Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

still kinda sick so still kinda phoning it in

I’m very interested in the question hooks sets up in the first couple pages:

“Commitment to feminist politics and black liberation struggle means that I must be able to confront issues of race and gender in a black context, providing meaningful answers to problematic questions as well as appropriate accessible ways to communicate them…How many feminist scholars can respond effectively when faced with a racially and ethnically diverse audience who may not share similar class backgrounds, language, levels of understanding, communication skills, and concerns?...Confronting one another across differences means that we must change ideas about how we learn; rather than fearring conflict we have to find ways to use it as a catalyst for new thinking, for growth.”

I love the idea of conflict as a means for growth and learning. From a purely pedagogical perspective, this is kinda the basis of what i even understand ‘learning’ to be: coming into contact with perspectives that are different than the one you already hold, and making sense of the discrepancies (“heterogeneous meaning making” a la Rosebery et al 1992, for any ed research nerds out there). But also from a personal/political perspective, I’m increasingly finding in life that conflict—as difficult and uncomfortable as it may be—is often an opportunity for growth, both on societal and interpersonal scales.

Ofc, the big question then is, how? How do you do conflict in ways that are productive rather than destructive? I think one of her classroom anecdotes starts to get at an answer for me:

“[one of the black male students] responded by calling attention to the reasons it is difficult for black men to deal with sexism, the primary one being that they were accustomed to thinking of themselves in terms of racism, being exploited and oppressed. Speaking of his efforts to develop feminist awareness, he stressed limitations: “I’ve tried to understand but then I’m a man. Sometimes I don’t understand and it hurts, ‘cause I think I’m the epitome of everything that’s oppressed.”

A barrier to understanding—and subsequently, being in solidarity with—others is this kind of instinct, which I honestly think anyone can have. In a political sense, it can be Black men’s experience of racism preventing him from seeing how they might participate in sexism like hooks exemplifies here, or a white women's experiences of sexism preventing her from seeing how she might participate in racism like we saw in the last chapter, or even a white man’s real experience of say, the harms of patriarchy preventing him from seeing how it’s the same system that also harms women and nb folks too. Interpersonally, it’s two people struggling to decenter their own hurt and see that of the other in order to resolve in a way that makes both parties feel seen. In so many contexts, we can be blinded by our real experiences of pain/oppression/hurt to a point that we aren’t able to empathize with and help solve the pain/oppression/hurt of someone else. 

A big shift for me that’s helped move through these tensions more productively has been recognizing we can all simultaneously be harmed and cause harm; there are no perfect victims, everyone will embody both sides at one point or another sometimes (oftentimes?) simultaneously. I certainly still struggle with it in some contexts bc yeah, seeing yourself as the bad guy is hard, but I’m increasingly seeing the recognition of literally ALL our capacities to harm others— even those we perceive as harming us—as critical to doing conflict good. Something something essentialism is bad, I guess.

discussion prompt---other insights as to what fascinates learning across diverse groups?

Also this is nothing about the content of the words, but was anyone else’s brain tickled by the phonetics of the line “Pat was into rap and he gave me a tape of a rap that opposed rape”? 

Comments

bhobba

As usual excellent.

AlexTheTutor

Unless one removes the ego entirely before learning across diverse groups, no learning will happen, only the appearance of learning. If you have no ego, it’s quite easy to blend into any group. So, remove the ego. The ego is armor. The bigger the ego, the bigger the armor. The ego struggles and suffers, since the ego always wages a battle that it imagines as being as inevitable as the sunset. So, the ego fights in darkness. If the armor becomes too big, what’s inside of you never interacts with the outside world (impermeable membrane). In the end, those with the greatest egos have nothing inside of them. So, either keep the ego and stay within the tribe, or remove the ego and explore other worlds. Also, feel better. maybe some honey lemon tea and plenty of rest.

Reading Point

As you also explored in your Einsteinian ethics video: "Zero-origin birthdays" will continue to be demonstrably false (creationist) in terms of "the sun evolves with all plants and animals on Earth". So IRL: #StopMisogyny + #ReparationsNow = ✌🏽 can also be proven at the scale of "false thinking" and #altermagnetism here, "now": 🍼+🍉=✌🏽=🌱 https://open.substack.com/pub/danwithglasses/p/coherent-spintronics-resists-false

AJ Biffl

My initial reaction at the beginning-ish of this chapter where hooks describes where perceived racial divides manifest and "[s]uddenly, the feminist classroom is no longer a safe haven" was along the lines of: 'ah yes, inevitable material conflict between social "organisms," groups of people categorized by artificial standards; under economic hegemony there is competition for resources at every scale of organization; hierarchy destroys itself; the solution is to dissolve the organisms, reject organization, reject category' ... but the 'categories' here are, like, entire genders and ethnicities. I'll stand by the fact that "abolish gender" is a banger slogan, but that's probably not happening any time soon. These categories aren't material organizations like corporations or countries or crocheting clubs, they're part of a lot of people's identities. So practically, the resolution of these conflicts needs to come about without actually getting rid of those structures. That quote about confrontation as a "catalyst" (literally the end of that same paragraph), that material conflict can serve to inspire change and growth, that embracing and addressing it can actually bring about its end - I love that so much. I think the key difference between conflict as catalyst and conflict being destructive is recognizing that the people taking part in the conversation are individuals, and they transcend the material interests of the categories they supposedly belong to. Even if there IS a real material conflict between two categories of people (and a lot of time there isn't even a real conflict), two people speaking as individuals with mutual respect and empathy can consider that conflict together almost as a team, rather than being forced to be hostile. There's a huge first step of even just acknowledging out loud how "your team" wants things to end up, where their material interests lie. There's an element of showing your hand, acting just a little bit against the interests of "your team" when you allow that part of the conversation to be said out loud. That first step in relinquishing pure self-interest, stepping outside of it, is a huge step, and opens the door for others to do the same. I've noticed this a lot as a TA when I'm open about why we grade things certain ways, or how the attendance isn't graded but the professors want attendance data to see who's actually showing up and caring and who isn't, etc. It's like letting down the curtain a little bit, and I think it feels good to have someone trust you with the "real" reasons for something, that you can share in the logic of it. And when there's conflict, with that shared perspective and shared trust you can start to construct solutions.

schlltchrn

YES TO THE PHONETICS!!! I was thinking how weird this would sound to a person not speaking English. I believe it is for sure a challenge having a conflict as the catalyst for learning in the classroom for a social science study. But still, everybody is on board to learn _something_ about the society and also putting their effort to be civil in this public space. Outside, in the everyday world... I don't know, sometimes it seems impossible to me. The focus in the text is on learning and teaching, and classrooms that she thought in, but the practicality of this productive conflict when not in such setting puzzles me. I manage to have it sometimes with some people in my family who may be of very different political opinion than me, because I know them well and care about what they think. And then I can't imagine having such a discussion with a random person in a bar, because I don't care enough to put in the work of handling all the rising emotions. Two things that help me is what my therapist told me once, to try to extend my empathy from somebody I perceive as oppressed in the conflict, also to the person I perceive as "the bad guy" in the discussion, to be able to continue the argument. The other thing is trying to do a check in, am I arguing because I read something, and now I want to prove I'm right, and they're wrong? Or is the politics I try to advocate for a symptom of some more general humanism and belief in the capacity of people to grow and be kind to one another. Usually it's both haha, but silencing the first one a bit can be helpful...

Mingo

The phonetics were very great!

Hari Sood

> the people taking part in the conversation are individuals, and they transcend the material interests of the categories they supposedly belong to. Good vibes!

Hari Sood

> other insights as to what fascinates learning across diverse groups? Not sure I'm understanding 'fascinates' right here BUT a thought is mb there needs to be a more institutional prioritisation of somatics, of understanding how our bodies react and how we respond to those reactions - so when we are in situations where there may be conflict, tension, anxiety, distress, instead of rising with them and descending into hostility, we can notice the reactions we are having and start to a) place them where they're actually coming from more accurately (likely not what is being said right now, but rooted somewhere else) and b) learn how to hold them and work through and with them to bring everyone with us. This doesn't mean there won't be conflict, just that when there is, we can be with it lovingly and progressively

Raphaël Royer

I've been thinking about that a lot these days, barriers to solidarity, reflecting on my life experiences, I find that my disability made me able to empathize more with people from a wide array of backgrounds, in the sense that I might not be able to fully know what it's like to be a woman in a patriarchal society but I know what it's like to be severely disabled in an inaccessible and ableist world so I can imagine even if it's not the same thing. Also, disability being this common, almost everybody will have some kind of disability at one point in their life, it may be super late in but still. I'm still figuring out how best to use my voice but I think I definitely made the right choice to go back to college to study special education! Even though my colleges are 20 years younger than me, (I feel so old😂) they give me valuable lessons and hope for a better future.

phil e the theyby

Big props to the focus on somatic experience. It is STUNNING how little insight we usually have that most of our arguments have almost nothing to do with what's being said, and almost everything to do with the biochemical response process (which developed to ensure that a tiger didn't eat you or a rival tribe doesn't murder you with a spear) that has been activated by the legacy of personal and cultural hurt and trauma, and that won't be undone by anything either person says or does. The aim shouldn't be for everyone to be perfectly regulated, "rational" participants in discussions (as that would mean that you'd never be able to discuss anything that's tied to hurt or trauma); it just means that we need to be VASTLY more mindful of when and how people are activated, and on supporting them in getting to a regulated enough space that they can hear the other person.

phil e the theyby

> try to extend my empathy from somebody I perceive as oppressed in the conflict, also to the person I perceive as "the bad guy" in the discussion, to be able to continue the argument. The funny thing about this is that most people act like this is for the benefit of the person we see as the "bad guy." But honestly, this just makes you more effective with people in general. When I meet with students for therapy (I'm a psychologist at a university counseling center), I routinely try to find ways to empathize with and understand the people they're upset with or who have hurt them. I don't always verbalize that empathy or help students to do the same (because my priority is helping the students feel heard and validated); it just helps me to have a more accurate understanding of their situation, so that I can better inform them on potentially helpful ways to respond to the situations that upset them.

phil e the theyby

I haven't done a lot of facilitating learning across diverse groups directly, but I've done a LOT of work trying to help people I work with empathize with people from different groups. I usually aim to tell a really compelling story about the group they struggle to empathize with, and that connects that group's experience to their own pain. This has been pretty effective in helping women of color empathize with men (by recognizing how patriarchy's impact on men and especially young boys leads to male oppression of women) and liberals empathize with Trump voters (by seeing how Trump speaks to and validates the pain of many economically disadvantaged people in ways that Democrats generally do not). These are obviously "easier" cases because in all of them, the people I was speaking to WANTED to empathize and learn. But I do think helping people to recognize the ways that their suffering/alienation/pain is intricately connected to the suffering/alienation/pain of others (even those who are privileged) is a helpful approach.