Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

hello everyone, i'm realizing it's going to take me longer than usual to get this next video out due to a confluence of life things i'm managing at the moment, so I wanted to record another office hours episode to put out here in the meantime. if you have any questions for me about my videos or work or the topics I discuss on my channel in general, leave it in a comment here and I'll answer it in a video in the next couple weeks. also, if you've sent me a question via dm for this, I've already added it to the list. looking forward to engaging with yall in this way, i really like office hours~

fatima

Comments

Mara Pyre

I want to start by saying I love your work and you're a big inspiration to me! I'm a physics major/astrophysics minor undergrad who is considering grad school in astrophysics. I started off in a community college as an art major for two semesters before pivoting. I'm also tens of thousands of dollars in debt due to a variety of factors. I'd say the two largest motivators to me for pursuing an education are out of my passion for the field, and out of respect/reverence for my ancestors who were denied an education. I'm a black and indigenous American, and only the third in my immediate family able to go to college. However, I am also definitely very unable to afford my education, and the prospective financial burden of my loans is definitely not a light at the end of a tunnel. I have basically taken the position that the poverty that i was born into was a result of generational wealth destruction, and the financial burden that i am being faced with are simply other parts of the history of inequality in America that i may or may not escape from in my life time. But i also believe that education is a human right which i am being systematically - not denied - but certainly economically punished for. I've worked multiple jobs at a time while studying, working full and part time year round wherever i can, and am still having to take out loans and donate plasma to make ends meet. I decided to go to college after being homeless with my entire family in the summer of 2016, initially hoping that I might be able to help my family, but have since become my family's biggest holder of debt. Sorry for all the background, but here's my questions: As a Doctor who is working in academia, what are your thoughts on the American student loan system? Like do you think it is something that students will be able to fight against and overcome in our lifetime, or is the machine oiled well enough that it might stand the test of time? How has it impacted your life? Do you think it is something which should dissuade potential students from considering certain education paths? If so, how could one find that line for themselves?

Wami Ogunbi

You mentioned that you have taken on a role in academia and I would love to know more about this if you are comfortable sharing on *gestures dramatically* the internet. I am currently pursuing teaching-focused roles in academia but want to expand by including public speaking and both fiction and non-fiction writing in an effort to reach a broader audience. As a roboticist, I fear the trajectory that we are heading due to the lack of diversity in my field. People view robots/AI as these "objective" things. But the reality is that robots/AI are a reflection of the people who build them--flaws and all. A homogenous group of people building the majority of robots means that we are building robots that are unable to equitably solve problems of a diverse world. I am trying to fight this by spreading awareness. You make YouTube videos for a very broad audience and are also pursuing an academic career. I would love to hear about how you are juggling it all and some insights that you have been picking up along the way. It might be too early for you since you are also just starting out, but I would love to hear any advice you have for people interested in similar paths as you.

Zebe Loun

Irrespective of any scientific or philosophical evidence or explanation: do you believe that there is a purpose for life? If so, do you know what purpose? If not, why?

Woke AF

Our solar system is in the outer part of on of the Milky Way's spiral arm. The closer you get to Sagittarius A Star, the super massive black hole at the center of the galaxy the area looks denser and brighter because spirals get more dense the closer you get to the center. Do we know what that area is like? Are stars interacting with each other's gravity? Can solar systems exist are or do they fall apart because they are just closer to each other. Like if planets exist there can you see multiple stars if you could stand on one at what passes for night? Is the dust to thick it reacts with other stellar objects? I understand that distance in the case of any object is relative. I mean it might look to us from our position that things are clumped in together, but obviously that only a perception so maybe planets, stars and asteroids aren't bouncing off each other. But is it more chaotic towards the center then it is were our solar system is? I've always wonder what space in that area of our spiral galaxy would be like if you could be there. I've been curious about this for ages and it's a question I've been dying to ask an actual genius astrophysicist for ages.

D

Hi! I’m a Pell grant recipient who started at community college thinking journalism, but ultimately graduated from a private 4-year with $50k in debt. I am also first generation student, second in the family to finish higher ed. I also had a single mom, we got evicted multiple times when I was a child, and have been without an address both before and after age 18. Also, the opioid crisis played a role in my mother’s passing & I went through many related hardships. It was a struggle & I go back and forth on whether it was all worth it. But I graduated in 2017, ended up doing Econ cus fuck capitalism, delusions about destroying the system from the inside, I like math and #jobz… I even somehow finagled a research Fulbright. Anyhow, I decided against grad school, ended up working in comms research for a bit (focus groups, social media analytics) and now do community engagement in government. I just want to say that… A sharp and motivated person will find a way. Maybe not plan a, or b, but… I really just believe in you. You are overcoming barriers that many of your peers will never understand on a daily basis. The credentials are bullshit, but the effort you put in, day in and day out, is making you so much stronger and smarter and more resourceful than your peers — once you find yourself in the right place, you will unquestionably excel. It is so fucking hard, but there are many of us with similar backgrounds who’ve proven it can be done. Thanks for sharing your story and reminding me where I came from and who I work for. I admire you for everything you’re doing, and your ancestors are, without a doubt, incredibly proud of you for all you’re doing and will continue to do. Two things in closing: 1) I think there are real political potentialities with debt striking, also. I remember a decent amount of noise around this about 2-3 years ago? And 2) even if that doesn’t happen, I’ve at least made my way to a position/salary/benefits that let me help out family and do other mutual aid Sorry to butt in with a wall of text, I know you weren’t asking me after all, but your situation sorta moved me. If I can offer any more info or thoughts or general solidarity I am happy to connect or respond more here.

Rafael Andrade

Have you ever thought on teaching, researching etc in other countries? + Is there any institutions/research groups around the globe that you have a particular interest? It's kind of a cliché for Brazilians go out saying "Come to Brazil!", and I will gladly fill that post (love living in a country with free education, even though is a daily struggle to keep it from being sold), but I am also trying to keep looking for new Science Education groups, to avoid the eco chambers I see so many college teachers in this field trapped in. Side note filling my post as the "Come to Brazil!" guy: International students can also do any Higher Education course for free in Brazil. I don't know exactly the process, but I had seen so many people from the USA talking about student debt that I feel obligated to point this as an option.

Annali3s3

Hi! First off just wanted to say I am new to the Patreon, I discovered your Youtube videos a couple months ago, I absolutely love them and am so excited to be here :) I wanted to ask, as someone who works tangentially to scientific fields but doesn't come from that world, how scientists who are hard objectivists rationalize things that seem to reinforce constructivism, like the use of (or even creation of) constellations. From my non-astronomer background, I understand the way we've grouped the stars is completely subjective to our view of them from here on Earth, and does not align with any objective truth about what stars are "related" to one another out in space, and yet was incredibly useful to humans as a map to learn more about our world. Even though we now know more about where these stars are located out in space and relative to each other, no one seems to be demanding that we get rid of the constellations that are only true in our experience/view (literally) of them here on Earth. This seems to be a great argument that for certain levels of exploring our world, we can use different frameworks of what we can observe, on the basis of what is most useful to us in that situation. Does this one slip through the cracks because the framework in question, the map of the night sky, is easily observable by most people without any scientific tools or background? How do objectivists seem to think about these sorts of things, and are there any other examples of subjective/constructionist frameworks that are widely used in more rigorous scientific settings?

Viviain Usher

Hi I wonder how you work to build community outside of Internet space. You give the vibes that it is something you do, as we all should, and I'm just curious what it looks like in your life.

wandfigur

OMG, this turned into an epic ❤️ love letter ❤️ -- I'm so sorry! Hi Dr. Fatima and fellow Patrons! Thank you sooooo much Dr. Fatima for your work—it’s rare to find someone who’s succeeded in both the humanities and STEM (as a woman!) and can communicate the limits of scientific “objectivity” with clarity, and depth. It’s refreshing and, honestly, incredibly grounding for a STEM x humanties academia reject like me, who still has come to the same conclusions as you ;) What I admire most about your work is how you’ve managed to navigate those same contradictions and pressures while maintaining clarity and conviction. You honor science but with a critical edge, and you make it accessible without watering down the complexity. So, I wanted to ask: Do you have advice for someone like me -- Your work has made me realize my insights and experiences might be worth sharing, especially since the most critical voices in public conversations around my topics of interest lack firsthand research experience, while others are more invested in presenting scientistic views as fact. So, I'm curious to know: 1. How did you manage to not lose your sense of discernment and confidence in your ideas, despite working within such contradictory approaches and standards in academia? 2. Now that you’re on YouTube and social media, where people judge success by metrics unrelated to rigor or depth, how do you stay true to your message without getting drowned out or dismissed? 3. And finally—any advice, struggles, or insights you’re willing to share would mean a lot. Just knowing that someone who shares my views made it through both academia and is succeeding on youtube is inspiring. Thank you for everything. Your work genuinely makes a difference.

wandfigur

That is so cool! I'm curious to know more of what you work on 💖✌🏻

Ezra Gouvea

Hey, if you need a voice or another voice after Political Event to say, "Hope you're ok, take care of yourself, hope whatever office hours or videos here aren't adding to your stress (or shame??) cycle"..um, then that! I'm looking forward to reading bell hooks. I started, it's lovely, and it's not that easy to stop once started. But I'm wondering if there's anything about your new position that you are up for sharing—more which/if parts about it happen to be exciting to you than whatever details you don't feel like unpacking publicly. I'm also wondering if there's anything related to your new position or about the new situation that has you reading anything else; and i'm wondering what you're finding interesting and exciting. These are supposed to be easy questions—if it's helpful to have a range to choose from. I only recently joined the Patreon and I'm assuming that you only pick a few that are fun for you to answer—not feel obligated to answer every one! Thanks for your work!

Atmosweeper

I've often heard about codes of conduct as tools for making academic work environments less awful. Obviously Patreon isn't a work environment for most of us here, but I guess it *is* your (Dr. Fatima's) work environment in some sense. Are there any specific guidelines that you have in mind for how we should be engaging here with respect to comments, DMs, etc? I haven't found any sort of code of conduct on here. Does it exist somewhere and I simply missed it? Are codes of conduct *themselves* problematic in some way? Interested to hear your take.