Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 634612781.mp4

Downloads

Content

this episode was a wild one. Emily and Richard are SO MESSY it's actually unbelievable at this point. even though I thoroughly benefitted from this scheme of theirs, it's still so incredibly messed up. that last scene of lorelai looking at Rory out of the window is so interesting to me! I feel like it's her seeing the life she ran away from and watching Rory seem to enjoy that life 🤔

Files

Comments

Luna

DING DONG THE BOY IS FINALLY GONEEE 😂 Okay, here me out… I know this was sad, and I really do feel bad for Dean because he genuinely loved Rory, but they’re just completely different people now, and it was so obvious that they were growing apart. They also don’t have the same interests or lifestyles anymore, so that’s why it never felt right ever since they tried being in a relationship again. I feel like this has been clear ever since Jess came along all the way back in season 2, but like… yeah. I was done with his character after their second breakup at the dance marathon in the middle of season 3. They should’ve written him out by that point. Either way, it was time for Rory to start moving forward in her dating life. Bouncing back and forth between her two high school lovers had to stop and was clearly holding her back from experiencing new things, especially now that she’s at Yale, while Dean represents safety and will always be a reminder of Stars Hollow, her hometown that sheltered her from the outside world. Like I said, I really do feel sorry for him. He blew up his marriage thinking they were going to make it this time, and then he gets pushed aside again, which feels lazy because the writers always do this whenever they introduce someone new. But also, Jared was going to be on Supernatural, so this was the show’s way of finally writing him out. As for Logan, he’s so much more than the love interest. He’s a great character on his own, with so much depth and complexity, and I loved watching him comfort her. He was such a gentleman in that scene 🥰 However, I will never get behind what Richard and Emily did here. Pimping Rory out so she won’t date Dean is just weird and unnecessary. I hated every second of it, and it makes me so uncomfortable. It’s literally none of their business, and she’s not even their daughter. They always project onto her to isolate Lorelai and make her feel even more guilty, which is such a regression because it felt like it came out of nowhere. The manipulation is a big no for me, but oh well… what else is new with them? 😅 I’ve always wished Rory would stand up to them more because she keeps letting them walk all over her when she very clearly has a voice of her own, but she’s just like me… a people pleaser 🙈

Luna

About that final scene, you’re so right!! It lowkey always bothered me, and I hope this is a safe place for me to say that I seriously hate how Lorelai expects Rory to hate the rich lifestyle just because she does. Rory’s allowed to enjoy it. We’ve seen it before in glimpses. And Lorelai says she doesn’t want anything to do with her parents, but it’s scenes like this that show you she’s just like them because she projects onto Rory the same way her parents do. Rory has the right to have a connection with her grandparents, and she’s old enough to know what she likes and doesn’t like. It’s all about taste, you know?? It’s such an interesting part of the show that I LOVE discussing 👀

Yasemin

I had such a looooooong day with so much work! This is a lovely gift now :) Will start watching shortly.

Logan

Goodbye Dean!

Luna

I LOVE ME A MAN WHO CAN COOK OH LUKEY LUKE I NEED SOMEONE JUST LIKE YOU 😭❤️

Luna

Same here!! I feel like she would’ve been a bit more lenient, but she doesn’t know Logan’s existence here. It’s also so interesting that Lorelai and Rory didn’t tell Emily or Richard about the whole affair thing. I’m honestly glad they didn’t because it would’ve been crazy lol they’d find a way to blame Lorelai about it.

Luna

Fair enough!! I just assumed Rory hasn’t told Lorelai yet on screen about Logan because we haven’t gotten any indication up to this point, you know?

Elizabeth Gates

I get what you're saying about how Rory didn't technically do anything wrong in this scenario, but *thank God* Dean sees a future love triangle scenario with Rory and refuses to be the dragged-out, safe boyfriend while she's getting more and more attached to someone else *again*. Also, I do think Rory could have mentioned she had a boyfriend earlier when Logan was putting his arm around her/pretending to be her boyfriend (or she could have even mentioned it to the guy that Logan was "rescuing" her from.)

Elizabeth Gates

She doesn't know about Logan yet (as is referenced in future episodes).

Ryann Rodkey

while I do see what you mean and I'm happy that Dean left because he also deserves more and I just think they are bad together, I don't think that there was truly anything there for him to see as a possible future love triangle scenario. there was a group of guys, not just one and Logan didn't approach her until after Dean had left. I think it was just Dean's insecurities getting to him in that moment. Like I said, I'm happy that he left for himself - I think it's better that way for sure and she could've told that guy she had a boyfriend or even Logan like you said but I feel like she also doesn't have to tell everyone she has a boyfriend if she's just conversing with people. I'm sure if Logan hadn't immediately stepped in she probably would've said she did bc she immediately said she did in the pool house when Logan brought up who she was going to pick. But I do agree that it's better he just left bc something could potentially grow with Logan and I guess we'll never know whether Rory had learned from the Dean/Jess situation and if she would've handled a similar situation differently or not 🤷🏻‍♀️🩶

K

You would leave Liz and TJ alone in a building you own? I know TJ is in es-ca-row but still

Ryann Rodkey

Honestly yes 😅 I feel like they are going to do what they are going to regardless of if Luke is there or not

Yasemin

"Whatever the fuck you're doing, is not stirring, Lorelai" LOL!! So joyful :)

K

Rory did deserve a private break up, but it was the right thing to do and not because she necessarily did anything wrong (although she did leave Dean waiting 15 minutes.) The Rory that stumbled out of her grandparents’ pool house, tipsy and wearing a fancy dress and tiara and professional hair, is not the Rory that Dean thought he was dating. (It’s also not the Rory that Jess is pining for, btw.) You’re right that Rory is more comfortable in this world than Lorelai. I also find it interesting how Emily introduces Rory and says she’s going to be a journalist. Maybe it’s my cynicism, but it sounds like she’s humoring her granddaughter’s ambitions. It kind of sounds like her plan is for Rory to marry rich and be her. Also, pay attention to what Rory reads and mentions reading in this phase of her life. Dean in high school was the classics, Anna Karenina and Moby Dick. Jess was a bit more avante-garde and beat literature.

Luvcurls

I completely agree Rory and Dean should of never gotten back together but at least this phase is over with. I’m excited for you to see more Logan. He’s definitely one of my favorite characters and I do love the back and forth between him and Rory. He can definitely be controversial so I’m interested to see how you will feel about him.

Ryann Rodkey

Lmao 🤣 WHAT WAS SHE DOING!? It wasn’t stirring I’ll tell you that!

Lindsey Metcalfe

This is completely unrelated to the episode but I think you'll find it vaguely amusing: I recently went spelunking in ye olden fanfic.net looking for a particular story I vaguely recall reading wayyyy back in the day and JFC I forgot how long the Tristan/Rory shippers tried to hold onto the relationship that never was. Like, as this season was airing and we were starting to get Logan, Trory was still, I think, the most popular ship in GG getting fics written about it. Truly wild fan behavior.

Bruce

My favorite line from this episode: “fries are the devil’s starchy fingers!”😂😂

Nana

Rory never has the guts to break off a relationship when she knows it's over lol.

Ari

"Dean's not mature enough for this!" Oh yeah, you clocked him right off! lol

Ryann Rodkey

lmao I just knew in my soul he wasn't gonna be able to handle it 🤣

Scout

I feel like an awful person but I feel nothing but giddy during the Dean breakup scene. GIRL, BYEEEE. I'm SO glad that's over. I have a few other things I want to say but I don't want to even come close to being spoilery. I'm just excited to see you react to the next few episodes. "I thought she was gonna to kiss him there for a minute..." oh, no, its way better, just wait. (C'mon, thats not a spoiler to anyone who has seen a TV show before, it is obviously coming 🤣) and I am SAT for your reaction to that WHOLE episode girl. GET READY. Have a soda or tea or cocktail and cozy blanket for that one! Also, Luke is intelligent. The Gilmores can't treat him like a Dean. That drives me bonkers! Dean is dumb as a box of rocks. Luke has been a king to those girls!! Emily and Richard are wild. I have such mixed feelings. Were they wrong about Dean? Nope. Logan is a major upgrade in every way. Doesn't hurt that the actor that plays Logan could have chemistry with a wet paper bag covered in pigeon poop. I will forgive Emily and Richard for this, bc it was the right call for once. They'll be back on their bullshit soon enough and I will have comments for days. Trust. 🤣

Scout

Okay, I'm going to shed some light on this. This was partially her being quirky and likely was an acting choice. HOWEVER, actors are directed to do certain things in unnatural ways as to limit certain sounds that will interfere with production either during filming, or in post. Luke often stirs unnaturally but manages to do so in a less obvious way, as does Sookie. I was on set for a Big Bang Theory taping where Penny was stirring Mac n Cheese and that shit was SO LOUD. You'd be surprised the things those mics pick up. Sometimes I miss living in Hollywood and working in entertainment bc I learned so much fun stuff like this, but I'm old now and I'd be too damn tired to still be doing all that. Hope I have a few other fun tidbits to share. I'm trying to decide if I want to spill any actor tea on anyone. I'll think about it lol

Scout

Dean deserves nothing and I will die on that hill. Sorry not sorry. I have feelings, okay? Don't judge me. 😂

Yasemin

Very valid point! I have also worked a bit in studio/filming situations and haven't even thought of that! However, her stirring in this scene is particularly strange. :)

Ryann Rodkey

hahahah I'm happy as well tbh! it sucks, I hate seeing people sad and hurt but man oh man, it was TIMEEEE lmao my heart stopped I was like, girl you're boyfriend isn't even out of the driveway yet lmao 🤣 Luke has been a king to those girls - SAY IT LOUDERRRR right, Emily and Richard may be right about dean but also, it's Rory's choice and decision who she wants to be with so them stepping in to try to ruin something that, as far as they know, is going well at that time. it's just so out of line and inconsiderate to Rory and her feelings!

Ryann Rodkey

wait that's actually bonkers 🤣 kind of love that even when there were actual relationships going on they still were like, but not as good as what COULD be 🤣

Ryann Rodkey

oooh I love a controversial character, cannot WAITTTT

Ryann Rodkey

yeah I just feel like leaving Dean waiting for 15 minutes isn't crazy being as she was at a party that she had to get out of. if he was picking her up from her house for a date, 15 minutes is unacceptable, you should be ready, but he knew that she was ditching out on a party early and may get held up in some way. now we know that she was busy with the boys in the pool house and dean slipped her mind which isn't a good look and shows that he isn't high on her priories. the break up needed to happen but I feel like he just lets his insecurities take over. instead of being confident in front of the other guys, he breaks down and leaves. it's just unfortunate. think of the power he could've held seeing those guys at the door and instead of feeling small, stood the hell up and took her hand or put his arm around her waist and walked her to the other side of the car with confidence. that would've made a statement but he's too insecure or immature to do that. I get that it isn't the Rory he thought he was dating but that also wasn't Rory's doing, her Grandmom did her hair, makeup, and the jewelry. if my boyfriend couldn't handle seeing me look a little different than normal or interact with people of a different status to the point of breaking up - that's embarrassing and an awful partner. so very glad dean is hopefully gone for good. oooh great point with the way Emily said she's going to be a journalist, I didn't initially clock that but just reading your comment and replaying it in my head, you're so right! I'll totally keep an eye on the books!!

Ryann Rodkey

I also really don't understand why he continued to be such a major character after breaking up at the dance marathon. we didn't need it, no one needed it 🤣 I just want Rory to move on and be able to breathe a little. I agree about Richard and Emily fully and also totally get Rory as I'm also a people pleaser but it is frustrating to watch 🤣

Emmanuel Paquette

The maturity wasn't what made him have that reaction. It was the fact that she was dressed like a proper princess with diamonds and tiara, he realized the class difference is way too big to overcome and its a losing battle and or he wont be able to provide the life she deserves or that her family will expect for her. This was the notebook 2.0, he thinks hes not good enough for her. Lorelai doesnt care about her family's expectations but Rory hasn't freed herself of her grandparents grip yet at least she realised it tonight thats how they always act. Lorelai has never been happier in her life without a doubt then right now with Luke a humble guy with low means. If Rory is happy with a men from higher society cool its a nice bonus but it must not a deciding factor her heart should choose.

Tax2er

I do see a triangle. A triangle of lifestyles. Rory coming out there with the guys late, saying lost track of time is a sure indicator for dean that she had a good time. And she never had such a good time at a party her grandparents gave. And there seperate the two lifestyles, which he also says "what am I doing here", like he doesnt belong in the world she obviously starting to enjoy. What bugs me the most, that the only thing that made Richard and Emily kinda accept Dean in the first place, was the fear of not being included in her life if they keep bashing onto him. And well they won, by including her into their life.