Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Hey Folks,

Here is the first of 2 new Fragments videos, both investigating the drilling technology that could potentially have been used to build the Antikythera Mechanism. In this one, I have a good look at a plausible method for creating an ancient equivalent to drill rod, and then shape it into a useful drill bit.

The next one is the main video on the drilling tool, and it should be finished uploading in approx 24 hours.

Cheers,

Chris.

Files

Previews only

Antikythera Fragment #5 - Ancient Tool Technology - The First Precision Drill Bit

Antikythera Fragment #5 - Ancient Tool Technology - The First Precision Drill Bit, by Clickspring. There are a number of cutting tools implied in the wreckage of the Antikythera Mechanism, and one of the most interesting is the drill bit. In this video I explore a possible method of how an effective and precise drill bit could have been made in antiquity. The video where I show the carburisation process in detail can be found here: https://youtu.be/V_Mp1fNzIT8 If you would like to help support the creation of these videos, then head on over to the Clickspring Patreon page: https://www.patreon.com/clickspring ________________________________________________________ A very special thank you to Patrons: Sinking Valley Woodworks (http://www.sinkingvalleywoodworks.com) Glenn Trewitt Christopher Warnock Mike Manfrin Steven Sladewski Rollin W. Patrick, Jr. Jim Popwell Gary Levario Pete Askew Norman Lemke Andre van Soest Andrew Smith Bernd Fischer Rudolph Bescherer Jr Sam Towne Adam Slagle Jack Cause Jeremiah G. Mort Dave Seff Olof Haggren Stassinopoulos Thomas Florian Ragwitz Larry Pardi Michael Harmon Lonnie Koehn Tim Bray ________________________________________________________ You can also help me make these videos by purchasing via the following Amazon Affiliate links: Cameras used in this video: Panasonic GH5 - https://amzn.to/2rEzhh2 Panasonic X920 - https://amzn.to/2wzxxdT Tools & Shop Products: "Solidworks 2013 Bible": http://amzn.to/2FObS1D "Hardening, Tempering and Heat Treatment (Workshop Practice Series)" - https://amzn.to/2KbZo6l Salamander A-6 SUPER Clay Graphite Morgan Melting Crucible: http://amzn.to/2pkVAak Norton 1-by-2-by-8-Inch Fine/Coarse India Combination Oilstone, Red: http://amzn.to/2tTEPb0 Saint Gobain (Norton) - 4 Arkansas Stones + case: http://amzn.to/2HCOAMX Abbreviated Transcript: 00:12 The existence of an Ancient style of drill bit is strongly implied in the wreckage of the Antikythera Mechanism. And its fabrication would have likely hinged on a crucial process: The ability to take a malleable wrought iron, and transform it into something hard enough to cut bronze. 00:28 I've covered the process in detail in a separate video, but essentially it involves packing an animal based charcoal and salt around the soft iron, sealing it in clay, and then heating it up to a red heat I'm using a low carbon mild steel as a substitute for Ancient wrought iron. Its soft and ductile. 01:00 But there are some great examples of long slender turning to be found within the wreckage of the mechanism itself. There's a shaft that extended from the lunar phase gearing up to the phase display on the front dial that's roughly 4mm in diameter. 01:16 And there are numerous other pins and shafts, some less than a mm in diameter. I'm using a modern furnace for convenience, but a traditional charcoal furnace is quite capable of generating the required temperature. Once at a red heat, the process of carburising the iron is purely a time exercise. 01:51 So I reheated the rods, rolled them straight on a flat surface, and then requenched. The once soft metal is now very hard, but also extremely brittle, and so easily fractures under a light bending load. So to be of use as a cutting tool, it needs to be tempered, in this case to a light straw color. 02:40 I can see this end of the rod is a good straight section, so that'll become the actual bit, and the excess will be removed at the end of the process. A gentle heat raises the temperature of the rod until a pale straw color just reaches what will become the cutting end. The material is now in a tempered state. Still very hard, but tough rather than brittle. 03:23 Despite no longer being widely used, it still has a number of attributes to recommend it. The first being that its very easy to make. Because the primary surfaces can all be formed by hand, on flat abrasive stones. The cutting edges can be shaped for unidirectional cutting, or as in the case that I'm showing onscreen, for single direction cutting. 03:59 And once the operational length has been decided, it can be permanently set by scoring the metal with a file, and then snapping off the excess material. 04:38 In its rigid cross section form, this sort of drill bit will often perform much like a traditional D bit. Delivering a very straight deep hole. Now there is of course an obvious drawback to the drill bit design: The need to repeatedly withdraw it from the work to clear the chips. 05:36 As soon as the cutting edges start to dull, a quick hit on the stones will bring them back to original condition. Now you won't want to throw out your twist drills any time soon, but its a great option to keep in mind for those rare occasions when you really do need a custom drill bit. References: Watchmaking by Daniels: http://amzn.to/2FH3cyh The many books and DVD's by WR (Bill) Smith: https://wrsmithclocks.com/dvd/ Antikythera Fragment #5 - The First Precision Drill Bit, by Clickspring.

Comments

Dustin

Now if there was only a way to show how to make homemade sheet bronze stock, just like great great great great great great great great great great great great great great gran'dad used to make

Chris Talbot

New Clickspring always makes my afternoon. :)

Leo G.

Le Sigh... More of my "Bob Ross of Machining" fix. One question though. You mention making a hand powered drill which you covered in another video, but it seems that video didn't survive the perils of the dreaded 4chan beast on its quest to the holy land of YouTubes. Did something go wrong, or is that video still upcoming? PS. Any chance you could add another couple tags on Patreon for the Antikythera Mechanism and Fragments playlists?

clickspring

Ha ha! Still on its way mate, should be finished uploading in about 22hrs - The interwebs are bloody useless in my part of the world :)

Tyler Moore

Two hours after I become a Patron! The opposite of delayed gratification haha.

Phil Sydor

Another great video - thanks Chris.

Anonymous

Very interesting. If the drill point is slightly off centre (since it is made only by eye) does it still drill accurately?

Ryan Das

Yes, because compared to a twist drill, it's very rigid. A twist drill is two helices connected by a thin web, which is very flexible in comparison.

Ryan Das

You just had to tease us with the shot of the drill itself!

Brent Moore

Is there an option for a go fund me to get Chris some quality internet? I would throw in a few bones if it got me my clickspring fix faster.

Ralph McCoy

Will the drilling tool have a build plan, like some of your other tools have ?? Great to be alive now instead of 2000 years ago. Ralph

Ralph McCoy

Is this now "tool steel" ? Ralph

clickspring

I'm pretty sure its currently all based on carrier pigeons... Actually the speed isn't so much a problem as the dropouts. So many times I'll be 3/4 through an upload and it hangs because of an interruption. I'm really looking forward to the mobile 5G when it becomes available

clickspring

Yes Ralph, the plans will be available from later today as a free download - its a great little project to build.

clickspring

Kinda - Its missing some of the trace alloying elements (Mn, Cr, W etc), but I think its probably fair to call it a proto drill rod. At the very least, its a functional equivalent given its hardness characteristics after the quench. Cheers mate :)

Al McKague

As usual, a great video. Would a D bit br more rigid since you leave more material behind the cutting edge? I suppose on these small scales, it would be hard to tell the difference.

Kenneth Klose

Greetings Chris from the opposite side of the planet. Great video! At 4:16 you mention we should check out another video on your use of hand drills in the Antikythera construction. Did I miss a video somewhere, or is this an as yet unreleased video you are referencing? Cheers.

clickspring

Greetings Kenneth, thank you! Yes that second video is uploading at present, it should be complete in approx 8 hours - Cheers :)

Rene Schickbauer

Whats the difference between using leather and other materials like wood as your carbon source?

clickspring

Its hard to be sure - The old texts are quite specific that it should be an animal based charcoal (horn, hoof, bone, leather etc) but are silent as to the reason why. My best guess is that there is something organic in an animal based carcoal that also assists the CO reaction, perhaps as a catalyst. Cheers :)

Anonymous

Thanks for another captivating video! How would you go about getting wrought iron into a drill rod geometry (straight, constant diameter and circular? I don't think the (ancient) lathe is an option for long and thin parts like that, is it?

clickspring

Thank you Jan! I will cover this in a later video, but yes it was definitely possible. The wreckage of the machine is perhaps the best proof: it has a number of long slender parts in it eg the lunar phase display shaft (approx 75mm x 4mm) as well as a number of retaining pins approx 1mm x 25mm - these dimensions exceed the turning requirements to form the green drill rod - These parts and several other features point to a remarkably sophisticated lathe tech that was surprisingly close to our own - Cheers mate :)

Kevin Reardon

Now I see where you've been spending your time. Who knew you had to sign into Patreon to get updates? Well, this idiot just increased my donation to $3 so I can get better updates. I would really like to see that paper you submitted. Making this drill is a PhD in and of itself.

clickspring

Ha ha! Thank you mate :) I need to re-work the paper a bit to incorporate the suggestions from the peer review, and I also have another idea that I want to write up that is probably a bit more substantial, so will take longer to finalise - once they're good to go, you'll read about it all here first - Cheers :)

Clifton Ballad

Would this style bit offer any advantage for sheet metal (.06" and under) or putting holes through round objects? Maybe make it more like a 135* vs 118* point? I have a decent length of .25" W1 tool steel sitting at work and I've been plotting on making a spotting/sheet metal drill out of some of it...

clickspring

Definitely worth a try mate - My own experience is that they're very effective in certain applications, have a definite self spotting capacity and a good suitability to shallow holes. Several viewers report that they use these drills often in a commerical setting, either shop made, or the commercial variant: <a href="https://www.sandvik.coromant.com/en-us/products/pages/productdetails.aspx?c=hc%204" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">https://www.sandvik.coromant.com/en-us/products/pages/productdetails.aspx?c=hc%204</a>

Frank Donahue

Another great video about a wonderfully useful tool to add to the ever growing list of shop projects for when I get my shop rebuilt thanks again Chris for making such great use of our patronage have a good night/day

Matt Lukes

Absolutely brilliant- you've answered yet another question I've always had about how the ancients managed to do things. It's particularly impressive that such tiny diameter bits are possible, and how it's really quite straightforward to make cleanly-spaced holes. I sometimes struggle with such things using modern twist drill bits (at 1mm they can be very flimsy), and I'm definitely thinking of trying some of these ancient designs! Thanks yet again Chris!