Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

hi all, i’m sick so this is gonna be an extremely minimal post on my end

The next chapter is about feminist thinking in the classroom, so im wondering if this one (that doesn’t seem particularly about education) is something of a lead up to that one.

Some quotes i highlighted:

“As one Black woman put it, ‘ it burns me up to be treated like shit by white women who are busy getting their academic recognition, promotions, more money, et cetera, doing ‘great’ work on the topic of race.”

It burns me up too. And this isn’t just a thing in women's studies—a lot of the education research in physics/astro on race (and DEI work in general) is done by white women who get a lot of attention and praise for caring about the wretched minorities, but then are absolutely horrible to people from those same populations they ostensibly do so much work to support. I mentioned last week my hesitation to call this out bc of how it can be weaponized against this kind of work in general, but the ubiquity of this phenomenon, both in my own experiences and that of my colleagues, is so upsetting.

“Fear and anger about appropriation, as well as concern that we not be complicit in reproducing servant-served relationships, have led black women to withdraw from feminist settings where we must have extensive contact with white women. Withdrawal exacerbates the probelm: it makes us complicit in a different way. If a journal is doing a special issue on Black Women’s Studies and only white women submit work, then blakc women cannot effectively challenge their hegemonic hold on feminist thoery. This is only one example of many. Without our voices in written work and in oral presentaitons there wil be no articulation of our concerns…Withdrawal is not the answer.”

This made me think of a couple things—in Jenny O’dell’s “How to Do Nothing” she talks about how exiting society in whatever way (communes, off grid living, digital detoxes, whatever) don’t actually solve the problem and also create their own problems bc we actually do need to be connected to society in order to, if not survive, thrive. I have similar feelings about relationships with men, where basically a lot of women and nb people i know have experiences with men that are so bad that their conclusion is to just divesting from men as a population as much as possible. At times I’ve felt that same pull, but I have yet to cave to it bc i think being a feminist presence in men’s lives is essential to changes the condition of society for all of us (and like, writing off half of humanity just feels so defeatist to me). I’ve been putting it off for a while but i will be getting into the men thing in a video eventually. But yeah, this chapter makes me think a lot about how to engage with populations that have more hegemonic power than me for the sake of benefiting everyone while also protecting myself. Its a hard balance but a critical one, i think.

My head hurts too much to come up with a discussion question for you, hopefully will be more on it next week 

Comments

Michael

I wish you’d rest instead of putting out work if you’re sick, but thank you and hope you feel better soon!

Moz in Oz

My main take is that bell hooks is emphasising intersectionality - everyone has to do the work, you can't delegate up or down the hierarchy and say "someone else can/must fix this". This one felt foreign to me, in the literal sense. So I'm not sure I have anything useful to say. I didn't grow up in a slaver society (Aotearoa) and even Australia has never been built around it the way the USA has. So the colonial legacy is different, and also different between the two countries I have experienced. The examples didn't land, in other words. Mentally translating 'black' to Maori or Aboriginal is tricky, and somewhere I read a rant from a kiwi or aboriginal feminist about the difficulty of mapping US hegemonic feminism onto our culture. But I can't find it now so instead I give you this more on topic article by an aboriginal australian feminist: https://postcolonialist.com/civil-discourse/indigenous-feminism-politics-and-the-importance-of-intersectionality-a-conversation-with-celeste-liddle/ It's also fun from the other side of the hierarchy of oppression, because on the one hand STFU and let other people also not say anything feels wrong. But how long should I wait to see whether anyone feels able to speak up? I occasionally console myself with the thought that at least I gave others something to react against :) On the gripping hand yet another argument about invisible disability manifesting as poor social skills and whether that's just a weak excuse from an arsehole is kinda tiring (when that happens).

Moz in Oz

Also, I missed the last chapter discussion and I really wanted to say... I prefer to see identities as pigeonholes, but fuzzy "quantum" post-modern ones where you can be in as many identities as you like all at the same time. We're all wave functions that only collapse into single particles/identities at the moment we actually speak from that identity, then immediately go back to being probability clouds until the next interaction. Speaking as a macropodarian all this literary stuff is a bit over my head :) (sorry Dr Fatima, I have to say quantum. I just do)

schlltchrn

I can relate to the fact that US cultural hegemony misses many particularities of local (Austria) racism and sexism, and people in both academic and informal settings rely on it, even in anti-imperialist discussions. The flavour of racism we have here is a different one, and it cannot be the same. It is very frustrating. That being said, I still saw so many useful parallels when translating the text to my surroundings. The examples that she gave were maybe different, but also surprisingly similar in my opinion. Not sure how it is in the US, and I don't want to equate the examples in the text to my examples, but they helped me understand more. For example, it made it more apparent to me why I, as a foreigner, would feel very uncomfortable, at this stage of my life, paying another woman to clean my flat, so that I can... be academically more successful and earn more money? If I know with 100% certainty, that woman will not be a white Austrian. Zero chance. More probably the woman would be from my home country or somewhere else on the outskirts of "the West" and that just makes me angry somehow? It may seem like these women came here to do such service work free willingly. This is not true for many reasons. Also, I talked to the service workers in our language, and I know how much they resent the white Austrian women and see them as infantile, even though, when speaking German, they could not express the resentment and anger. Just one example that struck me as surprisingly relevant for my experience at a different time and in a different place.

schlltchrn

This chapter solidified further the position that intersectionality is necessary, but also made it apparent that it often has to be intentional. The phenomenon where oppressed people (white women in the text) are oppressing even more oppressed people (black women) is kind of universal. It is for sure a part of why fascism is on the rise in the US and Europe. It is a very different context, but the phenomenon is I think related. It is also something that I sadly notice in some of my own opinions I've had, when moving to EU country as a white non-EU citizen. Being oppressed and privileged. There is for sure much racism that raises in that ecosystem, which will take a lot of intention and effort to deconstruct. After all, after 10 years here, most people I encounter consider me a local, which is a privilege that people of colour don't have, even after being born and raised here.

Lycoperdon perlatum

Feel better soon Dr Fatima. Thank you for hosting this book club.

Raphaël Royer

thank you for fighting sickness and posting, like a true warrior 💪😂 This one made me sad a bit, intersectionality is a necessity for greater class consciousness but damn, I just put myself in a woman of color's shoes and I understand, at one point I would just say, nah, fuck white people! Or a women just abandoning all hope for all men and I don't know what to do about that... Sorry for the doomy vibes, get well soon 💜

AJ Biffl

Hope you feel better soon, doc! Appreciate the post even while you're out I've been thinking a lot about the passages leading up to the ones Dr Fatima highlighted, where hooks describes (around the start of pg 104) how most white women writing feminist theory on race focus on analyzing black and brown experience instead of focusing on their own white experience. Instead of reflecting on how white supremacy has affected them personally, they analyze and study black and brown women as subjects. A bit further into the paragraph, she says that these scholars "forget that the very focus on race and racism emerged from the concrete political effort to forge meaningful ties between women of different race and class groups." So in my life, coming from a place of whiteness, my first step in antiracist analysis has to be an examination of MY white privilege, how white supremacy has shaped MY experience and shaded MY life, with the explicit purpose of leading to more supportive, healing, and sustainable relations with people with different racial experiences. How has white supremacy shaped my life and my perspective, and how can I change my behaviors to resist and subvert that white supremacy? In practice in the feminist movement, this meant listening to and respecting black voices, supporting black academics, and not stepping on the toes of black experience by dissecting it from a white perspective. I think those principles carry over to most other fields too: respect and support, and don't stamp people out by picking apart a perspective you don't have. The point is to let those voices be heard in their own right, not as toy examples or tokens, and for them to grow and attract attention and be empowered by that attention. It goes back to the power of experience from last chapter, that while no it's not the end-all-be-all way of knowing, experience is hugely important in helping people understand a perspective. It's also hugely important in guiding the process of healing, because how can I know what needs to heal if I haven't directly experienced the hurt? I especially appreciated hooks in this chapter illustrating ways that sort of healing looks like (starting around pg 108), about acknowledging that we all have racist assumptions and being open to others' experiences of racism, about trying to close the gap between words and deeds, about being committed to antiracist action even at the expense of opportunism or privilege, about creating new models for interactions and promoting respect and reconciliation, and about committing to move on through fear and rage "in order to explore new grounds for contact." But that's not the only step in finding ways of healing. Hooks mentions in the final paragraphs that "[t]o counter this complicity [in failing to confront "the racist assumption that we can never overcome the barrier separating white women and black women"], we must have more written work and oral testimony documenting ways barriers are broken down, coalitions formed, and solidarity shared." She says that this is a "collective work," that we need to have a dialogue, "to exchange ideas, to have fierce debate." In that spirit, what are some ways other people think about the process of healing, about forming coalitions? And what am I wrong about?

phil e the theyby

I fell into an illness and then depression hole of video game and internet addiction, wheeee! But now I’m back and reading books again! This chapter just felt TOO fucking relevant to my life. A lot of what’s put me in the hole I’ve been in is working in a “DEI focused” role and trying to figure out what I’m actually doing, because most of what I’m trying to create is exactly what bell hooks is pointing at in this chapter: the ability for people from different backgrounds (racial or otherwise) to meaningfully interact across their differences and create an environment that isn’t so fucking oppressive. I’m literally considering giving this chapter to my boss (who is a White woman who’s done a bunch of shitty things to BIPOC folks on staff…but we have a good relationship and I do talk to her about this kind of thing). A while ago at our job, we had a consultant come in around racial issues, and for a brief period of time we were doing affinity groups (a White affinity group and a BIPOC affinity group). It sorta fell apart, in part because I think we as White folks were too caught up in “helping marginalized people” and didn’t really get how much our own psychological and spiritual liberation is tied up with dismantling our own racism. I think I’ve learned a lot since then…I might bring back a White affinity group, because I think I know a lot more about how to tap into how much potential there is for White folks to heal ourselves and have deeper and more meaningful relationships by dismantling the racism and oppression we’re all raised in, and by learning to decenter ourselves without adopting a savior complex or a passive complicity. Obviously I’d want there to be a BIPOC affinity space as well, I just wouldn’t be the person running it. I think a question people with privilege really need to ask themselves is why they don’t have meaningful relationships with people from marginalized groups. It’s not enough to just blame lack of contact; if there isn’t any contact, it’s because you’re being complicit in your environment excluding people who are different from you. Once you are no longer doing that, and when you really listen to other people’s perspectives, I’ve found it’s often quite easy to form relationships with folks who do not share your privileges. bell hooks gets at this a little bit, but only when specifically thinking about race. I think we should all be thinking about this sort of thing across identity.

Hari Sood

I am so late here that I will j share one thought this chapter made me think of: The idea of white women not bringing whiteness as a consideration into race discussions (such a good point!), and the idea that perhaps it comes from a place of 'the fear that black women have power to see through their disguises, to see the poarts of themselves they want no one to see' gave me a thought. When I think of things like Black History Month, whilst obviously good to diversify the curriculum, it can be seen as this kind of still embedded power thing, where white teachers/curriculum setters get to decide what black history students gets to learn. I could imagine how some people may also find it infantilising, to be like 'oh now is the special month where we get to learn about YOUR history, how fun!' And ofc, Black History month is lacking a key component - the role of white history in black history. It made me wonder whether there should be a 'White History Month', where BPOC students get full liberty to teach the rest of the class about their understanding and experience of white history. And all the white students/teachers have to listen and learn from the different viewpoint of those that whiteness has oppressed. So instead of white history students learn being like the WoRlD wArS aNd BrItIsH mOnArChS (at least in the UK), it would become about colonisation, slavery, genocide.

Hari Sood

Love your thoughts AJ! In answer to your question (and a bit indirect), I was talking to some friends recently on the starting point being willing to be called out, and a way to exhibit this is self-policing - if you find yourself being closed off/oppressive/hegemonic, catch yourself and make clear you want to unlearn. This helps people feel they can also call you out without fear of anger/violence, which then helps create the space where equal and open conversations can be had. It would be soooo much easier to make progress if white fragility wasn't a thing

Hari Sood

> learning to decenter ourselves without adopting a savior complex or a passive complicity > if there isn’t any contact, it’s because you’re being complicit in your environment excluding people who are different from you. Love how you phrase these ideas phil - I'd read your book!!