Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hey Folks,

There are quite a few very interesting tools still to come in this Fragment series, but I have to admit I've been super excited about these: A set of hand cut files suitable for constructing the Antikythera Mechanism. Please enjoy :)

Cheers,

Chris.

-------- Video Notes --------

Amazon Affiliate links:

Cameras: 

Panasonic GH5 - https://amzn.to/2rEzhh2 

Panasonic X920 - https://amzn.to/2wzxxdT

Tools & Shop Products:

Optivisor Headband Magnifier: http://amzn.to/2HFg1FU

Saint Gobain (Norton) - 4 Arkansas Stones + case: http://amzn.to/2HCOAMX

Dykem 80300 Steel Blue Layout Fluid, Brush-in-Cap (4oz): http://amzn.to/2HGPaJJ

Books: 

"Solidworks 2013 Bible": http://amzn.to/2FObS1D

References

The Nicholson Guide to Files & Filing: http://www.nicholsontool.com/MagentoShare/media/documents/nicholson-guide-to-filing-2014.pdf

The late Ken Hawley on the Sheffield file cutting tradition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FB58hkncznI

A modern toolmaking company, producing magnificent hand cut files and rasps: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvr2nZeAfNc

Another beautiful video on rasp making: https://youtu.be/gQ09O3d8y9Q?t=3m22s 

Another look at traditional filecutting with a blend of both the modern filecutting machine as well as traditional hand cut files (German, no English CC's): https://youtu.be/koZkKDAg3Zs?t=18m10s 

Files

Previews only

Antikythera Fragment #3 - Ancient Tool Technology - Hand Cut Precision Files

Antikythera Fragment #3 - Ancient Tool Technology - Hand Cut Precision Files There are quite a few very interesting tools still to come in this Fragment series, but I have to admit I've been super excited about these: A set of hand cut files suitable for constructing the Antikythera Mechanism. Please enjoy :) The other video where I case harden the files can be found here: https://youtu.be/V_Mp1fNzIT8 If you would like to help support the creation of these videos, then head on over to the Clickspring Patreon page: https://www.patreon.com/clickspring ________________________________________________________ A very special thank you to Patrons: Sinking Valley Woodworks (http://www.sinkingvalleywoodworks.com) Glenn Trewitt Christopher Warnock Mike Manfrin Sam Towne Adam Slagle Jack Cause Daniel Taraldsen Jeremiah G. Mort Dave Seff Matteo Neville Olof Haggren Stassinopoulos Thomas Florian Ragwitz Larry Pardi Samuel Irons Tim Bray Sean Kuyper ________________________________________________________ You can also help me make these videos by purchasing via the following Amazon Affiliate links: Cameras used in this video: Panasonic GH5 - https://amzn.to/2rEzhh2 Panasonic X920 - https://amzn.to/2wzxxdT Tools & Shop Products: "Foundrywork for the Amateur (Workshop Practice)" - https://amzn.to/2Kd1iUb "The Backyard Foundry (Workshop Practice Series)" - https://amzn.to/2KdfTip "Hardening, Tempering and Heat Treatment (Workshop Practice Series)" - https://amzn.to/2KbZo6l Salamander A-6 SUPER Clay Graphite Morgan Melting Crucible: http://amzn.to/2pkVAak Dykem 80300 Steel Blue Layout Fluid, Brush-in-Cap (4oz): http://amzn.to/2HGPaJJ Abbreviated Transcript: 00:40 The Greek civilisation was well into the Iron Age at the time of the devices creation. But the question of steel availability is not easily answered. Certainly there was a form of crucible steel known as Wootz, from the region we now call India. But there was also the technique known as case hardening, which essentially converts the surface of an iron object into steel. 01:23 The first step is to take this raw stock, and shape the basic file blanks. In recent history, this job was done on a massive grinding wheel. And although it would of course have been much slower and less convenient, similar hand powered abrasive tools are known to have existed in antiquity. 02:46 No matter how much I roll the file on top of the work, it rotates so that the file will still cut reasonably flat. Ok, so with the file surfaces stripped, the next step is to form the teeth. And I need to make a few more custom tools to get this part of the job done. I've made a simple file cutting workstation, based on the traditional approach, but scaled down to suit the size of my shop. 06:15 And that first tooth now becomes the reference for the next tooth. The chisel blade is slid up against it, and then the subsequent teeth are laid down one after another. Each time, using the previous cut to locate the next. 08:59 Well I'm not about to give up my commercially made files any time soon. But they do work quite well. They're probably equivalent to a modern #2 cut file, and although the cutting action is not quite as sweet as a new, modern file, its a reasonable balance between metal removal and surface finish. They're durable, easy to handle, and certainly perform well enough to have constructed the original mechanism. 10:31 But there's still quite a high degree of consistency of the root angles around each given wheel. That suggests to me that the teeth were in fact formed by simply plunging the file into the workpiece, like I've done here. And that the root angle variation observed across the gearing, was in fact generated by a small selection of files cut specifically to construct this mechanism. Ok, so to wrap this one up, Its still very early days for this reconstruction. And I've still got a lot more research to do into the tool technology behind this machine. References: The Nicholson Guide to Files & Filing: http://www.nicholsontool.com/MagentoShare/media/documents/nicholson-guide-to-filing-2014.pdf The late Ken Hawley on the Sheffield file cutting tradition: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FB58hkncznI A modern French toolmaking company, producing magnificent hand cut files and rasps: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gvr2nZeAfNc Another beautiful video on rasp making: https://youtu.be/gQ09O3d8y9Q?t=3m22s A look at traditional filecutting. A blend of both the modern filecutting machine as well as traditional hand cut files (German, no English CC's): https://youtu.be/koZkKDAg3Zs?t=18m10s Antikythera Fragment #3 - Ancient Tool Technology - Hand Cut Precision Files

Comments

Matt Lukes

Wonderful Chris- you've inspired me to try making more of my own tools!

Doug Strain

Hi Chris! I noticed (dare I say it :-) a slight wobble of the chisel on some of the strokes. Instead of a flat struck-end of the chisel, would a radius centered on the sharp end tend to self-align the cutter? Thanks for these!

clickspring

Hi Doug, yes it certainly does - At the suggestion of others I made the mod to the chisels shortly after making the vid , and it made the tool a lot more predictable to handle, much less of the wobbles! - Cheers :)

Dominik Rogala

Hello Chris, like always your videos are amazing and precious! I recently read “Hardening Tempering And Heat Treatment” by Tubal Cain which you recommended. Author suggests that after casehardening we should allow to cool, than reheat again and quenched. I saw on your videos that you are quenched right away after removed case. Could you explain why you use this method other one mention by Tubal Cain. Btw I’m totally newbie in all that metal thing, just starting.

clickspring

Hello mate, in this instance it would serve no purpose to let the part cool and then re-heat, and would only risk further oxidation of the delicate teeth. The carbon infusion has already occured to the required depth, so an immediate quench is all that's really left to do - Cheers :)

Anonymous

You are a wizard.

Anonymous

Beautiful and fascinating, wonderful as always Chris!

Paul Busby

Quick Stop working. A new video is out. Amazing as always. So now you are building the tools to build the tools that make the device :) Always been a bit of a mystery how files were made and this video makes the process so easy to follow. The simplicity of the process and some of the tools is what i find amazing. When you first show the stripping device i had no idea how that would help and yet it is obvious once shown. This Old Tony is right. What bad things could be said.

Khanh Khong

Ah, my dream came true. This video made my morning. I appreciate all the auxiliary information in the video notes. I've seen the videos, but didn't know of the Nicholson PDF. I can't wait for more tool videos.

Peter Muller

Always appreciate how accessible your vids are. Liking the home foundry work too. Maybe some casting vids in the future?

Anonymous

Dang Chris. Your patience is legendary! Excellent video as always.

Jess Neal

The planning and patience that you are putting into this is second to none Chris. So impressive and informative.

Phil DeJarnett

I really love the insight into the technology of the time period. What amazes me more than anything is seeing the mountain of knowledge that was already necessary by this time just to build the tools needed to build the mechanism. Woodworking, leather, iron, brass, steel hardening, getting fires hot enough, understanding how to get the carbon into the steel, etc, etc. It would have already taken the support of a large community and wealth of history to get here. And without the knowledge acquired up to this point and through complex projects like this, we wouldn't be able to continue expanding our civilization. Thanks again for the amazing video and the wonderful education!

Stephen Behan

Chris, really superlative stuff. A wonderful extension of the theories that others have contributed to trying to understand what the ancients were able to achieve; . I know the watch and clock making world was at one time centred on London and in particular around Clerkenwell; do you think the Greeks had specialists to resort to in the way Mudge and Harrison did? Were there families in Greece who specialised in smelting , forging, file making, tool making etc etc? Or do you think it was one small group of particularly gifted people? You've shown one person can make the tools, and do it using materials and technologies the ancients could probably access, but, do you think there was an organisation behind the makers of the mechanism? I have to say, I cannot wait to see the next episode - I think your work is amongst the very best on Youtube; well done!

Buddha Buck

It's a lovely video. Thanks for making it. When I saw you grinding, scraping, and filing the file blanks before cutting the teeth, I could see a lot of iron dust building up underneath the work. Is it possible to collect that iron and recycle it (using period techniques)? It seems that if iron is a valuable commodity, some effort would have been made to conserve/reuse scrap. What would have been done?

clickspring

This is what blows me away too - its clear that the Hellenes were well and truly on the verge of an industrial revolution of their own had conflict not intervened.

Al McKague

Fascinating stuff! An education in every video. I wonder if the maker(s?) went down with the ship and the knowledge was lost for centuries. On a practical matter, how often did you have to sharpen your cutting chisel? Was it so hard that it kept an edge through all the files?

clickspring

Hey Stephen - The current guess is that the workshop tradition started several hundred years earlier, possibly on the island of Rhodes, under the guidance of a master (perhaps Archimedes) and then passed down as a generational thing within that "school" or workshop. Archimedes in particular contributed much militarily, so the connection to the military production craftsmen of the day seems entirely logical. For example, despite their culture being well into their Iron Age, bronze (+ leather) was still the primary material for personal armour. I would guess therefore that preparing raw bronze sheet stock would have been a well established process that could either be taken directly from the armourer's knowledge and applied, or perhaps the armourer provided it directly, saving a massive amount of time, much like Clerkenwell - A wonderful thought no? "Here you go Archy, 10 sheets of premium bronze sheet... Now what sort of gadget are you planning to build this time??" :)

clickspring

Hey BB, It looks like a lot, but in reality its really quite a small quantity, so much too small to be recycled. Its enough to make a decent mess though! Having said that, iron was definitely considered a premium material at the time - Alexander is known to have instructed his generals to capture all of the iron they found, simply because it was considered so valuable. So any practical amounts were likely kept and reforged into something else. Kinda makes you think though doesn't it? given how much of the stuff just sits in the yard at every scrap dealer on the planet... Cheers mate :)

clickspring

Hey Al - I gave the chisels a light touch on the wheel after completing each face. It probably wasn't necessary to do it quite that often, but I really enjoyed the feel of the fresh blade, and the way it throws up such a clean tooth, I couldn't resist. I think the shop foreman would probably have had words with me back in the day!

George Harris

Love these home shop tool builds, looks like a lot of work has gone into this one. Brilliant as always Chris!

Paul Devey

Chris, is making these videos now your full time job or are you still working in a local coal mine like the rest of us?

Gordon Burns

Bloody spot on, as usual, Chris. To have me as a Patron, in Parteon, you must be not just good but great! Thus, I have but two Patreon beneficiaries and you are one of them, I sit here in good old Blighty, eagerly awaiting your next missive, which I hope will not be too far away. I'm now 65 and hope that I live long enough to see the finished Antikythera machine.

Frank Donahue

Chris can you give a bit more info on how you did the file teeth cutting thanks another great video

Peter W. Meek

High-class video, as always. You never fail to impress. I've made a few files and saws, either for a special shape, or because a proper file or saw wasn't handy. It is surprisingly easy to get regular spacing for the teeth, isn't it.

clickspring

Hey Paul, still working at the school, but have cut back the hours a bit to spend more on the videos :)

clickspring

Hey Frank, there's really not a lot more to it than I show in the video - You lay the chisel on the work, lean it back away from you a bit, and then whack it with a hammer. Slide the chisel blade up to the front of that first tooth, and then whack the hammer again, and then so on up the line. Once you get in the groove, its surprisingly straight forward :)

clickspring

Thank you Peter :) Yes I was really pleased that it was much easier to do than it looked! Kind of relaxing too once I got into the groove. And I noticed that I got a lot more uniform cuts if I didn't stop at all. In fact the irregularities always occurred when I took a moment to look at the previous cuts - If I just belted through top to bottom, the result was much better. Cheers mate :)

Frank Donahue

I think I get it now after more watching of the reference videos and yours too the chisel cut is set referenced by feel of touch by fingers holding the chisel and by eye too

clickspring

Yes that's it exactly, you can feel it just touch the raised surface of the previous tooth, and while its sitting there, you just give it a hit. By far the most important part of the whole job is getting the straps and anvil to securely hold the blanks. You'll notice that it wants to walk on you particularly for the first face. The subsequent faces grip the tin, so they stay put quite well, but that first face is a bit harder.

Chris Talbot

Now come on Chris, you're cheating a bit mate. "Tools and techniques true to the period"... where's the video of you knocking together a little pedal-operated grindstone setup then eh? ;) Thoroughly interesting, and very professionally produced as always. I'm really looking forward to the next full video in the A.M. series!

ShamWerks

Awesome stuff, as usual. I did watch the video about the carbon/heat treatment first, and I was wondering "hey, how did I miss the time he made those files??" :-) Now I know. Thanks for all the hard work I have no doubt you put into making these beautiful, informative, inspiring videos.

A Glimpse Inside

I think this video series will have a similar legacy as the antikythera device itself! Loving this content so much brother!

Anonymous

I'm glad you're going to the trouble of making your own simple tools to work on this project. I'm not a metal worker but I find your videos so fascinating.

Khanh Khong

I've watch this video so many times now. If my understanding is correct, file teeth perform better when they are more uniform whereas rifters/rasps do better with a more random variance. I've notice that the struck ends of your chisel are flat instead of rounded/crowned. I think that rounding/crowning them may help you have a more uniform tooth. It would probably help more with the wider files. They also seem to use a very specialized hammer as well, but that maybe a little bit much for just a few files. <a href="https://www.hrionline.ac.uk/matshef/unwin/MSfilecutter.htm" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.hrionline.ac.uk/matshef/unwin/MSfilecutter.htm</a>

Anonymous

When chiseling in the teeth of the files, wouldn't a slightly less deep chisel mounted/spaced a bit behind the main chisel allow you to 'slot' in to the prior hit and keep the teeth both uniformly spaced and exactly at the same angle? In my head I'm envisioning your main chisel head, and then up and out a small amount another head, when you strike a line, you move the chisel up and tilt down to slide the other head in to the new groove, then tilt back forward for another strike.

Anonymous

Thinking more about this, seems you could make this a reusable tool by having dowels/pins (not sure of the right word) off the main chisel, and having the slotting chisel slide on to them, with washers to space it out further depending on how wide you want the spacing between the grooves to be.

Anonymous

Why just one locating pin, when drilling for the rivets? Don't you need 2 to prevent both translation and rotation of the pieces?

clickspring

Hey Eric - One radial pin will suffice in this instance, due to the central bore being filled with a large diameter pin also. Between the two of them, they keep it all locked - Cheers mate :)

Duncan Luddite

Watching this again Chris, (for the umpteenth time), and I think you need to make a 'Clickspring' touch-mark punch to sign your files :)