Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Last chapter! As usual, comment below to start discussing this chapter, but while you're here, if you want to participate in the live writing session finale for the book, please fill out this when2meet by THIS FRIDAY---I'll make a post that day announcing the day/time and some prep logistics.

For those who are new, the live writing session is where we all get on a google doc at the same time and write prompts/questions/thoughts that we can respond to in real time--it's a little slower than an actual conversation, you have time to think and digest before responding to anything. Looking forward to it!

fatima

Comments

Captain Mikee

I don't think I'll make it in time but after watching the Galileo video I decided I wanted to read the book even if I was late. So I just got my copy last week! Looking forward to the video and hearing everybody's feedback.

AJ Biffl

Really appreciated the extra week to read this chapter. It was gigantic - so much great stuff and overall a hugely inspiring book! We definitely need to read Pedagogy of Freedom. ,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+., I've been thinking a lot about Freire's views on authority as a necessary component of organization, and as a natural shadow to freedom: "There is no freedom without authority, but there is also no authority without freedom. All freedom contains the possibility that under special circumstances (and at different existential levels) it may become authority. Freedom and authority cannot be isolated, but must be considered in relationship to each other" (pg 178). On the chapter one discussion Preethi Basani and Shree Hari Mittal mentioned Andor, and the idea that freedom occurs spontaneously. Every exercise of agency is in some way an act of freedom. Random acts of liberation and resistance occur constantly around the world in situations of oppression. My question to others: does authority also emerge spontaneously? And how does freedom "become" authority? ,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+., Second thing I want to mention, I think I'm narrowing in on what exactly bothers me so much about Freire's human/animal talk. I think he spends so much time on it to emphasize the importance of praxis as opposed to ahistorical activity, which is fair enough. He assumes that only humans are capable of that kind of awareness, and so uses the contrast between humans and animals to illustrate the contrast between the types of action. But then he also says things like this: "while all development is transformation, not all transformation is development. The transformation occurring in a seed which under favorable conditions germinates and sprouts, is not development. In the same way, the transformation of an animal is not development. The transformations of seeds and animals are determined by the species to which they belong; and they occur in a time which does not belong to them, for time belongs to humankind" (pg 161) He seems to be under the impression that were it not for humans, the world would be an unchanging and static landscape; only humans are capable of changing the world at the largest scales. And this is eminently false: the oxygenation of the atmosphere, the covering of the global landmass by green, damming of rivers, overfishing of mountain streams, overgrazing of meadows, are all things carried out by non-human life. Freire's conception of "development" ignores the tendency of life - any living system (probably with many exceptions, but on the whole) - to perpetually grow and consume. Without some limiting influence, life adopts the same grammar of endless growth, accumulation, and control as cancer and capitalist-imperialism. This is something I feel like I've seen several times recently, of people drawing this false contrast between "human development" and "natural development" as if hierarchical society were anything but an extension of the resource-accumulating drive of all life. But I think this actually contributes to Freire's point. The self-interested drive for growth, present in the "development" of western society, is NOT praxis, does not emerge out of an awareness of the historical character of the world and a desire to transform it, but out of simple self-interest, to bend the world toward one's own ends (whether or not that awareness is present). Liberatory action drives against that desire. So I think Freire is ignoring a lot of the real large-scale transformative power of non-human life, and I think the fact that he ignores it actually makes his point weaker. ,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+.,,.+*'*+., (all page nums from 30th anniversary edition pdf)

AlexTheTutor

Freire writes that to exercise freedom implies assuming responsibility, that others must see you as a legitimate person to assume responsibility, and so therefore in this sense, the person exercising freedom does so with authority, and Freire says the converse statement is true (if one has authority, one has freedom), that freedom and authority have a biconditional relationship .. the question now becomes .. is this universally true or true only in certain contexts and if so, which contexts does this relationship not hold? or, do we not accept Freire's claim and believe the relationship of freedom and authority not to be as Freire holds?

Christopher Garcia

Big chapter, but I think ultimately I view this final moment as both an indication of how aware and how limited this piece is when it comes to how one chooses to engage with it. At its core I find the book mostly a summarization of a man's feelings and beliefs based on his experiences and observations. In that regard it's a solid time capsule and a good look into what someone dedicated believes and how some of those beliefs may extend into an even farther radical nature than your own. A way that I wouldn't recommend engaging with this book however, is as a guide to revolution. It's flaws primarily come in the limitation of the language of its author. He speaks to using love and sympathy to synthesize cultures, but often maintains a consistent formal and almost authoritative tone while doing so. Many times I felt as if each paragraph would feature a statement along the lines of "____ is not possible without ____" or "you can not achieve ____ by means of ____". He's aware that direct instruction is not a dialogue, and stresses that dialogue is essential for communal growth, but it doesn't come off like he's really talking to the reader. It feels almost like he's just reassuring himself of this. I don't think this is inherently a flaw, I think it just means the reader needs to observe this far more subjectively than the tone implies. The animal sections to me are the things that illustrate this best. I've seen many others here comment on how much they don't agree with his phrasing of the difference between man and animal, and how even slight observations at how nature interacts would indicate there are similarities that he denies. But he speaks to his stance with the same level of objectivity that he does with most everything he discusses. He's not trying to convince anyone, he's simply stating what he's observed and found to be his truth. In that sense I don't really view this as an example of the dialogue he seeks out, but if anything more as the authoritative instruction that he denounces. But that just might be my interpretation.

AJ Biffl

'summarization of the author's feelings and beliefs based on their experiences and observations' -- isn't that all writing? I do think there is value in writing in an accessible way (and he falls firmly in "academic" territory much of the time, though some of that may be translation), but I think trying to write a book, which is fundamentally a monological medium, in a dialogical way would be dishonest and probably ineffective. So I don't fault him for not saying, "but that's just what I think, dear reader, why don't you go have a think about it yourself?" every paragraph. I know it's just what he thinks, he wrote it.

AJ Biffl

I see the link between freedom and responsibility (autonomy means you are responsible for your own destiny), but I don't see where legitimacy in the eyes of others is a requirement there. I also see that autonomy could be phrased as "authority over the self" but the way he uses "authority" around page 178 (the discussion of Organization, where I quoted) seems to clearly imply authority *over others*, and I don't see how or where such authority actually emerges - Freire seems to merely take it as a given that such authority exists and must be exercised, and in the discussion of how revolutionary leadership is formed (around pg 163), seems to assume that former members of the oppressor class who have 'switched sides' are the ones to exercise it. I have actually noticed a connection fairly recently between responsibility and authority (in a different sense of the word "responsibility") which is that people are given authority over projects when they volunteer to take responsibility for them - but that requires the existence of projects that require (or are assumed to have) leaders, and some larger authority to be granting sole responsibility over those projects. But maybe even without those constructs people claim authority whenever they claim responsibility over a thing? EDIT: and a person gains authority over others when others cede that responsibility to them? EDIT 2: but ceding responsibility may be temporary, or partial, or conditional. Making the leap from 'taking responsibility' to 'having authority' ignores any sort of feedback mechanism where decision-making power is removed. Responsibility is transient.

Christopher Garcia

I wouldn't call that all writing by any means. Persuasive writing by design is meant to flow like it's a conversation often without making explicit acknowledgement of the reader. Information is presented in such a way that it anticipates the likely response you'd have or questions you'd ask and follow up with it right after. The author says something bold, then immediately backs up and addresses complaints or concerns the reader may have. They may use a depressing statistic or story to illustrate the severity of their topic, then follow it up with a lighthearted outcome that came as a result of the change they're arguing for. Data can be presented with mention of any caveats or gaps that the data does not address and whether or not that affects their position in a significant way. That's why I won't say I'm particularly upset that this isn't like that, because I don't think it's trying to be a persuasive text. But that in itself feels odd when by its very nature the subject matter is both considered an extremist opinion by many and also revolves around what it takes to unite people under a cause that they may be hesitant to accept. That's why I think it's best to see it more as just a look into one man's perspective rather than a potential guide for those looking to expand their horizons politically. If I didn't already agree with most of what he's saying, I don't think I'd get very far. Even if someone was primarily interested in his academic style of writing, if they're a Ben Shapiro type who is very direct and intentionally tries to come off as educated in their speech patterns, when they read him bringing up how essential love and human connection is then they'll probably just scoff and dismiss it. And that is what it is, this book isn't for people like that. But who it is for feels like a very specific niche group and not the masses it wants to champion.

RA

Chapter 4 aged extremely well in my opinion! It's so impressive that this book was published in 1968 but he was able to include so many timeless pieces to build his argument. 1. His deep understanding that coloniality ("Antidialogical action") is embodied and unless one replaces it revolutions will falter ("Without a revolutionary theory there can be no revolutionary movement"). 2. His heavy emphasis on action not JUST theory but praxis, antidialogical action (Unity, Cooperation, Organization), etc. 3. Revolutionary leaders must work with adherents to bring them to conscientizaçáo 4. Him deeply understanding various colonial strategies used by oppressors: Cultural Invasion, Manipulation, Divide and rule, Conquest, Weaponizing "liberal democratic" values to oppress. Many people today couldn't list them - despite them STILL being used 5. Him realizing the oppress need a theory/praxis ("Theory of Action") that is a unique , tailor-made solution break free from their oppression 6. Him using this entire book to position educators (whether in a formal school or not) as "revolutionary leaders". capable of using knowledge and practice to foment a revolution. I think this is him being perceptive enough to know that many oppressed people will need intermediaries to an extent and can't go from 0% to 100% by themselves. It's just so astounding to me he gleaned all this before major works on coloniality, or books like "orientalism", major works on phenomenology, or works explaining how financial domination is used by former imperial powers, many proxy wars. Even so, I think he "misses" key points... Right now, up until now we've seen a lot of evidence, IMO, that "antidialogical action" will not ever probably work with the current incumbents, especially those overly invested in the colonial order of things. In the 55+ yrs since this book was written, we've seen attempts at the mutualism that Freire advocates for made by the formerly colonized or enslaved (i.e. global majority) or the no- ruling-elite in global south countries but made little progress in changing the minds of a significant portion of these elite colonial beneficiaries and their coalition. Even now with the accelerated collapse of this system they've built, their behavior is still nearly identical to the antidialogical action Freire enumerates. The oppressed might have to consider other options... Another issue seems to be that Freire lacked the resources to expand his analysis to geopolitical theorizing. It's virtually impossible to understand how former imperial states continue to contribute to under developing the world without mentioning world bank, IMF, US, etc., Lastly, I think he missed the opportunity to go into more details about what TYPE of content should be taught. He talks about seeing the world through the oppressor but doesn't say what it means to not do that. Overall I think the book is a must read for any revolutionary or any educator. There absolutely needs to be a "pedagogy of the oppressed" to move us all toward Conscientizaçáo.

AlexTheTutor

Paulo Freire was born in a house in Recife in 1921, one year later in 1922 in São Paulo many prominent artists hosted Semana de Arte Moderna, a festival not only celebrating modern art, but defining what modern art should be for the Brazilian, the artists wanted to move away from the dominance of European culture and create a distinct Brazilian cultural identity, thus to become an intellectual during this time and place meant to be aware of cultural invasion and embrace cultural synthesis (of the indigenous the rest of Brazil for example), but then in 1929 the great depression spread all over the globe, including Brazil, and as a result Freire’s family had to move to another town, his childhood would be marked by poverty, in particular food insecurity, but eventually through hard work and studying, Freire returns to his birth town to study law, he graduated and passed the bar, but never practiced law, phenomenology and the psychology of language resonated with Freire more, he wants to understand how reality appears to our conscious experience, the study law gives Freire an understanding of the legal power structure that hold society together, but philosophy is a way to understand his own childhood in reference to those global power structures, in 1964 Freire lives in Brasilia working on the National Adult Literacy Plan (many Brazilians during this time could not read, and Freire understands that a pathway to personal freedom is to be able to read, so he took action to make that happen) until the military coup manipulated, divided and ruled the capital and country, soon after he lives in exile in several countries, the first one being Chile in which he develops the ideas in Pedagogy of the Oppressed, and in 1967, he starts writing his book, first published in Spanish, and only later in English and then Portuguese, it was only in 1980 when Freire would return to Brazil, and São Paulo this book in a way is his expression of his life experiences through a first-person perspective but projected in the third-person

Jacques Vincelette

'The oppressed might have to consider other options'. That gives praxis meaning over activisim; of which dialog takes one form. Am I open to feedback and comitted to engaged participation? I remain a succer for good counsel, even under layers of makeup painted in the intimacy back stage.

Jacques Vincelette

Agency holds the heart of Mystery, how human is exeptional or not in this matter. Life expands broadly, certainly. We have cracked the meaning: "for the emerging leaders to acheive authenticity: they must die in order to be reborn through and with the oppressed". My fataly wounded ego demotes me to fisher king.

Jacques Vincelette

"In cultural invasion the actors (who need not even go personally to the invaded culture; increasingly, their action is carried out by technological instruments) superimpose themselves on the people, who are assigned the role of spectators, of objects." This Artificialized Intelligence has been creeping up on us for millenia. I am happy to bear witness with you as we hit the hyperbolic wall. (I hope to see you on the other side with your best songs and dance moves; praxis give us permission to improvise a little, taking each other into account).

Craig

"up until now we've seen a lot of evidence, IMO, that "antidialogical action" will not ever probably work with the current incumbents, especially those overly invested in the colonial order of things" Did you mean dialogical action? I think what we have right now is perfectly encapsulated by the concept of anti-dialogical action, and I think it is exactly why we get reproduction, rather than the transformation Freire was advocating, of the structures of dominance. It all comes down to a lack of critical consciousness, which is the outcome of, primarily, neoliberal education. If children got to 16 and had a developed ability to read the word and the world, we would have a population whose majority were immune to the manipulation required to manufacture consent for the incumbents.

Captain Mikee

I found it tough to get through because of the academic language - he makes a lot of statements that sound abstract and absolute. I remember being taught never to say "I" in an academic essay, with the implication that it sounds less authoritative. And then in recovery, I learned the opposite - I use "I" statements to express my own experience without invalidating that of others. I've found that I _much_ prefer it when people share their personal experiences, over presenting what they've learned as "fact." And speaking in the first person lends itself well to examples rather than abstractions. I'm not against attempting to generalize, but I prefer to start from particulars.

Captain Mikee

I had a lot of trouble understanding what cultural invasion is. Missionaries? Residential boarding schools? Schooling in general? Advertising? Cultural appropriation and commodification of cultures? Mass media in general? Something else? I found the lack of examples frustrating, and it had me wondering if that's just the style in Freire's field, or if maybe we're expected to have a background that already includes the examples.

Yigit

I read this entire book with the phrase "housing the oppressor" ringing in my ears. And the themes of "development" as a contrast to "transformation" or "modernization" were remarkable because it reflects my own frustration with technology. Having worked in a big tech company I saw how much the logic was to provide new technological innovations that were "irresistible" to consumers in order to facilitate uptake, but the value to the company was in gaining a network of users, and all the data that comes with it. This value exchange was not explicit, and the company made no effort to make it known to the users that the exchange was happening in this way. Some of my understanding of this condition comes from the book titled The Age of Surveillance Capitalism, a 2019 book by Shoshana Zuboff. In effect, we, right now, here on the message board, are in a very real sense the oppressed that Feire is writing about. We are not technologically literate. The principles that guide modern tech companies, modern financial technology, and even modern mechanisms of democratic governance are almost entirely illegible to us. The greatest challenge I have experienced in this understanding is that explaining our status as oppressed in this current moment tends to have the opposite effect of what I desire. Instead of "waking up" and becoming motivated to move and learn, the people I talk to become overwhelmed and throw their hands up in frustration, rage, or numbed shoulder-shrugging. I believe now, that my pattern of wanting to educate others about the situation has been, in effect, a kind of "sloganizing" which he warns about in prior chapters. Here, in Chapter 4, Feire points out the importance of "development." I am drawing from page 134 in the Penguin Modern Classics. AJ Biff quoted the section just before the one I am intrigued by. In particular, the phrase that Feire uses that lights me up is "their transformation (development) occurs in their own existential time." Following AJ Biff's comment, I too am curious about what Feire means that "time belongs to humankind." I disagree that Feire is saying that nature is static, but I do believe he is pointing to something existential. It is no mistake he used the phrase "existential time." This is a different kind of time. It is not "clock time" which is the time of technology, factories, or our phones. Feire also draws a distinction from the time of (non-developmental) transformation of seeds germinating, seasons changing, clouds forming and raining. He is referring to something about what it is like to grow as a person. I think back to moments where I experienced an "endless moment" which I knew would be something that would live forever in me. I sat with my father-in-law several times before he died earlier this summer. In one moment, he was awake and relatively lucid (eyes open, wanting to sit up, but unable to form words). He had been completely unresponsive in sleep for the prior three days in the Veterans' home in central Pennsylvania. That day was beautiful and sunny outside, literally just outside the small window of his yellowish concrete room, so I decided to wheel him out with his lunch--a cup of chocolate vitamin-enriched milkshake. We sat outside listening to some of his favorite motown songs ("I Heard It Through The Grapevine", "What Becomes of the Brokenhearted", and "War"). After a few songs, we sat in silence and then noticed the birdsong all around us. All the while, Larry was taking sips of his milkshake and shaking his head while making small noises of contentment and appreciation. When he became agitated, I would just say "There's nothing you need to do. Your wife is on her way. You can just sit and relax. Nothing to do. Nowhere to go." That turned out to be his last meal. He became non-responsive that afternoon. He died the next night. I am surprised that this story is the one I am sharing here, and perhaps it is because I want to convey the nature of the moments in "time" that Feire is pointing to as "existential," as core to the moments of "development" of people. I find these moments in my life as utterly precious moments. They are moments that I grow as a person. Feire is pointing out that such moments are the ones in which the deepest lessons are learned. The lesson of liberation is accessible in such moments. The entire book is like a love song to such moments, and I am deeply grateful each time I find a book like Feire's that presents a new perspective on how to foster the capacity to hold such moments. Ultimately, I see this book as the fieldnotes from a practicioner of holding these moments so that the oppressed people (which is all of us) can breath fresh air and remember what it is like to be free together. I will sign off here with sincere gratitude to all of you who have written and read and responded. And to Dr. Fatima for the inspiration to hold this space. Thank you all! With love and solidarity, Yigit (pronounced "yeet")

cyphrsphyr

Chapter 4 Pg 127. “..merely imagine they have power...sectarian climate…bureaucracies…undermine the revolution. The double slit moment of the housed oppressor. Pg 129. “Denial of communion…in this case the revolution is NOT even carried out for the people, but “by" the people for the leaders: a complete self-negation. The housed oppressor can grasp purchase on the revolution. Pg 181. “Investigation-the first moment of action as cultural synthesis-…there is no true experimentation.” An Inquisitor (investigator) submitting to a smile of pleasure; phase one complete. Minds attained.