Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hey folks, hope you're all doing well!

I've been writing these tutorials for almost 3 years now. Wow! In that time, it's been an absolute privilege to be able to share my ideas with you, and it's been wonderful to hear about times when I've been able to help people understand and build amazingly cool stuff that is bringing enjoyment and wonder into the world. You're all awesome :)

I've also learned lots of new things myself ... After recently looking back at some old projects, I noticed things which I would now do differently, things which perhaps I didn't properly understand myself at the time, or just better ways of achieving a particular goal. So I'm planning to revisit some of my old projects and "update" them based on how I would do them now.

The first two projects I'd like to look at are two of my very first projects to be published - "RFID object placement puzzle" and "Call Me" - the rotary telephone dial-a-number-to-get-a-message prop. These are two of my oldest tutorials, but also ones which I know people are still keen to build. And, for any new supporters, I feel bad that if you try to follow the projects as described currently, you'd be following the advice of me of 3years ago! (complete with all its mistakes, reliance on sometimes broken or missing libraries etc.)

Now, here's the thing: if I want to describe what I believe to currently be "best practice" when it comes to these ER props, that would involve sometimes moving away from Arduino-based projects and using ESP32 instead (as they are more capable, faster, more power-efficient, have built-in networking etc.). And, although I would never want to make code more complicated than it needs to be, I would also include things like network code to interface with control systems like ERM, M3, or Node-RED. But if you *don't* use those systems, that might make these projects seem a bit scarier.

So, let me know what you think.... I'll definitely be redoing the projects anyway (and I'm desperately going to try to create the phone prop in a way that works for everyone, whatever phone system your country uses!), but would you rather I include additional features and more recent tech even though that might make the code more complicated to understand? Or would you rather I stick with something more familiar and just aim for explaining the "core functionality", without all the extra bells and whistles?

And also, how do you feel about the current system of Patreon (which can be a bit of a pain to find old projects on), and Google Drive links for code? I've been recently putting more stuff on GitHub - would you prefer that? (but if I did that, all code would become "public access" - it wouldn't be restricted to Patreons-only)

Let me know!

Comments

Ruben van Tienen

As an amateur I think for my interest a revamp of older solutions would be great using new hardware (or even leave out networking if possible) so things can work as standalone solutions. I haven’t had the time to look at node red, but understand that this is of interest for a ER business, but not for private use. Anyway, I love all projects, keep up the good work. One thing I would love to see at the end is to see an idea to combine multiple puzzles into 1. Like a puzzle suitcase

Matthew Lendraitis

Hey Alastair. Thanks for what you do. So for more complicated code (that os fine with me) you could just use // comment. So if someone preffers the extra features of network connectivity all they eould need is uncomment that part in the code.

Matthew Lendraitis

And yes. Finding old projects in patreon is a pain. It would be great if you just had your own website with good project search features and then you would just add link to patreon to see full project.

Euan Hair

Hey Alastair, I’ve followed along with your tutorials for about two years now and if you follow your projects from then to now you naturally progress your knowledge to the point you understand the networking and node red. I’d say keep going with the advanced networking as it’s making the Escape Room puzzles so adaptable and provides a real benefit to building your own props rather than going with off the shelf. GitHub is a great place for the code as you can jump between all your previous projects and find libraries etc if you want to tweak things.

Hannah Betts

Would love you to redo rfid, it's the bane of my life! I can't get more than 2 to work attached to one arduino so have done the most convoluted solution - don't ask...! I am trying to migrate over to the esp32 so I'm well up for that but I haven't go onto node red and stuff yet. I also dislike patreon, it's impossible to find stuff. There must be a better solution, but I don't know what it is!

Michael

hi alastair, let it how it is. dont make it complicated. we love arduino and we think arduino is ok for the escaperoom stuff. if you wanna go github. it would be ok but i think you will losse some patreons. we would stay if you move to git. and support you also in the future.

Michael

Telephone Arduino we have a good solution done with the MP3 player. because the most Problems where the SD Card functions. Also the sound Quality. With MP3 we have no problems and it runs perfect.

Michael

sounds good. our solution is a mix between yours and some modification with the mp3 player. We use that solution on a 1980 military cryptophone and also on a 1945 old Phone. it works on each phone. When iam back from holidays i will send you the code or i post it here. our script have a counter that a phone call is placed after 45 minutes also we have on a number the release lock function and on different numbers different hints we placed a colour changeing LED on right and wrong hints by changing from red to green lightnings

Jake

Hi Alastair. You have been a huge inspiration since I started building my escape rooms almost three years ago and I have integrated many of your solutions in my puzzles. The next step for me is networking them in node red and hopefully finding a way to extract data and automatically generate reports on individual games. So revisiting the old projects and updating them in respect to both hardware and code would be a tremendous help!

Michael

keep going on with cool new stuff. THX for that......

Walter

yes please do rfid again, i cant do work, sory my english . i folloe you from Argentina, please help with rfid, thx

Drew McGiffert

While some of the hardware is getting a bit older now I find Arduino based equipment a lot cheaper and easier to source. The Uno's have been very reliable but it would also be good to see how to move forward with something like the ESP32. Networking is a big plus! The Node-RED info you've been providing has been one of the biggest draws for me and it would be great to see more networking/interfacing content. I've found some of the extra 'bells and whistles' you've mentioned through different videos good, its given me inspiration and other ideas I've been able to go away and research more (partly why Arduino is a good platform as there is so much info out there to expand on). Someone else mentioned combining props into standalone solutions, that would be interesting too see, something like a portable puzzle suitcase. Patreon is such a pain of a system! I've been liking the content on Github but also think you might loose some credit/subscribers if you moved everything there, maybe it's time to build your own subscriber website :D

Masher

Finding older projects, really is a pain! I know you did an index a while back... but I can't find that, either! If you could do some sort of sticky index that remains at the top, with HTML links to the projects, that would be most helpful. Whilst I love the electronic puzzles - and I feel I've learnt quite a lot from building some of them - I wouldn't mind seeing some more basic non-powered ER puzzles if possible. Loving your work though... keep it up :)

Myles

As others have said, referencing is a pain, maybe a pinned post with links to each one would be useful, but equally, once you’ve opened the project it gets imported to our own google drive so I don’t find the referencing an issue. As long as you open up the link every time you post a new project. I use YouTube to search your projects, eg, I searched your channel for Wemos, and I got all the videos that used one so I know which projects code to look at. As for future projects, I personally like the more advanced functions you do, but once you understand how that code works it’s easy to implement to different puzzles. So maybe you could do separate videos that just cover the more advance features so people can have that choice, you wouldn’t need 2 videos for every project. You could just do a monthly vid on MQTT, another on NodeRed GUI for example and we’d just be able to implement them in to any of your projects. It also helps with content as there’s only so many types of inputs and outputs to make videos on. Another thought, have you considered your own store selling custom pcbs or shields? I could see quite a few people just ordering those and then flash your code on them for the ease. Seeing as all your projects are already in fritzing it would be quite easy.

steve stribling

Still new to this so prefer arduino. But hope to expand over time so not against the bells and whistles if is clear what can simply be removed for the less complicated. Agree, a clearer reference would be extremely helpful.

Jennifer

Hi Alastair, I find the Patreon search facility useful and its quite easy to find any of your projects by using some simple key word searches, but sticky links would be useful if practicable and could possibly be used in some sort of drop down menu. The more we have learned from your projects the more we have been prepared to tackle more adventurous projects, but some times they can go over most peoples heads, especially things like Node Red, which I would really like to get into more. Unfortunately learning C++, Node-Red and CSS etc etc to name a few, to achieve the most out of it does get a little too much at times. I have recently bought two retro telephones one modern Touch Panel in a retro style and a Genuine BT 746 one. Iv'e built the Push Button Retro one using a DF Player Mini before I came across your "Call Me" and did wonder why it used an SD card reader instead. Whilst I would love to get your Projects free via Git Hub, is that really the way to go ? I can see you loosing Patreons very quickly unless you have come up with a better way of funding all your great work, keep the projects coming especially Arduino but I agree Wifi functionality would add another dimension and I have just bought a Mega Board with built in Wifi by pure coincidence of course :-)

Stacie Folk

I was just about to try and build the telephone ☎️ prop. Are you saying there is an easier way to build this prop? I am new to arduino so this works for me. But seeing a new updated version wouldn't hurt as long as its simple to follow.

Michelle

I would prefer the best practice that uses recent and possible "advanced" tech like mqtt and networking. Though Myles suggestion sounds like a nice compromise. A mix where for every 3-4 "simple" Arduino projects, do an advanced project. I would also like to see more stand alone props that are battery powered. (A session on power and incorporating batteries might be nice). Regardless, thank you for these tutorials. They teach but also provide great ideas.

Pascal Wibaut

Hello Alastair. I would find it unfortunate if your work is in "public access". And apparently, I'm not the only one who thinks so, because the February 23, 2018 survey shows that a majority of your funders would be willing to pay $ 20 per month to have more projects. Before knowing you, I didn't think I could get Arduino to work. Today, thanks to you, I have already successfully realized: RFID (2017-12-04), Connect the Wires (2017-12-17), Pincode Puzzle (2018-02-07), Knock-knock ( 2019-01-21), Plasma Ball (2019-06-13), Take Me Home (2020-06-25) I have not yet embarked on the Node-RED adventure and the network code, but your explanations are so clear that even this challenge seems possible to me ;-) In "Non-Tech ER Puzzle Ideas?" (2019-01-15), a large majority of votes were in favor of a short weekly video (<5 minutes) showing how to create each individual puzzle idea; do you think this is achievable for you? I can't wait to discover your future project.

Tehral

Would be greate if you did the call me riddle again since for many it doesn't work. ANd yeah finding something is really hard

Great State

Love that you are going to update some of the older projects. I wouldn't mind if some of them also used some other tech. Perhaps a mix?

DAVID CASADO GAMO

Hi. Sorry my english is bad. I need i lot the multi rfid. You know when the revision? Thank you