Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

What’s up with boosters? And gathering for the holidays? Why do breakthrough infections happen? How will this January be different from last January?

All these questions — plus yours — as I get an update from your favorite Vaccine Infodemiologist Jessica Malaty Rivera! Let’s do this.

With a sore arm + a lot of hope,

Ol Ward

Comments

Timmy H.

If we are triple vaccinated do we need a mask still?

Timmy H.

Can we mix vaccines?

Lina Zikas

Boosters vs delta? Why is delta so powerful?

Timmy H.

What are the breakthrough infection numbers?

Cameron Brown

Will we need to get boosters once a year or what will be the procedure to remain fully vaxxed?

Mitchell Johnson

How do the PCR or antibody tests differentiate between the antibodies incurred from vaccinations versus those of an infection?

Vanessa Frey

Is it safe to get the Pfizer booster shot and a flu shot on the same day?

Kata Zarándy

What's up with the effects of the 2nd and 3rd shot? Why is it worse than the first one? (real question: Why did I get so miserable after my third vax?)

lousy cowboy

do you think we will ever be able to go back to living "normally" ie no masks or precautions? *

Kira Gowan

I got my second J&J dose in March (clinical trials ftw!) Is there any information on how long boosted antibodies last?

Deacon Raid

There’s been reports of some animals getting COVID-19 (cats, dogs, tigers, minks, and white tailed deer???) Will we see vaccines for them at any point?

Risa

What vaccine and booster combinations have been the most effective so far? Are there any that produce a larger or broader antibody response? I got J&J with a Modena booster. 😁

Kathleen Sachs

I got a Pfizer COVID booster and the flu shot at the same time. The combination knocked me on my ass. I had a headache and was tired the rest of the weekend. Is this generally not a good idea to do both together? Also, my husband claims that it was the flu shot that knocked me out, but I think he’s making things up.

Arianna Mattson

I got covid in March of 2020 and then I got the Johnson and Johnson vaccine in April and then had phantosmia for six months. I saw an ENT and a neurologist and structurally I am fine but both agreed that it may be a side effect. Has this been a common side effect? I don’t want it to happen again and am wondering if I should try Moderna or Pfizer but I don’t know which would be the best way to go.

Silvia Triverio

Hey, got my third dose few weeks ago as I am immunocompromised, still around me at school and work there are several unvaccinated people who also use masks poorly. What can I do to help them understand how important the vaccine and the masks are? Thanks!

Allison D.

My friend has had tinnitus since her vaccination in August. Her doctor therefore recommended she not get the second vaccination, and now her antibody test shows she has no immunity to Covid. Would a booster shot be ok for her due to the smaller amount of vaccine?

Greg Walloch

I've heard a lot about hybrid immunity, where a person had covid early and then both Moderna vaccines. Therefore supposedly giving them a more robust immunity, suggesting they may not need a booster. Is this true?

Kathleen Sachs

What changes that were made during the pandemic that you think is going to become a permanent fixture of our society?

Kelly Shaver

Is it true that high-risk people like me who got the booster are also going to be told to get another full dose soon?

Alexandre Catulle

In the spirit of debunking some of the bull sh*t going around. What are some of the worst fake news out there?

Lucy L.

Yes THIS. And not to be overly dramatic but WHEEEEENNNNN WILL IT ENNNNNND?!?! And how will we ever recover from excessive anxiety/depression as a society?

Kathleen Sachs

Cats who are infected with a feline coronavirus develop FIP (Feline Infectious Peritonitis) in some instances. FIP causes fluid build up in the chest cavity and lungs. How similar is FIP to ARDS (Acute Respiratory Syndrome) in humans. Can anti-virals used in humans also be used in cats (and vice versa)? Have we already found a drug that works for both humans and cats? Will we one day be able to give our pet cat an mRNA vaccine that would prevent FIP? Have treatments used in sick cats also influenced the way we have treated people experiencing ARDS?

Alia Myers

I recently read an article that said in cases where people have gone to the ICU for covid, patients who are on SSRIs have a way higher recovery rate.... What's up with that?

Michael Kovall

Why are we getting this booster so early compared to the tetanus booster?

Lucy L.

I feel bad about getting a booster when parts of the world haven't been vaccinated at all. Anything we can do as individuals to help share resources on the global level?

Alia Myers

So is corona officially endemic or is it too early to know?

Jennasis

My 11 year old is now eligible for the vaccine. But she just had her 11 year shots and boosters. Is there research specifically on interactions with other vaccines. When should I have her get it? Btw don't read this part out loud but I changed my Patreon name for online safety reasons. I used to use my real name phonetically spelled out but now that I started my own podcast I use my online name on all the things.

Alia Myers

As of now, which animals do we know can transmit and/or contract covid?

Ashley Kelly

For people who recovered from covid with no lingering symptoms, it it possible to start having difficulty breathing when climbing stairs 7-8 months post recovery?

Susan G

Remdesivir is a drug that was initially used in cats for FIP treatment, that has since been used to help treat people with COVID. I am not sure of the specifics with regards to human treatment, but in the cat world it has changed FIP from a fatal disease to one with hope!

Kathleen Sachs

Tangentially related…are we actually making the problem worse when we spend our time and energy debunking fake news? “No, Aunt Ruth, horse dewormer really can’t be used to treat COVID.” Are we just giving people spouting blatantly untrue information too much attention? Finally, what are more effective ways of convincing anti-vaxxers to take the vaccine? A nurse managed to convince a friend’s mom to the get the vaccine after said friend had been begging her to get vaccinated for months. I would love to know what the nurse said that managed to get her to change her mind so quickly?

Kathleen Sachs

I would love to go back to teaching, in person, with no mask. Making myself understood in a second language is hard when wearing a mask. When will things go back to normal enough that we will be able to safely remove our masks? One year? Two years? Five?

SamSo

So excited for this update episode!! I'm struggling with the amount of misinformation and hatred there is out there with regards to public health - how do you balance your mental health needs with continuing to advocate for public health? How can we ensure that the next generation has the tools to battle mis/disinformation? Even if this question doesn't get asked - thank you Jessica and Alie for doing this and all of your work.

jac

What are the current findings regarding the long-term effects of contracting covid-19? How long are covid-19 vaccines effective?

Jazmine alexandra

What are some good resources to share with family members who haven’t/won’t get vaccinated? Or what is the most effective way to approach that conversation?

Rebekah Hatherly

Should Christmas be cancelled this year? Are we going to have a COVID-19 vaccine booster annually like the flu shot, but mandatory?

Michael Swords

Myocarditis - I had read that the risk for males 17 - 27 was higher. What's up with that? Is there any more data?

Maja Lecher

First-time question asker here! How likely is it that a vaccine will be developed that can prevent virus transmission? And would the working principle of a vaccine like that differ from the ones we have at the moment?

Megan Ramirez

Hello! Long time lurker, first time question asker. I currently live in the UK where I recently read that a pill has now been approved to help treat symptomatic COVID. What's Molnupiravir's deal? How do anti-viral pills work, and are there other things like it in development?

Liser K

Should people be getting their antibodies tested before getting booster? What are the health risks if you get the booster and already have enough antibodies?

Ira Gray

I am unclear on the ethics of getting a booster when so many people around the world have been unable to access the first dose. Should I get the booster the the 6 month mark or abstain? Are other countries authorizing a booster and if so which ones? (They/them)

Ira Gray

Also Ive heard some tests are less effective at detecting some of the new variants, is this true? If so which tests are the least likely to give a false negative/best to use? (They/them)

Sophie Whitaker

Respiratory therapist from the frontlines here, what research has been done regarding the various treatments? Does proning really help long term, or is it just a bandaid?

Emily Knight

(first time questions asker) with hindsight, what should actually have been done around the world as soon as there was news of a virus outbreak in china?

John Worster

This year I've had so many shots in my left arm. A shot for the flu, shingles (2 shots), 2 shots plus a booster for rona, can your shoulder build up scar tissue from getting so many shots in the same place?

Brandi Harbaugh

Hello! I had COVID and now I am experiencing some side effects from the virus, mostly just a shortness of breath and having a little more difficult time with breathing when doing activities. I’ve been doing exercises and trying to help myself get better, but my question is: have there been any research on how people who have lasting effects from the virus can they worsen if they get covid again? Also: how can we really tell the difference if we have covid versus a sinus infection, or even just the flu? I know people have been getting sick recently, but when should we worry it may be covid creeping it way in and not the flu or a sinus infection?

MB

I have a toddler (16 months, currently). From the data I've seen, his risk of complications and death from COVID are lower in his unvaccinated state than mine at age 35 fully vaccinated plus booster. Is this true? (Note: We're still in mostly quarantine because of his vaccine status and that likely won't change until he's vaccinated, but he starts group daycare in January and I'm panicked).

Breanne Adkins

KIDS! I have 6, 4, and 1 year old smologites. We live on a military installation. Masks are required indoors everywhere and there is no wiggle room on that. The 6 and 4 year olds go to school, masked, on post. All three are very healthy. Please give me all the reasons that the oldest should still be vaccinated. My husband is concerned that the benefits don't outweigh the risks and that in our situation the kids don't need to be vaccinated. (Took him a while to finally get his own shot as well.)

Breanne Adkins

As an aside, if you have any tips on convincing 6yos that shots aren't the devil's work, that would be much appreciated. K, thanks, burbye.

Matt Ceccato

My first Moderna shot wiped me out for a day. My second one did not. What can I expect after my booster?

Samantha Mitts

Does the booster have to be the same brand as your first two shots?

Ally Tylock

Lets talk about the most recent NIH data about mixing and matching vaccine types with your booster! Im in a clinical research trial for Janssen/J&J, and thru that study I was vaccinated in March 2021. Last week, I had a routine bloodwork visit, and since boosters had just been approved in NY state for everyone 18+, they offered me a J&J booster at that time. But I asked to talk with the study doctor about some articles i had seen about mixing it up w the booster, and she basically told me I am better off getting an mRNA based booster, and showed me a graphic compiling data from the recent NIH studies showing that if you got J&J for your initial vaccine, getting either Pfizer or Moderna as your booster is significantly more effective and causes much higher antibody production levels. Can yall discuss why mixing the adenovirus vector vaccine with the mRNA based vaccines is so much more effective than sticking with J&J for the initial and booster? Whats up with that! Edit to add: I was able to book an appt online for 2 days later at Walgreens, and got my Pfizer booster on Friday! Had a slight headache and a very sore arm yesterday, but nothing crazy. Feeling good about my decision, and a bit less worried about getting sick over the holiday season 💖

Lucian Stern

With so much vaccine hesitancy in the US (and some abroad), what is a realistic expectation of the next 5-10 years if anti-vaxxers don't get the jab? Will COVID variants progressively get less deadly to keep the host alive and healthy enough to spread? Will it stay just as deadly until we get everyone on board?

Jeremy Roszko

I can't help but question the effectiveness of the vaccine. I'm got my J&J back in March, an shave been fortunate enough to stay clear of this awful disease, but mostly by being careful. Previous vaccines such as MMR and Tetanus actually prevent you from even contracting the disease. This vaccine has 3 different options, which never has even been a factor in vaccines of the past. No option prevents you from getting Covid, they all just reduce the potency of the disease. In that sense, it seems no different from the flu vaccine, which is about 50% effective from my understanding. I desperately want this vaccine to work, but it does not seem like the answer. So how effective is this vaccine? Is any research being done to come up with a better vaccine that can actually prevent the disease from being contracted? Or is there another answer to this pandemic?

Cheese

I've heard from several friends that since they got the vaccine (any brand) that their periods were out of control, one for months. Do we have any idea why that may be?

Raelee Grimm

Hi! Question regarding our littlest smologites. I have an almost 1 year old that is still nursing. I'm fully vaccinated and got a booster at the end of September. What's the data on any protection transmitting to her through my breast milk? My 5 year old will get his second dose on Dec. 1. Hoping my family is fairly protected so we can be a smidge more social around the holidays. Thanks!!

Cheese

You have to consider the history of the vaccines you're comparing against. The tetanus vaccine has been in the works for over a hundred years, and it only used to work for like a month before you were vulnerable again. The measles vaccine was in the works for 10 years before it was licensed. You're right in that it's not 100% the answer but it's the best thing we have to gain greater public immunity to keep moving forward and allow the medical community the breathing room to work on something better.

Vesper Holly

I got the booster (Pfizer) two days ago and feel like I’ve been hit by a bus. Similar symptoms to the second dose with extreme muscle aches and an inability to manage my body temp (shivering and sweating buckets).. Other people I know had absolutely zero symptoms after their booster. What’s going on there? Is it because I still had rockin’ antibodies? (Or am I just a Namby-Pamby?) Should we be testing for antibodies before getting the booster? And are there any concerns with getting the booster when we still have antibodies? With uncontrollable shivers + lots of hope.

Margaret Downs

What's the story on mixing and matching mRNA vaccines? I've read some things that suggest it may increase effectiveness. I'm in the group of people who "may" get a booster and I plan to do so before traveling for Christmas. I had Moderna the first go-round and my current plan is to get Pfizer if it's offered where I go.

Vesper Holly

Have you been checked for a blood clot? This is what happened to my mom months after she had Covid, she had a blood clot develop in her lung, and has since been dealing with excessive fluid buildup as well. I hope this is not the case with you, take care!

Vesper Holly

I was told it’s “not recommended”, why is that?

Vesper Holly

This is some pretty extreme and extended trauma. I feel like mental health services should be subsidized in the same way the vaccines are.

aedy miller

One of the biggest problems (in America) has been a lack of community responsibility. As in, people can do whatever they want to keep themselves safe, regardless of whether they’re endangering others or not. “It’s my choice” only goes so far when your choices directly impact the health and well-being of others. Of course, individualism is more America than apple pie, but why is it the case that so many people actively or unconsciously seem to not care about the consequences of their actions on others?

Chanelle Zap

We've got two immunocompromised/auto immune disease peeps in our family. Neither had strong reactions to either dose so we're worried there might not be much of an immune response. I've heard there might be a different vacine type in the works for later this year/early next. Would it be worth waiting for that or should we just get whatever booster we can asap?

Vesper Holly

I was told it was “not recommended “ to get them both on the same day, so I opted for the Pfizer booster, and it still knocked me on my ass. I think we were both just “lucky” that way. I’m wondering if it means we still had plenty of antibodies. Which begs the question, should we be testing for antibodies before getting the booster?

James Nance

Long time listener, first time question asker! My girlfriend is type-1 diabetic and her blood glucose levels are usually high when she gets sick. Do vaccines affect blood sugar in the same way? Thank you for all you do!

Lauren Cooper

How do you think mRNA vaccines could help us fight other diseases in the future?

Tess Hebert

I got my booster a week and a half ago. I was really hoping by the time I'd be eligible for a booster, we'd have a new version of the vaccine better equipped to handle delta. Is there any timeline for a new vaccine at this point? And will I have to wait 6 months to get it if a new one does come out, since I just got my booster?

Jackie Wydra

At first I heard the recommended booster time was 8 months, and now I hear that it's 6... There still seems to be so much conflicting information and no cohesive plan within or between states in the US... What gives?

Catie Noble

Will I need another booster at some point? Like a 4th shot?

Cassandra Rodrigues

Would love to hear Jessica’s thoughts on regular COVID testing in vaccinated populations: I’ve wondered why this is not a widespread thing when we know that vaccinated peeps are less likely to be symptomatic with COViD and even though transmission rates are lower, they are not zero- is it not worth the kerfuffle?

Britt Kline

D I T T Ooooooo!!! Adendum: HOW do we let go of the rage that this behavior inspires?! It is so divisive (the behavior - but also the rage)...I want to accept and respect and have comapssion and love our fellows and all that...But man. I am WIPED tha EFF out from the stress that this behavior engenders in me, and then the rage that wells up...So many whammies. Help out? I mean, yes, meditation, and breathwork and such...But...Just...Woof. So exhausted. I wish we could make people understand science and actual facts, to begin to mitigate/eliminate this sort of struggle. Where do we start?

Rob Lara

I just got the kiddos vaccinated and my wife and I did the booster shots at the same time. Pray tell what does the future hold?! Kid boosters? Regular yearly Covid/flu shots?

Igorina

Should we expect boosters regularly in the future? Similarly like a yearly flu shot. Every year you get poked and hope they planned for the right variants.

Jess Swann

Genuinely - am I a fool for considering traveling at Christmas? I have a complicated web of family members making various choices depending on how they rate their health vs their emotional relationships with others and I just... I don't know. I want a solid answer but of course there is no solid answer and I'm not really expecting the ologist to give me one. But does Jessica have any insight at all?

Jess Swann

More of a scientific question - is there a time period after the booster until it 'takes effect' or some equivalent? If I get the booster and then see someone three days later, am I 'covered' by whatever good the booster does?

E-Veh-Lease Sanchez

For the love of God, when will it end?! I'm an ER nurse, and I'm tired. All the adults in my family are vaccinated and boosted! My middle child is fully vaxxed and my youngest just got his first dose! But I'm not going to lie, the breakthrough infections in vaccinated people are upsetting! Most of my patients that have had breakthrough infections are and are vaxxed are discharged home--which is wonderful and means the vaccine is keeping people out of the hospital. But I want to live again! It's been so hard to balance being safe with trying to do things like gathering for dinner. Thanks, Ivelisse (The "I" is pronounced E as in Ian)

Theodwyn6137

Yes, this! (And as an aside, my husband's response is, "When you were doing this "research," were you wearing pants?")

Sara Wells

My understanding is that the efficacy rates are pretty high comparably, so I wonder if ones like MMR seem more effective simply because more people get them so there’s less virus going around to catch? Maybe the ologist can speak to that?

Lauren Harter

How worried are you about covid spreading among deer in the U.S.?

Sara Wells

^ THIS. Maybe we need a sociologist or social historian to help us sort this out, but really interested in commentary here. I constantly see myself sacrificing for others when they won’t sacrifice for me. Why is a “we’re in this together” mentality not more popular?

Paul Rosen

At the beginning of all this we were told to wash our hands for 20 seconds. I haven't heard anything about that since, though. Is it still believed to help? If so, does it also help with preventing colds and flu and other things? In general, what is the recommended length of time to wash?

Beth Van Eman

I recently got the booster and flu shot at the same time. Had a bad reaction about twelve hours later -- racing heart for more than 12 hours. I also had flu-like symptoms, but it was the racing heart that was really bad. I'm assuming covid boosters are going to be in our lives for the foreseeable future, so..... how bad is it to get two different types of shots at once? Best to avoid?

Heather Goble

Should you get cross vaccinated? Like if I got Pfizer should I get a Moderna booster?

Sara Wells

It seems to me that a lot of the issue were having is that people stopped trusting government, official info channels, public health officials, etc. Interested in any commentary on when this happened, why/how, and how we might regain that trust.

Emma Draughn

Will there eventually be a Tamaflu-esque treatment for those who believe they may have come into contact with someone with Covid?

Sara Wells

+1 — What does this look like in 2 years? 5 years? 10 years?

Parks

What do you feel are the ethics of getting a booster if you are a two doses in, healthy and under age 45? Knowing the WHO position and that many countries don’t have vaccine access yet. Personally I got one because my Doctor advised me too, and not getting one doesn’t mean that dose goes somewhere else, it only means that dose sits in my Doctor’s office and possibly goes to waste, but what can we do to help others who don’t have privileged access?

Cate Strehlow

Same-ish question. We have friends in a different major city asking us to visit over the holidays. Our friends play it fast and loose with COVID guidelines. (We are fully vaccinated and boostered due to our occupations). Is going completely idiotic?

Alice Rubin

I live thousands of miles away from my family and have been isolating and masking (in fact, double masking) since March 2020. I'm vaccinated and am planning to get a booster. I am struggling with going to airports and getting on planes. Besides not travelling, what are the best practices to ensure safe air travel?

Cate Strehlow

My husband and I are exposed to unmasked and (many) unvaccinated people daily at work; we are vaccinated and have had boosters. We have been getting tested twice a week. Is that a waste of resources?

Cheryl Kolatorowicz

Can you talk in general about the vaccines and kids? Especially those who are hesitant about the long term effects of the vaccine? I’m sad that several of my family members are not getting their kids vaccinated. Some worrying about the reproductive issue and some about heart issues.

Rebecca Shay

This was my question too! Mix and match or stick with 1 brand?

Cate Strehlow

This! I am in contact with unmasked and unvaccinated people every day. (I wear a mask and have been shot a 3rd time.) Thanks, Dad!

Omennik

Interesting, I just got both on the same day, this last Thursday. Though I remember them wanting to wait two weeks between on the first round. I just figured I'd go for it and get two bingo squares covered in one sitting.

Cate Strehlow

Eek! I got the Moderna 3rd shot and the flu shot on the same day. I was VERY tired for 24 hours afterward.

Vanessa Frey

Nik E Thistle did you feel okay afterward?

JM

How high-risk is pregnancy for the pregnant person if already boosted? I remember the low lung capacity of my first, and how many colds I picked up. Terrified of being higher risk but we've put off our plans for too long in hopes of an impossible covid-free future date to have number two. My OB is non-committal on risk.

Aoife Holmes

WHEN DOES IT END?!? I am from Ireland and it looks like we may be heading into another lockdown some time soon. I thought that the vaccines would end the lockdowns but I am losing hope and I feel awful about it all. Please tell me when it will end

BeckytheSassySeagrassScientist

Will mixing and matching vax’s give me immuno super powers? What about the idea that the worse you feel the next day the better it works? If that’s true I must be invincible!

BeckytheSassySeagrassScientist

So once and for all, how contagious are you if vaxed? How susceptible to getting it are you if vaxed? This has been so confusing throughout

Alannah Wood

Do lockdowns work? From an Australian perspective I think they do but we still are getting protests. Is 80%vax rate high enough to drop restrictions?

Zoltán Szászi

What do they expect from the future? If this disease is here to stay, what happens if a seasonal coronavirus outbreak coincides with an epidemic of another serious respiratory disease?

Ms. DEENA SAHI

Hi. Why are parents who have gotten the vaccine readily but are apprehensive to getting their children vaccinated? It is frustrating

Ella Shively

How do we make sure non-COVID patients get the care they need when hospitals are already overburdened with COVID cases?

Emily

I’ve had my third vaccine booster. When can I go back to normal? I mean eating at crowded restaurants, going to holiday parties, nor worrying about if I need to wear the N95 or if the cloth mask is ok normal.

James Jakes

If you contract COVID, but were vaccinated beforehand, is there a waiting period for the booster, or could/should you get it right away?

Paul Hossfield

I have been geeking out SO MUCH during the pandemic, but I often detect holes in my background knowledge, especially when listening to high-end podcasts like "This Week in Virology," Could you recommend any good books about virology and/or immunology for someone who hasn't seen the inside of a biology textbook in over 40 years?

Orrin Stanforth

Will I ever be able to eat in a busy restaurant with out fear again? What about vacations?

Elina

So are we going to have to get boosters regularly from now on? How often? Every 6 months? Once a year? Or is it going to keep mutating every year like influenza?

Annalise De Young

Cervidological and or zoonotic illness question: I live in Michigan, where white tailed deer are almost as ubiquitous as squirrels. Studies are showing the deer population is full of SARS-COV2. Its pretty clear Bambi & friends got this from humans, but unclear whether they can give it back. How will we know if they can give it back? What will it take for it to make the jump? I'm especially concerned since the deer are a top game species, which means humans do come in contact with their bodily fluids.

Laura Acosta

Hi! According to google around 59% of the US population is vaccinated, but I was wondering how accurate that is? I say this because I'm an international student whose Central American relatives have flown to the US to get their vaccines because there is such a delay in our countries. And they don't have to present residency status or anything at Walgreens or wherever you get your shot. Are their shots counted as "US citizen vaccination" ? Do you think this group is big enough to be of significance? Is it possible the US could overestimate how well protected their population is for another variant?

mtcoz

I don't know how to ask this question without sounding completely ignorant but what do I say to friends and family who say "well we won't even know if vaccines are safe until 2023" and also "I personally know someone who said someone died from a car crash but the hospital reported it as COVID so therefore COVID is a hoax." Maybe this isn't a valid question for this episode but like is there somewhere I can get 3 undisputed facts to respond to these people with? Agh.

Ologies with Alie Ward

Oooh great question -- I woulda forgotten to ask about this but the COVID rates in deer seem to be BANANAS dude

Matt Jolliff

Why do bats in particular seem to get blamed for new or emerging diseases?

Mark Hewlette

In reading the data on breakthrough cases, it seems that the older you get (particularly past 80), the less effective the vaccine and the more likely you may be to have a breakthrough infection. It seems as you age, your immune system isn't quite as strong anymore? If the vaccine's job is to "alert your immune system" to the potential presence of the virus, this can only work if your immune system is up for the job. Is this right? Beside staying fit and healthy, is there anything else our older population can do to increase their odds agains this and other harmful infections? Seems as a population, having a higher rate of vaccinations would go a long way correct?

Clayton Cromley

WTF? How do we square Colorado's 81% vaccination rate and 419 case rate per 100k against Georgia's 49% and 96 case rate? The topic may come up at Thanksgiving

David Villafranco

vaccine or natural survivng the disease, which is better ? both maybe?

Allen Lee Palmgren

Vaccines ... they don't stop the spread of a disease. They give individual bodies the tools they need to fight an infection. People contacting people is what spreads the virus. Getting a vaccine gives an individual the antibodies to help fight the virus. But if an individual chooses to mingle with other people their chance of an encounter with the virus increases. If unvaccinated an individual runs an increased risk of hospitalization and/or serious complications from a virus. If vaccinated an individual may still get sick but their chances of serious complications are reduced. Of course, individual immune system capabilities are also a factor. Bit strong or weak immune system, a vaccine gives a body more of a fighting chance to overcome the virus rather than the virus overcoming a body. The weekend before last I attended a punk rock concert. I was on the floor with a thousand other jumping, sweating bodies. Was I exposed to the coronavirus? I am sure I was. Was I worried? No. I am vaccinated and boostered. I expect I will contract this virus sometime before I die but because I am vaccinated appropriately my body has the tools it needs to fight off the virus. Does this mean I won't spread the virus if I come in contact with it? No. If I am exposed I will most likely expose others. And if those others are vaccinated they are most likely alright. If they aren't vaccinated ... Imagine two soldiers walking into a firefight. One soldier has on full body armor while the other has nothing more than his/her helmet. The soldier in full body armor stands a much higher chance of walking out of the firefight than the unprotected soldier. The protected soldier might get a small wound or two but survivability is greatly increased by wearing the armor. It's really that simple.

ALEX ERHARD

Any suggestions for those with autoimmune diseases who may not make antibodies?

Marcus Harvison

With family members who are immunocompromised, and the never ending feeling of new variants popping up, many of us feel as if there is no end to this even though we are vaccinated and boosted. What sort of vaccination percentage of the population would it take for immunocompromised people to have a confidence that they can leave the house?

Meg Ahern

I'm not an expert, but as an obsessive reader: Get all the boosters you can, and then really lean on the other measures -- avoiding travel/crowds, and wearing a good, well-fitted filtration mask like an N95, KN95, or KF94 whenever you're around people outside your household. Personally I wear an N95 on the rare occasion I have to go inside a building that's not my house, and then a KN95 or KF94 for passing others during hikes or having outdoor meetups with friends. (FWIW, KF94s are more comfortable but slightly harder to put on/take off, so KN95s are good for the hiking situation where you're just putting it on when you're encountering others.)

Meg Ahern

You see this in other countries too. It's partly about testing, but largely an example of how vaccination is just part of the picture. It's essential but, contrary to what many Americans believe, it doesn't mean that other measures are no longer needed. Containment measures have a huge (sometimes bigger) impact on controlling the spread than vaccination alone.

Meg Ahern

This is a great question. I'm not aware of any system that is tracking which vaccinated people are US residents. I'm not sure how many people are flying in for vaccines but would guess this is not accounted for. But the bottom line is, 59% is already far too low to be in the ballpark of being a well-protected population, unfortunately.

Meg Ahern

What basis would there be to suggest they could not give it back? If the virus has gone this readily from humans to many other species, wouldn't it just go both ways?

Meg Ahern

This was a great episode -- thank you so much! The only point that might deserve correction was that a PCR test can let you know "for sure" whether or not you have COVID. While it's certainly better than a rapid test, it can still have high false-negative rates especially if you are testing earlier than 3 days or later than 5 days after exposure. (False-positive rates are extremely low, though, so a positive result can be considered "for sure.") The most substantial study on this still seems to be this one from 2020: https://doi.org/10.7326/M20-1495 I've been searching for something like it that would update for Delta, but to no avail. (The optimal testing window would now be earlier, though -- we do have data to show the most viral shedding for Delta is 3-5 days after exposure.) False negatives are challenging to study, so it's good to be aware of how poor our data are. I was hoping the sensitivity of the test was better with Delta since Delta tends to involve a lot more viral material, but haven't been able to find data on that (if anyone has found a good study on this, please let me know)! (There's a lot of incorrect information circulating, such as websites that cite a low number for the false-negative rate of PCR tests but it turns out that number is actually just the discordance, or difference between different tests.)

Clayton Cromley

Thanks Meg! Your assertion is backed by published data (https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0249891). I'm having trouble accepting that Georgia is doing the containment measures that much more diligently than Colorado. At least to my tiny brain, their 49% vax rate means around half of Georgians think COVID's probably not that big a deal, which should logically lead to lower containment adherence. [I've lived in both so I'm bringing my own biases to the table.]

Roxanna McLaughlin

Is there a sure fire way to determine when I should get a test? I have allergies that gift me with runny nose, sore throat at times, etc. And if my Neto pot rinse flushes out a little bloody mucous, but I have no other symptoms, should I get tested for the Rona? Thanks!

Hanna Vaughan

I hear so many contradicting statements from trusted sources and for the whole pandemic I've been blind to whats really going on and I've lost trust for all sources of information. Sos

Meg Ahern

That's a fair point. I don't know what to say about that. All I can offer is that anecdotally it seems that some people avoid masks because they DGAF while others avoid masks now even though they wore them earlier because they've gotten the message that the pandemic is over if you're vaccinated (grrr). Maybe there are other things going on in these two states... Anyway thanks for this great article!

Meg Ahern

Besides not travelling, you could wear an N95 and face shield, and try to eat/drink beforehand so that you don't have to take your mask off on the plane, if possible. If you absolutely must take it off for a second, do so when the plane is in the air -- that's when the powerful ventilation system is on and it's safer than the airport, any public bathroom, or when the plane is on the ground. And then of course be touch-aware and keep your hands clean. If I were visiting family, I'd also try to shower and change before touching anyone.

The Deal with Animals- Podcast

What's up with our dogs and cats getting covid? What's the latest research on whether they can give it back to us?

Popita

Will this ever go away or just keep mutating? Will I have to get boosted every four months and wear a mask the rest of my life? I know the answer is we don’t know but is there a potential for it to go away? It seems like every pandemic has disappeared at some point.

Matthew Thomas Hill

What is the deal with spike proteins going around the body causing pronoems, or is that flimflam?

Julie Bernicker

Hey Alie and all fellow ologites! I am a new Patreon user, so sorry if this is stated somewhere else, but when will this episode be finalized/released? how far in advance do we need to submit questions? I listened to an older episode with Ms. Rivera, but have a lot more/different questions since things keep changing so quickly!