Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

At 1pm today I sit down with Dr. Suzanne Pierre, an expert in... Critical Ecology! WTF?? 

How do human ideologies shape the world? How do climate issues affect justice, and vice versa? How have systems of injustice shaped our ecology, and what solutions are best going forward?

https://www.suzannepierre.com/

I will also be asking her how I should feel about taking a plane to ask her these questions. 

Leave your questions for her below!

Comments

Augustus Herrera

Im starting college this year as a conservation biology major in Colorado! How can I have the greatest possible impact ASAP?

Jessie Dragon

What’s the best way to promote environmental justice? How can we help our local areas but also help the most dire areas?

Aubrey Nelson

Obviously there are small steps individuals can take to help reduce their impact, but really how can we make a bigger difference with so much outside of our control?

Meghan McLean

What small steps can folks do on a daily basis to help the planet?

Derek Peloquin

My question would be what are some people/organizations that are doing really good in this area (so we can support them better) and what ones are doing excessively bad?

Mackenzie Cyr

How worried should we be about climate change not slowing down within our lifetime? I hear of all the solutions the world is trying to come up with, but I still worry that we are too late.

Tony Vessels

How does war and other military conflict affect the climate? This feels timely especially due to the invasion of Ukraine... What does the ecological fallout look like after war?

Bethany Goodine

How has religion affected climate/environmental policy?

Leah Lodevico

When comparing traditional Eastern and Western ideologies, how much does imperialism & the imperialistic mindset impact the way the environment is treated?

Seán Thomas Kane

How helpful are more curated methods of ecology like green belts, forest preserves, or national parks? Are they truly wild if humans are deciding how far they should extend or what sorts of plant and animal life we want to live there?

Lindsey Grutchfield

How can we feel less useless as individuals combating climate change? How can we BE less useless?

lk

long time listener, first time asker! when i was younger, i struggled very badly with being so depressed about the state of the environment and feeling like i couldn’t do anything about it. over the years i’ve learnt to sort of put my feelings of impending doom aside and focus on the present, and not let the crushing fear of the earth burning get to me. so my question is, what’s the best way to stay positive about climate change/action? how can i help spread that positivity amongst others as well?

Emily Krieger

are there studies looking at the impacts on ecology in non-capitalist societies and how they may differ from impacts in capitalist ones?

Serena Palmer

How can we spread sustainability to those who might be really opposed to changing their ways? Do you believe strong or weak sustainability will help us reach our goals of trying to save what’s left of the planet while also ensuring the safety of the environment and people?

Emily Krieger

also: what does the "critical" refer to --- criticism? critique? essential?

Jakin Yang

Sorry, a long one but this is close to my lil’ heart. Hi, I’m a tree planter who works up in Canada. Here, natural resource industries are a huge deal. In BC, forestry is growing hotter than ever and forests (old growth and new) are being cut down. There are a million different issues and problems, but my question is, how can we articulate the importance of ecology to actually trigger a fundamental change in how we operate these industries in order to save the ecology that is providing these resources? Right now, tree planting is a cop-out so that forestry companies can keep on cutting down massive trees while leaving behind “replanted” “forests” to say they tried and cover their asses. In reality, it seems these forests never really recover and when they do regrow it’s an incredibly “unnatural” monoculture forest built only to produce lumber to cut down again. Thoughts?

Alyssandra Goss

What’s the best way we as individuals can help combat climate change? What are some logistical ways in which we can help make a difference?

Hannah Thorpe

How accurate are those "measure your carbon footprint" tests? In my late high-school years I remember taking those quizzes and being kind of guilted into doing anything possible to lower it even though sometimes it seems that individuals can't make much of a difference on their own

Matt Thompson

What are some good intentioned ecological fixes that most people do that is actually harming biomes?

Paul Hoch

If all of humankind disappeared from the planet today, how long would it take until the planet had no evidence of us existing? Assuming we didn't disappear due to war, I would love to know how long all the plastics, cement, buildings, dams, roads, all the stuff that we have done to make the planet modern human-centric would still be here. If an alien spaceship landed on the planet a million years after we were gone, could they tell we were here?

Ren

I'm SO EXCITED for this ep. I'm a non-binary person who works in environmental ed and interpreters love to talk about how sometimes when you're doing ID, the field guide might not line up with what you see in person because the organisms "don't read the field guide". How do we get people to move this idea beyond just physical characteristics and think about gender in this way? I want to push past gay penguins and talk about how we impose our own binaries on nature!

Alex Morales

What do you consider an aspect of inequity that has had the greatest impact on our environment?

Emily Krieger

also: would critical ecology include subjects like Elinor Ostrom and the commons and her work that upends Garrett Hardin's tragedy of the commons?

Gabrielle Jolin

How can we as individuals combat climate change ourselves and help others to do the same?

Kelli Brockington

Came here to ask this - what can I plant in my yard to help the world? Is home gardening good for overall ecology health of environment?

Kate Watters

How best can we try to halt the destruction of indigenous forests in the Amazon rainforest since (even though it's not in the news anymore) the bulldozing is still happening.

Ashley Bray

How do we determine “what is worth saving”?

Natalie (she, her, hers)

Do you have any advice for an undergraduate student in Political Science looking to make the switch into ecology and research after their degree? What are the top few ways you have found these disciplines interconnect in your research? How can one become involved in The Critical Ecology Lab? - *not* asking for a friend :)

Jesse Hurlburt

How can we get teachers or I guess school systems to incorporate more aspects of being helpful for climate change, or bringing minorities in the field of science into classrooms so students of color can see they are represented.

Jesse Hurlburt

How many animals go extinct in a year?

Quincey Robisheaux

Oh boy I have a lot of questions... Pick your favorite I guess lol There are some countries (mainly European) that put environmental protection in the forefront. Have these efforts actually made much impact? Do mass exoduses like the Syrians and Ukrainians have significant environmental impacts, either negative or positive? What do you think of governments that prioritize conservation over the welfare of their people? You see this a lot in many sub-saharan African countries where poaching is common, but it's also common for farmers to kill an animal encroaching on their cattle, but in the latter case the farmers get punished

Ashley Bray

To clarify: In the sense that we’re seeing high rates of extinction, how do we prioritize what species/landscapes are most “important”?

Isabelle Brooks

Does pursuing a zero waste life actually have a large impact? How much longer can we expect snowsports to be possible//even more elite?

Isabelle Brooks

What animal has the biggest *positive* impact on climate change

Sh4rkH4ts

How best can we help others understand and accept that humans are the current, primary, cause of climate change, and that climate change is real? My grandpa has recently turned climate conspiracy theorist and doesn't believe humans are to blame.

Alli Barg

As a PhD student in applied ecology I think a lot about how to talk/teach about the history of the field. How do we talk about the work of people like John Muir and Aldo Leopold without glorifying colonial, white-savior type concepts of conservation? It seems impossible to avoid talking about them altogether, but I don’t like the way we tend to discuss them as “fathers of conservation” when that’s just not true.

Ren

Another one - how do we help people move past climate nihilism and see climate change as a space where we can (and must!) imagine new systems that are better for us and our environment rather than just a death sentence?

Amelia Frank

Man oh man - I struggle with kids and climate change. I have one kiddo and would have to have more (who knew kids were so much fun?!) but I feel like a heel procreating when I feel some guilt-induced side-eye (ie I am doing it to myself) over the potential negative impact of having children on climate change. So - is procreating an actual problem for climate change? Can I carbon offset my kids?

Caitlyn Powell

I know much of the criticisms for western-minded conservation point to the harms to rural/developing communities. How can conservation incorporate needs of local or indigenous communities while still meeting biological goals? Are we getting any better at this?

Deacon Raid

I’m hoping there’s some conversation about how the old feudal style “the lord owns all the animals” system has influenced current conservation and land management priorities. Like is it true that one of the best ways to support Conservation is to buy a deer tag (even if you have no plans to hunt) because that money funds the conservation activities of the department?

Popita

It seems like much of climate change has been caused by corporate greed and corporations in general not caring. What is the best way to hold these people accountable? They are getting away with murder.

Deacon Raid

*priorities and practices

Ali Vessels

It's well known that marginalized groups are the most severely affected by climate change and environmental issues. I'm thinking specifically of landfills and noxious factories being built next to poor communities. Does your research see any way forward in reversing these patterns and creating more just environments in the US? What needs to be done to progress environmental justice at a community level? I'm a brand new grad student in environmental policy and management so this Ology is incredibly interesting to me!

Talia Dunyak

What is something that gives you hope when it comes to climate and critical ecology?

Lisa Smith

Has the warming of the planet any direct correlation to the increased number if viruses on the planet? I've read our encroachment on forests has led to negative climate impacts because they are no longer big enough to host all species.

Taniya Heuchert

Boy howdy, I'm so excited for this episode! I'm a teacher, how do I teach about environmental issues in my environmental science classes without causing eco-anxiety in my students? We can make a change, how do we do it without them being afraid of the bigger picture? (Name pronounced Tan-eye-ya Hi-kert)

Ali Vessels

This is something I think about too, but I particularly like the question "can I carbon offset my kids" 😂

Gina Woolsey

What are your thoughts on what's been called the 6th great extinction caused by humans? I've heard arguments for and against it based on the rate of species going extinct and the actual percentage of species that are out there. It feels like we would be ignoring a big impact if we said we weren't the leading cause of extinction going on right now

Average_pi

Why are no people doing anything about climate change it seems like people are just talking about it and i feel like action already. Should we just leave it all alone and let it fix itself(it being nature)

Lisa Smith

How would the crazy idea of irradication of mosquitoes realistically impact the environment. I worry while it solves one human problem it could open a pandoras box of more problems.

Vojta Opluštil

In central Europe, there has been an epidemic of Bark beetle due to native trees being replaced by quickly growing spruce trees. After all the wood is disposed of (or harvested), we're left with a clear cut. What would be the best way to repopulate these areas so that we can get closer to original mixed hardwood forests?

E-Veh-Lease Sanchez

When will we--or have we already begun to see the effects of the 2019 Amazon Rainforest fire on our planet? And is there any good news for our planet? Thanks, Evie

Roxanna McLaughlin

First World problem, I know.... but how can I offset my carbon footprint when I drive hundreds of miles to camp in the desert? Is there a formula? I have made groups working for Climate Change legislation my priority in my donations and volunteer efforts. Is there something else I should be doing? If I could move there I would, but my mate cannot handle anything over 75F. Thank you so much. Yes, you can put me on a guilt trip if you show me an answer too. :)

Ashley Bray

Is land that is fragmented still worth preserving, or should we spend our time/money on large swatches of land that can support more biodiversity?

Julie M

How can (or should we even?) shift the focus from what individuals are doing and put the responsibility on corporations, governments, and other organizations to decrease the individual burden? I know that we all need to do our best but it feels like too much for one person to tackle on the daily since burgers are tasty.

Gaelicpearl

Curious about the relationship between cultural beliefs and how that affects our relationship w/ & treatment of the environment. I read a really interesting book in uni on ecofeminism that looked at British historical views on the environment, specifically the shift to perceiving nature as feminine, and how there was then the intertwining of femininity as something to be controlled/managed/performed and environmental management and resource extraction. Essentially if nature is thought of as a woman then the patriarchy can control + exploit her. I guess the question is, does this ring true in your experience of western cultures, and what other approaches have you seen?

Sikwani Dana

What do you say to people that say the world is over populated with humans? I grew up in a mixed race house hold and this was said all the time. I heard years later that it’s actually not true and came from yt supremacy. Thoughts?

rachel

Is there something we can do that bypasses depending on governments for action? What can we do that actually has impact? Skipping straws, and not eating meat feels like something to make me feel less hopeless, rather than actually save the planet.

Ashley Bray

Should we as individuals be taking steps towards reducing our “carbon footprint” or is that just a way that large companies make us feel like the onus to end climate change is on us to take attention away from them?

Ashley Bray

Also, how are you able to interview so many experts in one day Alie? 😂 are you ok?!

Lene Olszeth

Please ask if we can fix the world or if it's just like this now

Spencer Parks

Oof, this is a big one. No questions but I can't wait to listen.

Caitlyn Powell

How can western science find climate change solutions that are fair to developing countries? ( I'm thinking about westerns getting angry at poor people for chopping rainforests while we use airplanes willy-nilly)

Chris Brewer

If humans developed a food replicator, how would this affect the world?

Aven

What is the best way to tackle plastic pollution keeping in mind racial and industrial justice- obviously not all countries have access to drinkable water through taps and rely on plastic bottles to get safe drinking water. How do we tackle that massive production of plastic pollution in a responsible and fair way.

Super_Sara

How badly have we fucked up the world, is there any chance of unfucking it? Generally, humanity seems hesitant to chance it’s ways, have we reached the point of no return.

Diane Tarantino

What steps can we take to help the world? Is it possible to undo the damage we've done?

Charlotte Fjelkegård

If I've understood it correctly, our successful transition from fossile fuels to electricity depends on batteries. And most of the rare metals needed for batteries are mined/extracted in countries in the Southern hemisphere. What are the odds that these countries will be compensated for the environmental damage which will occur, and what steps can we take to minimize the damage and maximize the compensation?

Reiley Allison

How did we get to the need to have a branch of ecology named "critical ecology". IS it a relatively new field? Is our planet fucked? What is most impacted, soils, plants, animals, air, water, our lifestyles?

Rachel Murdock

How does brownfield redevelopment fit within critical ecology?

Hannah Nuest

What career/grad school advice do you have for someone like me who is into ecology but also the social side of environmentalism?

Maya Chorobik

What can ecosystems teach us about restructuring our political systems to meaningfully address the biggest overlapping challenges of our time, including climate change which is a crisis multiplier? Another way of putting the question: Even within the most progressive governments at all levels (local/state/national), we're not able to enact systems change at the pace and scale needed, indicating that political systems need an overhaul/reorganization. What can we learn from ecosystems to help with this reorganization so we're not all fucked? (first time question asker, hiiiiiiiiiiiiii!)

Hannah Nuest

How do you respond to doomerism? I feel like I see it so much more often than denialism these days and I think it’s just as bad if not worse

Geo Beck (Becky)

As a geologist, I've become more and more interested in the interconnection of geology with pretty much all other aspects of our world/nature/human history. What is one/some interesting ways that you've found geology connects to your research and work?

Rachel von Morrigan

This! I’m very interested in how/if we can unfuck all of this.

Geo Beck (Becky)

also, I just have to say im so pumped to listen to this episode when it's out!!!

Jackie

I'm sure the human idea of property and ownership affect ecology, what are some less obvious idea of our that shape our interaction with the natural world?

Patty S

I love this topic. Multispecies relations is my jam and I'm curious to hear your guest's take on the rights of nature. Some indigenous groups and others have managed to pass legislation to grant rights to nature (wild rice in MN, for example) and there is a group currently working to ensure Salmon have rights. There are a handful of countries in which nature has rights. This opens up lots of possibilities for better protection through legislation, and it could create interesting scenarios when it comes to accountability of Planet-destroyers. Is this a viable path forward?

Patty S

oooh also First time question asker here!

Gwen Kelly

What’s the next major paradigm shift that we (western neoliberal societies especially) need? How do we change how we think about the earth, the plants, the animals, everything? I feel like we need this, a change away from viewing the earth and it’s many inhabitants as resources to extract and exploit, to something else? But having been raised in this worldview, it’s so hard to imagine an alternative. We need a whole social and cultural and scientific paradigm shift but what does that new paradigm look like?

Mia Manzer

I know religion plays a significant roll sometimes in human actions, and sometimes theres overlap in various religions. Do you think there was an original religion that branched into what we see today and do you think religion plays a significant roll in why humans are basically destroying nature right now?

Leigh

What is critical ecology?!

Martha Lowry

Do you have any favourite methods for getting better mycorrhizal associations in our crops? Particularly for orchard systems?

Mark Hewlette

How do we overcome the powerful motivation of greed? Historically, many "accomplishments" came about with greed as an underlying motivator. I'm not sure it's any different today. People who want to do the right thing do not have much (relative) power and typically are governed by a set of rules and principles. Those with great wealth seeking more wealth are heavily motivated, do not play by any rules, and don't seem to care about anything or anyone in their path. It is REALLY hard to change this - are we doomed?

Rob Brennan

What are your thoughts on ecofascism and the prevalent belief that the world is becoming 'overpopulated'? Is it a capitalist ploy to distract from the world's food waste issues and the unsustainable, profit-driven food industries?

Benjamin N DuBow

What's the last connection you learned (biological, historical, ecological, whatever) that blew your mind and made you think, "Why is everyone not talking about this?"

Willow Hall

Oh, damn, I have so many questions! What are her thoughts on Ecological Restoration? Does she think the mindset of ecological restoration is beneficial or could it be harming in the long run? Also, what can people who aren't in the field of critical ecology but are very passionate about the environment/environmental justice do to help the cause? Finally, so I don't write a novel, I saw on Suzanne's website that she incorporates archaeology into the lab. Does she also work with biological anthropologists? (I ask as a dork with an undergrad in bio anth who is applying to an ecological restoration masters program)

mckenzie faas

Every day, we're bombarded by more and more human influenced ecological crises. I want to do my part but recycling and composting feel like a drop in the bucket. Anything I do feels overwhelmingly hopeless, especially compared to things like extinction and deforestation. Don't even get me started on the futility of recycling... That hopelessness leads to apathy and then guilt for feeling apathetic. What can we do as individuals to foster a better relationship with the environment that isn't laden with guilt or apathy?

Leila Laco

Also worth noting that many disabled people rely on single-use plastic products eg. straws and pre-packaged chopped fruit/veg, and would be impacted by blanket bans on single-use plastic products.

Hope Shinn

Hello! First time question asker here. I've seen a big push for "green infrastructure" or "nature based solutions" in human infrastructure development, especially in urban areas. Is this a good thing for everyone, or has it been intensifying gentrification/inequality?

Markelle Morphet

First time question asker here. What is your take on the conflict between institutional ethics boards and indigenous research methods? How much do the scientific method and publication standards influence indigenous peoples inclusion in ecology studies?

Karlie V

How much of today’s climate situation can be traced back to the Industrial Revolution?

Ryanne Flynn Rossi

First time question asker! Are LEED-certified buildings actually a sustainable path forward for future building and infrastructure or is it mostly just greenwashing?

Riikka Puttonen

In an urban setting is there a way to sustainably fill in (or otherwise tamper with) soil or is it all just shades of bad? Also I read that urban soil will start to fossilize if sealed. Does it mean that after we're gone, all out formerly paved roads will have created a giant worldwide spiderweb of fossils? Also should I hide something interesting under there before the pavement machines roll over? You know, for the imagined posterity of humankind. FTQA, although you did once read my silly joke about bear butt plugs. Name pronounced REEK-kah POOT-toh-nen.

Kasey Carrick

Things that make me sad and corresponding questions: “Most of pollution comes from industries and corporations” - How do we change this narrative to empower individuals to take more responsibility for the health of the planet? - What are realistic steps we as individuals can take to protect the health of the planet? “Hunting helps prevent overpopulation and makes the ecosystem more sustainable” - Is overpopulation of hunted animals actually an issue that hunters should be trying to manage? - Are there better ways to make an ecosystem (say a forrest) more sustainable besides hunting cute little forrest puppies (deer)? Natural spaces being destroyed for urbanization - How can we help protect natural/green spaces? - What can we do at home or in the community to foster the ecosystem since green spaces are being taken away? Agriculture vs Livestock farming - What changes to our diet or the overall food system are the most effective to improve sustainability?

Cole Robertson

(First-time question asker here!) I know planes are pretty bad for the environment and that Greta Thunberg sailed across the Atlantic for the climate change summit. Cruise ships are also bad for the environment, though... In a perfect world, what does the ideal overseas transport look like?

Dr Laura M Smith

What are your thoughts on changing the narrative that ecological conservation is the work of NGOs/charities and actually needs to be taken on by corporations and governments in meaningful ways (not just tokenistic PR initiatives)? Ecological degradation is not an externality - there are real costs to our societies as well as our ecosystems.

Christopher Go

First-Time question asker :DD I'm curious with all the statements of "irreversible effects" that scientists called that will likely happen if humas continue this path of degrading our ecological landscape. And defintely as an overthinkiner may I ask how terrible are these irreversible effects and how will it impact our daily lives?

B P

How have the ideologies of Abrahamic religions, patriarchy and capitalism influenced the way many modern societies treat the natural world? Is there any hope that we can shift to a nature-centric view where we see ourselves as part of nature, not the boss of nature?

Gabby Sweet

Are we all just doomed at this point no matter what we do?!

Hazel

how do you perceive renewable energy as a critical ecologist?

Maya Zambrano-Lee

Thoughts on nuclear energy compared to other green energy sources? What are the drawbacks to different clean energies?

Jessica Cuddy

How should one go about convincing climate deniers that climate change is real?

Trinaty

Can you talk about environmental racism/how climate change and how non sustainable cooperate/governmental practices has specifically affected marginalized communities?