Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

How do you feel about your knees? A LOT OF US HAVE THOUGHTS. Drag up a chair on the porch with me and San Francisco orthopedic surgeon Dr. Kevin Stone, who has fixed ballet knees, sports knees, injury knees, arthritis knees, Jarrett knee and more. 

Also for some reason the asides just...really ... went places. I debated cutting some down but you know what -- you need to know this trivia and bizarre medical history.  

Okay let me know how you felt about it. I'm all ears. Also, Livestream tomorrow and if your tier is included you should have received the YouTube link! 1pm Pacific, Sat. Dec 18. I have STORIES to tell, people. 

Hearts and high fives and knee creaks,

Ur Dad

Files

Genicular Traumatology (BAD KNEES) with Kevin Stone - alie ward

How do your knees feel? How do YOU feel about your knees? Buckle up to better your relationship with what some listeners call their most hated and contentious joint. Globally-lauded orthopedic surgeon Dr. Kevin Stone agreed to sit on a porch and explain everything from cracking to popping, patellas

Comments

bee

Please, please, please do an episode with Aubrey Gordon! She is @yrfatfriend all over the place & is the co-host of the outstanding pod (with lots of receipts) Maintenance Phase. I wholeheartedly second Ren’s sadness about the fat phobia. I thought your aside was mostly good, but there is SO MUCH BIAS in science & medicine that goes unchecked, and so many fat people who cannot get treatment for anything they have, because doctors will flat out refuse to listen to anything they have to say unless and until they lose weight. Additionally, a lot of fat phobia is rooted in racism and ableism. Love you and Ologies SO much, but please try to hear this in a non-defensive way. There is a lot of good science that proves that fatness isn’t the evil it’s made out to be, but that science runs counter to so many multi-billion dollar industries and power structures, so unsurprisingly it doesn’t get the consideration that it should.

Ren

I gotta say, as a fat person with healthy knees despite a long history of playing a sport that is VERY hard on knees (I can't tell you how many buff people's ACLs I've seen tear irl), I was bummed out by the lack of push back on how "weight optimization"" actually looks irl, particularly given how much emerging research we're seeing that says that we Just Don't Know how to achieve significant weight loss and maintain it. Doctors love to throw "lose weight" at us fat folk for literally everything, but medicine doesn't have an answer on how to actually do that successfully over the long-term so instead doctors can just keep writing off our legitimate medical concerns because we didn't listen to them.

Ologies with Alie Ward

Hey PJ, thanks for the comment, and that's awesome that you have been able to be so athletic your whole life and haven't had knee problems. That muscle you've built is probably keeping your knees well supported and happy, as Jarrett and I were just lamenting how we have been less active and have lost a lot of muscle and conditioning over the pandemic, and that shift is one reason his knee went out. Your thoughts above are exactly why I included such a lengthy* aside about causation vs. correlation in terms of weight and knees, BMI controversy, and anecdotes from so many self identified fat people about their own knee experiences. We also covered how movement is key to keeping knees working well, best lower impact options, cited studies on osteoarthritis, included thoughts from someone who studies the biomechanics of osteoarthritis and body mass, and covered specific nutritional advice Dr. Stone gives his patients looking to change body composition. So I really thought we had it covered. But a subsequent episode on physiology and weight would be wonderful, and that would be a great place to dive into the specifics of weight, “optimal” weights, long term maintenance, ableism in medicine and media, film flam etc. Let me know if that's something you'd want to hear! (*no joke, I spent probably 10-12 hours on just that one aside between research, consulting with a trusted and paid anti-ableism advocate, reading blogs, articles, and poring over studies. So it definitely matters to me, and I'm happy to dive into it deeper on a future episode.) Sometimes I wish these episodes were 6 hours long and came out once a month. ❤️

gg

Thank you for asking, my knees are just fine and seem to have a nice bend to them. (1) Knew a lady whose doctor told her she needs surgery and she asked for other options. He said no. So she waited ten years for the development of arthroscopic surgery and was happy with the results. Had a wife who when she was with Solidarity in Poland thought she needed to go under the knife but was told the medicine here is not so good so you should tough it out with physical therapy. Hurt a lot but ever since she's a runner and an ICU nurse. Is going under the knife still a thing? (2) Can you recover from being "knee capped?" I see it being done in movies and it seems painful but can you walk after reconstructive surgery? (3) They 3D print everything these days. Can someone print a knee cap?

Emilio Chacon

With having a cadaver, is it possible to train a leg back to a strength before the injury that put the cadaver there in the first place? Or are they permanently unhealable?

The Spider Incident

At the very end you mention a possible episode on ADHD. I'm in my early 30s, and have been managing an anxiety disorder with moderate success for a while now. Just last year I was diagnosed with ADHD, and SO MUCH about myself and my past just clicked into place and made sense. My treatment plan shifted and is working better. All this to say...I'd love to hear an episode on ADHD, especially if it includes a discussion about how it looks when it's diagnosed in adults. (I am male, but I was not the "typical" ADD hyperactive rambunctious boy).

Ologies with Alie Ward

Also I'm sorry -- this reply is really long and earnestly, it's a bit defensive. Which isn't super mature of me. Sometimes it can feel tough to make sure that every base is really well covered and I do put so much effort in that direction -- particularly for this one -- so I didn't take that criticism with quite enough grace. I'm sorry. And though there wasn't room -- or frankly the relevant expertise -- to cover it in the knee episode, I think an episode about weight management and body composition is a great idea and I would love to do that if you have any names of folks you'd like to suggest. Some topics are tougher than others because there are differing opinions, or perspectives that might not arise until after you've posted it. So my apologies for the long reply aside about the long aside and again, I'm thankful you brought it up and that your knees are a-okay, Definitely recommend buying a used convertible instead of a new ACL also.

Ren

No, Alie! I totally get it and I appreciate knowing a bit more about how the episodes take shape. I am similarly defensive about doctors discussing weight loss since a lot of fat folks have had experiences with fatphobia in medicine. I really appreciate this!

Ologies with Alie Ward

Aw man thanks for saying that. I was worried I didya a double dirty. Intentions and impact are different, I know, and I always appreciate learning perspectives and amplifying them. ❤️❤️❤️

BolognaShoes

DITTO. I'm in my early 30s and trying to get a diagnosis. Given everything I know about it through my own research and talking to other adults with a diagnosis, I'm sure I have it and would LOVE for my insurance to cover treatment!

Beverly Sobelman

OK first, very stoked to have my question included in the episode. W00t! Although he didn't exactly answer it but so it goes. Second, I had a "Say what?" moment when you mentioned that the back of the knee is called a "hough." As it happens, we in the circus biz sometimes refer to hanging by your knees from a trapeze as being "in hocks" and I never knew where that came from. NOW I DO. https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/hough

Emma Van Huss

I’ve been listening to Ologies for about a year and hearing you mention you might make an episode about ADHD made me zoom over to Patreon to become a patron to keep a look out for it. I can’t believe I haven’t become a patron earlier! An episode about ADHD would absolutely tickle me pink! I’m in my early 20s and I’ve been struggling for years with managing it and now that I’m getting older I’m realizing how much it effects me. I’m *quietly and politely* BEGGING for an episode on it. Loved learning about knees ❤️ keep up the good work, you’re an angel ❤️❤️

Ted Vician

Ted’s helpful observation: you can’t drive stick after dislocating your kneecap. I dislocated my left knee playing volleyball (wooo! Ambulance ride!). My kneecap moved back into place, so no surgery, just several months of treatment and physical therapy. Couldn’t drive myself to work for a month or so because my options were my stick-shift car (lots of left leg motion) or my motorcycle (use left leg to hold up when stopped).

Rice G.

HELLO. I see I'm not the first person who had this reaction but--I've thought about becoming a patron for awhile, and even the casual threat of doing an ADHD episode was enough incentive for me to finally do so. I've had it my whole life (currently in my late 20's), diagnosed very young, and have gone through a lot of different coping strategies at different phases of my life. It's a very complex and misunderstood condition! It's also got an interesting but not well understood relationship and overlap with ASD. My only request would be, if possible, to pick an expert who either also lives with ADHD or a similar neurodivergent condition, since they tend to have more empathetic and nuanced understanding of what it's like to live with my weird brain! And if you have a possible diagnosis on the horizon--best of luck to you. It's scary, but sometimes it feels good to be like, "oh, that's why my brain does that!" Thank you for all your hard work ❤️