% of all suicide deaths, how can we better support our elderly and how can programs such as assisted suicide help for those with terminal diagnoses?

Bryanna Reina

Why is suicide seen as unforgivable in so many cultures?

Lauren Dwight

Why is there such a big stigma around assisted suicide? What can people do to help get legislation passed to make it legal?

Reuben Clamzo

How does the study of suicide intersect with philosophy, like the existentialist Emil Cioran?

Ainsley Blische

what are the most common patterns of people who are “preparing” to die by suicide? (ie. giving things away)

Anna Thompson

Acknowledging that everyone is a unique case what are some general signs someone might be contemplating suicide and what can their friends and family do?

Anastasia

If you feel that urge to do that act, what are the top three things to do to bring yourself back from that precipice? (Whether you've made a plan or not)

Stephanie Broertjes

How can we lessen care fatigue for MH professionals? I left working inpatient adolescent psych because it was hell on my own mental health

Ed Rumsey

Any good books or films etc. that you think help someone to deal with understanding suicidal thoughts and more importantly understandanding how to help someone else going through this and their thought process

Eric Girard

Other than being there for that person and the hotline what other resources are helpful to both help spot it as an outsider and for the actual person?

Patrick Javarone

Substance use/serious mental health counselor here, I’m curious about your thoughts on the correlation between social media use and increased Suicidality?

Lizzy Carr

How/should you talk to people about a suicide attempt afterwards? A friend of mine attempted suicide a few years ago and she's doing a lot better now, but in the immediate aftermath of her attempt I didn't know if I should try to talk to her about it/what to talk about if I did, or if it was more helpful to just pretend things were normal.

Shay Stemplewski

Do you ever really heal from losing your best friend to suicide? How do I? Some days are worse than others but as someone who has attempted multiple times and been suicidal, before losing my friend, will the thoughts about ending everything ever really go away? Like it’s not a constant daily struggle anymore but there are moments when it’s so hard to see a better option.

Adriana Alfaro

Are there any studies which show which types of programs or intervention work to prevent suicide? As a service member, I see a lot of programs and training about suicide and how to spot the signs or where you can turn if you have suicidal ideation.. but it feels more like a way to redirect responsibility to the individual suffering which seems like it would be ineffective. Do things like this actually work?

Brea Plum

Is suicide endemic to the human psyche? Granted that for much of history is was an event that was left unspoken, can we trace it back through history reliably (not including events such as Socrates, sentences for crimes or transgressions) as a mental and emotional health problem? Is it built into human brains or did it develop, perhaps as a response to changing social environment?

Kelsey Byrd

What happens in our brain that makes us have suicidal thoughts or actions?

Rae Hebert

Hey Dadward! This is a very important topic to me as I’ve struggled with suicide since age 11. My question is this: what is the difference between actual suicidal thoughts, ideations, and random intrusive thoughts? And how do tell the difference and rationalise?

Justin So

Some people think of suicide as cowardice, while some think of it as courage or surrender of life (e.g. assisted suicide). How do you see it? Is it always so black and white? If someone thinks that they have lived enough, isn't it selfish of us to try to keep them alive?

L. Wink

What distinguishes physician assisted suicide from other forms of suicide?

Cairhys

Assuming that interviews occur, what steps are taken to keep people safe? Has studying gotten easier/better/more able to be done given that conversations on mental health are more normalized?

Rachelle Nolan

No question. Just wanting to say thank you for covering this, educating us about it, and to the -ologist: Thank you for dedicating your career and energy to studying this phenomenon, so that we may better understand how to help others ❤️

Shay Stemplewski

What’s the best way or just a good way to dissuade someone from committing suicide?

Gianna McClain

I lost a close friend to suicide almost two years ago. I had seen him a mere hours before and hasn’t seen any signs. I think about our last interaction and the weeks leading up a lot. He did not leave a note and it did not seemed planned. How many suicides are planned and how many are spontaneous? Or is it usually a mix?

Rahala

As many people know, suicide rates in the military are very high. Is there something that could be done or done better for military members/veterans to help lower these numbers? What matters most when talking to people who are in a rough spot and might be considering it?

Jennasis

I know there is a national prevention hotline but are there local numbers too? Sometimes there are issues that are regionally affecting people that someone on the other side of the country might not understand.

Allie Rosser

Why is the thought of dying so scary, even though everyone dies? Is it a left over from our less evolved ancestors? Can we evolve past the fear to choose when we die? Is that still considered suicide?

Julie K. Rose

My husband is a survivor, having lost his mom to suicide many, many years ago. Therapy was not helpful for him at the time (late 1980s). How have therapeutic approaches changed (for those left behind) in the last 20-30 years?

Rachelle Nolan

Ooooh I like this question, too. I’d love to hear about the various cultural ideas of suicide

Stephanie Porter

Has there been an increase in suicides in more recent years? Or are we just hearing about it more?

Duffy Martin

First time question asker! I was wondering what (if any) impact Christianity had on the Western perception/practice of suicide. I know shame accompanies suicide in many cultures, but the notion of those who died by suicide suffering in hell seems to permeate modern attitudes. Did the rise of Christianity impact the rate of suicides? How did the concept of punishment after death influence popular understanding/sentiment? Thanks Allie<3 this is a tough topic but you always handle these subjects with care and I appreciate your dedication.

Caitlin H

I teach health in a high school and am planning to do a self harm and suicide prevention class. What are some good resources for lesson planning and what are ways to approach this with 14-16 year old students acknowledging some may have personal experience with self harm. I don't want to add trauma, stress or stigma.

Gianna McClain

Also how do you feel about assisted suicide and the right to die?

Rachael Hall

How do you breach the subject gently with random people? My brother-in-law died by suicide a few years ago now. I wear my “out of the darkness” and “survivor of suicide” walk t-shirts, and I have a semicolon tattoo. It either goes really well or really horribly when people ask what my shirt or tattoo are for. Often people just shut down and don’t want to talk anymore or they’re all of a sudden really awkward with me in conversation moving forward especially about mental health issues.

Linda Bonney Bostrom

Does suicide seem like more of a choice for one’s self if you’ve seen it around you? I have multiple family members who have made that choice. Does that normalize it for me as an option?

Skylar P.

What are some of the biggest myths about suicide that you’d like to bust? As a teacher of teenagers, what’s the best way to talk about suicide in a sensitive, nonjudgmental way? And is Youth Mental Health First Aid a good resource?

Ella Sugerman

People experiencing suicidal ideation are often dismissed as "attention-seeking" or "needy". Does research offer any insight into how to best counteract that narrative?

Maria Jouravleva

Asking for my partner, Tyler Duckett: Japan has seemingly done SO much as a country to counteract and decrease their suicide rates (e.g. changing the color of subway platforms)... why have their numbers not budged at all? Is it a lack of scientific basis informing their practices? Thanks in advance.

Shay Stemplewski

TW: The relation to self harm and suicide please? And eating disorders and suicide

Lizzy Martinez

What stories/lessons/realizations have been shared by people who survive attempted suicide? What can we do better to support them in their recovery?

Miranda Panda

No question here. I don't even know what I'd want to ask. But with such a large audience could you please make a note for folks to please, for the love of god, stop making suicide jokes. It sucks, it's not funny, and it's traumatic for people who've dealt with suicide.

Ainsley Blische

what are your thoughts on the term “committing suicide” in relation to societal stigma, such as committing crimes, committing sins, committing adultery

Allison D.

I once stated that suicide is the most selfish thing a person can do, and was (understandably) excoriated for it. But I don’t mean selfish as in “character flaw.” I’ve been severely depressed myself, and I mean it literally in that depression or desperation that severe can make it nearly impossible for the sufferer to consider anything outside of their own self.. I’d like to know what your expert would say about this “selfishnesss” (and if they might have a less harsh way of describing it)?

Stephanie

Has anymore research been done into why Logan, Ut or Cache County, Ut has had some of the highest suicide rates in the country for years? There was one study done a while ago but I haven’t heard any follow ups or further digging into it since then.

Ainsley Blische

has the global pandemic had any effect on suicide statistics

Shannon Feltus

As someone who has been on the mental health island with serious intrusive thoughts of self harm in my past, what is way to explain these feelings to someone who does not understand depression or suicide?

Brooke Suchy

Why do people think its wrong? If a person is fighting 'demons' we can't see and chooses not to anymore why is it considered selfish? I would really like to know.

Lauren Krupens

what do i even say to help someone who may be contemplating suicide? i’m so afraid of saying the wrong thing!

keli

what do different faiths/religions have to say about suicide? are people who commit suicide seen to be “stuck” between worlds?

Tess Hebert

In your research and experience, are people more likely to commit or attempt suicide if they have access to a weapon, such as a gun? I guess another way to phrase this question is, are people statistically more likely to attempt suicide if they have access to a method that causes minimal pain and a quick death? This is a very important subject to me and I just want to thank Alie for talking about it. To anyone reading this and struggling right now, you're not alone ❤

Sarah Kulig

I’m a mental health counselor taking an incredible training with Dr. David Jobes on a really well researched, evidenced based method for treating suicidal ideation. I feel like he’d be amazing to talk to because his philosophy is so person-centered, compassionate, direct, and helps people understand the many various emotions and circumstances that can contribute to suicidality. Honestly I think counselors don’t get nearly enough training for how common this issue is and I am so grateful for his work!!

Ainsley Blische

or any other modern/current issues; like the climate crisis, election, increase in mass shootings, etc

Alexandra Burch

Is the normal amount to think about suicide really “never”? It seems like even for mentally healthy people it must come up passively at least SOMETIMES

Ainsley Blische

is there evidence of when the first suicide was completed?

B

How do I help a loved one who is going through mental health struggles?

Michelle Dempsey

I recently learned of a friend of a friend who had 3 sons and 2 of them committed suicide. The first was her eldest who was bullied and was convinced suicide was the answer and took his own life at 19. The second was her youngest, at 7, and did not understand the concept. He desperately wanted to see his brother again and then also committed suicide because he thought he could visit his brother and come back after. I know there is no "one size fits all" answer, but my question is how can we try to explain death and suicide to children who go through losing a loved one? How can we help them comprehend the finality of it without causing further trauma?

Shannon Feltus

Also, in the Pacific Northwest (and other gloomy weather areas) is there something to the thought of seasonal depression increasing the cases of suicide?

Somerset Francis

**How do you respond when someone opens up about considering suicide? It's still common to hear people try to invalidate non-suicidal self-harm. What really is the relationship between self-harm and suicidal thoughts?

Ezra

Is there a connection with reduction of suicide rates and creating systematic supports for people in disadvantaged situations? If not what is the best way to approach ?

Ainslee Lara

Scrolling & I see an “Ainsley”?!? I’m 45 & am so not used to there being other Ainslees. This is my 1st Patreon question & if you use it please use both my names, pretty please. “Ainslee Lara.” I’m curious if search engines do anything to reach out when users search “suicide methods” … I’ve considered searching & feared the repercussions. Maybe you’re a writer, maybe you’re in crisis?!? Also afraid to ask how often people do actually Google best suicide method. And if we’re going to go dark, is it okay to ask … by gender?

Andrea Theisen

It came as a total surprise to everyone when a friend committed suicide in highschool...how can you prevent it if you don't even know someone is struggling?

Ainsley Blische

^^ at what point does a thought about one’s own death become a cause for concern

Andrea Theisen

We had a series of 4 kids commit suicide in highschool...is there a reason behind this?

Dani

I often hear the terms suicide ideation or suicidal thoughts. Are these the same thing? I don't really understand what suicide ideation is even though I've tried to google it for more understanding. Thank you!

Chris Brewer

No question but thank you so much for doing this ology and recognizing those who are suffering. For those of us who have lost loved ones from suicide we are eternally grateful.

Sydni Bowers

That is an interesting topic considering samurai would perform seppuku, sometimes to avoid falling into enemy hands, in a ceremonial fashion.

OJ

Is there any data suggesting a most effective method of suicide prevention?

Sayyada Dharsee

This is such an important subject, thank you for this! 1. where do we draw the line between suicide prevention and bodily autonomy? In the UK, a common response to people who attempt suicide is forced hospitalisation/'sectioning', which (in my experience) does more harm than good. I've also felt like a lot of that institutional monitoring/suicide prevention was taking away my own autonomy and choices about my life. However now several years later I *am* glad that I'm still around! Where do we draw that line when talking about suicide prevention? 2. Any advice for people who have been/sometimes still are suicidal, who are now working or volunteering in roles that involve mental health first aid and suicide prevention? There seem to be several of us!

KataMari

How do you help a tween battle emotions without going immediately to "I want to kill myself" and continuously having to explain that suicide is not an emotion but an action? And should parents and teachers be trained in the CSSRS?

Michelle Dempsey

Are there potential calling cards for when a person may commit suicide? For example if you know of a person who is going through a really hard time, or may seem depressed but refuses to seek help. Are there any consistent red flags that they may be ready to commit suicide?

Amanda

I've had severe depression/suicidal ideation my entire life, but have never been driver to actually attempt to harm or kill myself. It honestly feels like I'm locked in a cycle that is inescapable because my thoughts aren't severe enough but also not minimal enough for me fully function. Is this a common experience? How can I break this cycle?

KataMari

Follow up don't worry he's in therapy (as am I) but it's just a common phrase he says all the time. And Its frustrating

Madelaine

Can you discuss the coupling effect of suicide

Ainsley Blische

hi fellow Ainsley, my questions are first timer questions too!

Brandi Harbaugh

Everyone has probably heard about the idea of allowing suicide to be legal, what are your thoughts on this? If it becomes legal do you think they will make stipulations on it; for example, needing to find help and going through those channels beforehand?

Nicole Kleinman

I recognize that if you’re a danger to yourself and others, it’s reasonable for extra precautions. But I have experienced and heard the true horrors and neglect from mental health facilities. How do we change those systems so they are actually HELPFUL and not destructive? How can we make GOOD help available to everyone?

Tara Hartford

Also, thank you for covering this topic. It sucks to talk about, but once you find someone in the club of survivors, you bond with them. They become part of an unfortunate family you never wanted to join, but so thankful to have them.

lauren

FTQA: How can we help reduce the stigma of talking about death by suicide- especially for our loved ones who have lost people this way? Can you address the nuances of this type of grief and ways we can work on better supporting those effected by these losses?

Ainsley Blische

thoughts on being involuntarily committed to a mental health facility after an attempt…do they help or just make the situation worse?

Marron Brown

What sort of things, physiologically, are going on when individuals are considering suicide? In other words.. chemically, what is going on in the body during thoughts of suicide?

Marron Brown

Also, thank you for covering this topic. Love ya dad

Tara Hartford

ETA: my brother died from suicide in 2018. Can you please talk about survivor’s guilt, EMDR for trauma, and how suicidal ideation runs in families, especially after someone has died from suicide. I think it’s also important to tell people to watch other family members who lost someone to suicide closely after the death. Those same wonky brain chemicals are probably fucking up their head too.

Julie April

I'm a therapist in training, and something I regularly wrestle with is that psychiatric hospitalization (common practice when someone is at imminent risk of self-harm or suicide), while sometimes essential for ensuring safety and stabilizing someone who's struggling, can be just as traumatic in some cases as suicidality itself. Any thoughts or suggestions on ways that friends, families, and mental health practitioners can support a person either before, during, or after they've been hospitalized for suicidality? PS: Thank you SO much for covering this topic! Suicidality is so much more common than people realize, and society's stigma and fear of talking about it make it so much harder for people who are struggling to ask for help. <3

Chloe Jones

Could you discuss the relationship between suicide and guns?

PixieMuffin

Suicide in the media - how could it be better? I was in a book club and a character died by suicide and I realized that my friends did not know much of anything about how suicide can happen in a moment of crisis etc. I realized that my first-hand experiences with suicide and suicidal ideation have led me to know more than the average person and it would be nice to have resources to refer people to.

Shella Stosik

I don't think I will be able to listen to this episode since I lost my Dad to suicide. But thank you so much doing an episode on this ❤

PixieMuffin

Seconding the question about how to educate others about self-harm vs suicidal ideation vs suicide

Somerset Francis

**In your opinion, are there circumstances wherein suicide is a rational option?

Rowen

someone from Project LETS might be a good guest. they approach suicide from a disability justice lens & as a social/political issue rather than only individual, and they really center survivors and lived experience.

Olga

What’s the best way to approach someone if you suspect they need help?

Talia B.E.

Second-time-question-asker. I am also a teacher who wants to know the best way to approach ADMIN about the need to be able to discuss suicide in classes as young as 5th grade. My very first year teaching, one of my 8th graders took her life and it broke me. But I'm still here even when I don't want to be to make sure my students know they are not a burden and that they can want to live through their pain. My mom's a child psychologist + everything I've read has told me YOUNG kids get suicidal ideations & talking about suicide does NOT encourage it. My admin (dif school than the 8th grader who passed away) has never explicitly given training to faculty or students on suicide prevention, but I want to convince my school that we should do this. What's the best way to do so? And are there free/affordable experts who routinely come speak to schools and offer that type of training? And are we EVER going to destigmatize suicidal ideations/suicide/mental illness? Thank you for reading. And thank you for doing this Ward.

Ashley Herbel

How do you challenge the idea that suicide ends someone’s suffering when it’s ultimately a true statement, even if it’s obviously not what we want to happen to someone contemplating it. Especially when physician assisted suicide for terminal illness stands as an example of the relief people can get.

Alexandre Catulle

How to cope with the guilt of not being able to prevent a death by suicide?

Shoshannah

Why are people who’ve died by suicide considered selfish?

Richard Tran

Any time I try to find a new therapist, they always ask if I’ve had thoughts of suicide. I haven’t… but I’ve had suicide adjacent thoughts, like what if I got into an accident (purposely) that just gave me a “legitimate” reason to just not have to do anything. Is there a term for this? I guess more importantly, are there any recommendations for how to get myself from thinking thoughts like that?

Anika's Cat Arya

FTQA very important topic! How would you best recommend handling conversations about sensitive but important topics like suicide with young people? (Like for example if a family member passes away from suicide or for education)

Jessica Ward

First time question asker! Why are Native Americans more at risk for suicide?

Jessica Ward

And different question, do must people who suffer from suicidal thoughts do so for their entire lives or do they generally recover fully?

PixieMuffin

Also, arguing for death with dignity when people conflate death with dignity and suicide in crisis/mental illness.

Talia B.E.

Eep I know I'm not the expert here but I have so much info on this! Catholic school teacher, former-lapsed Catholic, daughter of a Catholic child psychologist. What I offer give rn is that it's been real shady and shitty in the past (and still is in the way some religious distort the teachings) but the Catholic catechism currently says verbatim "we should not despair if the eternal salvation of persons who have taken their own lives." So absolutely the Church is responsible for the shame they have instilled. I'm SURE they contributed to the stigma. But I am grateful that if I ever hear someone say something awful about a beloved child going to hell for taking their life, I can shove this in their face and tell them to bugger off. Thanks for ready this very non-expert but passionate opinion!

Shygster

Is the suicide rate (action or ideation) more among those with ASD or ADHD? As someone with ADHD, I've had it both be worsened by, and worsen, other mental health struggles. Sometimes intrusive suicidal thoughts don't come from a sadness, but from a feeling of futility.

Sara Rogers

Sending you love and support, Richard. I hope you are getting the help you need. I'm glad you are asking the right questions for yourself. <3

Anna G

My question is similar - is there such a thing as being, like, casually suicidal? I've had pretty much the same exact thought, Richard, so you are not alone! I also get repetitive intrusive thoughts where my brain tells me I want to die, but I don't actually. It's more annoying than anything, at this point.

Sonjabird

I spent about 20 years of my life contemplating suicide. I struggled with treatment resistant depression and the thought of leaving this existence was sometimes all I could think about. Luckily my psychiatrist didn't give up on me, and we found a medication regiment that has allowed me to take my life back. Now that those thoughts are no longer in my brain, it seems so foreign to me that they ever were there. It's almost as if my brain has purposefully shut off that ability to remember those emotions. Is there an actual mechanism for this? Or just compartmentalization?

Drake Bruner

How do, in a not so awkward and sudden way, let people know you’ve attempted suicide? I’ve had several instances where people are curious why I’m so touchy when people say expressions like “kms.” I want to be able to engage in discussion with them about the topic without outright shutting them down and making them feel guilty.

gremlin kisses

First time question asker 🧡 This one hits very close to my heart. As someone who has lost a close friend to suicide, I deal a lot with feeling like I need to be there for anyone and everyone I know who is struggling mentally, even if it’s at the cost of my my own mental well-being, because I feel as though I need to be there for them so I don’t lose them to suicide too. Any thoughts on dealing with “survivors guilt” of those who have lost someone close to them by suicide? And how to preserve your own mental health when trying to help other people who are also struggling?

Katie Delaney

FTQA If a parent is at high risk of suicide action, is their child more likely to have the same challenges? Is there any kind of hereditary link that can be passed on by a biological parent to their child?

Becks Woodruff

Thank you for covering this. My best friend died by suicide in our early teens, and another close friend died by suicide a few years ago (I'm now in my 30s). I miss them both all the time. My school seemed ill-equipped to deal with my best friend's suicide (this was the early 2000s). Without getting into specifics, their handling of the situation exacerbated our trauma. Now I work in a school. Though I obviously hope no student ever dies, I also don't want to repeat my school's mistakes if it does happen. Where can I go for resources? What are the best ways to prevent the death of a student who is struggling? How can teachers and school staff best handle the aftermath of a student suicide and support the person's friends and loved ones in their grief? How can I work to bust the stigma surrounding mental health and suicidality to get people talking and encourage folks to be more open about their struggles? Again, thank you for tackling this subject. It's hard, but so, so important.

Richard Tran

Thank you Sara! Also thank you Anna. Not that I want you to feel this way, but it’s kinda nice to know I’m not the only one. Sending you big love.

Beckett Grae

First Time Question Asker: Hi! I am a survivor of a suicide attempt (some odd 15 years ago) and still struggle with self harm ideation at times. Here in BC, Canada, the mental health supports are, as many places, not up to snuff, and I want to get involved in ways other than volunteering at the crisis line. What are some things that folks can do in their communities to support positive change in access to quality (ideally free) supports for all age groups? Also how can someone get started in peer counselling?

gremlin kisses

FTQA - The rate of suicide among disabled and/or neurodivergent, (specifically autistic folks like myself) seems to be higher than that of neurotypicals or non disabled people. I know for me, the weight of dealing with the experience of being so socially different to the people around me, and experiencing sensory input at a much higher and painful level, can contribute to feelings and thoughts of suicide. How does the suicidality of disabled/neurodivergent people differ from that of non disabled/neurotypical people?

Scottie

How do we balance suicidal depictions in media vs. showcasing it/ putting the idea in people's minds. For example 13 reasons why was criticized for an increase of cases in young people when it came out

Hannah Nuest

I’ve heard there are a few places or societies where there is virtually no suicide. What makes these places unique? (Nuest pronounced Noost)

gremlin kisses

FTQA - How do we deal with the ever increasing sense of existential dread and doom, which can contribute to suicidal ideation, when the world around us feels like it’s literally falling apart, due to the climate crisis, global pandemic, and political divide?

Sam K.

Not a doctor, but the term "intrusive thoughts" like Anna referred to is a great descriptor when talking to therapists! I've worked through similar things in therapy (sudden intense/traumatic thoughts or "impulses") and learning that it's a stress response from my brain has helped with identifying and de-escalating the feelings that come with them. Sending a brain hug.

Lindsey O'Neal

First time question asker! Did the Netflix show 13 Reasons Why lead to an increase in teen deaths by suicide or teen suicide attempts? If so, why?

Chell

Seconding this question - I recall a stat being shared around that suggested that it did, but would like to know if that study was legit/reliable.

Anne

It seems teenagers have a higher rate of suicide ideology, is this accurate? If so, why is that?

terry goss

This is a very personal one for me - I have "exhibited" "Suicidal Ideation" for my entire adult life. It's a default reflex of my brain. My therapist suggested I might be suffering from dysthymia, in addition to depression, and SSRIs only partially mitigate the issue.

Chell

Thank you for covering this topic! My question is about intersections with eating disorders: to what extent is starvation-focused disordered eating treated as self-harm behavior by clinicians, and are deaths as a result of eating disorders categorized as suicide?

terry goss

Arg - Return carriage isn't a line-break, I need to remember that!.... :D - Anyway, Suicide affects others in ways that the individual engaging the act usually cannot fully expect or even comprehend (-*how* could ANYone care??), and I've seen this unfold in suicides around me; that has been a massive consideration in my not following that path: I see what it does to those close by. I'm exceptionally selfish and negatively-narcissistic, I know this, but I also have a hard time subjecting my wife to the whirlwind aftermath of suicide, not to mention family & friends. And yet, THOSE THOUGHTS PERSIST. Sometimes it's like it's not even "Me", it's as though it's my Duty, in some bizarre existential way......??

Richard Tran

Thank you Samantha, that’s helpful. Sending a brain hug right back at you.

terry goss

All of that is just the part of my brain having weird imbalances that make others genuinely confused, and makes me confused that anyone else could be so joyous about continuing Life - but doesn't even begin to address the very real fact that Human Society is crumbling, and crumbling of our own volition and desire. Even if I didn't suffer from Chronic Depression, just look at the world!! (And I'm a white man, and my wife is a black woman - holy shit, the things SHE has to deal with!!....)

Sarah Meaden

Is there data on how many suicide survivors (I don't know if that is the correct term, feel free to substitute it for something more appropriate) go into the mental health field as a career after their most intense struggles with self-harm/suicide?

Jessii Arp

Do suicides really come in groups?

Anna Guzman

Not a question but i would love it if you discussed suicide in veterinary medicine and the NOMV/NOMVSS movement. I have lost colleagues and mentors in this profession and I have struggled with suicidal ideation myself. Especially during the pandemic, burnout in our field has been worse and overall we are not okay.

Eve Ross

FTQA: what is the age distribution of deaths by suicide in the US? And attempts, if such data is available. Have heard it’s quite frequent in the elderly although most of the attention focuses on high school and college students.

terry goss

As one who suffers this way, I'd say "TALK to me, tell me what you're feeling. Just talk to me first." - sometimes just getting the words out is a massive help.

terry goss

Just offering to talk, about anything, is helpful. Sometimes just talking helps.

Riikka Puttonen

Access and opportunity increase suicide rates and we're told that rather small things, distractions and delays can make the difference between life and death by suicide. Things like limiting access to weapons or building roofs, putting up higher fences, calling someone, asking how they're really doing, encouraging cis-men especially to express their feelings and generally talking about suicide to reduce the stigma people feel about their ideations. At the same time we tell grieving loved ones that there was nothing they could do, it was going to happen anyway. How can both of these be true and how should we try to reconcile this cognitive dissonance? How is it not "our fault" if there's all these things we could do as individuals and as a society?

terry goss

For what it's worth, simply offering to be there to listen, any time, about anything, without judgement, is a big help. Just talking things out helps a lot. This is tricky though, as I believe (?) you'd be in a position to notify relevant authorities if you heard something concerning - and that might prevent someone from opening up.....?

Ashley Oki

Is it possible for the chemicals in someone’s brain to be so messed up that they’re born without the will to live?

Bee

First time listener (and question submitter); my husband has PTSD from a sexual assault, bipolar 2 disorder (aka baseline sad), and in his own words 'suicidal ideations' since he was young. I'm unsure how to support him as I'm not well versed in mental health. What can I do to help keep his baseline sad at a level that's livable? I'm always worried he might go and off himself.

Jackie Garcia

Why is it so common that when people are suicidal they are shamed about it from others instead of shown compassion?

terry goss

In my tiny experience, a lot of that is emotional backlash by people who are left shocked and confused, and unsure of how to process the situation and still live their lives. I've seen it in friends and family after suicides; I think it's a reactive thing, not a genuine assessment.....?

SueG

I am glad you are here. Thank you for speaking out.

Luna Idunna

How often is it "normal" to think about suicide? Daily? Yearly? Never? Do most people experience suicidal ideation at some point in their lives, or is it just us unlucky few? What are the stats on people who attempt but do not complete suicide as far as their recovery or relapse? I have heard lots of anecdotes of people being relieved that it didn't work, but I'd love to know what the numbers are. (Also howdy from a long time listener but first time asker!)

SueG

Unfortunately there is a very strong component of religious stigma.

Somerset Francis

Ah, are you listening to Philosophize This! by Stephen West too?

SueG

Excellent question!

Terri Fisher

1st time question asker. Can it "run" in families? I have a branch that has too many in the past generations. I grew up being told it's just what the family does.

Camille Bird

I don't have a question but I do have a graitude...thank you for choosing this as a topic. I lost my father to suicide as a very young human and as an addict in recovery have suffered through an almost lifetime of suicidal ideation. Much love to you, Alie...for choosing the hard choices, too. I'm weeping, now...and grateful for -ologies and for you.

Ashley Oki

How can high schools and colleges make students want to be honest and come forward about what they’re feeling?

Ashley Oki

In my own experience, I’ve noticed that suicidal ideation feels like an addiction. It’s familiar, feels safe in a way, and I feel lost without it. How do you break these cycles of relapse and get away from these ‘cravings’?

SueG

Excellent question!

Dave

Does dying by suicide mean that the final moment of death is caused by your own intentional action? How can we quantify deaths from addictive behavior like alcohol and drug abuse and work to address all of them as similar etymology even though the moment of death may not be intentional?

Hillary Kofsky

What are ways we can encourage someone who feels suicidal to seek out support? And how can we be a better support system for them? Are there organizations other than the suicide prevention hotline that can provide a network of support for people? And for the LGBTQ+ community- what organizations and services are out there to protect and prevent suicide. My understanding is that that community is particularly vulnerable to it.

chels

First and foremost, thank you for covering this topic. First time question asker... My best best friend since the day she was born (literally! Our moms are best friends and she was born two months after I was) died by suicide 8 years ago. She had struggled with mental health forever but her suicide was out of the blue. I have heard that there are different "types" of suicides... some are planned and some are impulsive. It makes sense but is it something that is studied? If so, how do you reach out to the impulsive people like my best friend? She showed no signs her mental health was in a bad place, left no suicide note. In fact, she had just graduated nursing school two days before. Last thing... almost one year ago I walked myself into the hospital and had myself checked in because I was in a very dark place and was thinking about taking my own life. Today, 11 months later, I can tell you all that it does get better! It is hard work but you can get through the darkness!

Jess Swann

*offer of internet hugs*

SueG

First time asking questions: 1) Are there any other animals who die from suicide? 2) Is there a connection between suicide and people who have had NDEs (Near Death Experience)? Thank you.

Erin

Death with dignity: what is the rational behind legislating against this? If someone is terminal and their quality of life is low shouldn't they have bodily autonomy with out some stranger decreeing their way is the only way? And why is this grouped in with suicide?

V.E. Griffith

I've thought about suicide as a real or preferable alternative every single day since I could put words to the concept. That is my normal. The difference is only in what's going on in my life and the state of my mental health treatment. How common is that? Most mental health professionals freak out if such things come up and want to immediately hospitalize me, but for me, it's just my normal. (I've been hospitalized, and it doesn't help -- it's only taught me to lie about what I'm thinking so I can get out and go back to work and not lose my job.)

kerry wells

Instead of a question can I make a request to mention my dad who took his life November 29, 2016? He was 65, Vietnam veteran avid lover of science. His dad also took his life when I was 15, 27 years ago. He was a WW2 veteran. Grandpa Vernon made it to 70. My dad was the smartest person I've ever met, his name was Sid Halford. He taught me all 88 constellations and inspired me to study physics. So many veterans take their lives. I wish my dad and his father could have gotten help. Suicide is so detrimental to the families. Sending love to all the families of suicide victims 🙏 ❤ 🙏

Jess Swann

I heard (somewhere...) that many people who attempt suicide by a less immediate method (say, jumping off a bridge) often have a moment when they realize they want to live partway through (like, halfway down to the water). Is that statistically prominent and what sort of psychology is happening there?

Medora Kea

I was suicidal on & off (but mostly on) for about a decade throughout high school & college. Then, I participated in a spiritual retreat where our primary directives were to keep silence and to not rush ourselves. At the end of the retreat, I felt like I was literally walking on clouds, something I've never experienced before or since, and after that, I haven't been suicidal since (it's been about 3.5 years). I'm definitely not complaining, but also, what's the scientific explanation for that??

Jess Swann

This is very vague and makes me sound like an asshole, I fear, but how can you tell when you're truly keeping someone from attempting suicide as opposed to "just" wanting attention? Where is the line as a bystander/friend/community member when you know you need to act/step in?

Jess Swann

What's the difference between suicidal thoughts and intrusive thoughts? Is there a level of imagining 'action' that separates them?

Bruce

If you have lived long enough, why isn't ok to choose your time, on your terms, to move on?

Kristen

Has there ever been any studies into if the brain physically changes for people who have attempted?

Spooky Dandy

I’ve considered ending my life before but was able to get help. One sentiment which helped to debunk the flimflam that suicide was a solution: Suicide doesn’t end the pain, it just passes to someone else. I know not everyone with suicide ideation can take comfort from those words but if there is one person out there who can, I want them to know. It can be hard to remember that there are others who know and care about you. They will never be the same if you’re gone. They will always hurt for not seeing the signs, for not doing more to help you before it was too late. The pain doesn’t end with suicide, it is merely distributed outward.

Somerset Francis

**How much of an influence are social media and the web on suicidality, and could tech companies be doing more to make the internet safe in this regard?

Sarah Schmitz

Fascinating topic. I know you will choose someone compassionate to discuss this particular -ology. I'm still recovering from my mom's life going away because she wanted it to? IDK every time I try to say suicide it just seems mechanical and strictly etymological, and there's a world more that goes into every death. So just a nice wave and maybe I will hold off until I do more therapy to listen to it. :)

Mandy Hobson

I am someone who has contemplated suicide many times and I also self-harm. I just want to know WHY? Why does someone who has a good family & friends and decent life think about ending their life?

Thompson Crue

I’ve been interested in suicidology since my first research project at 14. I think my main question is - what part of the brain is responsible for deciding whether to end ones life? I do not pass any judgement and I presume (I’m not an expert) that there are many factors at okay. I just want to understand which part of our brain makes the decision to die by suicide. Thank you.

Alli

FTQA. I’m trying to word this as best and as I can, but there’s a lot of layers here — I was wondering how physician-assisted suicide differs from what we typically consider suicide, in terms of the emotional and mental state of the person involved. How do professionals differentiate between these two types of death?

Lauren N.

FTQA: I’ve heard that the death of a parent during childhood dramatically increases the chance of suicide as an adult. Can you talk about this?

Nicole Metzger

FTQA: what are effective ways to prevent suicide contagion both short-term and long-term?

alex

Im someone whos tried firsthand. Im saying this because i want to know, whatnis the percentage of gen-z then previous generations?

Devon Glish

I am the same way and would like to know this as well.

Devon Glish

Yes, I'd love to hear about how suicide is talked about in other cultures (if it even is).

Devon Glish

This is a wonderful question. I don't consider myself suicidal anymore but when something bad happens it will almost always pop into my head, but I usually dismiss it away now whereas before I would entertain the idea. I wonder if the frequency of the thoughts is a fine line between suicidal and not?

Emma✨Rose🌹

Why does the suicidologist personally believe life to be valuable? Has studying the reasons people might want to die by suicide ever challenged that belief?

Devon Glish

What would it take to be considered a "suicidal" person? Is there a number of times one has to ponder the thought to be considered so? Or is it the amount of time one spends thinking about it overall maybe?

Rae Hebert

I’d also like to know more about the way suicide tends to be “contagious”

Sam Kilgour

Where is the line between right to die/assisted dying/euthanasia and suicide? I read an obituary recently where they said the cause of death was depression. Often a person with depression will live with it on and off for their whole life, is this any different from, for example, a cancer diagnosis?

Rae Hebert

When working with suicidal people, has there ever been a situation or a case where you couldn’t come up with any reason they shouldn’t do it aside from “it’s bad”?

Rae Hebert

What are your thoughts on 13 reasons why

Sam Kilgour

Why do some people end their life in different ways? My auntie saw someone jump off a bridge in front of a train. She described it as a "selfish way to die" because of the psychological impact of witnessing it and the many other consequences. Other people might be listed as a missing person until they're eventually found in the woods, lake, etc having taken their lives. 💔

Sam Kilgour

(last question for now!) Is suicide always caused by depression?

Alex

As a psych nurse of 10 years now working with the geriatric population, I'm wondering where the line is with a terminal patient with psychosis who wants to declare themselves a DNR. Or even a younger patient worth florid psychosis who is refusing tx for a new diagnosis of cancer that will become terminal without treatment. These situations come up frequently and aren't given much thought.

Brandon J. Willis

Ashley - sadly… you have almost exactly told my story… thank you.

Janna Wisniewski

Can you talk about what’s going on with people who die by suicide for a cause? Kamikaze pilots, suicide bombers, people in cults, etc.

Lux ❤︎

What interventions are most effective in convincing family and friends in support networks that suicide is not selfish?

Lux ❤︎

Most interventions and awareness campaigns are focused on approaching suicide intervention on an individual basis. What evidence can you speak to about it being a symptom of systemic issues such as debt, capitalism, racism, the prison industrial complex, misogyny, lack of access to healthcare, resources, community support, etc. What interventions would be effective at this systemic level?

Juliet Petrencs

If you use my question during your podcast, Please use my handle Radar the Cat, not my real name. I would like to know the suicide-ologists thoughts on Ketamine as an emergency treatment for a suicidal person? Ketamine has recently been approved for treatment-resistant depression and unlike more traditional psychiatric medications for depression works very quickly. It seems to me it would be a solution to forced (and often harmful) hospitalizations of suicidal individuals.

Emily Okerlund

THIS. I would love to hear an ologist’s answer to this ❤️

Emily Okerlund

Thank you thank you thank you for covering this topic. From someone who has dealt with suicidal ideation on and off for many years, thank you, Alie, for tackling this interview, and thank you to the ologist(s) for all of your work on this important topic. ❤️

Arianna Mattson

Suicidal ideation seems to run in my family, including myself. I’ve noticed a pattern that it starts around the age of 9 to10. Is there anything developmentally or neurologically that happen around that age that may be the cause?

Emily Okerlund

How would you recommend discussing suicide with younger children, either because someone they know dies by suicide or because they are exhibiting potentially suicidal thoughts or behaviors themselves?

Ashley Oki

Thoughts on physician assisted death? We debated this in my bioethics class but no one could come to a conclusion

Emily Okerlund

Have you ever worked with very young children who exhibit suicidal tendencies in situations without significant trauma? If so, where does this come from?

Ashley Oki

How do we talk about and raise awareness for suicide in society when it’s so sensitive/taboo?

Ashley Oki

How do you support the family members of people who have a suicide attempt/died by suicide?

Ashley Oki

I’m in a support group for college students who are going through mental health crisis’/those who’ve just gotten out of the hospital. Do you have any tips/advice for them?

Ashley Oki

Why is it so hard to reach out for help when you’re feeling suicidal? Why do we tend to self isolate in those moments?

Ashley Oki

How do you feel about media depictions of suicide- from perks of being a wallflower to 13 reasons why?

Ashley Oki

I’ve been hospitalized for a suicide attempt and one thing I noticed from the support groups is that people don’t want to get help for suicidal ideation because they don’t want to be hospitalized. When I was hospitalized, it was somewhat worse because of covid- I was isolated from friends and family. There was nothing to do because they didn’t allow you to keep anything besides a pencil and paper and I just had my depressive thoughts to occupy my time while stuck in (basically) a hallway with no windows or fresh air. There has to be a better way to do things than that.

Ashley Oki

What protections can we put in place for the mental health workers to keep them from being abused?

Ashley Oki

How should we react if someone repeatedly threatens suicide to get what they want?

Sandy Moore

Both of my brothers died by suicide. The youngest was expected, as he told us his plan for years. Attempts to help resulted in name calling and worse. My next brother died unexpectedly in late June of this year. Both were determined, any suggestions on how to prevent and cope?

Iva

I am so sorry for your loss.

Iva

Follow-up, how can a person themself recognize if they actually want to die vs they want attention? They are sometimes not in the best state of introspection in those moments to actually be able to recognize what they want.

Kata Zarándy

How to help those left behind? How can I express my compassion so that it means something? Also, I have a friend who confessed they thought about suicide but they wouldn't find the courage. This was years ago; fortunately, I never heard of the topic again. How can I make sure they never find the courage?

Natalie Pearson

First time question asker! Any advice for discussing suicide with kiddos? I work with children and generally believe they're just little humans who should be spoken to with respect and honesty. I was talking to an 8 year old about Kurt Cobain and when the issue came up, I realized that suicide is a completely foreign idea to her. Not sure how to answer questions about "how" and "why" in a way that's truthful to the complexity of mental health but also safe and not overwhelming.

Kelly Pavelich

I work at NAMI (national alliance on mental illness). You might be able to work with our chief medical officer. If you’d like me to make the connection, let me know!

Rhiannon Edwards

First question I've ever asked. Big 'ol trigger warning here. Could you discuss the ways long-term, repeated trauma affects the brain? Specifically in the context of suicide in conditions such as cPTSD and personality disorders (especially Borderline/BPD)?

Marianne Thomas

It often bugs me to hear people talk about suicide prevention, because- when I was suicidal- it felt like taking agency away from the person. Like saying "you don't know what you're doing", when a person might have spent a really long time thinking about it. The worst thing after one of my attempts was my friends saying things like "please don't do anything stupid". Of course, now my life is excellent and I'm so glad I wasn't successful. I'm stuck on the language though- how do we talk about prevention without wing patronising & implying people don't know their own minds?

Marianne Thomas

*being. Without being patronising! The edit function is tricky on mobile 😳

Aurel Chaoul Pelleg

Is there a connection between suicide and heroism (self-sacrifice)?

Annika

In my family we have had close family friends die by suicide unexpectedly, how do you move on when it’s so sudden, heartbreaking and unexpected? What signs can we look out for in the future? The only person who saw that something was wrong when I was struggling was a teacher, not my family or my friends. I don’t know what he saw that made him react, but he got me help and helped me inform my family. Also, how do you talk about it without people getting uncomfortable? How do you politely tell someone it’s not something funny to joke about and that it hurts people? I have had experience in life when people joke around and when I point out that it isn’t a joking matter they get upset and say I’m sensitive and that you can joke about everything. I’ve even had people tell me in not allowed to be sensitive about it because I’ve not experienced loss as a result of death by suicide without knowing anything about me. If I point out that it’s happened close to my family and has been a struggle for me as well as a teenager struggling with a undiagnosed mental disorder (adhd) they look horrified and get away from me the conversation as soon as possible. Why is that?

Rita Barroso

Hi there! First time question asker too and apologies if someone has asked the same but, is there any connection between suicidal tendencies and hormonal imbalance? I think that might be the reason why I struggle with this issue (since I'm 10/12) - no family history.

Kai Kishimoto

Have there been any studies on educating teens about suicide leading to lower suicide rates in their futures?

Valerie Jaruzel

Check out the PrepareU curriculum. It was created by a group of psychotherapists, one of which specializes in suicide. It has gone through high schools in almost half the states at this point, has good data to back up its efficacy, and is an absolute resource for educators looking to breach mental health issues. 🖤 PrepareU dot live is the address and Ryan Beale (head guy and former business partner of my husband) is the guy to contact if you need any help figuring things out.

Galeet Cohen

I teach at a high school, and the move whenever a suicide occurs (ugh what a tragic phrase) is to not talk about it in any broadcast way for fear of creating a cluster. I want to trust that it's the right thing to do...but is it really?

Valerie Jaruzel

What a tough topic to take on, kudos to you for being brave. I’m married to a psychologist and I think some of the hardest stories that trickle over (absolutely unidentifiable) are the “f*ck you” suicides people perform as a giant middle finger to the people in their lives on their way out. Very messy, resulting in extra complicating the grief process for survivors. I imagine there is immense suffering all the way around in these instances. Therapy is an absolute viable option to process that grief, and I guess my question echos what others have asked, but, how can we be there as laypeople for those left to clean up the mess? I know there is immense power in just being there and not avoiding being around the people we care about during these painful processes but gosh I want a step further.

Matthew Sparks

Why do some people feel like they are a ‘coward’ or a ‘failure’ when they cannot go through with suicide? What is happening psychologically?

anthony willis

In their research, what methods have they found that works best when a friend or even a stranger comes to you and expresses their feelings or thoughts about suicide? Are there ways that can make the conversation easier? How should one even address it if someone brought those feelings up to someone they know or care about?

Mar Gosselar

No questions, just a thank you for covering this. It’s gonna be hard to listen to. Necessary and hard.

Bridget White

Has there been a study on the average length of time someone goes from thinking about suicide to dying by suicide? I was privileged enough to get help and find help over the last 15 years. What are some of the reasons people don't have access to help?

Emma Tweten

I’ve had a couple people close to me die by suicide, several of my friends attempt, and I have also experienced suicidal ideation since I was 14. A common theme I have seen in us is the idea of selfishness. I have heard my friends say that their attempt was so selfish and they hate themselves for it. But isn’t your brain so neurologically messed up that it is very very hard to think about anything but the overwhelming desire to die, especially when everything feels so extremely hopeless? Suicidal ideation and depression are so overpowering, I have a hard time seeing the act or thoughts as selfish when they’re so impossible to control.

Hannah Miles

FTQA. I actually have two! As someone who is slightly more introverted, it is hard for me to approach people sometimes when I sense them struggling as I don’t want to seem all up in their business. Any advice for fellow introverts on how to best support those who we feel need that support? Second question: I have been closely impacted by suicide unfortunately, and always want to reach out to those when I see them impacted as well. I remember how overwhelming it was having so many people speak to you immediately after. Is it better to reach out and support immediately following, a few weeks later when things calm down, or both? Always afraid of overwhelming people, especially during such an emotionally fragile time.

Taylor Price

I imagine we've come a long way since Durkheim wrote Suicide... what's new? What does the field think of that really old book, or have they moved passed it?

Sara Nelson

Is suicide a reasonable choice given certain conditions?

Florpin M

Why is it that women attempt suicide more often, but men succeed more often?

Rose Moon

How to we support children of people who have died by suicide? I'm thinking of how to help them cope with the grief but also how to help them not be angry with the parent who "abandoned" them.

Rachel Hungerford

My father died by suicide and I've often wondered how long he had this end in mind. Specifically, he used to say things like "I would die for you" a lot and that haunts me because it seems as though he decided we would be better off without him. Maybe? I'm not sure. Any thoughts on how long people plan their suicides would be appreciated.

Ričards Kaupužs

First of all, thank you for covering such complex and serious topic, Alie. As for the questions, how recent did the phenomenon of dying by suicide emerge? Has it been only the last few centuries or have we done it as far back as we could form complex thoughts? Also, do any other animals die by suicide intentionally?

Shannon Montague

Has there been any data observed that shows how to grieve well? Survivors/Victims seem to struggle in a variety of ways.

Ashley Oki

How do you feel about the romanticization of suicide in pieces such as Romeo and Juliet? Sorry for all the questions Alie, but this is an issue that’s very personal to me and I would love some answers

Ashley Oki

In my own experience, I’ve observed students that are in the gifted programs and go to academic schools with high standards, the students’ mental health seems to be neglected in favor of better grades. Is there any data that follows this trend?

Jessica Chance

I would love to know this too. I also would love to hear a discussion about how we find the balance between needing to talk about suicide and suicidal thoughts to let people know they're not alone, offer resources - and how that feels risky because shows like 13 Reasons Why or news of high profile deaths by suicide seem to trigger others to do the same. It feels like a lose-lose situation.

Jessica Chance

This is a great question. What are the similarities and differences between what we typically consider deaths by suicide and deaths of despair?

Jessica Chance

I have the same question. Has there been any significant evolution over the past several decades in how we think about physician-assisted suicide, culturally or legislatively?

Jessica Chance

Hi Natalie - at the risk of committing a party foul by recommending a different podcast, I wanted to mention This American Life Episode #557 Birds and Bees, the segment called "About That Farm Upstate." It's a really moving piece about helping kids process death, including suicide, by being very honest with them and helping them find good outlets for their feelings. It changed a lot about how I think about talking about death with everyone, including little ones.

Eric Hortop

Where's the line between ideation and just thinking about suicide and scenarios involving oneself? Is there one? What are helping pros' responsibilities when they hear about suicide-related thoughts? What about us civilians? (Pronouns he/him, FTQA)

Sammy

I'm also very interested in this! Additionally, how have the societal attitudes surrounding suicide evolved through the years? And where do you see them trending toward? (FTQA, they/them)

Katy Yoshimura

FTQA - What are some of the lesser known or recognized signs of someone who is thinking about/planning a suicide?

Katy Yoshimura

I also just want to say thank you for discussing such a hard, complex topic that has affected so many people.

Cat Baklarz

I'd like to ask something about the way social media screens the word "suicide" - and if you see that as a good/bad/neutral thing. Gen Z calls it "un-aliving yourself" in part because of TikTok censorship, but we use this term in real life too. Does it matter what we call it?

Cat Baklarz

Also, what do you do when a friend constantly talks about suicide, but you're not sure how to react because you've already had this conversation... But they could be serious?

Alaina Militello

FTQA and I have a whole lot of them but I’m sure so much will be covered based on the other comments. Where is society as a whole at with physician-assisted suicide? What makes someone an eligible candidate? Also, how do you feel about media coverage when a celebrity dies by suicide? Is there an appropriate or most respectful way for news outlets and other media sources to cover these situations?

Amanda DuShane

FTQA: Is if possible to know that if a person never had exposure to suicide or the idea of it, that they would still kill themselves? Are there places or cultures where suicide is not stigmatized?

Lee T.

Is it true that anti-depressants can, for certain people, temporarily increase one’s risk of death by suicide? If so, why aren’t those at higher risk monitored more closely? Why prescribe them at all for high-risk individuals?

Lee T.

I second this inquiry. Two high schoolers in my district died by suicide last week… and I want to add to Galeet’s question: Has the pandemic affected community cohesion and connection? Our student response was wildly incongruent with what I anticipated. Instead of mourning, grief, reverence, or even a little respect, students were mostly unaware and/or unaffected by these tragedies just 4 days apart. The teachers, on the other hand… So yes, galeet, question the administrative response! And try to do what’s right for your kids. We teachers have a tough job but I really think the best thing we can do is to show up and show we care.

David

I don't have a specific question, but I want to thank you Dad Ward for tackling this very important, and very emotional issue. I'm looking forward to this episode even more than usual!

Sandra Dunlap

1. Are there any correlations with suicide rates and religious/non-religious people? 2. Are there any animals that die by suicide?

Somerset Francis

I second this question, and I have long wondered, why is "suicide terrorism" called cowardly? As terrible as it is, I always assumed that it must take quite a lot of courage?

Nikki DeMarco

Has there been any data on suicide and the pandemic? Specifically teens or young adults. I’m a teacher and while suicide is an unfortunate reality in my profession, it feels like rates have gone up during virtual school.

Danae DeJournett

I’ve heard of something called “passively suicidal” that I feel I went through for some rough years and I was wondering if that was an official term somewhere? Is that an actual thing? I feel like maybe people don’t know there’s a spectrum of active and passive. Like some people have a plan and the will to execute and then there are people that just wish a car would hit them while they cross the street or wonder what would happen if they drove into a tree. Also can we talk about how wild it is that you can be in the throes of a depressive episode and think that the people around you are selfish for keeping you there when you just want the pain to stop and then you come out of it and your worldview shifts. How can we flip flop so hard between both viewpoints with the same brain?

Danae DeJournett

Technically some mama animals are kind of committing suicide by having their kids because they eat their mother (spider?) or the mother starves to death raising them (octopus). That’s the first thing that comes to mind. And also, wow does that suck…

Doug Paice

I second the questions on the line between suicidal ideation and being actually suicidal. But my real question is around coping with the guilt of making an attempt. Is it useful to hold on to that as a protective thing? Not guilt for failing, but guilt for trying. Background and content warning, mention of a past attempt. So, I survived a suicide attempt last year (long story, but I'm doing well now and am doing ALL the therapy) I was admitted to an inpatient program the next day. After I started to improve, I got hit with a wall of guilt and shame about what the impact would have been on my family: taking away their husband, dad, son, brother.... I was told it was probably a helpful guilt as it can be protective. I know I wasnlook back and say "what was I thinking?" but I know I wasn't thinking "amygdala hijack", no rational thought. I just wanted it all to stop.

Danae DeJournett

Also, why do you sometimes just snap out of a depressive episode? How can it hit you with no warning and then suddenly you’re fine in the middle of the day on a Tuesday and able to function again? ALSO, maybe talk again about the way depression gets you when you’re concussed because it wants you to lie down so the brain can heal. Stupid brain…

Karen

Hello Dad Ward. I think you might find this interesting. Veterinarians have the highest suicide rate of any profession. 7x the national average. Here is a link to one of our support groups. https://nomv.org/ Thank you for all you do.

frances they them

Should suicidal people be medicated (because of all of the risks of taking medications such as SSRIs)? What have you found is the best advice for suicidal individuals? Is there anything that you can do to help someone who is suicidal?

Kristen Carroll

FTQA: Do you think that medically assisted suicide should be available to everyone? What regulations or procedures do you think should be in place for this type of service?

Kim C

I'm mostly wondering about what those people around those who are suicidal can do to be supportive, and to try to get it across that we're here and want to help? I went through the angsty teenage years where it seemed like a portion of people had suicidal thoughts that you kind of grow out of, but then there are those in my family who have mental and physical trauma who I don't want to go down that road (and hey, found out those stats about vets b/c they were looking at entering that field), friends trying to support trans children who have suicidal thoughts, and I currently work as a civilian in National Defence where there are a portion of people who choose suicide. So I'd really like to know if there are specific tactics to use to let people who are vulnerable know that you love them and want to help in whatever way you can.

Reuben Clamzo

I am, and I often wonder about issues where science and philosophy intersect.

Erica Zalk

How do we open this conversation with friends and family who are/have been previously unwilling to talk about this and get this conversation on the table?

Chelsie Webster

We lost a family member to suicide during the pandemic - can you speak to the connection of depression, suicide & Covid 19? And the potential cultural ramifications that may come post pandemic and how we can help mitigate those ramifications 🤍 glad you are bringing awareness to this issue 💕

Monika Blue (they)

Is it true that everyone thinks about suicide? How much suicidal ideation is too much SI?

Laura Stacey

What do we know about suicidality as it relates to the lgbtq community?

Lauren Mappledoram

First time question asker! What are your thoughts on the presence of suicide forums online? Are they judgement free places to discuss suicidal feelings anonymously or are they dangerous?

Aven

I remember when my uncle committed suicide his older brother was somewhat cruel to my grandmother and told her he wasn’t going to heaven so why have a service in church. I was in middle school at the time and remember not being able to understand why he would say something so cruel. How does suicide affect the normal grief process of the family and friends? Is there a different psychological impact or stats regarding how people cope with that differently than non suicide deaths?

Leanna Shuster

How much does historical record accurately portray the frequency of suicide in past eras? Does this differ by culture?

Jennifer Green

What's up with the rule of threes on celebrity suicides?

Eberheardt Wilson

First Time Question Asker! Will you do a deep dive on how historically suicide became an uncomfortable/taboo/shameful experience for the families that experience it? For instance, parents who lost a child to suicide have often hidden the cause of death to their friends/relatives out of shame, guilt, etc. Where did this notion come from? Is it more or less prevalent now compared to the past in our American culture and cultures of the world?

Tim Ward

I, too, am concerned about this. My step children's father was killed by his brother in a murder/suicide at a family gathering, in front of the children. I worry for them that the depression that may have been prevalent in their father's family is now exacerbated by the loss of their father coupled with the PTSD of being a witness to it.

Miriam Felton

My friend is doing her doctorate in the topic. I know she's an ologies fan and if she can't talk about it, she could probably tell you who to talk to. I'll give her a heads up and ask her to contact you.

Beatrice Au

Why is suicide considered so bad or negative? We often died not by choice (old age, accident, illness), but in the case of suicide, it is a choice? Why is it so stigmatized as a negative kind of death?

Rae Press

FTQA - If we understand that suicidality has been and is a part of life, what can we do in our relationships, our communities, and our societies to offer meaningful support and reduce the likelihood of dying by suicide? I mean the big building-the-world-we-want-to-see, transformative stuff. Where can we start and what could we build to? Thanks!

Elizabeth Loxterkamp

Can you please speak on the topic of passive suicidality? I know people will sometimes put themselves in risky situations because of a 'I could die in this, but don't care' mindset. What's the best way to treat this form of suicidal ideation?

Amanda Gripe

Pamela Wible, MD...expert in physician suicide (as in physicians who die by suicide, not those that assist others). Refer to her "Do No Harm" film.

Julia

How do structural inequities impact suicide rates and demographics? Can suicide be passed down genetically, like depression, anxiety and other mental health issues?

Emma Fiori

This is such such such an important topic, and one I am very personally involved in. My question is why can't suicide be an acceptable end to a lifetime of suffering? Suicide after a temporary heartbreak or the like, and certainly teenage suicide are probably 99% tragedies that ended what could have been a good life. But for those of us who have struggled severely for 20+ years with depression and have tried every possible available treatment including all of the out of the box options, and have never improved? The need for medical intervention for depression is often compared to the same need when an arm is broken. Why then is an intentional and peaceful end to a lifelong disease of suffering considered to be so horrible and tragic? Why cant friends and family who have seen a loved one in so much pain be happy for them when they are finally released from the bounds of this world and allowed to finally be at peace, just as someone dying from cancer would be uplifted by family happy for the end of their suffering?

Fwaeldling

not sure if we are too late for this... a love of my friend chose suicide.. (imo committed is an judgmental word) after months of crippling depression, they didn't seem to have planned it (for very long); going of on the plans they made with other people that evening and weeks after. is it true that many suicides (that end in death) haven't been planned on, but are more of an impuls decision made in minutes to hours.

Fwaeldling

is there research being done in people who tried suicide, but it didn't end in death. what's the best way to help people deal with the aftermath of the TS? thanks Dadward

Allie

Is it dangerous to make jokes such as “wow I’m going to kill myself” while you are depressed and dealing with suicide idealization? Will it make you more likely to try or does it desensitize you to the topic?

Chelsea Mullen

I don’t know how to phrase the question that I want to ask, or even figure out the question I want to ask. But I just want to say thank you, for covering this topic. And all of the topics you cover, but especially this one. My dad died by suicide 6 years ago, and this is definitely an important topic for me. Thank you ❤️❤️

Scot Nickels

Good to see this subject as an ologies! My wife and I had an incident recently while pulling into an isolated non-designated camp site. We were just passing through spending one night on a rushed end of our trip, when we came upon a troubled soul who had just injured himself in a quad accident. He told us his difficult life story, as we tended to him, and he spoke of suicide. He was alone, but family was coming that night he told us, which was obvious given what he had already set up at the campsite. He had injured himself (not sure that this was an attempt or not) as he had also been drinking which likely lead to the accident. We talked quite a while, hugged often, and hoped we convinced him to sleep it off until his family arrived. When we woke early the next morning we saw that his family had arrived during the night. Everyone was still sleeping. It still haunts me thinking about the choice presented to us at that moment. Do we wake them up and discreetly (it looked like they had several children) speak about the previous nights events, or do we leave the family to best deal with it? I have been taught in these situations to always leave word with someone, but in this instance, being the wee hours of the morning, many hours away from the nearest hospital, and no cell service, it was difficult to know what to do. This is of course a very short synopsis of the real events, but do you have any advise on what would be the best possible course of actions to take in this instance? Suicide certainly leaves an enduring mark on those touched by it, even for those distantly and suddenly engaged with it for only a few hours.

Meg Ahern

I appreciate this question. I've only heard suicidal ideation discussed as basically a self-esteem issue, with remedies like "think about how many people love you" or "think about the good you could do in the world." But does the field have ways to think about how to address those for whom it's more about feeling that life brings too much suffering and pain? Like it's a raw deal? (I'm not implying there isn't hope for this too; just haven't heard it addressed in helpful ways in public settings.)

Meg Ahern

I'm so sorry for your loss.

Julie Spradley

Has there been any work done on identifying when impulsive suicide (like stepping in front of a train on impulse vs. planning it all out) is most likely?

Elexander Weil

Asking if you could discuss the neuroscience behind this phenomenon! What chemicals and structures in the brain are involved in the reaction to/triggering the symptoms of suicidal ideation? What's [chemically] going on during a depressive vs a suicidal episode & how/when do they overlap? Thanks!!

Anna Schmiel

Are there really higher rates of suicide among young men? I'm not trying to downplay that as a very real problem, but as a young woman who has both experienced suicide ideation and has had a couple of female friends experience it as well, this statistic has always surprised me. Do women just not go through with it? Are they more likely to seek help?

Anna Vilnīte

*first time question asker* (last name pronounced like "veal-neat-eh" :) First of all, thank you for talking about this!! My question is - could you please explain more in depth what suicidal ideation is and how it can present? I've never said I've dealt with it because I have never actively thought of harming myself directly, but during my first heavy depressive episode I spent most of my days in bed either sleeping or wishing I was dead. I had no intention to do anything, I just kinda hoped not to wake up some day soon. I also thought about all my friends and family and what each of them would do if I died, and while I didn't want to make them sad, I was too tired and sleepy to care so there was no feeling of guilt in wanting to die. Does this *count*? Please validate my belonging to least *some* club, even if it's the literal suicide squad. Otherwise I kinda feel like I'm not 'sick enough' to deserve the care I try to take of myself.

renata mirón

A photograph of a falling man from one of the Twin Towers on the 9/11 terror attack was published in the NY Times and was received with horror. In the photo however, the man is still alive, he is a live person jumping into a death of his own choice. He chose to die by the fall rather than the flames or smoke. The fact that the public received this image with fear troubles me. How do you think we can start to talk about choice and suicide, how do we overcome the stigma of suicide and our fear of death?

Alanna Richman

Is there an evolutionary/biological explanation for why suicidal thoughts are so common among our species?

Erin Nansel

Is there any research identifying younger children to determine if they’re at a higher risk of suicide and if there is any early prevention? I’m talking elementary age or earlier.

Daphne McKee

Can they say more explaining/demystifying the data about rising incidence of suicide in Black children? saw scattered media reports

Daphne McKee

Also I used to volunteer for the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline and I am here for ANY and ALL shade and public airing of bad experiences people have had with the hotline. Understaffed, untrained volunteers, not good coverage, etc. My experience is with a crisis center in Memphis, Tennessee but I wanna talk to any and everyone who’s done this work tbh

Daphne McKee

Also—do people who have survived suicide attempts generally report that residential mental health treatment helped them?

lordofthefries

Is there any chemical difference going on between those who experience only suicidal ideation but don't act on it and those who do? When I've felt extremely depressed, I think constantly about wanting to die or stop existing, but I could never actually harm myself because I fear the pain involved.

Emily Krenzer

Is there an evolutionary explanation for suicide/suicidal ideation? I find it interesting that as suicide rates rise, and children experience suicidal ideation younger and younger (I started at 6) I just guess I want to know- why? Is it ONLY a result of chemical imbalance or is there something else behind it?

Emily Krenzer

Are there any studies or evidence that suggest living a non traditional lifestyle (i.e. living off the grid, homesteading, not living in a big city and devoting 40 hours/week of your life to a demanding office job) reduce suicide rates/ instances of ideation? I often feel that the stresses that lead to my ideation would be significantly lessened if I was able to transition to a lifestyle that better suits my neurodivergency.

Alicia Geilen

If you are concerned someone is at risk of self-harm, is there anything you suggest to try and stay connected. so they know they're not alone?

Emily Krenzer

Very interested in this as my ideation started in elementary school

Alicia Geilen

Can you speak about survivors' guilt? The brother of a dear friend died by suicide and she was wracked by guilt for a very long time, thinking she "should have seen it coming" or "should have done something".

Meg Ahern

This is such an important question.

Meg Ahern

Anecdotal, but this resonates with me! I was struggling with this in July, and once I took a break from work, started unplugging from stressors, focused on dealing with my emotions, and went for daily walks in the woods, the ideation went away after about a week. N=1, but fwiw. Learning more about high sensitivity has been helpful too in thinking about longer-term changes to make in my life.

Miriam Felton

If you're still looking for people to interview this is what my friend studying Suicidology recommended. April Foreman (works with Louisiana Veterans, has been the head of the American Assoc of Suicidology) and Thomas Joiner (Florida State U, also works with the military, wrote a book debunking suicide myths)

Kelly Lewis

I have a question please (my first one!) Why do some people plan and write notes and some people are more sudden and don't write notes (from an 8 times suicide attempt survivor who has never written a note and never planned for longer than half an hour)

natashaski

I just learned about an organization called “Mission 22.” They focus on providing resources for veterans who may be experiencing thoughts of suicide. (The 22 is to represent the 22 veterans who die by suicide, daily - and the mission is to reduce/eliminate these deaths). I learned about this organization when a friend invited me to do a 22-kilometer walk in South Dakota, with the local chapter. I wonder, in what ways can non-military people help in a genuine way, even if they don’t “know what it’s like” from experience? And this maybe translates to anyone experiencing suicidal thoughts. How can someone approach the conversation with an understanding of our common humanity, and the understanding of pain/loss/hopelessness/stuck-ness/etc. in a meaningful way?

Natalie Pearson

Thank you Jessica! Never too many podcast recommendations

Nuala A

Thank you thank you thank you for this ! I think it's so important to talk about suicide as a social reality, and as a situation which has existed in every culture throughout history. It's a subject I would find fascinating to study one day if I ever have the time and mental stability. My question is why are uncompleted (failed) suicide attempts so often brushed off as 'attention seeking' or 'not serious enough'? Is it a gender/age/ethnicity specific situation? I personally think young women are more often dismissed in this way than other people, but I was wondering if there is any evidence for this and if it differs in different cultures/societies.

SteeljawPanda

Any non-obvious tips on dealing with suicidal thoughts would be welcome…?

Dani Cav

How can I do better about talking to my friends and family about experiencing suicidal ideations? I’m doing better now but the pandemic dropped me back down. I tried to be honest with what I was experiencing without scaring them. No plans, not in immediate danger but the potential to get there was present. I was able to get my meds changed and started seeing a counselor again (SHOUT OUT TO BETTERHELP!!!🌱) and that made a huge difference. But I’m not sure how to talk about it without scaring them. It’s something I live with and have lived with for most of my life and don’t really have any good resources on it.

Dani Cav

I did this a few years ago, change my life to suit my needs, and while it did help tremendously, for me me it never really goes away. It’s always there but most days it’s not bad. The bad days do suck but I have a pseudo-mantra of “try again tomorrow”. My thinking is, if I can make it to tomorrow, than there’s hope for a better day. I do think that I wouldn’t have survived if I had kept trying to live a “normal” life. And while I do get flak from family sometimes, most have seen the improvement and are supportive!

degrees_of_freedom

What is the science on how and when to use trigger warnings on topics like suicide? Do trigger warnings function different for different trauma, on average? Basically, do trigger warnings work and what are best practices today?

Daphne McKee

Oof, def second this. My leanings are toward using TWs …very sparingly and only for extreme material, but I wanna know more of the scientific research about it

Daphne McKee

I have no science to add here, just wanna say as a random stranger 💪💪💪💪 v proud of you for doing all the (extremely shitty and difficult) work to come back from suicide attempts. People don’t realize how hard it is and this rando is cheering you on 💚 Residential/inpatient treatment sucks in so many ways, and anybody who comes through that in one piece is tough af in my book

Sharika Elahi

Why is suicide a sin in so many religions? Even as a child I thought this was crazy and made no sense, why do so many people in the world think it's the fault of the person who died from suicide?

Phoebe

Has the typical profile for someone more "at-risk" for suicide changed in the last couple of years? I'm thinking of factors unique to the world's situation right now like the influence of social media to the economy to the pandemic. I don't know if the current climate has statistically shifted the age, gender, occupation, mental health, cultural background, etc. of someone considered more likely to experience suicidal ideation or actions.

Dana McKenna

May be a bit late to add this thought, but the second season of the podcast Last Day is all about suicide and it is discussed in a really thoughtful way. The first season was about opioid addiction, also a really important and relevant issue. The host, Stephanie Wittels Wachs, is great.

Sonjabird

Wondering if you could talk about suicidal teenagers, and resources to help their families. My teen is currently being hospitalized for suicide attempts and I am so frightened to have him back home. This has changed the entire family dynamic.

Katie Murray

Have you (whatever expert you choose) done any research into physician assisted death in the elderly and terminally ill? I’m a hospice nurse and have had some ethical dissonance when I think about some of my patients not being “allowed” to end their lives as they wish (in this state at least).

Katie Murray

** < forgot to put those on the last comment. Also any advice for how to support someone who recently attempted? Contact is limited for now due to a wilderness therapy program, but is it mostly a play-it-by-ear situation when you’re around them next? And totally depends on the person and where their frame of mind seems to be at the moment?

Michelle

Have suicide rates gone up since 2020?

Ilse Van Meerbeek

What would/do you say to people who say that suicide is selfish?

Theresa Egan

What may lead someone to suicide if they do not have any mental health issues?

Freek de Bruijn

Many people have a negative association with suicide and would like to prevent it in all cases. In some countries (like the Netherlands, were I live), it is possible to commit physician-assisted suicide (euthanasia). If it is consciously decided, well thought-through and legally validated, would most people still consider it bad or merciful to accept someone's personal decision?

Bethany Goodine

Why is suicide such a taboo topic to talk about?

Aoife Holmes

I used to at risk of death by suicide and thanks to so much help I am better now. But what I found very difficult to overcome and still struggle with is. My reason for being alive is because dying would hurt the people around me. It is so hard to find self worth after being told over and over again that I shouldn't die because it would hurt others. What can we tell people who are struggling that will keep them both safe and some level of self worth intact? What can we tell people who are struggling other than think of your family? Is it possible to convince someone in that state of their own self worth?

BatRachy

Hopefully not too late on this one. First time question-asker from the UK here. How it the huge gaping chasm reduced between all mental health support/advice being "ask for help, got to A&E, you need help if you're planning suicide or have suicidal thoughts/urges" and the reality of A&E psych and crisis teams rejecting you because "if you were actually suicidal you would have just done it"? The system is broken, how can the way of thinking start to be fixed (other than a new government)? Also huge thank you to everyone involved foe covering this, as someone who has/is battling suicidal thoughts/urges/attempts for over 20yrs more conversation is needed globally 💜