Post or Pre TF? (Patreon)

Hey friends! Commissioner and I have been debating between this sketch and which we think would be most effective for the image.Imagine you come across this photo and see the figure behind it.

Would it be more interesting to find a photo of a young woman, then a Saiga close by in her clothes.

OR

You‘re exploring an old house with your young woman companion and find a photograph of her as this animal, like a future prediction.

Basically a before or after scenario.

What do you think?