Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi everyone!

The galileo video is out, feeling quite happy with it and excited to shift my production into shorter, more frequent videos for the next months (pls pray to the scope creep gods for me). I have some cool concepts for the first few and I’m looking forward to seeing what yall think, so here’s me committing to a deadline of the end of the month for the first one.

BUT i’m not here to talk about videos i’m here to talk about book club!

I just ordered my copy of Paulo Freire’s “Pedagogy of the Oppressed” (found a free pdf copy here) and hope to start this round of reading on Monday June 16. So get your copy if you haven’t yet, and in the meantime, I have two questions to inform my planning of this iteration, a short one and a long one:

Short question: how long do you want to take to read this? Its 4 chapters, 16-58 pages each, 140 pages total. Could do a chapter a week and get through the whole thing in a month but open to a different pace if people want it.

Long question: I’m thinking of restructuring the bookclub and i want your input!

For those that are new, what we’ve generally done for book club is break the book up into weekly readings (sometimes a chapter, sometimes more, depending on how the book is organized or how dense it is), and each week I’d write a post with my thoughts on the reading, and then everyone can have a discussion in the comments. We also usually do a collaborative live writing session at the end of a book where we all get on the same google doc at the same time drop in some initial questions/prompts, and then just spend an hour writing responses to whatever feels interesting—it’s close enough to real time communication to be able to go back and forth with someone on an idea, but slow enough to give time to read and think and digest before responding. 

Something I had wanted to try towards the end of the last book was, rather than me writing my thoughts on the reading in the weekly post, I’d not share initial thoughts (which I think can sometimes bias the conversation in some direction, and tbh i dont always have a ‘take’ that feels worth sharing) and instead engage with some of the comments, (which I currently don’t do). However, right when I was gonna do that, the grant termination thing happened so I ended up not participating in the last chapter and haven’t tried this new model yet. 

All that said—I want to take this new book as an opportunity to check in with what people want to get out of the book club and what way of organizing it is best suited for whatever that is. So if you’ve participated/plan on participating, let me know in the comments how you’ve liked it, what’s valuable, what’s not that important, what’s worked, what’s been difficult, what other ideas you might have etc etc.  In general I don’t do live conversations (e.g. zoom calls) for moderation reasons, so if it requires me to moderate in real time it probably won’t happen. That said, I do want to make this as fruitful as possible for those who want to participate, so I’m very open to trying something different.

looking forward to getting into this book together, really couldn't be coming at a better time (for us in the US i mean 😬) 

fatima <3

Comments

Aidan

I’m new here so I don’t have a perspective on how your previous book clubs went. But I do like your idea to engage with comments and collaborating on a google doc. It’s reminiscent of a book club I’m in for (it’s actually for this book lol).

Irving Flanagan

I also hope to participate in the live writing session, though I might not be able to depending on the timing. So it might be fun to have smaller conversations in the comments

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Hi! I'm new. This google docs talk idea feels like it's a lot of fun, I'll try to participate. I think I'll try to read the book just so I'll be able to join :) I haven't read The Pedagogy of the Oppressed before, but I'm familiar with Freire's work because he's such an important reference around here (I'm Brazilian). When I worked in primary care Freire was a major source of inspiration for our work as health educators, which was an important part of the job. When I was in university as an undergrad I read his 1997 book A Pedagogy of Hope (not sure if it's been translated into English). I'm not sure if I'd be able to read a chapter a week with everyone, because I work crazy hours. But I'll try.

boopdeedoo

i’m really excited for this! Love the idea of google docs and asynchronous engagement

RA

Hi! Here is my input: [Short question: how long do you want to take to read this?] I think reviewing a new chapter once a week would be ideal for this specific book. [Long question] I think we can try you not initiating question first for this book. I'll participate irrespective of which format you choose. It would be interesting to get engagement in the comments. Though, not sure how your previous cycles have went but some might misread not getting engagement from you but see you give it to others. Just my two cents. PS, I have never done a writing only book club. I'm actually interested to see how this goes!

Djoran Keil

I haven't participated in a book club yet and so have little to contribute other than to say I'm using my participation as motivation to actually read something worth reading. This may sound trite but with my ADHD I really struggle to get through material and need some sort of external push to continue beyond just my initial interest. So far it seems to be working since I'm already up to page sixty-six (I pre-empted 'cause I saw somewhere that this was going to be the next book club choice). Looking forward to seeing how the book club actually works and learning how best to contribute to ones after this one, though.

AJ Biffl

One chapter a week sounds reasonable to me (though forewarning for people reading that pdf version, there are about 30 pages worth of introductions, forwards, and prefaces before chapter one starts, so not a bad idea to get a head start). I'm open to trying the new format but if you're inspired with burning discussion questions please still share! (reject methodological restriction of book club conduction!)

Jacques Vincelette

Sorry for my lack of decorrum, I am half way through Chapter 3. I have taken notes and don't mind going back to keep pace.

Tawfiq M

Pedagogy of Hope has been translated into English by Robert Barr. I read part of it during my maths teacher training and found it really useful!

Tawfiq M

(New patron here!) During my teacher training, with time before the lecture, my lecturer would ask us to find two quotes we agree with and one we disagree with from our reading that week. Then, he'd show each quote on the board to guide discussion (in the room we'd move to one side of the room or the other for agree/disagree). This format felt well-facilitated, driven by student interest, and covered a broad range of themes that the paper discussed. Maybe something like this could work?

Jacques Vincelette

In the wake of DOGE, my employer announced a new "Performance Assurance Program" to monitor employee keystrokes and streamline our workforce following Ford. So this morning, I have reached out to our Director of Governance & Compliance & Culture, and our three renegade poet Human Performance bloggers to recommend Bell Hook's 'Learning to Transgress' and Paulo Freire's 'Pedagogy of the Oppressed'. These women are friends, even when we butt heads. (They'll say I'm the butt head.)

Alfalfafield

My copy just arrived in the mail today! Excited to read this. Flipping through it, I'd agree that one chapter/week looks like a good rate. It's my first time participating in one of these, so I don't have a strong opinion about the structure - but maybe a good middle ground would be a few open-ended questions as a prompt for discussion rather than a full-blown write-up?

Shree Hari Mittal

This is my first time joining, and I have wanted to join for quite some time. I think one chapter per week is ideal rate to read and *discuss*. I think I quite like the idea suggested by @Tawfiq M, to choose quotes you agree/disagree with. i think it might be worth changing it quotes you found to be most insightful. As for what I want out of book club, I am always looking for people to discuss books that I read, because I believe it furthers my understanding of the text. And I really like your analysis in your videos, so the community here is definitely going to be one that will have insightful thoughts on any reading and will hopefully find my contribution useful as well.

Travis

I have not had capacity to participate in the patreon book clubs lately, but I am excited to be back and talking with folks!!! This community is a good one :)

Tom Cassidy

Here's a possibility about how to run the discussion: when you have a burning question, ask it; if not, ask, What did you think?

Kurty

whats cookin, i been a fan of dr fatima for ages now, but i joined the patreon cos i love pedagogy of the oppressed, cant wait to overshare with yall🙏🏽

Vitória Xavier

Hiii! Loooove the New vídeo! There's some topics that you mentioned that i've always wanted to know more about and never knew how to study It or with whom to talk to. It would bê amazing If you explore in other vídeo about how could the ocidenta science and scientific method be less rigid without missing important conclusions and "autority". I've always thought about how could we change It (as a physics major student) but never concluded anything, i guess the academ already shaped my brain

Victor Steuck

Hi everyone, I’m really happy to be here! I decided to become a supporter of the channel after seeing this new round of the book club, especially because Pedagogy of the Oppressed is a book I already know and love. I’m from Brazil, and I’m a writer, journalist, and poet, and I’ve admired Dr Fatima’s work for a while now. This felt like the right moment to join and be part of this space. Even though I’ve read Pedagogy of the Oppressed before, I’m planning to reread it now in English. I’m especially drawn to it from a philosophical perspective. I find its ideas deeply coherent, particularly when it comes to the concept of praxis, which is something that has shaped the way I think about writing, politics, and everyday action. Looking forward to reading this book again with all of you, and to studying this incredible Brazilian author we all love, and hopefully meeting some thoughtful people along the way, Warmly, Victor Steuck

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

Hi! I wanted to ask where do I leave a question for office hours? How often does it happen? I'm new here and I'm still a little lost regarding possible ways of interaction. I feel weird just posting a question here on the comments to this post, is this how it's supposed to happen?

Saoirse

I'd love to chat more with you in the comments :) If you had a longer-form or deeper response to any of the readings, you could always "seal it in an envelope " and return to it after the group discussion (or at the end of the book) and see what's changed for you. That could be a fun segment for a stream.

Saoirse

Pedagogy of the Oppressed is hands down one of the three most impactful books I've ever read (the others being The Dawn of Everything by David Graeber and David Wengrow and Seeing Like a State by James C. Scott). Can't wait to nerd out about Radical Pedagogy even more with y'all!