"Teaching to Transgress" - Chapter 7: Holding my Sister’s Hand (Feminist Solidarity) (Patreon)
Content
hi all, i’m sick so this is gonna be an extremely minimal post on my end
The next chapter is about feminist thinking in the classroom, so im wondering if this one (that doesn’t seem particularly about education) is something of a lead up to that one.
Some quotes i highlighted:
“As one Black woman put it, ‘ it burns me up to be treated like shit by white women who are busy getting their academic recognition, promotions, more money, et cetera, doing ‘great’ work on the topic of race.”
It burns me up too. And this isn’t just a thing in women's studies—a lot of the education research in physics/astro on race (and DEI work in general) is done by white women who get a lot of attention and praise for caring about the wretched minorities, but then are absolutely horrible to people from those same populations they ostensibly do so much work to support. I mentioned last week my hesitation to call this out bc of how it can be weaponized against this kind of work in general, but the ubiquity of this phenomenon, both in my own experiences and that of my colleagues, is so upsetting.
“Fear and anger about appropriation, as well as concern that we not be complicit in reproducing servant-served relationships, have led black women to withdraw from feminist settings where we must have extensive contact with white women. Withdrawal exacerbates the probelm: it makes us complicit in a different way. If a journal is doing a special issue on Black Women’s Studies and only white women submit work, then blakc women cannot effectively challenge their hegemonic hold on feminist thoery. This is only one example of many. Without our voices in written work and in oral presentaitons there wil be no articulation of our concerns…Withdrawal is not the answer.”
This made me think of a couple things—in Jenny O’dell’s “How to Do Nothing” she talks about how exiting society in whatever way (communes, off grid living, digital detoxes, whatever) don’t actually solve the problem and also create their own problems bc we actually do need to be connected to society in order to, if not survive, thrive. I have similar feelings about relationships with men, where basically a lot of women and nb people i know have experiences with men that are so bad that their conclusion is to just divesting from men as a population as much as possible. At times I’ve felt that same pull, but I have yet to cave to it bc i think being a feminist presence in men’s lives is essential to changes the condition of society for all of us (and like, writing off half of humanity just feels so defeatist to me). I’ve been putting it off for a while but i will be getting into the men thing in a video eventually. But yeah, this chapter makes me think a lot about how to engage with populations that have more hegemonic power than me for the sake of benefiting everyone while also protecting myself. Its a hard balance but a critical one, i think.
My head hurts too much to come up with a discussion question for you, hopefully will be more on it next week