Against Method: Chapter 11-13 (Patreon)
Content
CHANGE OF SCHEDULE: I had asked in the original scheduling post for this book whether people would want to do a collaborative live writing session at the midpoint the way we have been doing for the end of books so far, and people seemed interested so I’m going to interrupt our regularly scheduled programming to include that. This week is still our normal discussion of chapter 11-13, but next week we’ll pause the reading to have a discussion session and perhaps give people a chance to catch up on the reading, before continuing on to the second half of the book. If you’d like to participate in the live writing session, indicate your availability next week on this when2meet and I’ll announce the time/day this friday. I also edited the original reading schedule to reflect this change. Hope to see you there!
~~~
Chapter 11 - Such ‘irrational’’ methods of support are needed because of the ‘uneven development’ (Marx, Lenin) of different parts of science. Copernicanism and other essential ingredients of modern science survived only because reason was frequently overruled in their past.
Chapter 12 - Galileo’s method works in other fields as well. For example, it can be used to eliminate the existing arguments against materialism, and to put an end to the philosophical mind/body problem (the corresponding scientific problems remain untouched, however). It does not follow that it should be universally applied.
Chapter 13 - The Church at the time of Galileo not only kept closer to reason as defined then and, in part, even now: it also considered the ethical and social consequences of Galileo’s views/its indictment of Galileo was rational and only opportunism and a lack of perspective can demand a revision.
~~~
am i the only one who's been bringing this book up in every other conversation since starting to read it???
How shall we proceed in order to bring about such a fair comparison [between old and new theories]? The first step is clear: we must retain the new cosmology until it has been supplemented by the necessary auxiliary science. We must retain it in the face of plain and unambiguous refuting facts. We may, of course, try to explain our action by saying that the critical observations are either not relevant or that they are illusory, but we cannot support such an explanation by a single objective reason. Whatever explanation we give is nothing but a verbal gesture, a gentle invitation to participate in the development of the new philosophy. (ch 11 pg 112)
So at this point Feyerabend has me pretty sold on his take of the scientific method re Galileo and the Copernican revolution, and I felt like this chapter prompted me to think of other examples. His idea of progress requiring a ‘step backwards’ certainly holds for many scientific paradigm shifts—Maxwell, Bohr and Einstein, are all good examples—but it’s a lot easier to identify these things after the fact, once we’ve already done a lot of work to support the once outlandish theories. It got me trying to think of what ideas are out there today that might be examples of the irrational ideas that we should retain ‘in the face of plain and unambiguous facts’?
The main one that keeps coming up for me is MOND, which I talked about as an alternative to dark matter in my video about gravity being a social construct. I think it has a lot in common with Copernicanism in Galileo’s time—an idea that’s been around for a while that has its small group of dedicated supporters, but generally dismissed by the mainstream as silly and not really worth indulging in. tbh I had some second thoughts after publishing the video that it was too silly and unscientific of a thing to take seriously, but maybe thats what it looks like to retain new ideas that don’t yet have the support to be compared productively to old ideas? like, I’m not saying that I Fully Subscribe to the idea of MOND, but Feyerabend’s argument makes me feel a little more justified in inviting people to participate in the development of a new philosophy, so to speak.
I’d be curious to hear if anyone else thought of any modern ideas that might fall into this category too?
also the discussion of galileo’s trials goes hard, the comparison between the church and the orthodoxy of modern scientific institutions is… wild but also makes total sense??? I hope there’s more on that coming, and if there’s not im gonna have to go follow the references in his footnotes bc the irony is too strong to not deep dive further