Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

  

In this episode the basic structure of the mechanism comes together, and I put forward a theory on a simple method for achieving the extremely close clearances observed in the original device.

Its an extra length episode for you folks, so please enjoy!

PS Thank you to Peter Meek for the idea to wrap the small parts vise closing ring with leather - It now has a very pleasant feel as its closed or released, and the wood is well protected from scuffing. Thanks very much for suggesting Peter :)


Cheers,

Chris.

 

-------------- Video Notes: --------------- 

Amazon Affiliate links:

Cameras used in this video: 

Panasonic GH5 - https://amzn.to/2rEzhh2 

Panasonic X920 - https://amzn.to/2wzxxdT

Tools & Shop Products:

Sherline Lathe: http://amzn.to/2pnXM19

Optivisor Headband Magnifier: http://amzn.to/2HFg1FU

Saint Gobain (Norton) - 4 Arkansas Stones + case: http://amzn.to/2HCOAMX

Hegner Scroll Saw: https://amzn.to/2IhteVW

Dykem 80300 Steel Blue Layout Fluid, Brush-in-Cap (4oz): http://amzn.to/2HGPaJJ

Super Pike Saw Blades Size 4/0 pkg of 144: http://amzn.to/2IO6aPw

Books: 

"Gears From The Greeks", Derek de Solla Price: http://amzn.to/2pii4ZD

"Solidworks 2013 Bible": http://amzn.to/2FObS1D

Files

Previews only

The Antikythera Mechanism Episode 3 - The Plates And Main Bearing.

The Antikythera Mechanism Episode 3 - The Plates And Main Bearing, by Clickspring. In this episode the basic structure of the mechanism comes together, and I put forward a theory on a simple method for achieving the extremely close clearances observed in the original device. If you would like to help support the creation of these videos, then head on over to the Clickspring Patreon page: https://www.patreon.com/clickspring ________________________________________________________ A very special thank you to Patrons: Tim Bray Sinking Valley Woodworks (http://www.sinkingvalleywoodworks.com) Mike Manfrin Christopher Warnock Glenn Trewitt Dan Keen Samuel Irons Sean Kuyper Matteo Neville Daniel Cohen Larry Pardi Olof Haggren Stassinopoulos Thomas Florian Ragwitz Matthew Middleton Dave Seff ________________________________________________________ You can also help me make these videos by purchasing via the following Amazon Affiliate links: Cameras used in this video: Panasonic GH5 - https://amzn.to/2rEzhh2 Panasonic X920 - https://amzn.to/2wzxxdT Tools & Shop Products: "Solidworks 2013 Bible": http://amzn.to/2FObS1D "Gears From The Greeks", Derek de Solla Price: http://amzn.to/2pii4ZD "A Portable Cosmos: Revealing the Antikythera Mechanism, Scientific Wonder of the Ancient World" https://amzn.to/2NoLgIR Dykem 80300 Steel Blue Layout Fluid, Brush-in-Cap (4oz): http://amzn.to/2HGPaJJ Dormer A190202 Jobber Drill Set, 1.0 mm - 6.0 mm x 0.1 mm Size: https://amzn.to/2DR5fdb Dormer A190203 Jobber Drill Set, 6.0 mm - 10.0 mm x 0.1 mm Size: https://amzn.to/2ITfeTa YG1 NC Spotting Drill 8% Cobalt HSS 1/8 to 1/2" 120 Degree 5 Pc Set CNC Machine: https://amzn.to/2G7ylv6 Blue Matador Abrasive Paper - https://amzn.to/2IAFiBT Heavy Duty Arbor Press: http://amzn.to/2G4gog7 Saint Gobain (Norton) - 4 Arkansas Stones + case: http://amzn.to/2HCOAMX Abbreviated Transcript: 00:23 So what exactly is the structure of the mechanism? Well if you strip everything away, it comes down to this. A single main plate, with a single main bearing located at its center. The front planetary display is speculated to have been positioned just above the main plate, and the rear display is known to have been located on the other side. It's a 3 tiered structure providing support and alignment for the entire mechanism, and you can see that it has features spread across all 3 levels, that are all somewhat related. 01:41 Now its impossible to know for sure if the original maker used the same technique, but certainly some sort of systematic approach would have been essential. 04:07 Using one of the pins to gauge the progress of the taper. The pins were then hammered firmly into place, and the opposing holes on the other plate given a light countersink. Now for the plates to all sit flush when stacked, the pins must sit beneath the surface of each matching plate. 06:41 Registering each plate with the one beneath it. Again taking care to align the plates carefully before drilling, and placing the pins in regions of the mechanism known to be available space. I can now work with the plates aligned in a complete stack like this, or in various combinations as required, and be confident that the relative positioning of features will be accurate across all 4 plates. 07:49 The sub plate was then returned to the stack to pick up the correct position for the pillars, and finally the front dial plate was returned to the stack to drill out the pilot holes for the pillars. Now without register pins, this would have been quite a challenging task to manage. 10:44 And this is significant, because the presence of a square hole in the spacer leads to an unavoidable conclusion: That the part was in fact fabricated from 2 separate pieces. A spacer with a square hole, and a main bearing body, that were then pressed together to form the full bearing profile. 11:29 All throughout the device, virtually every sub assembly incorporates this idea of spacers and wheels, Either riveted together as a sort of layered sandwich, or threaded onto a shouldered arbor, or both. Certainly the wheels and spacers could have been formed from stock selected to achieve a specific clearance, much like this bearing. But its easy to imagine the maker taking it a step further. 12:13 With not much more than an flat abrasive surface and good eyesight, the maker could have achieved exceptional dimension control without any need for absolute measurement. References: Gears From The Greeks - Derek de Solla Price: http://amzn.to/2pii4ZD The CT and PTM data that the AMRP have made publicly available can be found here: http://www.antikythera-mechanism.gr/data Gear schematic can be found in Tony Freeth's 2012 research paper: http://dlib.nyu.edu/awdl/isaw/isaw-papers/4/ Credits: Clips from "The 2000 Year Old Computer" courtesy Images First Ltd. The Antikythera Mechanism Episode 3 - The Plates And Main Bearing, by Clickspring.

Comments

Andrew Larking

Perfect timing. The rains have come and it's too cold to go milling tonight. I'll crack open the wine. :-)

Mark Doss

Thx. Much appreciated! My 4yo daughter loves what you do. Myself also.

David

That was brilliant! Well worth the wait😃

Al McKague

A perfect thing to find in my inbox after running around mowing the lawn. Sit down with a nice cold beverage and watch Chris do magic for a while.

Chris Muncy

Chris, I warned you about releasing the videos during working hours here in the U.S. ..... Fortunately I've taken the day off in anticipation of this video release :-)

clickspring

Cheers David, thanks for being patient! This one was a particularly time consuming one to edit. It took way longer than I ever expected (or wanted!!)

Chris Ivison

I'm enjoying this so much! I've already watched the series 7 times! :D Can't wait for the next episode. Hopefully the wait won't be as long :) Love everything you do.

Ralph McCoy

Chris, Great video. Where is the London Sundial at ? Ralph

Anonymous

Well that was the shortest 17 minutes ever! Whatever mechanisms you are making, Chris, you are adept at making time speed up :-D Great video mate and it is really interesting the way you have paid so much close attention to the scans of the mechanism to come to the conclusions you have. Brilliant.

Anonymous

Again, another great video Chris. You're editing and production is second to none - love your work, look forward to the next instalment.

Ralph McCoy

Chris, thanks for the response. A question you drill out the pinion shafts after you cut the teeth, why not the other way around ? Thanks Ralph

Anonymous

So glad to get my Click Spring fix today. Great Video, Chris.

Anonymous

Fantasic as awlays! Can't wait to see it with all the moving part. Cheers!

clickspring

Hey Ralph, by doing it in that order I get to use the radial pattern and "tit" from the facing cut to align the cutter :)

Mike Oswald

Thanks Chris, this is great.

Giovanni Viscardi

:D i love the smile after seeing this email come across my phone notifications.. im instantly like "well i know what im doing this instant".

Toby Keane

Beautifully mesmerising as always Chris! Like Matt, I love the attention and integrity paid to the original scans, fantastic. Not going to lie, I was starting to get worried as to when I was going to get my next fix. I've been considering counseling. Feel much better now :), thank you. Please, not so long next time! Toby

clickspring

Very pleased you enjoyed it mate :) Yes its been a bit stressful for me too! I don't want to let you all down by not getting the content out regularly, but at the same time I feel compelled to make sure its up to scratch in every respect - this one was frankly a bit of a nightmare to get over the line - it has basically consumed the entire month. I've learned a lot about how to present this project and also improve my own processes as a result, so hopefully I will be able to avoid the dramas from here on.

Gordon Burns

Yet another great video, Chris, showing your exquisite skill in metal working. Thanks, mate.

Adam Ackels

Amazing work as always! Just wondering though, not including time to edit this video, but how much hard time do you have invested in making components in this video?

Michael Lloyd

Awe inspiring work. I just bought my first mini lathe. The journey begins

clickspring

Hey Adam, its kind of hard to say because for me the process of video making is so entwined in the part making as well: plan the shot, light, shoot, re-position, light, shoot etc Also the b-roll, continuity shots, close ups, setups for the CAD effects etc. If I were to only complete the parts (without any video recording) it would probably take me 6 to 8 hours to do the work shown in this video. The shooting magnifies that time significantly (between 5x and 10x), but its the editing that accounts for the majority of the time input for the videos, this one in particular took a massive amount of time to edit.

Gordon Burns

Yet another exquisitely superb video from my antipodean friend, Chris. Despite my having served an extremely intensive technical engineering apprenticeship in the 1960s,, I deeply admire your work, which is bordering upon perfection. Keep it up mate.

Leo G.

Another amazing video. Thanks so much. I'm learning so much just listening to the explanations behind shy doy things in the order you do them.

Greg Nixon

Great interpretation of how the clockmakers of old did things. Another great video.

Greg Nixon

Can you please tell me the cutting oil that you use?

Paul Busby

Great video Chris. Amazing to see you blend the brass pins and the bearing and watch it disappear as if it never had a whole in it. What is the name of the anvil type thing you have that has the holes in. Used when you joined the main bearing together.

clickspring

Hey Paul, that is called a Bench Block. The one I have is a jewellers version, I can't recall where I picked it up but a quick google search pulled up this one from the Brownells catalogue which is quite similar: <a href="http://www.brownells.com/gunsmith-tools-supplies/general-gunsmith-tools/bench-blocks/gunsmith-steel-bench-block-prod682.aspx" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://www.brownells.com/gunsmith-tools-supplies/general-gunsmith-tools/bench-blocks/gunsmith-steel-bench-block-prod682.aspx</a>

Peter W. Meek

Paul - Larger versions of the bench block (for working on larger projects) are available from industrial supply stores like McMaster-Carr or MSC in the US. They often appear used on eBay.

Peter W. Meek

Chris - beautiful videography, as usual. This project bids fair to surpass even the clock (which I never would have thought possible). And thanks for the mention; it's always nice to see one's name in lights.

Lucus Landers

This new series really shows what can be done with a simple hand file. For my first assignment in a machining class I took years ago we had to hand file a precision cylinder to fit into a hole. We then machined that same cylinder. The purpose of the assignment was that you should never have to hand file when you have machines. Because of this I have stayed away from the file as much as possible. But now I am rethinking that decision!

Tom Colson

Thanks for another fascinating view into the project. Your explanation of your thinking about the process and how it might relate to the historical build serve to differentiate this project from YAMV (yet another machining video).

James Cromwell

It's looking great Chris! I see you added some leather to the metal on your clamp, does that help its hold or just to protect the wood?

clickspring

Hey James, yes to both - it was a suggestion from Peter Meek, and works extremely well. The closing action is now smooth and subtle, and can be finessed to suit the part. It has also eliminated the small abrasion of the wood at the closing contact point. It has made the tool quite outstanding to use. In fact the massive throat depth alone makes it far more versatile than either of my bench vises, and it has largely superseded my little Panavise.

Rc

stunning!

Anonymous

In reference to the Bushings and the like.. I wonder if the ancients were using this method because the cost of metal was high and they were just using off-cuts of rod and sheet stock. This method does seem to produce the least amount of waste (at least from my cozy chair).

clickspring

Yes that was something I considered too. Another possibility is that it was simply due to turning limitations of the day, ie turning integral pieces was simply beyond the available technology. However there are other features in the device that suggest a 'lathe like' device of considerable swing and rigidity must have existed, so I think this unlikely - more on that in a future episode.

Gottfried Schuss

Chris I really appreciate your craftsmanship video (both cinematography and editing). I'm curious about how you grind your tool bits. Yours always appear to have single facets. How do you do this? Also, would be interested in your background and how you came to this hobby. Thanks.

clickspring

Hey Gottfried, I appreciate your support mate, thank you :) Regarding tool bit grinding, I form them freehand on a benchtop grinder. The best thing I can recommend is that you practice with some cheap mild steel, until you start to see the shapes you want. The multi facet thing you mention takes a fair bit of practice to learn how to avoid. The key is to develop the surface as a single facet from the beginning, and then keep it all of the way to the end, correcting for small errors as you go. When you bring the metal back to the wheel after each progress check, carefully feel it rest back onto the wheel in contact with the primary facet before you press it in for further grinding. A light touch with your thumb is enough to hold it in place to begin with, to ensure that the primary facet is the surface in contact with the wheel. If you feel side to side 'rocking', decide which of the 2 facets should take priority, and then hold that surface to the wheel, and grind out the other. It takes a little bit of time to get a feel for what I've described, but before long you'll be able to immediately feel the primary facet get into contact with the wheel, and also correct any secondary facets as soon as they appear, with just a bit of preferential pressure at one end or the other of the tool bit.

Anonymous

What a wonderful project.

Ron Hunn

Cheers Chris, It's hard to believe that this device was built 2200 years ago. Thank you for bringing it to life out of something other than Lego. :-)

Andrew Larking

Can I ask, for a first time clock maker who wants to work in brass what plan you'd suggest? I have a mini lathe and mini mill.

clickspring

Hey Andrew, I would suggest go through the list on this page: <a href="http://www.clockmaking-brass.co.uk/clock_construction_books.html" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://www.clockmaking-brass.co.uk/clock_construction_books.html</a> There are a few single train, recoil escapement clocks to choose from that are ideal. Bill Smith's "Skeleton Wall Clock" is a common first clock, as is the one that I made. I think its important that you really like the look of it too - its way too much work to put into something that you're just lukewarm about. A big thing to also consider is the quality of the instructions in the accompanying plans. John Wilding and WR (Bill) Smith are the pick of the bunch in this regard. EDIT - I forgot to also mention, be sure to check the largest wheel in the train is less than the swing of your lathe. For example the largest wheel in the Large Wheel Skeleton clock requires the swing of a 9x20 lathe to cut the teeth on the lathe as I do.

My Growth Rings

That was so rewarding to watch! I was so engaged that I tried to blow off the dust at 12:23! (I wonder if I'm the only one!) So cool, Chris. Scott

Scritch

Your videos are incredible, and now that I'm finally in a financially stable situation, I'm happy to be able to help support their creation. =)

Genya Ayneg

Great work! Thank you so much for all the time and effort you put into these videos. I am always excited when I see that you posted something new. I have never before considered becoming a patron until I started watching your stuff! This is the one and only project I ever felt the need to support. THANK YOU!

Andrew Hoadley

I've only been compelled to support 2 projects, yours and primitive technology. Imagine my surprise learning that they are both out of cairns. :) Your work is just beautiful in every way. Thanks from one queenslander to another.