Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

POLL TIME >:)

  • Mushoku Tensei 247
  • Overlord 96
  • That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime 226
  • 2025-08-14
  • —2025-08-27
  • 569 votes
{'title': 'POLL TIME >:)', 'choices': [{'text': 'Mushoku Tensei', 'votes': 247}, {'text': 'Overlord', 'votes': 96}, {'text': 'That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime', 'votes': 226}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 8, 27, 22, 53, 44, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 8, 14, 16, 41, 29, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 569}

Content

OKAY friends. The time has come for another poll! I know we watch a lot of isekai's and i'm aware that I usually get uncomfy with some anime, but I've decided for the sake of isekai's i'll put in even the most popular ones 😂since they're well known and others have watched them too and seem to find them funny :' ) vote away my friends

Comments

vinceeditsss

BRO THESE ARE ALL PEAK IDK WHAT TO PICK

Nashty Doud

Mushoku Tensei is so peak, The world building is just top notch. This was a great poll selection no lie 😭😭

Herberek

Mushoku tensei will make you uncomfortable the most but it's also the best anime from those by far

Impulsife

Picking MT even with knowing how many icks you'll have with it 🤣

CarbonDog

I'm conflicted, I love nearly everything about mushoku tensei, except the MC

Roronoa Zoro

I voted with my heart. But just in case Mushoku Tensei wins i’ll warn you now. You’ll probably not like the main character for a lot of season 1. Season 2 and beyond he’s a way better character. But you’ll probably like slime the most.

Kyle Martin

Slime 100%....2nd is Overlord and mushoku isnt worth watching

Ploppy_P

Slime is the best, and id like to see your reaction to it. Just know that season 1 mishoku tensei will not be a fun watch, great show further on, just season 1 is a hard watch

Adam Lawson

Hmmm, never seen Overlord. I think you'll probably enjoy slime the most. Mushoku Tensei isn't bad at all. But you won't like the MC in the slightest and the show will make you uncomfortable. But, the show has its good moments

James Morgan Belcher

Never watched MT and don’t really wanna. As for Slime, it’s definitely my preference - it’s definitely a slow burner but I thought Overlord was SOOOO boring.

MishkaTho

She’s gonna hate Mushoku with everything ‘weird’ related, let’s be honest 😶 I actually like it but not sure it’s a show she’d enjoy haha

faroh

pffff i figured people would enjoy someone like me watching it

Snow

Yea she for sure is not going to enjoy mushoku so definitely slime is better choice here

Gocho

Of all three mushoku tensei is the most popular and by far with the best story. But you will need to just accept Rudeus as flaw as he is. The character was designed that way and you will need to pass through a few uncomfortable scenes. Now if you want to go the easy way. I think that Tensura "That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime" is going to be the safest option for you

faroh

i feel like you'd all enjoy me being in shock though hahahaha

OfficiallyGames

Feel like voting for Slime is the better choice even though Mushoku Tensei will likely win as I hope if she does get too uncomfortable with Mushoku Tensei and ends up dropping it (based on Season 1 and the way Faroh is, I feel like its highly likely) then she will just start to do Slime instead (which imo is a better show and story)

pooper

you're gonna hate mushoku imo. overlord is good, not sure how you feel about genuinely evil villains as the MC. Slime is good choice

Radiochip

Mushoku Tensei... yes, please and thank you.

OfficiallyGames

Inital shocks sure but not really if you're just going to be uncomfy the entire time which you most likely will be with Mushoku just with the first few episodes alone.

Saitama

Mushoku tensei is unbarable to watch, i would not recomend it

Darkwisp

I'm an Overlord fan, love the characters, love the world. An "evil" DnD campaign essentially. #2 for me is Slime, it's a fun series. #3, MT, The show has good animation, excellent world building but I just don't like the MC.

Daimah

Yes, out of those 3 animes Slime is the safest choice.

X

Overlord is evil but i still vote for it. I want to see your reaction.

Flox

Hmm Mushoku has some good world building and great animation but you're 100% going to be uncomfortable bc of the MC. Like i can put up with fan service and pervers moment if the story is good but i couldn't with this anime lol. Let's say the MC is a big pervert and I'm being nice lol. I think you'd probably like Overlord, it has a really good world building and i think you'd like to deeply analyze some of the characters

faroh

ive heard that it gets better and the main character isnt meant to be likeable though so im prepped hahha

SCUMUNCULUS

Never gonna try and stomach Mushoku again, people say the MC gets better but he never gets better enough to truly stomach him imo.

Seán

i agree with all the people saying Mushoku tensei is a uncomfortable watch

Fathx19

Mushoku is the greatest isekai imo but I like the 3 of them

SaltyFish

Mushoku def the worst but Overlord on top✌️

Gocho

Even with a character as flaw as Rudeus, Mushoku Tensei is the most popular of those 3. the reason is because the story is so good that people watch it regardless. I can only imagine how popular would be if Rudeus was more Likeable.

Mael

I'd recommend Overlord, but mainly because it might give a chance in the future to react to Isekai Quarter (a crossover of Re:Zero, Konosuba, and Overlord). hahaha 😅

Brynden

Definitely what OfficiallyGames say, if she will be uncomfortable or if she won't like it, I wouldn't enjoy the reaction either. I want to see reactions of good/fun animes, but the reactor needs to be having fun to make the reaction good

Snow

I'm a very avid watcher of anime, ill literally watch everything (including some very sus ones like highschool dxd) but this anime was one I couldn't s1

lasher840

The MC in mushoku is an absolute piece of shit, and sure he gets "better" but when your starting at the literal bottom of a cesspool there is only one direction to go I guess. The art/animation/soundtrack and story are 10/10 tho. Slime has some issues, but way more wholesome than the other two.

Bambi

some very difficult watches, slime and overlord have some bits of good comedy at least

vanity

I know mushoku is popular buuuut i'm concerned for her on this one. It's probably not going to sit well at all

MrCinos

Even if you end up hating Mushoku Tensei's MC the actual character writing of many developments is amazing so hopefully you'll be able to get past some shaky bits early if the series does win. I also think people overblow the amount of stuff that is "unwathcable" according to them as well but everyone has different thresholds so your mileage may vary. Either way, the series is neck and neck with Re:Zero for me and MCs and some emotional stuff surrounding them was a big part of that. Any other isekais can't compare to those two series' as a result, but that's just me.

No name

Mushoku tensei It's not suitable for you. The story is good but it's a harem. I recommend something else. Sakamoto day

Rome

Honestly I don't think you would enjoy any of these. Recommendations for future poll: Code Geass, Gundam IBO (closest show to 86), link klick (underrated gem that is very emotional), Ancient magus bride, Beastars, Golden Kamuy, Dorohedoro (acid trip), Devilman Crybaby

Enrique 99

I really like mushoku but I feel that it doesn't go with your ideals, it would be very difficult for you to enjoy it since it has controversial caps

Enrique 99

The protagonist will literally disgust you, it is a story of growth with a very good world creation.

Rome

Don't watch Mushoku Tensei. The protag is a complete degenerate creep who in the LN though about SA-ing a six year old

Sleepy Boi

Mushoku is great but... Your gonna hate the mc like the rest of us. Tbh Idk if you'd enjoy any of them-

Herberek

and over 50% people have call of the void and they are still living today, or how many people in anger want to murder somone for half second and they can't event hurt other person. Once you have unfiltered and not "socialy correct" thinking pattern (not action) and people are talking like they have never though worse thing in their life. then there is thing about him being older but is he? can you call yourself older or even still yourself in new body? if your soul was transported to mind of a yearslong crackhead wuld you still be you? if you think so i thing you are delusional. but why think when you just can look good for social points

NR sensei

Mushoku tensei is one of my favorite works of all time and a part of me is very curious to see your reaction. But I do think you'll find it very uncomfortable during the first half of the season. If you skipped Nagatoro you'd probably want to skip this one, though it gets much worse imo. If you do decide to carry on with it, at least you are prepared. Just now that the MC is purposefully made to be a horrible person.

Gotsii Nouzen

Mushoku is entertaining removing the entire first season hahaha

mlg

People saying mushoku's mc "gets bettter", it doesn't, some people somehow just get used to it being an absolute piece of trash.

mlg

he doesn't "gets better", some people just gets used to it

ummm

if you found kazuma to be uncomfortable, i highly recommend you don't watch mushoku tensei. the main character acts worse and unlike konosuba they don't play it off as a joke.

Fire in da Hole

Agree 100% Add the Fate series while your at it too

ummm

slime is a lot of fun though! i think it will be the best choice given what shows you like

Sammy

I won't just outright say you shouldn't watch mushoku bc alot of ppl say they can ignore the mc somehow but I can never get past some of the things he does. The mc is a p3d0, it is blatant and REALLY creepy imo and he never stops being one.

ClusterDSA .

Ooof, I think Slime is the best choice for you. I like all 3 of these anime but Slime is the most tame, it's mostly just wacky fun. Overlord is good IF you can root for the bad guys. Because despite the MC doing some "good" things especially in the first season, make no mistake, he's out for himself and his allies and he's not going to let morality stand in his way. Mushoku Tensei is I think objectively the best show of the 3, BUT it's a show whos strengths are worldbuilding and character development. And the characters, especially the MC are not all good people. The MC is strait up a disgusting person in his old life for sure. Yeah he has trauma but you can't use trauma as an excuse to be horrible yourself. He has to grow to be a better person in his new life, and he does but the journey starts rough and takes a long time much like it would in real life. So while it's very good and very well done, I don't think the juice would be worth the squeeze for you. I think you'll just strait up not enjoy it and enjoyment is the whole point so just my thoughts.

Enrique 99

The slime anime that if you like it is calmer but interesting and with good world construction

Leeskimo

I cant f***ing wait 💪💪💪🔥🔥

Racc

For the people that dislike Mushoku Tensei because of the MC, what do you look for in a show to watch? just something you could self insert? Personally what I look for in a show is an entertaining story. I don't care if the protagonist is the biggest piece of shit of all fiction or if it's a saint. Watching a show doesn't mean that you condone every action of the characters in the show. There are shows like Dexter or the Netflix series of Jeffrey Dahmer and all the true crime stuff on youtube and I am sure that 99.9% of the people that watches that kind of things know that killing is bad but guess what those stories are enternaining.

funnyman

Seeing how you would react to Mushoku Tensei is the kind of tea I'm here for ngl 👀

Asakura04

MC can be flawed and interesting without being what Rudeus is, thee series treats all that shit weirdly. if you are ok with it cool but dont disregard people being uncomfortable with a show like that

icybino

Oh my god, I think Mushoku Tensei will reach "I'm gonna drop it" status, BUT, if you manage to push through, I think you'll enjoy the actual story! Either way, can't wait for new reactions!!

klairvoyage

Are y'all being obtuse on purpose whenever you guys make this dumb ass argument?

Carl Rigney

I would not ask you to sufffer through Mushoku Tensei, but That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime has its charms. Overlord is also a thing that exists in this world.

Carl Rigney

Code Geass is a classic. Golden Kamuy is great if one doesn't mind a bit of gore. Ancient Magus Bride is excellent.

Sammy

Man, its not just not condoning the mc's actions. Its very uncomfortable to watch this 40 yr old man sa children and there's no enjoyment i can get out of his adventures knowing what he is.

Itz A Dolphin

I think you will struggle with mushoku tensei, but the character growth is pretty good. Reincarnated as a slime will be more your speed and be much more positive.

Kingsley

I think mushoku tensei has some phenomenal world building and character growth but. God season 1 is so hard to get through with rudeus. Like. He has some great character changes especially later on but.. im not sure she would be able to stomach his bullshit

DjodY LOL

If youre patient with MT its easily the best here imo

Ryan Torres

You’ll be disgusted in MT.

Gowtham Ketharanathan

I do enjoy a lot of parts of MT, but at the very least, you can't just expect everyone to be comfortable with it (Rudeus in particular). You know damn well that the sexual content involving Rudeus is reasonably something people wouldn't be okay with.

Herberek

People screaming the most about this are watching anime like AOT or even overlord, but remember , one guy touching somone is 1000 times worse than ains kiling milions of peoples where many were tortured for days or months. I never understood this. Average isekai MC kiling robbers is based, 7th prince anime having a thic thighs and anime shoud not exist...

rebillihp

honestly what a great defense of a story with outright pedophilia lol

Racc

@Gowtham Ketharanathan I do understand, is just that from my perspective picking up the 99% of something that is really good and throw it to the trash just for something thats barely a 1% that you dont like is a waste.

Blinkyhill

Just to give you an idea you may dislike the MC as much as you disliked Lakan. If you can accept that flawed people can take a long time to become better (not fixed) then go for it. We will be there to listen to the hate rants.

Juan Noquez

I’m rooting for Slime on this one. MT is amazing with great animation and story but knowing how you feel about certain things I don’t think you can get past the first few episodes

sebastian jorquera

I really hope its not slime it loses its charm so fast and becomes such a bore

Azer S

I...partly disagree. The main selling point of slime is IT IS a bore. This is your happy, really slow show were nothing too serious happen and you know it. So it keeps its charm...for people seeking this kind of show.

Azer S

I vote for MT because i want to see how Faroh will go through Rudeus lol.

jadjad

I can't imagine Faroh going through a whole season of MT tbh i kinda don't want her to start it bcs she'll probably cringe a million times halfway through so I think slime might be more suited for her

Racc

@Azer S it does lose its charm and it becomes boring. at least on the side of the anime. I have not read the novels but I am up to date with the manga and I like it quite a lot. it's just the anime couldn't figure out the pacing

ExitStrat

Slime has a good start but gets boring FAST. Overlord is OK. MT is absolude masterpiece, much closer to a fantasy than an isekai in terms of writing style and world building. Yes, the MC is super cringy and I can fully understand why people hate him and give up on the show, but the entire series is SUPPOSED to be about his growth, development and redemption. It is a slow burn, but never really boring.

Curro Medina

The truth is that, unlike the rest, I think Mushoku would be perfect. It's a series in which the protagonist evolves and improves, dealing with themes such as loneliness, emotional wounds, self-definition, and overcoming trauma.

ExitStrat

I dunno, if she can handle Tapoki, she can handle pretty much ANYTHING except maybe Redo of Healer and Devilman Crybaby.

ExitStrat

True, the other two start strong and glide into monotony. MT starts ethically disgusting but evolves into a world and characters you love and are invested in. In that way MT reminds me of Konosuba, except the characters actually grow.

ExitStrat

It's the one of the three I would actually watch.

Klimentt Mart

Its absolutely different type of a show

Anthony Watson

I’m surprised to see it here and I’m also surprised it’s not running away with it. I think you may find you even enjoy it, after awhile. Either way I hope you only do it if you’re comfortable. If it wins that is

Gocho

After thinking a bit about MT. I think that if she can manage to set her mind that Rudeus is a fictional character and just enjoy the story, she can actually do it. There is a reason why this anime is so popular even with a character like Rudeus. It is because the story is excellent.

Racc

Very much agree. I have seen other creators that have reacted to mushoku tensei and think to myself "I dont think they are the kind of people that would like this show" but they did , obviusly "complaining" to Rudeus when he did something bad (as one should) but they still were able to enjoy the show.

Kyle Martin

fiction or not the MC is a pedo man......30-40 year old in a kids body trying to sleep with a 10 yr old is very creepy/messed up

Gocho

This show would be cancelled in the first season if that was true. Do you think that a show showing a 40 year old pedo will be that popular?

Craig

I'd say it very much depends what you're in the mood for. All 3 have their good and bad points. MT definitely has some of the most objectionable parts but so long as you can accept he's a protagonist with some serious flaws then you should enjoy the story. Overlord is very much a story about the bad guys and how their motivations and how they address problems are not constrained by normal morals, though I particularly like the growing political intrigues. And slime is the most cosy of them all, nearly everything in that show is aiming towards trying to create a happy universe of smiles, even if there are road bumps along the way.

Anime. JP

Well I always see your reaction and I prefer you to not watch MT, it's really good story but there's many characters that have weird profile in that story, it's not for everyone kind of show, you will become uncomfortable immediately judging from my experience watching your reaction all this time

Kyle Martin

dude he has the body of a kid but the mind of a 30/40 year old and he tried AND WANTED to sleep with the red head girl when she turned 10....if that doesnt say pedo to you then you are crazy af

Gocho

In that world at the age of 10 it was normal to get married and consume it. She showed up in his room and basically told him that was ok to do it. But when she change her mind, he didn't do it. And the first time he did it was with her 5 years later.

Racc

@Gocho Bro, in my opinion there is no need for you to defend or justify this. Is it weid at times? of course. do I care? No, they are just fictional characters. To me the two or three weird scenes weight too little in comparison to the other amazing things the anime has to offer.

Gocho

@Racc I am just depicting the full picture of how that imaginary world works. Just to clarify after someone just said part of the info to try to justify his point of view.

Kyle Martin

it doesnt matter if that world says its okay for a 10 year old to marry....he is from ( lets say our world) where a 10 year old is still a child and the fact he went for it shows he a pedo and even more so when he actually did it to her when she turned 15 which is still a child.....there is no defending him or his actions

Gocho

According to your standars, doesn't matter if he is 2 years younger than her, only matters that his mind has live for more than 40 years. If we apply that logic for example to Nazuna from call of the night, she is a 40 year old woman with a 14 year old boy and according to them sucking blod is the same to do it. I assume you are equally gross out about that.

Itz A Dolphin

MT is great because Rudeus is such a flawed character and watching him grow, mature, and improve is one of the plus points of the show. He starts out as a total scumbag, though, so you need to suck up the first season.

Itz A Dolphin

Oh yeah the morals behind MT is great, but Rudeus starts off as a total scumbag and I understand it can be hard to tolerate his behavior.

Itz A Dolphin

Ive been into the positive chill shows lately, so Slime is up my alley. Its def a show you need to be in the mood for.

Sensitive Sushi

I was uncomfortable watching Mushoku Tensei because it has moments when the main character is too much of a incel.

Racc

Does anyone know when is she going to start reacting to mushoku or wich series it will replace?

Luccii7887

I personally enjoyed mushoku tensei, but I’m not trying to cringe watching Farohs reaction

Kyle Martin

I never watched call of the night and blood sucking isnt the same as a grown adult trying to sleep with a kid....and the fact you keep defending the pedo MC is very concerning

Gocho

I don't have to defend something that doesn't exist. You are the one that is trying very hard to see something that is not there. There was never an adult trying to have sex with a kid. You just decided to see that trying to bend your perspective.

Big Duval

Mushoku is coming. Time for me to renew my membership again.

Paul

She liked the show, if you didn't check it out she is caught up. She understood character's decisions better than quite a few other reactors.

Luccii7887

Yeah actually suprised but I enjoyed seeing her reactions