Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi folks, I hope you're well. I have a problem/question for you:

Over the last couple of months I've been experimenting with some Ultra-Wideband modules (based on the Decawave DW-1000 chip). If you're not familiar with UWB devices, they are radio transmitter/receivers that can be set up as "anchors", and by measuring and comparing the timing of signals from several anchors in different places, you can determine the position of a tracked "tag", theoretically with an accuracy of ~10cm. A bit like creating a local, indoors, precise GPS system. 

Now, this all sounds very exciting and (as with my other projects), I was *hoping* that the outcome would be a way to demonstrate how to use this tech in an escape room - I'm sure you can probably think of loads of fun ways that players would have to position, or move any number of physical objects in completely free 3D space, with no obvious sensors. However, I'm coming to the conclusion that the tech just isn't usable for the majority of Escape Rooms :( 

It's not that it doesn't work, as such - it does! But, it's complex, requires setup and tuning to get optimum results, and the accuracy is affected by environmental factors that means that I would never be able to provide instructions for a generic "out-of-the-box" solution for using them - every single installation would have to be customised, and I fear that if I gave you the code that I'm using, it would generate a whole ton of questions as to how to modify it for different use-cases that I wouldn't be able to support. Now, if you're a massive company like Amazon and you want to track the location of all the assets in your warehouse, that investment in optimising a UWB system is probably worth it. But, for most escape rooms? No - it would be easier and cheaper to just fake the effect using other methods.

Now, this is causing me some frustration - both because I'm disappointed not to be able to create a reliable puzzle based on this cool tech, but also because I've invested a lot of time in researching pages of datasheets and settings, writing trilateration code and Unity visualisations that I will now probably never end up using...

So, my question to you is quite simple: would you still find it useful if I were to create a tutorial video and share what I've done, even though I would not recommend you use it? On one hand, I'd like to share what I've found out, but ultimately I'm not sure it would be of use to many of you (other than perhaps to save you investing time researching the same tech yourself). I know the reason many of you support me is because you want practical projects that you can implement in your escape rooms, not just arbitrary discussion of tech that turns out not to be useful, so I wouldn't want anyone to feel deceived! (and the tech *is* cool, but I wouldn't personally want to rely on it).

Let me know what you think!

a.

x

Files

Comments

Ryan Vervack

I do enjoy the projects that end with practical, demonstrable capabilities... but I'm here for the technology. I would definitely enjoy learning from your experiences, even if it didn't end up being practical for most escape room scenarios.

Masher

I think that I have learned quite a bit from watching your tutorials and also from building a number of your escape room puzzles, As you have already put so much into this latest effort - even if it hasn't turned out to be viable - I'd happily watch a video on it. Who knows, it might be useful in a different (non-escape room) project. Thanks.

Mr Terry Meech

I think it's still worth sharing, as you said it might not be useful for escape rooms but that could save someone doing what you've done. Or perhaps there might be a permanent installation it could be used. I'd certainly be interested anyways.

Steve Baudains

Whilst I can't personally think why I would want to use it (as you mention, if I wanted to do something where placing an object was required, I'd need to do it with 100% reliability and use a more solid method) I love the research and challenge of creating things like this. Not saying I'd ever try to replicate it, but I would be interested in a video on your process that's for sure.

Aleksey Linetskiy

Please do share it anyway - I'd love to learn about this technology, even if it's not yet applicable to practical use in Escape Rooms. And, who knows, maybe I or someone else might come up with some idea based on your research on hot to make it usable!

Katelyn Cahill-Rowley

As a matter of personal interest, I would enjoy watching it. But I honestly agree it could end up creating difficulties for you. People will still try it, and they'll still probably ask for support "just in case" it's a quick fix, or because they've now gotten so invested in it they can't see dropping the idea without reaching out. Or, they won't ask for support, but they'll end up feeling sour about the channel. You might be able to mitigate this by being very deliberate and deft with your caveats and framing, or by going into a little bit of detail on the tech you'd recommend in its place. Are you thinking just Patreon or YouTube as well? I think on Patreon, you have more leeway to go a bit "off brand" from the highly practical, follow-along-DIY that we know and love your channel for. We're a bit more invested here than YT, I imagine. Sorry for the equivocal answer!

T3chrs

Please do share. I’m still very interested in the tech and your process even if it isn’t ready for production use. Who knows you might save someone the frustration of trying it if they have your video to make them aware of the pitfalls.

Fogjack

Dear Alistair, It is of course difficult to assess whether it is useful to share the experiences gained. In any case, it might be interesting to show the knowledge and difficulties gained in this project. Personally I find it more fun to see a working project but knowledge is also interesting. If you show it, you can clearly state the restrictions.

Toon

Hi Alastair, Just another thumbs up for sharing lessons learned. When I refer colleagues and friends to your channel, it's not as a source of plug and play Escape Room puzzles. But as a repository of knowledge and inspiration to get them started or help them forward. So please do share. Even if it's just here on Patreon. Maybe include a disclaimer in big, bold, shiny letters? So to not put yourself in an endless comment and PM line of fire :-)

Steve Classing

I'd also be very interested in seeing what you've been experimenting with. I'm toying the idea for a room-scale virtual reality-based escape room and so having the beginning steps towards indoor positioning would be super helpful.

Vaggelis Ioannidis

hey Alastair! i had the same idea for one of my puzzles at my new room ! i would like to see the tutorial of what u made!

Din_Jävel

Oh dear, oh yes! Show us, please. I have spent quite some time drawing on a similar thing, but I lack in the skill departement.