Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Um pardon me what? Cycads. Thems a plant, an ancient one and they look like pineapples and also palm trees? But also: THE DRAMA. They are stolen and traded and on the black market and it’s nuts. Leave your questions for Nathalie Nagalingum, Ph.D., the Associate Curator of Botany & McAllister Chair of Botany at the CA Academy of Sciences. I love her.

Okay, leave questions below! Lemme know if I’ve never said your name on the show — or if I’ve said it wrongly!

Botantically yours,

Ward

Comments

Lulu Hall

you said my name correctly and I love you. I’m excited to think of all the questions I have about these plants after I hear the interview I never think of questions until we dish a little first you know?

RJ Doidge

This needs a dramatic Netflix documentary. Get on that Dadward. Can’t wait to learn more about this!

Jules Kingsland

Why are they so weird and scary and cool

Emily Krieger

Is it correct that I tell my kids cycads were around when dinos were? Pls say yes. Also, thank you for doing a deep dive on these lesser known plants, I'm excited to learn more!

Rose Scherer

Are the stolen and trafficked cycads only fossils or are they also living plants?

Joe Mueller

Is there any possibility of these plants being brought back to life or is the environmental issues currently not suitable?

Rose Scherer

Is there any cycad evidence found in coprolite fossils?

Gerald Thompson

YESSSSSS! We have one native species of cycled here in Florida called Coontie that has a crazy conservation story. It's highly poisonous but the local indigenous peoples somehow learned how to make bread out it by fermenting the roots, but it got over harvested post-colonization, to the point they though the Atala butterfly that used it as a host plant went extinct. So my two questions are: what type of uses do these poisonous non-flowering plants provide for wildlife around the world, and how many cultures around the world use them for food?

Kairsti

First time question asker :) In reference to Sagos - Are these actually poisonous to doggos? What about kids? Are they an invasive species to TX and FL? Should I not plant them in my yard???

Mia Manzer

Ayyo first time question asker! Was googling online, but why are these so rare? and follow up, why are they values so much for gardens? Thanks!

JENN 'Benthopelagic squirrel' ALVAREZ

Someone "glares at neighbor with new landscaping" dug mine out of my yard 100 yrs ago. Also, iirc the seeds cause serious issues for puppers who chew on them.

renee fezatte

i read that they were around during the same time as dinosaurs?!?! how prominent were they and what factors have led them to become an endangered species?

Aki

I hear these plants can host many things. What are some of the most unusual things that have been found in Cycads?

Liz

I honestly have no idea what this is - however, really looking forward to learning more! Teach me!!

Emma Garschagen

Hi it’s me - first time Q asker, love you long time! ‘Garsch’ like marsh, ‘a’ like what the dentist tells you to say, ‘gen’ rhymes with begin.. hope that helps. Anyways, these look like palms but they’re not? How and why? Also, i read that various parts are poisonous? In various ways? Neurotoxins and poisonous seeds? Is this true of all cycads? And how are some parts edible? Would dinosaurs have eaten these? Thanks Xoxo

Gina Woolsey

What can these types of plants tell us about botany from millions of years ago?

Scottie

Is a palm tree a true tree? My ex insisted it's not ...

Spencer Parks

Do people think you study cicadas?

Caitlyn Powell

What is it about cyads that helped them survive so many extinction events?!

Gina Woolsey

What's the weirdest feature of these ancient plants/

Jacob Bowman

First time question asker here! I read on wikipedia that cycads are often pollinated by a specific species of beetle. Have cycads evolved any specific features that make them more noticeable for these beetles (like orchids and wasps)?

Joseph Wooten

Hey unrelated but wanted to say hello in hopes you see this Alie. Want to say thank you so much for creating a space for someone like me with adhd to learn about the science they love without having to read it in a book....forget it.... and read it again. I'm a young aspiring entomologist who's always eager to see a new podcast about insects and the strange science that come with it. Once again thank you 😊 and hell maybe one day I'll get to be a guest🐜🪲🐝🐛🦗🕷🪳🐞🦋

Caitlyn Powell

Why do they grow so slow? What's the evolutionary advantage there?

Molly Johnson

So they're not pineapples? Are the pineapple looking things on them be edible (or could dinosaurs eat them?)

Chels Davis

Not a question, but: heck yeah dinosaur plants! :D

MB

This is more about toxicity to mammals, buuut... Most toxic plants taste bad, but apparently toxic cycads taste good. Why? Are they just so primordial that they predate this evolutionary trend? Were they not toxic to the animals when they evolved? Do they hold a grudge against our ancestors for eating their ancestors?

Marcus Harvison

I read that because of the rarer species being so few populated, that natural fertilization doesn't take place anymore. Would cloning bring enough population to help bring back a large enough population? Or would the genetic pool be too small for that to help?

Noah Siem

Is it true that cycads are pollinated by beetles because they existed before bees evolved?? (1st time QA)

Eric Girard

Can humans eat them and if so what do they taste like and where can I get one?

Ashley Platz

Cicadas vs Cockroaches: who lives longer

Jess Loeffler

How much can we tell about the diversity of cycads now vs in the past with the fossil record? Since fossilization is a rare happenstance. Also how do you tell species apart just by their fossils? Morphology alone seems like it would be really hard way to determine different species

Rachel Walwood

This seems like a type of plant that would be excellent for research into practical application as medicine. Yes/no/maybe? (First time question asker)

Zoe Armistead

Hi Alie! First time question asker here, how can you tell the difference between male and female cycad plants? (They kinda look like they have giant wangs..)! Thanks dad ward

Cheese

Given how long humans have enjoyed eating pineapples and such, are there more domesticated species vs original wild ones?

Bee Greenberg

Why is the habitat so varied from species to species? (or subgroup idk proper terminology) Did some googling and it says they can exist in rainy areas as well as semi-arid areas, that some need lots of sun and some need lots of shade. What's up with this tale of two cities vibe?

Anthony

I've read that any part of cycads are toxic, what the heck is this all about? If im not allowed to be their personal pollinators, then who is?

Matt Jolliff

How long have cycads been around? Thanks.

Sarah W.

What evolutionary pressures acted upon cycads to cause some to have such HUGE cones? (First question ever, last name rhymes with "container". 🙃)

Harper

I saw this and 100% though you said cicadas. This is the first time I've looked up cycads and now I want to know more! Has the pollination method for cycads been mostly the same as it is today based on the fossil record? Have cycad pollinators co-evolved with the plants, or have different species been the primary pollinators at different periods? One article mentions that some cycad trunks can be used to make bread. Please explain how the texture of the trunks is different from something like juniper or oak! Does it taste woody? What's the color and texture? Could I find some cycad toast at a local health food store? The same article notes that some cycads can be toxic to animals. Same ones as the bread cycads or would these also be toxic for humans? <3<3<3 thanks for the rad pod, Alie!

Hannah Soyer

I'm sure this question will be asked by others as well, but what's the difference between cicadas and locusts? Also, do they actually live underground when they're "dormant"?

Autumn Knol

Why do they have such stubby trunks? Is there an evolutionary benefit to their wonky shaped seed pods/pineapples/pinecones?

NanoNaturalist

A million years ago I read "Island of the Colorblind" by Oliver Sacks and I remember the conclusion he made was people there ate toxic cycads that made them lose color vision. Is there any new information about toxicity of cycads and how eating them as a staple can have health effects?

Nathan-Andrew

That scene in Jurassic Park - when an amazed Dr. Sattler holds up the living frond of an extinct plant - was that supposed to be a cycad? And is there any way to recover ancient plant DNA, since they sure didn’t get it from a mosquito?

Alex

First time question asker! (love this pod, love you Alie, so stoked to be here!) Interested parties want to know, how different are modern cycads from those found in the fossil record?

Karla Maria Pires

WHAT??!?!?! Cycads have motile sperm cells?!?!?!?! Tell me more!

Christi Kazakov

What type of fruit does it bear (if any) and how old is this tree?

Christi Kazakov

Is the ZZ plant a sibling plant of the cycads?

Beck

Can I grow one in a pot in my midwest apartment?

Bálint Novák

I just read that book and I'm so excited to read your question! 😄 The colorblindness in the book was due to genetic factors on Pingelap. But there was indeed a theory about a neurological disease called lytico-bodig on Guam being caused by ingesting the flour made of cycad seeds, but the theory had not been proved at the time of Sacks writing the book. I tried googling around a bit, but could not find anything conclusive. Did they find the cause of lytico-bodig since

Lizzy Martinez

What's a fun fact about Cycads that not many people probably know about?

Kelly Shaver

What is with the thing where animals eat toxic cycads and are fine but then humans eat the animals and are affected by the toxins?

Kelly Shaver

Also, why aren’t pineapples cycads? They seem like they should be cycads.

cardi_gan

I had no idea of what a cycad was when the patreon notification came by email, so I google it and... I kind of see them all the time and now I feel bad for not knowing their name before? I live in São Paulo, Brazil, and often travel to smaller cities with more green areas nearby. Are they specially common in subtropical regions?

Maddie Rodriguez

First time question asker here! So excited about this episode because we just learned about cycads in my biology class. Do they have a symbiotic relationship with cyanobacteria? If so, how does it work??

Archietedeli

First time question asker!! Are palm trees true trees? I hear they're technically woody herbs, but after 20 ft they can be classified as a tree... are and cycads true trees??

Chris Moore

How are they dispersed?!?! This is both historically, and today 😁

Hannah Pinter

As a cycadologist, has she ever had someone attempt to convince her to sell some of her specimens to them like a shady backwards drug deal?

Ellen Skelton

Question from my plant biologist boyfriend (Mark): what was the diversity of cycads like before the rise of angiosperms (flowering plants)? How different were pre-angiosperm forests, plains, and wetlands?

Sam Kiley

First time question asker... What's the oldest cycad recorded? Guessing dendrochronology would tell us the tree wisdom we seek, but is there a way to tell the age without chopping these big ol' land pineapples down?

Marie

Cycads can I eat it ? And additionally what is its strategy for surviving / How does it reproduce / spread?

ilovelisteningtopodcasts

first time asker! do they have any appearances in mythology/ interesting stories about them?

Miriam

How old can cycads get? And how do you find out how old an individual tree is?

Andie

I think the LA Zoo has some of these and they’re very proud and protective of them! How common are they in public conservatories, arboretums and zoos?

Ashley Emanuele

You said my name right, also oh hi! How can you age a cycad? Do they have rings like deciduous trees, or do you have to give it a series of knocks and incantations to gain its prehistoric knowledge?

Shannon Foster

First timer and future botanist here, soooo let’s talk about sex. I read cycads are not both male/female. Each plant is one or the other and they need to be near each other to pollenate. WHY!?

Dr. Niki

Do you hate the word "living fossil" as much as I do? Just checking. -Dr. Headbutt

Alexis Luxion

This! And also, what evolutionary niche do they fill? What would some comparable plants be? (1st time QA, last name sounds like luck son.)

Ben Kmo

First time asker, the last name is pronounced ‘Kershmar’. My wedding ring is designed after cycad fossils! Somewhere in a neuro lecture, they talked about cycads & Cyanobacteria & neurotoxicity changing research on neuro diseases like ALS. WHAT THE HECK?

Laura Jones

First timer here! So where do these guys grow naturally? Also, since they are a black market item, is there a problem with people sniping them from their natural habitat or people's property to make some extra cash? Like are humans so awful that we are killing off this plant?

Allister McRae

OK, so I've heard that they are the only species that has multiple flagella on their sperm...I've also heard that sometimes, human sperm have this as a mutation, and it makes them just go in circles. So, what's up with multiple flagella?

Allison D.

Love this show, and as a midwesterner, I’ve admired palm trees from afar. Now I live in Nevada and see a wide variety of non-native decorative palm trees throughout Las Vegas, especially adorning the properties of the wealthy and the nicer hotel chains- are any of those cycads?

Trevor DeCuir

Is there any hope for encephelartos woodii? Also, what the heck is up with beetles having orgies in cycad reproductive structures?

Lynn

Are they related to ginkgo trees? They’re the only other trees I know of that have separate male trees and female trees

David Villafranco

So we're cyads killing brachiosaurus that accidentally ingested them in prehistoric times or nah, also you never said my name but this is only my first time responding to one of your questions😂

Penelope Adkins

Is it true that there are no female wood cycads. Or they’ve just never found. Anyway what’s the deal with the lady the trees

Bailey Jones

Where in the world are cycads normally found??

SueG

Pollinators, who are they? Any problems due to global warming killing their pollinators? Or are they self pollinating??? Many thanks Alie :-)

Amanda Corey

Why so pokey and amazing? Dino food?

Laura Stacey

Are they especially valuable? Hence the black market shenanigans?

E-Veh-Lease Sanchez

Male and female strobili?? They are so alien and dong-like! What is up with those??

Wayne

Hi Alie , love your show ,, when I,m a little down , I listen to your podcasts n feel a lot less alone ,, my question is ,, Do all cycads need a lot of processing to be edible, here in Australia they are poisonous unless prepared correctly , , 🤢🤮 , Thanks again ,, 🤜🤛

Claire Irvine

How to they pollinate? When they evolved, was their pollinator specialised to that tree specifically? Does that pollinator still exist?

BENJAMIN

Are there other ancient plants like it in the present world?

Rachael

I was reading about how cycads have a symbiotic relationship with cyanobacteria that live around their roots and help the cycad to fix nitrogen. But the cyanobacteria also create a neurotoxin that gets into the seeds. This seems like it would be a problem evolutionarily (it’s generally maladaptive to kill the critters that disperse your seeds)? Does the neurotoxin have another evolutionary advantage or is it just a byproduct of their bacteria buddies?

Julie Burton

Ok so the Malawi based endemic cycad, the Mulanje cycad has leaves that are predated by endemic Tiger moth larvae, so they also become poisonous and pollinated by an endemic weevil--a triple threat. Thats great bang for the buck conservation I would think, are there other cycad situations like that to assist in cleaning up this cycad-gobbling?

Colin

What is Dr. Nagalingum's dream find in the field?

BeckytheSassySeagrassScientist

Climate change impacts? Who knows! Maybe cycads will be an exception and benefit and take over the world!

Mark Hewlette

Are Cycads Palms? Are they the same? Related? Are they farmed? If so, what do we farm from them? Did these plants evolve to have bare trunks to withstand hurricanes & tsunami's? Coastal storms? I could look it up but I thought it would be more interesting to hear it from Nathalie. Can't wait!

Natalie Gertz -Young

How different are the cycads of today as compared to cycads of the past? How have they changed from the Carboniferous to the Jurassic to today?

Willow Hall

This! I would love to know the evolutionary history of cycads too!

Reiley Allison

From what I understand there is a vast geographical diversity of Cycads. Does this mean that they each have their own evolution in surviving to a wide range of soil conditions?

Earl of Greymalkin

1) Where does the name cycad come from? 2) Are there dryads of cycads? 3) How the heck does one go about stealing a cycad and not killing it? 4) How much illegal plant trading happens around the world? 5) How old can they get and how can you tell? Do they make tree rings? 6) Do cycads still have features we can see that would have protected them from being eaten by dinosaurs? 7) Are there any bird or bat species that are associated with these plants, like building nests/roosting in them? 8) If you want to propagate cycads, do you have to dope in particular microbes for the root system microbiota?

Jeanette-o-saur

Add on: do they have mycelium connections and fungi friends?

Lucy Smiles

In your knowledge and opinion, what are some of coolest uses of the different parts of this plant (ancient and/or modern)? :)

Lucy Smiles

I really like this question! I think you meant to send it to the other call for questions post. :)

Stephanie Leské

I read that they have female and male trees how do you tell these pineapple palm tree cosplayers apart?

Fwaeldling

this is the niche stuff I get out of bed for... (or stay in it well entertained)

Jessica Arend

Why do they look like palms/ferns despite not being closely related to palms/ferns? (First time asker, last name pronounced “errand!”)

Jessica Arend

(Like, what’s going on evolutionarily there?)

James Wallis

How do cycles harvest the silica they incorporate to reduce herbivory?