Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Last chapter! Excited to see what y'all have to say about it.

To close off this book, I made a when2meet to schedule our collaborative live writing session. For those who are new to the book club, the idea is that we all get on a google doc at the same time, share questions about the reading, and then take an hour to engage with eachothers questions. Its like a halfway point between these weekly discussions and a real-time conversation; you have time to sit and think and write thoughtfully, but we'll all be there for the same hour so you can get responses within minutes instead of days later. If you're interested in participating, fill at the when2meet and start brainstorming a question you want to bring to the discussion.

Comments

AJ Biffl

What an amazing wrap-up chapter. ~~~~ "The academy is not paradise. But learning is a place where paradise can be created. The classroom, with all its limitations, remains a location of possibility. In that field of possibility we have the opportunity to labor for freedom, to demand of ourselves and our comrades, an openness of mind and heart that allows us to face reality even as we collectively imagine ways to move beyond boundaries, to transgress. This is education as the practice of freedom." ~~~~ "I am reminded of the power we have as teachers as well as the awesome responsibility. Commitment to engaged pedagogy carries with it the willingness to be responsible, not to pretend that professors do not have the power to change the direction of our students' lives." ~~~~ More thoughts in replies for scrollability

AJ Biffl

A couple experiences directly resonated: First: "I was reminded of this during my trip to the emergency room after falling down that hill. I talked so intensely about ideas with the two students who were rushing me to the hospi- tal that I forgot my pain." I love this imagery, and while I definitely haven't experienced anything as extreme as this, I've definitely forgotten anxiety, fatigue, nerves, because I'm taken up by the ideas I'm sharing. Next: "Most of us are not inclined to see discussion of pedagogy as central to our academic work and intellectual growth, or the practice of teaching as work that enhances and enriches scholarship." Even just the other day I had a friend say, "YOU like teaching?" Within my institution, there's a culture where teaching is something you're forced to do, either as a stepping stone in your first few years or because your lab lost funding. The goal is to be in a paid RA position, and being a TA is the second choice.

AJ Biffl

I really like this emphasis on real-time feedback, not just leaving things to the end-of-semester evaluations. "When students see themselves as mutually responsible for the development of a learning community, they offer constructive input." I think this is a very natural extension of being present in the classroom, in listening to students and responding to their needs - in that sort of frame of respecting students as adults and building the learning process together, you get a natural feedback mechanism through two-way communication.

AJ Biffl

I absolutely loved the quote from Pema Chodron. I found the full interview online for anyone who is interested: https://tricycle.org/magazine/no-right-no-wrong/ (it's behind a paywall but there are ways around that... DM me). A slightly expanded version of the passage bh quotes: "But clean role models were never that useful for me. My models were the people who stepped outside of conventional mind and who could actually stop my mind and completely open it up and free it, even for a moment, from a conventional, habitual way of looking at things. And so people look for different things. But to look for “safety” in a role model, someone that will never hurt you and always confirm you, is very dubious. If you are really preparing for groundlessness, preparing for the reality of human existence, you are living on the razor’s edge, and you must become used to the fact that things shift and change. Things are not certain and they do not last and you do not know what is going to happen. My teachers have always pushed me over the cliff, and that is what has awakened my compassion for what human beings are up against. I am afraid that because of where we come from as Westerners, with our Judeo-Christian heritage, that if you get too focused on doctrine, on codifying, or ethics as a major emphasis, it just turns into harsh judgment. And then there is no genuine compassion." The title is "No Right, No Wrong" and it's absolutely fascinating (some of the content also makes me wonder if hooks wrote the previous chapter at least partially in response to the interview as well). Turns out I may be a Buddhist... at least, I got a lot out of the interview and what it seems to say about Buddhist doctrine, but I'm hesitant to define myself as "Buddhist" because ideological boxes tend to be restrictive and there may be situations where following a particular doctrine is more harmful than not... which is also the most Buddhist-coded shit I've ever said. So that was a fun realization Another quote from Chodron about the teacher mentioned in the quotation, Trungpa Rinpoche: "Things are not permanent, they don’t last, there is no final security. He was always trying to teach us to relax into the insecurity, into the groundlessness. He taught me about how to live. So I am grateful to him, no matter what."

Jacques Vincelette

"Without the capacity to think critically about ourselves and our lives, none of us would be able to move forward, to change, to grow".

Hari Sood

The thoughts she shares from Pema Chodron on preparing for 'groundlessness' is such a great, anarchist rallying call on how to approach education, and what lessons really matter - resilience, empowerment, curiosity, play. Makes me think so much about how we need a school abolition movement!!

Hari Sood

Wayback machine for the win lol: https://web.archive.org/web/20180922120728/https://tricycle.org/magazine/no-right-no-wrong/ Love your thoughts AJ! You may be interested in this (Buddhism without doctrine thoughts - https://secularbuddhistnetwork.org/the-five-principles-of-the-middle-way/ Also your thoughts on teaching are so real - there's this whole cultural joke of 'if you can't do, teach', presuming no-one actually WANTS to teach and the only people who do it are like washed up people who tried something else and weren't good enough, which is so tragic 😭 but also thinking about it feels like a way to remain disembodied with the idea of connection and change through education, to dismiss it as it is too threatening to engage and actually work towards self actualization (or whatever you can in a broken world) - the cultural West scores another own goal!!