Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter three discussion--this one's a long one so I hope you started reading early!

Y'all know how it goes: share questions, points or agreement/disagreement, or whatever else you like in the comments~

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

The British House of Lords criminalized protest as terrorism. Audrey Lorde left me wanting: "The Master's Tools Will Never Dismantle the Master's House". Chapter 3 filled the gap with 'Praxis' as reflective action and active reflection. This resonates with Bayo Akomolafe's "Post-Activism" or "Compost-Activism". Thérèse Cator points to 'Service' as spiritual pillar: "Ask, listen, act."

Jacques Vincelette

Essence of dialogue: the word-work praxis. "There is no true word that is not at the same time a praxis. To speak a true word it to transform the world.". Horriffic how Kant's moral philosophy was highjacked for human domination, erasure of praxis on the commodification of the American dream, If a tree falls does it sound?

Robert Herold

I loved this chapter and I think that it touches on very important points. I really liked the line from the paragraph where Friere says that true dialogue requires humility, he says, "How can I dialogue if I start from the premise that naming the world is the task of an elite and that the presence of the people in history is a sign of deterioration, thus to be avoided?" I want to talk about why this quote hit me today, and the short reason is that I think that there a lot of people within academia and tech who think this way, and this line of thinking as Friere points out is very bad, harmful to others, and it inhibits the project of liberation. Before I go onto my point I want to start with a personal story. I have never been someone who was religious in any way, my parents never took me to church or even argued against me going, I have gone to a couple of different types of churches yet nothing has spoken to me. But I was also never really told that I should respect other people's beliefs more that I should just ignore them. As such when I hit high school and early college I was the shitty atheist kid who tried to just shit talk all religious perspectives and looked down on others for their religious faiths. This changed later in my college life and when I look back on that time I realized that I was a very shitty person to a lot of people for no other reason than that I was sure about my belief in their being no god and I used things like science and logic to try to support my belief and I refused to listen to others. I was never going to be in a position where I could have authentically engaged in dialogue with others. I bring this story up because I have seen other people in my life and online who have gone down a very similar path, and most of the time people point to things like science as the reason why they don't believe in religion. Now this isn't to say that every atheist is this way but the point is that I think modern science and the secular world has taken over dialogue and has now gained the power to determine who gets to name the world. I have seen it in political science where academics look down on people, a good example is democracy research which often talks about people who don't live in democratic countries like they are stupid for not doing something or dumb for living there. It can also be seen in the devaluing of indigenous knowledge and understanding or even in the world of tech in which billionaires get to decide which technology will become prevalent in the world. AI is a good example of this, no matter what people want right now or in the future, because AI is able to help companies make more money the rest of the society is forced into this new reality without ever being given a say. I also think that the leaders in the tech world think this is a good thing and that people shouldn't be given a say. I think that a lot of people in academia and the tech industry see themselves as smarter and simply better than other people, in short they lack the humility that Friere is talking about.

AlexTheTutor

This Bookclub itself has been an example of what Freire talks about in Chapter 3: having an open dialogue and mutual trust in order to discuss for example Limit-Situations (conditions that prevent us from fully understanding potentially oppressive socio-political structures) by using Codifications (simple relatable examples that illustrate the themes and stimulate critical thought), in this case by using Religion as a Condification to discuss Limit-Situations .. this Bookclub is great pedagogy .. thank you for sharing your story! I am trying to think of a story I can share .. hm .. well I can think about the story of an RPG video game: at first the most innocent character realizes he is a Puppet for the powerful, but later it is revealed that many other characters are just Puppets too, in fact the so-called "powerful" evil oppressors are revealed to be Puppets themselves for an even greater powerful force, in the end there's nothing but a hierarchy of oppressors .. and of course in our real world .. in order to begin to understand the dynamics and institutions that may oppress us .. as Freire asks in chapter 3 .. we first need to discuss the Limit-Situations (Maybe I am not educated enough to understand these oppressive structures, Maybe I don't have time or patience, Maybe I oppress myself with addictions or vises, Maybe I succomb to talk-radio or podcasts that tell me how to understand oppression and I learn how to Oppress the so-called enemy, but the podcasters themselves are oppressed by the owners, and the owners oppressed by a greater force, and so on) or maybe regardless if I understand any oppression, what I can do is focus on creating something, creating dialogue, creating music, creating something with croche, creating food, creating opportunities for children to speak publicly to build confidence and senses of purpose, maybe we can all create something this week

phil e the theyby

Lots of really good stuff here, and I had a much easier time with this chapter than I did the last time I read it. Stuff I really liked: “They forget that their fundamental objective is to fight alongside the people for the recovery of the people’s stolen humanity, not to ‘win the people over’ to their side.” (94-95) I think this is harder than it sounds. How do you differentiate your own beliefs from the signs of someone’s stolen humanity? As a nonbinary person, gender is good example of this. How can I distinguish someone else developing a liberatory relationship to their own (binary) gender identity, especially within their cultural context, from reifying fundamentally oppressive gender norms? While there are certain markers that may make it obvious someone is recreating oppressive systems, there are a lot of times where things are more ambiguous. I think this is an ongoing and essential tension of working across cultural groups. [Speaking of Gabriel Bode] “…he has managed to communicate to the participants a sense of totality. Individuals who were submerged in reality, merely feeling their needs, emerge from reality and perceive the causes of their needs.” (117) I think this is a really apt description of what I’m trying to do in this sort of work. There’s a subjective experience I’ve seen many times where things “click” for someone, where what was previously just stress and tension starts to make sense in a broader context. I am mindful, though, that the same feeling can also happen in very misguided ways (e.g., someone listens to a populist leader and starts to attribute all of their problems to immigrants). I think this can even happen in less overtly problematic ways (e.g. coming to believe that all of your problems are the result of some sort of energy misalignment). To me, what distinguished that true “emergence” is that’s it’s more specific (it makes sense of a SPECIFIC issue, not of EVERYTHING, even if it can explain more as time goes on), it’s self-directed, and it’s curious (that is, it inspires us to explore and learn more and to look at things from different angles, rather than one lens). “Codifications are not slogans; they are cognizable objects, challenges towards which the critical reflection of the decoders should be directed.” (115) I’m not 100% clear on what every step of the process Freire describes in this chapter means in practice, so I’m not sure what he had in mind for codifications. But my mind went to art, and the ways that art can convey things in a way that challenges us to dig deeper rather than follow a set interpretation or perspective. I think the points around codifications both connecting directly to people’s felt needs, while also drawing parallels to things outside of their own needs, was super valuable. Stuff I had some questions/hesitations about: In the process Freire describes, it sounds like they’re generally getting groups of people and generating things from what they learn within those groups. The part I found myself unsure about what the experiences of those who are marginalized WITHIN the working-class (or, regarding the groups he discusses here, the peasant class) people. I’m talking about folks who are LGBTQ+, a religious minority, sex workers, etc. Essentially, if there are people who are discouraged from sharing their voice in the group you’re talking to, you’re going to fundamentally miss their perspective. My assumption is that part of what Freire would recommend is getting a group of THOSE marginalized folks specifically, or having enough of a critical mass of them within a group to uplift their voices, but I don’t think that’s always practical or possible. Essentially, my concern is that a certain oppressed group may scapegoat a certain subgroup that isn’t present. Freire may speak to this elsewhere (e.g. in another book), but my main concern with allowing the perspective to fully come from “the voice of the people” is that you will necessarily exclude perspectives whose voices are marginalized within whatever group is designated as “the people.” I’m not claiming Freire never considered this, just that I didn’t see it addressed well here. Given some of our recent discussions around Feyerabend and some posts last week about the human-animal distinction, the parts about humans vs. animals stood out to me as affirming worth to a certain way of being that might be overly attached to “rationality.” For example… “As antagonism deepens between themes which are the expression of reality, there is a tendency for the themes and for reality itself to be mythicized, establishing a climate of irrationality and sectarianism… In such a situation, myth-creating irrationality itself becomes a fundamental theme.” (101-102) I think I understand what the first sentence means, but I’m not clear what the “irrationality” he refers to means. Some of this may be a translation issue, but I basically wasn’t sure what Freire was referring to when he said rationality/irrationality. But it concerns me because the overvaluation of the “rational” tends to favor a certain way of showing up in the world which can be unnecessarily harmful to other ways of being, devaluing their potential contributions. Overly, this was a VERY interesting chapter to re-read, and I felt like I both understood it and was able to engage with it much more deeply this time around. Thanks, book club!

Tom Cassidy

I did NOT start early, so I'm just catching up! I found the first part challenging, in part because of the philosophic tone. I was not expecting reflections on Hegel's Master/Slave dialectic, but I saw the point. I found myself making mental comparisons to Frederick Douglass. American slave owners used Hegel's view of history to justify slavery, and Frederick Douglass believed that true freedom was only going to be achieved through education and resistance (it was not something that could be granted). Be that as it may, it picked up for me a lot once he started illustrating his points with examples. The story about a facilitator showing a group an image a drunk stumbling home was lovely. The group facilitator thought this illustrated the evils of alcohol; the group saw a hard worker at the end of his day. This put something into context for me: Does his critique of the Banking theory of education imply a rejection of education as cultural capital? No, not entirely. The point is that the other workers in this group brought their own cultural capital to the discussion which the leader had to respect. As a teacher, I have been in this position many times, where I bring up a topic or an essay which I thought had a clear point, only to see students take it into their own direction.

Craig

Great points phil, I'd especially like to discuss the irrationality issue - it seems to be the most pressing theme for us in this time. For me, I don't think we're talking about precluding any ways of knowing by speaking about making "rational" judgements. I forget the specific examples in the Feyerabend video, but it seems to me that, for one example, the likes of indigenous knowledges passed down through oral tradition, in Freire's view, can still be the basis of "rational" judgements and decisions. He's very much a contextual thinker, emphasising the uniqueness of each individual's limit situations, but with connection and overlap at broader levels of reality. The sentences you've quoted there, I think, are really perfectly describing what we can see happening right now with history being mythicised, hell, even what happens in front of our eyes being completely denied at times. We could find some turns or starting points for themes of top down myth making and then go back further and further to their antecedents, but maybe recently we could point to the invasion of Ukraine as a turning point in the myth of nationalism. Before that, there wasn't much appetite for military expansion, whereas afterwards, the whole world (I exaggerate), it seems, has turned into a war hawk. This all relies on the conquest of minds and the denial of ability to make rational judgements about the world, where the masses are woefully underdeveloped in the ability to judge valid from invalid knowledge claims, and therefore more susceptible to myths and sectarianism. So, for many reasons, it's an "irrational" move to invade Ukraine, yet we have a significant chunk of people taking as the starting point the inevitable and unavoidable system of nationalism on which they base a judgement that finds said invasion to have some rationality to it - this is what I see as mythicised reality leading to irrational judgements - false consciousness, basically. Only raising critical consciousness can tackle it, because the starting point for transformation is always in the minds of people (not to say the origin of thought is not external, which it always is). This is how I take the irrationality Freire was referring to.

AJ Biffl

Yeah he definitely doubled down on the human-animal divide in this chapter, though I hadn't made the connection to rationality/irrationality! But I don't think he's wrong to critique the irrational here necessarily. I read "irrationality" as the position that reality's themes (and reality itself) are rigid and unchanging. Freire writes in that paragraph that the climate of antagonism "threatens to drain the themes of their deeper significance and to deprive them of their characteristically dynamic aspect," and this antagonism leads to irrationality as a new theme. The irrational theme's opposite is "the critical and dynamic view of the world" (pg 102). From Freire's preface: "Radicalization involves... ever greater engagement in the effort to transform concrete, objective reality. Conversely, sectarianism, because it is mythicizing and irrational, turns reality into a false (and therefore unchangeable) "reality." " So I think Freire means a very specific false position when he says irrational, and very much devalues that position and perhaps overvalues its opposite: "a critical perception of the world, which implies a correct method of approaching reality in order to unveil it" (pg 111). Going back to the sections I'd highlighted about the human/animal divide (pg 97-100), the distinction was that animals, if they are not conscious, don't recognize reality as historical; their actions are "adaptations" to the world, not attempts to "transform" it - which is related to that sense of irrationality as being "submerged" in a fixed reality. But even if Freire is wrongly assuming that only human beings are capable of recognizing that reality is dynamic, and even if he's wrong in asserting that there is only one "correct" way to approach reality given that dynamism, I don't think the critique of this 'irrationality' is wrong either. There may not be one "correct" approach to unveiling the process of history, but you have to at least acknowledge that it is a process. .......... You raise a really good point about marginalized and marginalizing voices. I'd be really interested to see if Freire addresses this anywhere (or if his contemporaries wrote about it on his behalf. I think bell hooks' TtT chapter "Essentialism and Experience" touches on a bit) I also really like the points you made about things "clicking." It reminds me of C. Thi Nguyen "The seductions of clarity" https://philarchive.org/rec/NGUTSO-2 (and a bit of CJ the X's essay on "making sense" https://cjthex.com/reductio-ad-absurdum/) ........... EDIT: @Craig I really like your framing that irrational decisions can be motivated by mythicized worldviews. I'd started drafting my response before I saw yours updated, else I would have mentioned it! I think my framing of irrationality is complementary - to avoid being pushed into unreasonable decisions by these narratives, you can view reality as dynamic and transcending rigid myth-making.

Craig

@AJ Biffl Yeah, I think that Freire was saying the only way to reveal the world is through openness to different ways of knowing, as this is necessary to get at the uniqueness of each individual's limit situations, as well as finding the commonality in broader themes, rather than the only way is experimentation, for example. But I also have a post-it on my hard copy with a reminder to check if he later updated his views on animals (I haven't read anything really beyond Pedagogy of the Oppressed). I think it's likely that humans are not the only reflective species, so I find this theme quite interesting. It reminds me that it comes up in Vygotsky as well where he seemed to think the same as Freire that there's this great distinction between human and non human animals.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I haven't been able to finish the chapter yet this time. I'm not sure if this happened to more people, or if most of us did read through but are finding it hard to come up with things to say and share. I would like more time to dwell on this chapter, is anyone else with me on this?

aliin

(Just want to preface that I'm not yet done with the chapter but) I like the point on creating! A manga that I really love emphasizes the importance of art (wether music or drawing) in a facist society. I think music especially can have a big unifying factor and can move people to a great degree even if it isn't necessarily the intention of the artist. Once the art grows organically to take revolutionary character in the people's eyes that's what it is: revolutionary. At one point in the story the musician was labeled a terrorist and later even classified as "alien" which feels eerily relevant now as this was prior to the whole "illegal aliens" thing that is going on rn. Talk about dehumanization! It also emphasized the importance of living an ordinary life which I think touches upon Freire's point on humility. In thinking too big of ourselves or thinking we must become that bigger person before we can act/change we lose the perspective of the ordinary person, the humility, in the process of becoming that "bigger" person in our eyes. So we devalue the ordinary person, the ordinary factory/farm/retail worker, and devalue dialogue with them. As you say we may be too overworked or uneducated to critically engage in our liberation but what we can do in our own scope is just as important as the "big revolutionary work" and if it is creating then we create. If we can create, we can change. And if we create and change collectively we may change the world too along the way. That's the sort of thought that motivates me to suggest building a neighborhood garden on the next neighbors' meetup although I still might need some courage as idk how seriously they will take that proposition. I will do my best tho and put the thought at least out there✌️

AJ Biffl

I did manage to finish the chapter last week, but I had to reread almost the entire chapter to feel I had absorbed the words sufficiently, and even as I'm now trying to draft a post and get my thoughts in order I'm finding new things... there was so much!

AJ Biffl

Maria pointed out in the discussion for last chapter that this book isn't focused on all forms of classroom education but on 'conscientization' of oppressed groups, which has helped inform my reading. (sidenote, is the best english translation of conscientizaçāo "wokeness??" I think yes.) That said, this passage did suggest a major tenet of dialogical education that can be applied to technical fields: "Authentic education is not carried on by "A" *for* "B" or by "A" *about* "B," but rather by "A" *with* "B," mediated by the world — a world which impresses and challenges both parties, giving rise to views or opinions about it. These views, impregnated with anxieties, doubts, hopes, or hopelessness, imply significant themes on the basis of which the program content of education can be built" (pg 93) Which I extrapolate to mean that the content of a technical education should be about the curiosities or observations *of the students*, that their questions should motivate the lessons, that the things they want to know about are what they are taught. This isn't just a good practice for liberatory purposes, it's also just a good approach to educating in these fields in general - inspire natural curiosity, and find answers wherever that curiosity leads. In this vein, I really liked Arcie's comment on last chapter about having students think about ways they observe math and physics in their daily lives. But, there's always the risk that students' questions will be too broad for a certain class. Given constraints on curriculum, a compromise may be sort of like what Koshika Yadava mentioned last chapter discussion about Resnik and Halliday's textbook, which floats interesting questions at the beginning of the chapter for the students to think about. Felder & Felder's math methods textbook (one of my faves) has a similar structure, and it does seem to have the benefit of organically inspiring curiosity to keep students interested. Another surprising example of this is YT channels like Steve Mould, minutephysics, 3blue1brown, and Veritasium, that take some interesting click-baiting question as the jumping-off point to their videos before explaining it. Though I wonder if there's an element of manipulation in doing this, posing questions that never would've effected them organically. *.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.* Also, apparently I can't go a single minute without thinking about Feyerabend. Several times I went, "Hey! He talks about that in Against Method!" After collecting my notes together and re-reading some of the passages, I think I see something resembling a common thread. First, the things that made me think of Feyerabend: page 106, the mistaken view "that themes exist, in their original objective purity, outside people — as if themes were things," and page 107, "the objectives implicit in meaningful thematics are *human* aspirations... they cannot be apprehended apart from them." Then page 108, about a pluralistic approach to investigating themes that "avoids the narrow outlines of partial or "focalized" views of reality" ('focalized' being the same term used to describe investigation by specialists of particular fields, pg 119-120). In general on the topic of thematic investigation, page 107-108: "Thematic investigation, which occurs in the realm of the human, cannot be reduced to a mechanical act." Freire's "humanizing pedagogy," a process constantly in flux, is a methodology-transcending approach. The adaptability of acting in dialogue, responding and updating as in conversation, necessitates methodological agnosticism. Further, this approach is *pluralistic* both because the program content evolves for each new group of students and because each item of focus must be approached from many different angles. Adaptability and pluralism are requirements of a humanizing approach, as recognizing the intricacy and the variety and the dynamism in the ways that people relate to their surroundings. Adaptability (methodological agnosticism) and pluralism (counterinduction) are also major features of Feyerabend's philosophy. So we might be able to view this philosophy as a kind of "humanizing science," where we recognize the intricate, dynamic relationships between human scientists and the institution of science, recognize their process of investigation as dialogical - responsive, adaptable - and understand the requirements for operating in this manner in the same light as humanizing pedagogy. That you cannot separate the science from the scientist, that imposing a methodological rulebook is restrictive, that you can't see the flaws of a theory ("thematic universe") from inside of it. Feyerabend's philosophy gives an understanding for the *human* operation in the pursuit of science, and the project of humanization in the wasteland of scientism. Maybe you could fully encapsulate this link between Freire and Feyerabend by recognizing that science is the education of the self. *.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.* Last thing, during the discussion of animal and human production around page 100, Freire made the point that action and production without historical awareness or conscientization are instinctual, and that this type of ahistorical response is *adaptation* of the self, not *transformation* of the world. He also makes the point a few pages earlier that historical action requires awareness of a "not-I" to act on, a world in flux to change. I read this as meaning internal struggles - self help, nirvana, acceptance of god, flow state, whatever - would count as 'ahistorical, instinctual' pursuits. What's interesting is that bell hooks did not completely discard these internal struggles, but considered them a prerequisite for liberatory educators. In the first chapter of Teaching to Transgress she talks about the importance of "self-actualization" for teachers to engage in liberatory pedagogy, as needed to be comfortable relinquishing control in the classroom and being willing to show vulnerability. I'm not sure whether this self-actualization is a historical or personal project, but I wonder what others think. *.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.*.* (all page nums from 30th anniversary edition pdf)

Alfalfafield

I found this chapter a difficult read, and at times I thought it was too nuts-and-bolts particular given how theoretical it was also trying to be, but there were a lot of interesting ideas in here. One that I'm trying to reconcile and adapt to my situation is Friere's conception of the necessary ingredients for dialogue. Near the beginning of the chapter, he lists (at some length) five necessary pre-conditions for true dialogue: love, humility, faith in humankind, hope, and a willingness to engage in critical thinking. I think that all of this makes sense from the perspective of an educator who is attempting to engage dialogically with their students. But what about when you're the person with less structural power in the situation? I've recently had a number of opportunities to meet with various government officials and politicians in my city under the guise of "dialogue" with communities about our local housing crisis. For instance, later today I'm going to a meeting about "community safety concerns" with some politicians and police officers, but I'm not expecting a true dialogue about people's concerns re: eviction, police violence, etc. In reality, "dialogues" like these haven't been meaningful attempts to "name the world" together, and I would argue that they weren't that way by design. People with power frequently come into "dialogues" with strong pre-concieved notions of what people with less power *should* think about the issue, and they try to structure these "dialogues" in such a way that they reach a pre-determined conclusion. This is true in the classroom, as Friere points out, but I think it's true wherever there's a structural power imbalance. As someone engaged in these false "dialogues", what is to be done? Is it best to engage with love, humility, faith, hope, and critical thinking? Or is it better to try to disrupt the dialogues and expose their falseness? Or is it about picking your battles? In the absence of a good-faith interlocutor, how should we approach dialogue?

Warren Shull

I have 3 broad takeaways from this chapter that differ from what others seem to be saying (which I assume I'll agree with most of). I will order them from shortest to longest: 1) My biggest gripe with this chapter is the assumptions Freire makes about non-human animals. I suspect these are widely shared among humans, even those who study animals professionally, but I don't think we can assume that animals cannot conceptualize an idea merely because they cannot *communicate it to us.* 2) At least a couple times in the chapter I was reminded of one of Stephen Covey's 7 habits: "Seek first to understand, then to be understood." This comes through when he says "How can I dialogue if I always project ignorance onto others and never perceive my own?" (p. 90) as well as later on when he concretely describes the adult education process he is advocating (p. 110 onward). In recent years I have become a fan of this quote when it comes to attempting dialogue across large ideological gaps, though I don't get many chances to apply it. I would like to believe that, no matter how far away someone's views are from my own (even in the worst ways), mutual understanding can be reached if we both embody that habit. Unfortunately, few people on any side are good at this, but I'm especially saddened when a progressive refuses to do so. And even outside those tense interactions, I've heard other authors point out that teaching is mostly about *listening*, which Freire also seems to be implying with his prescriptions. I firmly believe this as well and try to embody it as a math professor, though most classrooms are not laid out favorably for this goal. (The author I heard this from is Alfie Kohn, any of whose books would be wonderful for a future book club. I actually read Pedagogy of the Oppressed right after Punished by Rewards in the same college course.) 3) Early in the chapter, when Friere discusses the danger of either action without reflection or reflection without action, I was reminded of a certain famous quote and a less famous response to it. The famous quote is the one from Teddy Roosevelt: "It is not the critic who counts: not the man who points out how the strong man stumbles or where the doer of deeds could have done better. The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood, who strives valiantly, who errs and comes up short again and again, because there is no effort without error or shortcoming, but who knows the great enthusiasms, the great devotions, who spends himself in a worthy cause; who, at the best, knows, in the end, the triumph of high achievement, and who, at the worst, if he fails, at least he fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who knew neither victory nor defeat." One response I read was in Jordan Ellenberg's book "How Not to Be Wrong: The Power of Mathematical Thinking" (which I would HIGHLY recommend for a future book club). Toward the end, Ellenberg brings up the quote and then references some individuals whose critiques made an important difference to the endeavor they were critiquing, and could therefore be viewed as "critics who counted." (A notable example is Abraham Wald. During the war, generals had noticed that some parts of their planes returned with more bullet holes than other parts, and asked "How much more armor do we need on the parts of the plane getting hit more?" He immediately noticed the survivor bias, and advised them to put more armor where there were *fewer* holes, since the planes getting hit there were not the ones coming back. These recommendations were quickly adopted and likely improved the war effort significantly.) Critics who *don't* count because they don't engage in action seem to be the intended targets of Teddy's quote, though reflection seems to consist of directing criticisms at oneself. On the other hand, the generals' initial impulse seems a good example of action without reflection, which Teddy seems to be praising. And it seems Abraham Wald represents a good mix of action and reflection in this example.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

"In the absence of a good-faith interlocutor, how should we approach dialogue?" This is such a powerful question! You proposed disruptiviness and exposing falseness. I think this can actually be a good strategy, but only when it is a collective one. In situations like the ones your are describing "having the numbers' really makes a difference. If the majority of the people in the less-powerful pole aren't with you, being disruptive is usually moot. But there is one general thing I think we can strive towards when we deal with interlocutors who we believe to be in bad faith, which is to expose precisely that aspect of their way of engaging. I think we still have to have love, humility, faith, hope, and critical thinking to do that. Think with me: you have to use your critical thinking to see the situation for what it is and to come up with a way to expose it. You have to hope that your strategy is going to work. You have to have faith in the other people in the room, that they'll keep up with your attempt. You have to have enough humility to maybe realize you are wrong about you reading of the situation (and make that clear from the start). And well, love is underlying all our efforts, right? I wanna share two situations I've been in where this strategy worked. Once, as an undergrad student, I was really unhappy with the person who was teaching a particular class. I believed this person wasn't qualified to ocuppy the position, and besides they would just not show up for half the lectures. When me and my classmates took our complaints to the department, the senior professors tried to brush off our concerns, and some more inflammed students started throwing accusations that the professors didn't care about the quality of our education. They were deeply affronted by such statements, and started defending themselves, telling us all the things they did to ensure we got a good education in under-provided conditions and often to their own personal cost. The meeting rapidally escalated and we were going nowhere -- turns out students had several demands besides that one teacher, and found the meeting was an appropriate place to vent (I think so too, actually, but it wasn't strategic), the professors really didn't want to listen to that at all. When I had the floor, I started with humility: "I don't think I'm the most informed of us all, and I may be speaking out of my place, but please allow me to point out some patterns I think I see emerging from this conversation" then I pointed out that the professors were repeatedly saying things that were all true and appreciated by us, but that did not address the specific issues we were bringing up. I tried my best to calmly expose the situation, narrating what I'd seen in the prior half-hour instead of making my own demands (as most students had been when they had the floor). I made the professors's atitudes seem childish and resented (which they were) and the sudents demands seem reasonable (which they were). I firmly expressed hope that we could resolve the problems through dialogue, but I also pointed that we probably could not solve structural problems in one meeting. But maybe we could solve that one problem with that one teacher in this meeting? I said if the professors were serious about how much they valued our education, and that I believed they were (this was sort of a lie), it would be beneficial to us all to try to come up with a solution, because we were very sure we weren't learning. The thing is: the way I exposed the lack of dialogue totally shifted the atmosphere in the room. Most people, students and teachers, were a little embarrassed. The meeting didn't last long after that, but it was the start of a process that did culminate in the substitution of that one bad teacher, and that also helped us students to organize to make our demands more heard in different ways. I find when you are careful about exposing hipocrisy people tend to pay attention, and the whole process can be aducational. You can start a better, truer dialogue with the other people involved in similar positions to your own, if not with the people who hold power (who are, in this setting, ultimately oppressors ). Now in a different situation, a very recent one: I was convinced the organization I am a part of was intentionally kept in the dark regarding a selection process to participate in a public comittee on public school meals. We are currently part of the comittee, and when the city council announced the renovation of the comittee, we weren't notified. So we lost the chance to apply again and we would not be able to be in the coming mandate, so I was pissed. We are very much unliked by the city council because we fiscalize their budget, you know? We had a meeting just between ourselves to decide on strategy, and some advocated to going straight to superior stances accusing the secretariat of foul play. But we chose to first try and expose the lack of notice as a problem, before we tried more disruptive measures. In our last meeting as parte of the committee I publicly framed the lack of notice as a lack of dialogue, a severe problem in communication and transparency, and just implicitly said that the council was intentionally leaving us out. And... they reacted as if they were baffled that we had not been notified, admited it was a huge mistake, and apologized and found a way for us to keep participating. I really think they tried to get rid of us, but failed.

Rafael Andrade

@aliin I 100% agree about art's potency for revolution and I would say this chapter really helps to know how it does (and sometimes doesn't). Art is revolutionary when it comes with praxis, promoting limit-acts that enables true change. A great Brazilian examples is Chico Buarque, that like Freire also needed to exile himself (even though for a much shorter period). Some of his songs evoke the theme of silence described by Freire, when the government's censorship would tell him to cut some words from his song and he just muted those words instead of recording again without them, or his great ability with wordplay so he could critique the regime without the censors noticing (Like in the music "Cálice", that means Goblet but sounds the same as "Cale-se", that means shut up). This also made me remember 2 documentaries, "Bobi Wine: The People's President", which talks about Bobi Wine's struggles, an Ugandan singer and activist for democracy. The other is "Soundtrack to a Coup d'Etat", that links the actions of several american musicians to the conflicts in Congo as they try to become more democratic while the US and Belgium force their imperial influence over them.

Rafael Andrade

The theme of being marginalized within the working-class I think it's one of the major tensions not just for Freirian works, but to humanism in general (as some Marxists thoughts). I've seen a really interesting critique of Julio Groppa Aquino, a Brazilian Foulcaultian thinker, and he talks how the presumption of being able to dialogue many times is idealistic. The fight against bigotry can't depend on the acceptance of the major group over the minority. Minorities often need to first conquer their rights to live by force so then they can go after acceptance for a more long-term peace. And education is by nature a front line to this struggles, so it can be very blurry to the educator to know how to position himself. In the chapter he uses the example of alcoholism, but we could use a similar example for homophobia. If you follow this approach it could come to normalize homophobia, at the same time, to simple condemn it probably wouldn't have effect. I guess it might be possible to think of a codification that helps to avoid those problems, but it's really hard, even more if we see educators also as overloaded workers.

Rafael Andrade

I love to compare Paulo Freire and Pierre Bourdie to Professor X and Magneto, so I agree that the critique of the Banking theory of education doesn't imply a rejection of education as cultural capital! That being said, it could imply the rejection of scholarization, bc it would be a mean to oppress those that don't come to school with this capital (Not saying that's my position, but I like how it can be provocative). But from the point of view of how to make a Marxist theory and praxis for education it is a huge problem that most (in Brazil, at least) don't quite grasp bc unfortunately people talk a lot of Freire but very few really read him or engage with his ideas.

Rafael Andrade

I got to finish the chapter, but a little later. My real problem was that as soon as I finished it I lost the book and my notes lol. (Later my friends found it on the bus station, so I still have my book but not in time so I could bring my notes here)

Rafael Andrade

I guess the biggest problem with using the therm "wokeness" (besides it making me cringe), is that Freire makes a lot of wordplay with "conscientiz(ação)" because "ação" means action. So to conscientizar would be, for him, something like to move and be moved, and wokeness at best only express the later.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I felt like this chapter has a very idealized idea of the teacher's role in education and society in general. As Rafael Andrade said in a comment: we have to see teachers as workers themselves. I think chapter three is a little blind to that, talking about an 'educator' that is not constrained by circumstances other than the particular group of students s/he faces. On the other hand, this chapter calls upon the ethical and moral duties of someone who comes to be in the position of authority that is teaching. I think Freire is very fortunate with his discussion of codification -- could be a really powerful tool -- but he also puts a little too much stock in it. How can teachers learn to properly 'codify' for/with their audiences? What about classrooms full of people that come from different backgrounds and would come up with radically different codifications? Freire was working in groups of students who were mostly in similar situations, just in a drastically different situation than the teachers themselves. I think it has its place -- when Freire strated writing, schools in Brazil were very very very baking. In the face of people citing Bourdieu in this comment section, discussions regarding "hidden curriculum" come to my mind. Another framework I think can help us grasp this discussion about pedagogy in educational setting such as schools and universities is the Althusserian concept of "ideological state apparatus". The way Freire puts it, education seems almost panaceia for most social ailments. He's walking a fine line of asking teachers to be effective at teaching their assigned subject-matter while also being political agitators. Which, you know, I actually appreciate... Some of the best teacher I has were indeed political agitators. Not all though. But it's obvious that education alone is not a means with which to make a revolution. And thanks for that, because such a stance would mean an instrumentalization of education that doesn't sit well with me. Social change is much more complicated than "teaching right", naturally. And I think (dialogical) education has an instrinsic value independent of any direct results it could produce. I think Freire is proposing some pretty radical ideas about what teaching even is, what it consists in. And he brings up interesting notions about how to best engage with students in real education. His writing can also empower students to think critically about the education they are getting. But I find it important to delimitate what Freire is discussing: "education" as a process, what it is and what it isn't and what it should be. His theories are very prescriptive and thus derive their value of being applied to concrete situations. And in applying them, we find beautiful and powerful experiences, but also several challenges he didn't account for, as 60+ years of attempts show.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

I also want to share with you all that even though I'm Brazilian and my mother tongue is portuguese, this chapter was much easier to read in english. I know Freire is very intentional and stylistic with his word-choice, and this is not supposed to be an easy read, but I still think it's worth sharing. I'll try to go back to the chapter and see if I think something was actually 'lost in translation', or if this apparent reactive simplicity in the translated text is just an artifact of Freire being more convoluted than he had to be (not a crime, but a bit tiring).

Alfalfafield

Thanks for your detailed answer! I absolutely agree that it's contingent, and I really like the idea that approaching dialogue in good faith (with love, hope, etc.) *regardless of the other person's attitude towards the dialogue* is perhaps the best approach.

Alfalfafield

The animal section bothered me SO MUCH. I think it was especially grating because it went on for so long and was basically inessential to his main argument. The point he was trying to make is that humans are capable of reflection, have an awareness of their history, exist in dialectical relationships, etc., and I couldn't see why it was so important to him to try to demonstrate that humans are unique in these respects.

phil e the theyby

Thanks for the thoughts, everyone! @AJ Biffl, I think that interpretation of Freire’s meaning of “irrationality” as believing that reality is rigid and static makes a lot of sense, and seems to broadly align with the text. @Craig I think that what you’re describing as “rational judgements about the world” is actually the very thing I’m reacting to or concerned about, because I think that rationality can (and has been) used to justify basically anything, it just depends on what your initial set of premises are. Whenever I hear someone provide what they describe as a “rational” descriptions of something, I just hear the thing the person preferred on an emotional level (which doesn’t mean it feels GOOD for them; it means that it aligns with their intuitive, emotional sense of “how the world is”) with a post-hoc justification attached to it. A good example of this is the idea of Donald Trump being nominated for the Nobel Peace Prize. This obviously seems absurd to us. But I genuinely believe that Trump (or at least some of the people who admire him) think(s) he is working in the interest of “peace.” It’s just that, for them, “peace” means “countries are no longer officially at war,” and genocide, exploitation, and oppressive domination of non-preferred nations are totally valid (in their eyes) means to that end. Most people here probably see those things as being not peaceful at all, but it’s because we align ourselves with a different concept of what a peaceful world actually looks like. @Rafeal Andrade I’m glad I’m not alone in this concern, and I think labeling Freire as a humanist (with the good and the bad that come with that label) feels like an accurate description. I think the tension you’re describing is a lot of what I try to address in my practical work. I do see dialogue as a necessary part of the process, but I think that people (especially people in dominant groups) are largely unequipped to have that dialogue. My intuitive sense is that addressing and working through the personal psychology of the oppressor class is where I should focus things (especially because I’m someone who largely falls into the oppressor classes), because I think that people who are in that class often don’t realize the spiritual harm that’s being done to them (as Freire beautifully describes, especially in Chapter 1) by aligning themselves with the oppressor class instead of joining in solidarity with the oppressed. Although bias alert: I’m a psychologist, lol. I certainly don’t think individual psychology is the ROOT of these problems or the best angle for everyone to take (as you point out, basic needs and right to live come first and need to be taken by any means necessary), but more where I think I should focus my energy and abilities. Certain books and theories and being targeted in the United States for “making White people feel bad about themselves.” And I think the reality is that White people ALREADY feel bad about themselves. They avoid thinking and talking about things because they don’t like how it makes them feel. I think they(/we, because I’m included in this) need support (from other White people primarily) to work through those feelings, reconnect with their humanity, own the harm we’ve done, and work towards reconciliation and dismantling oppressive systems. Sorry that was a lot of words, lol

Rafael Andrade

Another thing that might make it harder to understand is being the chapter that tries to build a learning theory 60 years ago. I have the impression that old learning theories are overly hard to read bc they try to mimic the "hard sciences" way to describe things and over the decades it stopped being a necessity. Reading Piaget or Vygotsky for example is like hell to me. And maybe by trying to keep his stylistic the translators were a little lighter on the technical terms.

phil e the theyby

I always appreciate your thoughts! It’s interesting because I read this chapter as…not really talking about school at all? I think I might be slightly reinterpreting this in the context of Chapter 4 (which I’ve since reread), but I do think that when I read Chapter 3 last week, I didn’t see it as focusing on school/university teachers. I took Chapter 2 to be the part that was most relevant to more traditional school teachers. As I was reading it, I interpreted the other sections (especially Chapters 3 and 4) to be about the processes revolutionary leaders take in “educating” the masses in the process of political revolution. And in that context, I do think he sees education (developing critical consciousness…the other word he actually uses is hard to type because I’m on my phone :P ) as the most essential part (but not the ONLY part) of revolution, and that REVOLUTION (as a process, not a singular moment) is the thing that will transfer society. I believe his other texts may speak more to more typical educational contexts and may be more applicable, but I can’t say bc I haven’t read them. In that context, I 100% agree with your description of the population Freire seems to have in mind (“students” whose situations are similar to each other’s and very different from the “teachers”). I also think your comments on how we engage with and use the text are spot-on; we need to be aware of its context, take the things that directly apply to our situations, and leave behind or expand on/improve the things that don’t work as well in our current contexts.

phil e the theyby

Oooh, love the Alfie Kohn idea for a future book club! Not sure if it’s up Dr. Fatima’s alley, but there’s a lot of good stuff there. (I’m less familiar with Ellenberg, so can’t comment there) I think that Roosevelt quote is so interesting in that context, because it does feel like this example of action without reflection. But I don’t think it necessarily DOES focus on that; I think “getting in the arena” (in Freire’s view) means being active WITHIN the process of reflection. I do think, while Freire is critical of bull-headedness and just acting without reflection, addressing reflection without action is a bigger and more pressing concern. I think it’s easier to get someone who is passionate enough to be active to build reflective practices into their action, than to get someone who spends WAY too much time reflecting (note: I MAY be talking about myself here) to move towards intentional action, particularly in the age of the internet where “critique” can FEEL like you’re doing something when you’re really not. I’ve recently come to a very firm stance that we need to spend a LOT less energy taking down or criticizing the bad people and the bad systems. There are so many of them that, if we tried to be thorough in our critiques, we would LITERALLY NEVER STOP. So I’m trying to look at all of these things I want to critique and say “Ok, but what am I actually going to do about this?,” and not allowing the answer to be “idk, just feel bad” (that will SOMETIMES be the answer, but it can’t be for EVERY problem). Because I can only control what I do; in most cases, me venting about the things that bother me will not have any meaningful impact on those things, except taking away energy from someone (me) who actually wants them to change. [Also, I just finished reading “The Indigenous People’s History of the United States” by Roxanne Dunbar-Ortiz TODAY, so I have to leave a “Teddy Roosevelt was a genocidal colonizer” comment. Doesn’t mean there’s no merit in engaging with things he said or thought, just needed to mention it]

phil e the theyby

@Not a Lady Maria [is this the best way to @ you? What do you prefer? I feel like I’m gonna be @ing you a lot moving forward, lol] that is an INCREDIBLE reply, and I deeply admire how thoughtful you are about the ways you show up and respond in the spaces you occupy. I think the way I deal with the “lie” you mentioned is that, when I say those sorts of things, I believe they ARE true… for a PART of that person/people. The best, most healed, most supported part of them, freed from the shackles of oppression, budgets, and capitalism, probably actually DOES deeply value your education. Maybe that part of them isn’t particularly visible most of the time because of all the bullshit the aforementioned things give them to deal with (and the bad ideologies that come from being raised in an oppressive world). But I do think there’s a “best self” within everyone that does want the best for other people, even if we don’t get to see it too often. @Alfalfafield I don’t have great examples like that, but I do think that, in addition to maintaining a calm and steady tone and knowing the composition of the room and who’s in your corner, I think turning to the “bad faith actors’” LANGUAGE and LOGIC in your process of disrupting the bullshit is incredibly powerful. If they say the goal of this is to (let’s say) address community safety, keep coming back to the ways the main points make the community unsafe. If you know what they really care about is (let’s say) budget but won’t admit it, weave in the ways that dealing with the real issues is BETTER for the budget, even if they didn’t bring up the budget. However you can, try to send the message that you do (or MIGHT) want the same things THEY want, and have a better way to do it, that doesn’t attack their ego directly (there are times and places where attacking someone’s ego is the most effective strategy, but it sounds like it probably isn’t in what you’re describing). That doesn’t necessarily mean being deferential (often that will be read as “feminine” or “weak” by people in positions of power who view being “masculine” and “strong” as signs of worth…and yes, I know that’s SUPER gross and oppressive), but more sending the message that you understand them and what they want (and you’re not attacking them directly for wanting what they want), and can send a clear message about how to get that. Good luck!!

AJ Biffl

Oh that's a really cool nuance in translation! I'd used "conscientization" as well, but maybe "conscientaction" would be better! conscientizification

Travis

There was a LOT of stuff in this chapter, and as a behaviorist/ethologist of course i have Lots of thoughts about the “human vs animal “ dichotomy. But i think this might actually be the perfect time to bring up what has been a hot debate in my local organizing scene: we don’t need any more rallies [in our city]. If i talk to basically any individual i organize with, they will agree that they are burnt out on rallies. They feel like performance without actually getting people to be involved, an event that folks attend so they can feel like a Good Person. We HAVE done things to make our rallies more engaging— having an open mic portion, and focusing on “action items”. But still, there are constant rallies and constant complaining about the constant rallies …without anyone actually planning something that isnt a rally! And yet it seems terribly difficult to get people to show up to something where we ask them to have agency, to strategize, to make decisions. I try to be optimistic about rallies by seeing them as an opportunity to connect with new people, and i have a goal of talking to at least one new person at every rally. But it gets difficult as i become a more central planning figure. And it gets difficult to put energy into a tactic i dont really believe in. I would rather spend my time power mapping, or canvassing in my neighborhood, or doing a book club with a small group of genuine people who want to learn how to effect change. Less talking at and more talking with.

Dr. Fatima

Tom—I also found the story with the image of the drunk worker super interesting! Having worked in qualitative research, I’ve read a lot about how to design surveys in non-leading ways, but the idea of inquiry methods that use more than just the written word feels very novel and exciting to me Rafael—I’d be so curious to hear what kinds of things are said by the people you mention who talk a lot of Freire but haven’t actually read or engaged with his ideas. I imagine he’s not mainstream enough in the US to have that kind of superficial engagement (at least in my experience of people who cite him), so I’d love to hear the perspective of someone in Brazil

Dr. Fatima

did anyone else clock the uncanny similarity between freiere's necessary elements necessary for dialogue (love, humility, faith, hope, critical thinking) and bell hooks' elements necessary for love (care, commitment, knowledge, responsibility, respect, trust)? they both consider love to be pretty central to pedagogy and influenced eachother a lot so the parallel tracks to some degree, but it's also making me wonder about how the ingredients of successful interactions between humans is mostly the same across literally any context. artistic collaborations come to mind as needing the same things, cohabitation, good work environments... maybe ethically and effectively people-ing is just its own skillset?

AJ Biffl

My bh reading list keeps getting longer... Definitely something to be said that a powerful boon during interaction is acknowledging the messy, nuanced, complex, contradictory, full-ass human on the other side of the conversation - hence hope, critical thinking, humility, respect, trust. Taking in that giant pile of information that that acknowledgement carries is a ton of work - hence commitment, responsibility, faith. Then I think love comes from truly seeing that depth

AJ Biffl

I loved reading this thread, I'm curious after reading the first part of chapter 4 (footnote 5: "Once more, let me repeat that this dialogical encounter cannot take place between antagonists.") whether y'all have more thoughts about dialogue across conflict in the situations Freire's referring to. All conflict has to end in dialogue *eventually* right, I wonder whether Freire's principles or what y'all have talked about can shed some light

Quezacoatl

I think the Che Guevara is kind of cute, especially when you see in later chapters how important Guevara is for Freire's understanding of the radical educator. I read Freire's (and bell hooks) concept of love as a radical acceptence of the humanity of the other, which is a common theme in post ww2 thinking. MLK and Emanuel Levinas coming to mind. It's quite interesting that Guevara, and through that Freire almost apologize for using such a loaded term, but then going all in for it.

Not a Lady Maria, She-Bear of the Global South

@phil e you can call me just Maria. I'm definitely not a *lady*, but lucky for me I identify very deeply with my given name. Love the @-ing game :) this is a conversation after all. I adore the idea you propose about other people's "best self". This alignes quite well with how I see things, but I hadn't been able to articulate my thoughts (and feelings) in such a manner. Reflecting on it, the lie I mentioned was not completely cynical. Maybe when there is no hope for a "best self" hidden in there layers deep under the internalized-oppressor, no dialogue is possible. And in the situation I shared, it was possible. And I believe asking ourselves about this possibility might be a good exercise in deciding if engaging in dialogue will be fruitful. I lean towards the idea that there are times when being too calm and polite might be read as deferential, and I think minority groups (oppressed groups) can't be expected to act like that in most spaces. But when there *is* a chance for dialogue, we can't waste it. Being respectful and hopeful is not the same as being meek or naive.

Christopher Garcia

This chapter lost me a few times I won't lie. It started decently enough, but the tangent on animal behaviors felt at best unnecessary and at worst naive. I understand the attempt at trying to rally humanity behind shared characteristics, but it didn't help trying to counter the behavior of animals in order to do so. After that section, I feel like it devolved quickly in step by step processes that seemed to work against his actual beliefs. He claims that elitism should be rejected, and that one should listen first and foremost, but there's such a cold, sterile tone used to describe it. Perhaps it's translation, but it felt uncanny hearing discussion broken down into a step by step guide, especially with how little example was used to demonstrate it. At times he alluded to moments where this was effective and some topics that may be discussed, but I won't lie this method struggles to appeal to people today. There wasn't enough focus on emotion, in my opinion. He didn't ignore it entirely, at times he stressed its importance, but by the end he seemed more focused on other elements. People rally behind beliefs expressed in podcasts and tiktoks not because these people are listeners (they can't be, they're literally recordings) but because they appeal to their humanity by coming off down to earth and relatable. They do as he notes, providing solutions for problems we all feel even if misguided. It's extremely hard to get people interested in politics outright, and any open forums are often immediately flooded with those who speak as though they have high authority. This is one of those rare instances where'd I'd consider his takes to be a bit too... not optimistic but potentially removed from being plausible.

Yigit

I recently heard adrienne marie brown point out that we have always be sold the need for "critical mass" but what actually moves us is "critical connections." Reading your comment, Travis, makes me see how much the focus on getting people out, getting out the numbers, achieving a majority, all have a flavor of "banking" in it. These efforts assume we want to be "counted" not heard. As for the rallies and what they feel like to me (a reaction to the latest cruelty), Freire writes "We must never merely discourse on the present situation, must never provide the people with programs which have little or nothing to do with their own preoccupations, doubts, hopes, and fears...rather [we are] to dialogue with the people about their view and ours." Simply put, it is more important to CONNECT. And how do we do that? That is what we are doing here, now. You are reading my words on this message board that Dr. Fatima has called into being. We are wondering what love's got to do with all this. I am loving reading about each of your perspectives, and I especially love the glimpses into your lives. Like Travis, your community of rally-goers, or Maria, She-Bear's experience in "problematizing" education in Brazil. I admit this medium is a poor poor replacement for talking to you all in person, and yet I am finding it deeply satisfying to read your words, and think about how I can give something of value to all of us through it.

AJ Biffl

I definitely felt the same aversion to the step-by-step methodology description, but as I realized on a second readthrough it was intended to be a guide for investigating generative themes in a *specific* example situation. Page 110: "Let us say, for example, that a group has the responsibility of coordinating a plan for adult education in a peasant area with a high percentage of illiteracy... Let us here... consider only the investigation of the generative themes." As far as focus on emotion, I don't think Freire's approach is lacking at all. The process of dialogue is angled toward letting people express their own perspectives, which hinges on their lived emotional truths. "Authentic education" is founded on views "impregnated with anxieties, doubts, hopes, or hopelessness" (pg 93). The generative themes are built out of the "complex of ideas, concepts, hopes, doubts, values, and challenges in dialectical interaction with their opposites" that define a historical epoch (pg 101). Unless you mean 'there wasn't enough focus on emotion' as in there wasn't enough of an appeal to an emotional reaction in the people you are trying to educate. I'd agree that this approach couldn't compete in the marketplace of attention-grabbing dopamine hits online today, but I also think purposefully eliciting strong emotional reactions is a form of manipulation, characteristic of antidialogical action as Freire lists in the chapter 4, and is neither necessary nor helpful.

Christopher Garcia

I definitely wouldn't condone utilizing reactionary dialogue prompts, despite how effective they are they do rely often on scapegoating and devaluing nuance. I just wish that the approach described further addressed how to counteract the current culture of turning all potential problems into talking points and taking sides. One of the examples he provided on pg. 118, where he described the way workers sympathized with the drunken man overwhelmed by the system when they likely wouldn't have if they had been asked directly of their alcoholism, did showcase what he believes would be a more productive dialogue. How you can better tackle a problem when people are allowed to express their frustration. But then he never followed through on what the results were. It is one thing to express frustration, it is another to tackle the stigmas against progress themselves. Outsiders of the problem often can't get through to those caught in it because by design the system works to devalue their opinions. The educated, the progressive, they and their methods are demonized. I agree with Freiere that love is essential to dialogue, and that you can't truly connect without kindness. But the system belittles kindness at every turn. Even now, progressives are becoming less and less capable of that forgiveness in the face of true cruelty. I disliked this chapter's approach because in many ways it felt like a guide to appealing to moderates, those who have the time and energy to sit down and talk rationally. Who will reward your patience with some of their own. But most of the oppressed have little of either time or patience. For many, all they have is frustration. I can hear them out, I have more patience than most, but I can't ask that of people who are too exhausted to participate in that model of discussion. I once read a book called Conversations with People Who Hate Me where the author described their experiences trying to start a dialogue with people who would leave hate comments on his online content. He found the experience fairly rewarding, but when he offered other people the opportunity to do the same he was hit with the realization that for many they don't have the space for that empathy anymore. When he was able to get a survivor of SA to speak with one of her haters, by the end she was downtrodden having to relive the same experience of explaining herself in circles to someone who could barely hear her. In the end her hater did eventually come around well after the conversation, but how many times can you try that before you run out of steam? And if you put forth a representative instead, someone to bear the burden of having to hear out people with hate in their hearts, can you truly trust them to know how to speak for you? I just think that he's putting too much stock into conversations based around class and universal human experience and not taking into account enough the way personal identity and beliefs shape individuals.

Tom Cassidy

As to the human/animal thing, it continues in the next chapter, and it has not aged well, because so much recent philosophy has focused on decentering the human. It helps me to remember the importance of the question "am I not a man and a brother?" in the anti slavery movement. For those of us living in the so called Anthropocene, the idealization of the human is a concept worth decentering; I see Friere as trying to extend and apply the promises of humanism (the ability to recognize and collectively work to improve ones situation) to the vast numbers who have been marginalized.

AJ Biffl

@Christopher Garcia so I don't think this chapter was intended to totally answer all those questions about how to apply dialogue. The outline of chapter 4 has a section on "theory of dialogical action and its characteristics," maybe some of those questions will be addressed there. I also do feel your complaint that the discussion feels overly optimistic/implausible at times, ex., affirming that if you open opportunity for dialogue people will actually engage, but I also think that optimism is warranted. I think people do generally like to connect with others and that conversation is rewarding, and having an opportunity to be heard is gratifying and encourages them to speak, and I think that's the hope here, though I do see the concerns about people sometimes just not having the bandwidth. It's similar to what phil e mentioned in a comment below about how marginalized voices within these communities will still be pushed to the side during this sort of dialogue, but I think the appropriate response to these concerns about whether voices will actually engage and be heard isn't to reject dialogue entirely, but to open space for those voices anyway. Maybe by seeking out those voices specifically, and being open and ready to hear them on their terms, on their schedule, when they're ready. As far as stigma, I think you touched on the solution when you talked about the alcohol example, which was that people were more expressive when you can find a way to avoid their stigma. The action of dialogue itself isn't inherently partisan/progressive/intellectual, so you just need to be wary of language that's common lingo of one side or the other, but I think just talking about material conditions isn't a trigger for stigma, and that's all you need to get started.

Christopher Garcia

I can agree that ultimately I might just have to keep reading to see more of what I'm looking for, but I should note I'm not trying to deny optimism. I think if I were to offer a solution to the potential problems with group dialogue it'd be shifting focus to individual dialogue. Take these methods he illustrates and move it to a personal conversation. Address family members, friends, coworkers, people who know and trust you so that you don't have to work past the stigma of an outsider trying to convince you of something you're against. In my experience that's far more effective than group discussion, and can be much less taxing. Someone in a marginalized group has less risk of being spoken over or being burnt out if they only have to appeal to at most a small handful of people rather than a significant portion of a community. And allowing the conversation to incorporate shared identity can help build mutual trust. I just don't think that option was given enough credit in this chapter, and there wasn't enough acknowledgment of the flaws in group dialogue. Also I mainly meant sigmas against those who don't participate in drinking rather than those who do. There is a perception of elitism towards people who don't partake that normalizes substance abuse that I worry is hard to combat even if the struggle of day to day work is eased.

Yigit

AJ Biffl, your question of self-actualization's role in liberatory educators is sparking something for me. I am reading this entire book as a musing on how to "teach" self-actualization. I realize this is paradoxical because it by definition the actualization happens within the self. Freire is again and again emphasizing the same basic challenges, how to have dialogue, with utmost love, with someone who is oppressed and housing the oppressor to such an extent that they are effectively in a trance. In this chapter he emphasizes that if you seek to replace the oppressor's slogans with your own then you have participated in oppressing the oppressed. This hits home for me when I see political memes trotted out as if out-meming a memer is the goal, just like all the billions of dollars in political ad buying is a process of attempting to out-sloganize your opponent. What Freire draws my attention to is how this very same process of sloganizing exists even in very small groups, even in interpersonal relations. I keep wondering how we, here, in the message board, can stay vulnerable, loving, and inviting of dialogue -- true dialogue -- which, as you point out AJ, begins with seeking first to understand eachother. AJ, one other point you made that lit me up is this connection between "humanizing pedagogy" and "humanizing science." I am a former scientist (in the sense that I am not making a living as a researcher at the moment, but I feel like I am still holding on to this identity of 'scientist' for myself). I used to be a professor of robotics, and then I worked in big tech as a manager of other researchers. I eventually found myself disillusioned because the team I was part of was attempting to build an intricately complex technical system but we did not have a culture of deep listening and collaboration that would be needed to create a highly integrated "collaborative" technology. We were seeking to make a piece of technology where all the parts could talk to eachother, sharing information and energy effectively, but we, the people building the parts, were ourselves incapable of sharing dialogue with eachother. It has taken me three years to finally articulate what the problem is, and if I attempt to summarize it in a sentence it would be: "In research, the corporate structure puts the role of the leader as one who must dictate the direction the entire group must go to stay cohesive, but this eliminates the actual process of research which is to pose-problems and the actual process of group formation which is to approach each other in curious, loving, conversation." I am not sure if I am able to communicate here effectively. I think I am trying to connect with you all and belong myself to this group because I find the conversation and insights so delicious.

AJ Biffl

Right, you also mentioned that progressives and intellectuals can be demonized, and that's the stigma I was speaking to. I like the idea of individual dialogue! I've also been thinking about ways that dialogue can be used to overcome conflict and yeah thinking about conversations with family members I disagree with, etc., individual dialogue seems like it could be extremely effective. Bell hooks and Ron Scapp talk about this a bit in Teaching to Transgress Ch 10 in the context of the classroom, about how the larger a group is, actual human connection gets harder and harder - "Even the best, most engaged classroom can fail under the weight of too many people."

Christopher Garcia

Sounds like a good read! I need to dive further into Bell Hooks's catalog. I've read All About Love and The Will to Change so far, but I'm always interested in hearing more about progressive teaching methods. That's something I do appreciate about this book too, I feel education requires much reform that many are hesitant to address so I always value teachers that are willing to do so.

Djoran Keil

There's an experiment being conducted by the ABC Radio National program 'Big Ideas' in Australia around the concept of 'Citizen Juries' (https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/bigideas/can-citizen-juries-put-the-people-back-in-democracy-/105459432). Reading through this chapter I'm struck by a lot of the parallels, especially around the notion that a public should not be led, convinced, or spoken TO, but rather be involved in a co-operative process of respectful and reciprocal dialogue in order for there to be meaningful systemic change for the better. Not saying these juries are a panacea or even intentionally working along or within Freire's pedagogy, as is evidenced by the first followup to the above linked program (https://www.abc.net.au/listen/programs/bigideas/citizen-jury-renewable-energy-zone-rcommunity-nsw/105481136) where it seems that the audience is being spoken about and to rather than on an equal footing with the 'authorities', but rather that there are some similarities in approach and thinking behind them.

Djoran Keil

I think that's very much a 'product of his time' issue. My understanding is that it really wasn't until Peter Singer's book that animal consciousness was mostly considered anything other than basic and reactionary awareness of environment. Hell, it was only in 2012 that we got something approaching a statement of convergent evidence on animal consciousness via the Cambridge Declaration on Consciousness. On a similar note, I definitely started noticing in this chapter Freire's Christianity coming through in some of the phrasing and framing and as far as I know, the separation of 'man' and beast has long been a cornerstone of Christian belief.

phil e the theyby

@Maria I totally agree! I think the idea that dialogue is impossible without that hope for a “best self.” And while I believe that best self underneath all the bullshit definitely always EXISTS, I also recognize that we can’t always access it in the contexts we’re planning to interact with people, especially when those are public spaces. I think that assessment of whether dialogue is possible in each situation is SO critical, just like you said. As your examples show, taking that chance to really lean into dialogue when it actually is possible can have a HUGE impact. I also think the fact that taking opportunities for dialogue is so essential also implies that it’s critically important for all of us to have community and allies wherever we can. Taking that risk of really leaning into dialogue can be incredibly hard. Anyone who have in our corner, either to support us as we speak up or just understand and validate us after we do, makes it VASTLY easier to take those steps.

cyphrsphyr

Chapter 3, Page 88. "Human existence cannot be silent, nor can it be nourished by false words, but only by true words, which men and women transform the world." Page 90. "It must generate other acts of freedom; otherwise, it is not love. Only by abolishing the situation of oppression is it possible to restore the love which that situation made impossible." Page 90. "How can I dialogue if I consider myself a member of the in-group of "pure" men, the owners of truth and knowledge, for whom all non members are "these people" or "the great unwashed." Page 95. "One cannot expect positive results from an educational or political action program which fails to respect the particular view of the world held by the people." Page 108. "The investigation will be most educational when it is most critical and most critical when it voids the narrow outlines of partial or "focalized" views of reality and sticks to the comprehension of total reality. Page 108.Even if the people's thinking is superstitious or naive. It is only as they rethink their assumptions in action that they can change. Producing and acting upon their own ideas- not consuming those of others- must constitute that process. I found these quotes to be a refection of our present state. Whether its our disbelief of broadcasted information, our nonreaction/reaction (investigation). The others, hopefully wll realize; "there is no love in a cult."