Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 338671852.mp4

Downloads

Content

sorry rationalists but the sokal affair was not the own you think it was

References: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1MW4KQooCns4fhchWapvFBdn_M1ycaH2uFKfXnu05eEw/edit

Music: “Argos Farfish” by Sharhabil Ahmed

Script feedback from Jo Howard

Editing support from  @costanzapolastri  

Files

Comments

Adam Reynolds

The one on YouTube is correct, but the references page on Patreon is to the Fermi Paradox video.

North Liu

This reminds me of Dr Angela Collier’s video on Gall-Mann Amnesia and the Gall-Mann Recollection, a term she coined to describe people who fully embraced Gall-Mann Amnesia and started to talk nonsense about stuff they know very little about (since if most of the stuff you see in the media is bs anyway, you might as well just start bsing yourself) and physicists are prone to embrace Gall-Mann Recollection PS: this is not a critique of your work. Also would you collab with Dr Collier?

Wami Ogunbi

I had not heard about the Sokal Hoax before this video, but this tied in nicely with something that I have been pondering about academia. I recognized the imperfections within the peer-review process, especially how it relates to the academic tenure track process. With the "publish or perish" mindset that plagues academia, the incentive would be to optimize doing the bare minimum to get papers out, rather than ensuring that you only produce good work. Certainly, there are plenty of dubious papers that have been published as a result. Still, this should not completely discredit the entire publishing system because good quality papers also exist. As you mentioned in the video, a lot of trust is put on individual authors to have academic integrity. I recently read "Breaking Through" by Katalin Kariko, the scientist whose research on mRNA played a significant role on why we were able to develop a COVID-19 vaccine so quickly. Throughout her academic career, she was defunded, fired, and harassed for doing what good research should look like. The incentive for her would have been to drop her mRNA research and do something that her field deemed more "interesting", but she refused. She also insisted on making sure all of her experiments were replicable before publishing, instead of publishing as soon as she got "good" results. For most of her decades-long academic career, she was an outcast. It took the pandemic for people to realize that her persistence/stubbornness/dedication to good academic work literally saved the world! It bugs me that to get a tenure track position as well as to receive tenure, you need an extensive publication record. In theory, this should be a good thing--having a long track record of research that others in your field recognize as legit is a good metric for determining fit for a professor position. But in practice, it also incentivizes rushed or incomplete work. Even in my field, I can see how one could game the system to churn out papers to make you look good for a tenure track position. But I just can't bring myself to do it because I pride myself on doing good work. Unfortunately, this means that my publication speed is not as fast as a selection committee might hope for. I could make up for it by exploiting student labor (which is another common incentive of the academic system), but I also can't stomach the idea of making a young person's life miserable for my own gain. I enjoyed this video. It added more to this ongoing topic that I am trying to understand and resolve in myself.

Wami Ogunbi

Also! Continuing your trend of you only publishing videos when I hit big milestones in my life: this video was dropped when I literally just moved to a different state to start my very first job! I'll be a visiting professor for a year! Will I secure a more permanent position after this? Who knows, but I am sure you'll have a video posted when I find my next position (and the milestones in between!) haha

Preethi Basani

When listening to part 4 of this video, I thought about how it felt like the Sokal Hoax in its intellectual dishonesty feels like it hacked people’s attention in a similar way to rage bait videos. This led me on a tangent train of thought on when it is worth debunking things like the Sokal Hoax as that might only bring more engagement which feels like exactly what Sokal is trying to accomplish, but not debunking makes it feel like the dangerous ideas might go left unchecked. Although I might be stretching out the analogy a bit too far. Maybe it's being a trans woman in an increasingly transphobic world, but my internal TERF alarm went out very early in the video. Like you said, the mask off TERF moment with the Dawkins paper wasn't surprising at all. But it makes me wonder about the people like JK Rowling and how engaging has only bought her more attention. The stakes feel lower in a purely academic context but when these ideas are being used to oppress and deny people their rights, it feels like an important question. To summarize my question: How should we be engaging if at all with intellectual dishonest arguments that are being used to enact real harm in the world? To me it feels like this video seems like a great example of how to do that: building a community where it can be trusted that it will not lead to more engagement with the argument in a way that the author(in this case Sokal) intended. From there we could use what we’ve learnt as a community to organize against the policies/actions the bad faith arguments are leading to rather than engaging directly with them (for example, organizing against transphobic policy and organizing for trans-inclusive policy rather than engaging with JK Rowling). I would love to hear other peoples thoughts on this.

Wami Ogunbi

Yes! This thought also occurred to me! The parallels between the Sokal Hoax and how misinformation spreads like wildfire in mainstream is uncanny. Sokal did not do exactly what he claimed to have done in the article he wrote exposing his "hoax". Those in the field or adjacent can more readily recognize this more readily than a general audience. And yet, the general audience decided to favor Sokal's story. I think this plays into a larger problem where it feels like we as people like to simplify complex things into "good" versus "evil". We have become so individualized as people that we fail to recognize the humanity in our fellow human beings. We would rather see someone as all good or all evil then something in between, and we seek stories to confirm our biases. Wait, wait, wait! This kind of ties into the video Philosophy Tube just dropped a couple of days ago, "How Death Changes Your Perspective (ft. Caitlin Doughty)". She talked about "affect", which she defines as an emotional orientation. When we have an affect, we have things that we are supposed to feel and things that we cannot feel. Information we encounter either conforms to what we feel, or, if something seems contrary, then clearly we just misunderstood the information, because of course all information conforms neatly into how we view the world in these narrow lenses! I think you (and Dr. Fatma) are spot on how we can try to combat this. Building community and having productive discussions in good faith, and then using this community knowledge against bad faith actors and policies.

Matías López

Hello! I've just seen the video, and wanted to share on a bit of Argentinean political lore while I gather more thoughts :3 I think that an element that contributes to make it it look like Posadas talking about UFOlogy is pretty out there is because he was a trotskyist, and that is in itself weird in most countries. Here trotskyism is the mainstream leftist movement, unlike most other countries where CP type communism are the mainstream ones. Argentinean leftist oral tradition states that tratitional PC parties dissapearde from Argentina because they supported the last genocidal dictatorship (the one USA put here with "Plan Cóndor", on the pretext that they were "patriotic nationalistic bourgeois" with whom they could make an alliance against imperialism. When the crimes of the dictatorship came to light, in paralell with the fall of the USSR, all the traditional CP parties became hated by the people, and Trotskyism became the mainstream left movement. So, when I heard about Posadas, it was like hearing about a normal CP leftist leader in almost any other part of the world. As always, thanks for the great video!

mgfreezy24

Long time viewer here. I believe I heard you mention Sokal in a previous video but only had a vague idea of what happened. Seems conceited and definitely working opposite to positive interdisciplinary discourse.

Tom Cassidy

I read Sokal's reveal when it first appeared in Lingua Franca. I remember being struck by this line (which I just looked up) "Anyone who believes that the laws of physics are mere social conventions is invited to try transgressing those conventions from the windows of my apartment. (I live on the twenty-first floor.)" I remember silently speaking back to the page: the question is, why must this concept of "law," with its juridical, theological baggage, be applied to out understanding of the tendency of things to fall? And what does it mean that it is? --I had heard the joke before, when my HS science teacher used the same line (talking about a third floor window) and it seemed clear that this was probably an old teacher's joke used to induce mockery and consent without making an argument. Looking at that line now, two more things stand out to me: 1) there is and was quite an underground movement of people who use contemporary technology to leap off tall buildings in violation of the laws: some use ropes, some use gliders, but it was very illegal for a while. 2) Taking Dr. Sokal's mean comment literally, it is an invitation for his dissenters to kill themselves. Does used the same word for the organizing principles of social order, religion, and science make it self-evident that people who disrupt the the third of these (through quetioning) should be put to rhetorical death?

Josh B

Great video! I have a response to your request for critique. Not gonna leave this one on the YouTube video because I don't want it to be a dogpile opportunity for people who aren't approaching it in good faith. I've been on "both sides" of various cultural/ideological issues at various times, as the way I was raised is radically different from the way I think of things today. One side effect of this history is that I have a finely attuned sensitivity to caricature and unfair dismissal of opposing views. Every time someone makes a stereotypical quip about how "they believe that because they're too stupid to realize they're being fooled" or "yeah the people in that camp are a bunch of dumb hicks", I remember my past self, book-smart and earnest and empathetic and trying my best while also believing those things, and I get a little upset at the ignorance of the commenter on "my team". Because I know that if I was still the person I was back then, their comments would be a biased and unfair attack on me. Now, you didn't do this. But you did something that set off the same alarms in my brain, which was to play the character role of your opponent via the costume change. I've seen this done many times, and it's very hard to pull off. It's almost definitionally a straw man situation, as you're not actually someone who believes the things you're reciting in that character. Your skit wouldn't work if black-top-and-glasses Fatima debated you to a standstill. You had to set up a version of that viewpoint just weak enough that you could best her in the debate, and to cap it off, you had her admit defeat. To me, that sours the video slightly, because it feels a bit like an un-earned celebration of rhetorical victory. Like you boxed a restrained opponent to a K.O. and are wearing the medal around. Or like a sham trial, ruling and judgment pre-ordained, as a spectacle for the viewers who already agree with you. I think the video would have worked just as well if you had just said things like "A common rebuttal to this premise from people in Sokal's camp is [insert statement]. But here's why that doesn't quite hold up. ..." No tacky impersonation required, and it gets the same points across. Sorry if this seems a bit dramatic, and I hope it doesn't sound too harsh. I genuinely enjoy and appreciate your voice on YouTube, and think your views on science and culture are a much needed breath of fresh air. I hope to see much more in the same spirit from you in the future, and I'm proud to support this endeavor.

Andrew Thompson

When ppl try to argue with me that PostModernism is over or not valid or that we’re not existing w/in the PostModern Condition, they usually throw the Sokal Hoax, or Baudrillard’s “The Gulf War Didn’t Happen” at me. I think Bruno LaTour’s 2004 essay “Why Has Critique Run Out Of Steam?” is the best criticism of Post Modernism/Critical Theory, at least in terms of a political culture (which IMO is what most ppl take real issue with) that I can get with. Everything is more complicated than we think it is at face value. Can’t wait to watch the rest of the video!

bhobba

I have heard similar criticisms before, but to have them all in one place is excellent. Well done on a rational contribution to the discussion. I must admit I get a bit worked up by some (I am more with Sokal), but yours was well argued.

bhobba

I am more with Sokal on this and side with the critiques of Postmodernism, but we all must keep an open mind. This video was well-argued. I am reading Beyond The Hoax and often suggest it to others.

Matías López

About Sokal, the funny thing is that I knew the affair by the name of "imposutras filosóficas", and glitched out when matching the book and the author, so I won't comment on what I thought about the affair haha. Nevertheless, I've felt deceived by most of what I consumed when young, and I've had to depurate most of my early theoretical framework. Now, when I hear "objectivity", it just rings like poison to my ears. I really empatize with what you said about keeping our egos in check. Truthfully, it's so much easier to "destroy" and to critique than to build and create connections, and the academia usually teaches us that critiquing is the higher form of knowledge or something like that, when... no? why? That is to say that, regarding your question if there is something to critique about your videos, I've been pondering seriously on that question for a few days, and on the meaning of critiquing, and, as a pedantic in rehabilitation, it's a framework that just rings hollow to me. When you described the dialogue between Chomsky and Foucault, was the word/framework of "critique" really necessary to convey the nature of the conversation? In my latest years, when I finally started to build meaningful relationships, I've never critiqued my fellow ones for a disagreement. We just shared thoughts and tried to be emphatic and grow a little bit from the process. Critique is something that I save for those that I otherize. Like, when I know there can't be any productive dialogue with that person. So, I was wondering if it was really necessary to even add the word "critique", when, for it to be productive, it has to come with a lot of other things that the word is clearly not associated with: "good faith" "constructive", etc. Even with the clarifications, the mindset the word "criticism" carries is... strong, and pulls us towards pedantry and lack of empathy. Like, even when writing this, I feel like a jackass, because surely the word was used to make more engaging the comment sections, and to experiment with this shift in framework. Also, you've said that it was really hard to construct a good prompt for the comment section, and I really don't know any better one, so why I am even critiquing this?

Matías López

Latour has some really nice ideas! It's an author that I sould explore more. His thoughts on the agency of non-humans are really interesting.

Matías López

By the way, maybe I should put this on youtube and read more comments, but it has become daunting to try to keep up with the comment section! Congratulations for making it such a living ecosystem! in summer vacations I'll try to plunge myself into the comment sections of youtube again haha, in the meaning time I'll share with the smaller comunity of Patreon.

Matías López

Hello Bhobba! A book that was really insightful to me is "Science Fictions", that tackles some systemic problems with how academia is run, and how papers distort science. It really widened my perspective on how things work in the universities.

bhobba

Thanks so much. I just got a copy :) :)

Rene Horn

My criticism is pretty much the same criticism I have for a lot of leftist content out on the Internet--whether it's you, or Philosophy Tube, or Rebecca Watson, or Hasan Piker, or even me--and I'm not so sure that it's solvable, to be honest. We're all too damn long winded! Don't let this change your content though, but it's something to think about. Right wingers have the luxury of being able to keep their messaging short and simple, which makes them much more memorable, but that always leaves out so much context. Just like Sokal here (who I knew nothing about before this video), he can put out a statement saying that this journal uncritically published his bullshit paper because obviously their leftist bias clouded their judgement. When Epstein published his research, those same journalists probably didn't even get through reading the abstract before they stopped looking at it, if they looked at it at all. We seem to have a need to approach a subject from as many angles as possible, and we then try to show that to our audience, but we don't realize that we've lost half of them just a few paragraphs into our paper, or a few minutes into our video or podcast. We don't want to give them an oversimplified version of whatever we're talking about because that doesn't feel right though either. I don't honestly know what to do about that.

Apostri

I have no general criticism. I very much like your videos. They are informative, fun and I vibe with your aesthetics, music selection etc. So instead I will try to formulate an alternative brief take on the Sokal affair. Specifically I will alternate the defense of Sokal, from the position of scientific rationalist to the position of philosophical anarchist. Which is not the position Sokal and his defenders take themselves of course. So this is more or less just speculative mental exercise. There are differences between philosophy and science, even when there are no exact boundaries between the two. In science the disagreements, conflicts, discussions and challenges to authority are somehow regulated and institutionalized. Methods of determining who is more correct are at core of sanctioned scientific praxis. On the other side in philosophy anything goes. Almost any form of intellectual attack is legit… all in the game, yo. Mocking of authority is at the very heart of philosophy. For example, Socrates mocks sophists or Zhuang Zhou mocks Konfucius. And there are things for which some postmodernist philosophy deserves to be mocked. Among others is the obscurity of the language, which seems to be at least part of the Sokal target. If Sokal did his prank and left it at that, then (in my opinion) it would have been legitimate and in good spirit. But he overreached when he started to draw some far reaching conclusions and used the hoax as support for the authority of his own rationalist positions. In that he transferred the whole affair from philosophy to the field of science and you correctly found him wanting. In scientific rules of engagement it really was not the own people thought it was.

saba

i would agree. im wildly positing but I think the left has a communication issue. the right is wayyy better at storytelling, and branding probably as you said BECAUSE they are willing to abstract in service of some higher goal (white supremacy, power whatever). Whereas the left has more moral principals and thinks that can be enough to win over the "moral and well meaning" liberal. Its like people on the left making lists of all the things joe biden has done for NATO and things. Its not sexy or aesthetically interesting. Which isn't the point of politics, but there is an aesthetic game that the left in the US at least is far behind in. but im not sure what to do about that either,

Nicholas Coughlin

I suspect what we've known for centuries might be at play more than who has the better argument. "Reasoning will never make a Man correct an ill Opinion, which by Reasoning he never acquired" - Jonathan Swift, 1721, A Letter to a Young Gentleman, Lately Enter’d Into Holy Orders by a Person of Quality

Yonas Kidane

Not sure if it's an apt comparison to make but couldn't help but draw parallels between the Sokal affair and the way it played out, and the way Pinker's Better Angels of Our Nature book was uncritically embraced and amplified by certain sectors of society.

Travis

Im rewatching this after some frustrating weeks at work related to operant conditioning and my PI proving (to me) that she cares more about “winning” the system of academia under capitalism than producing good science.

bhobba

It's not. The trouble is that I have had to discuss the issue with your so-called average person. I am a rationalist, but I concede it is not a lay down misere. When talking about it to lay people, to them (and to me, but I understand it is debatable and actually an opinion), and you say there is one objective truth, that truth is not subjective, it is tough to convince them otherwise. Of course, in doing that, I play devil's advocate, so I may not be the best person to argue the point. But the vast majority of people believe in one objective truth. It is a tough sell. This is why many, including me on occasion, think the average person rejects a lot of so-called WOKE stuff as just junk created by academic activists. It is hardly reasoned discourse, but documentaries like What is a Woman are pretty hilarious for your average person. BTW, again, from experience, do not pursue the issue, it has reached the point where I live; the 'discussion' can get heated, and it becomes a no-go talking point.