Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 542610215.mp4

Downloads

Content

New office hours with the new format! Trying to do this once a month now, if you want to contribute a question for next time you can do so with this form

getting better at this livestream thing, pleasantly surprised at some moments where the chat actually added a good bit to whatever it was I was saying. cool.

Files

Comments

Mohamed E

Thanks for taking the time to answer my question. I appreciate the perspective and optimistic framing. I’ll check that book out!

Mohamed E

And for saying my name correctly :)

AJ Biffl

I appreciate your thoughts as always! I like thinking about the breadth/depth distinction, and I can always get behind a multiplicity of approaches. Thank you for the answer

phil e the theyby

Only partway through the video, but I had the exact thought about “A Third University is Possible” before you talked about it in response to a comment. It’s cool how we come to internalize the ideas from these texts. Since participating in both your book club and in CJ’s, I’m able to call on ideas I’ve read more and cite sources more (even from books I’ve read outside of the book clubs) because these book clubs have me critically engaging with written ideas again, in a way that I honestly haven’t done since undergrad (grad school was a lot more specialized, whereas the kind of reading I do now is much more interconnected and interdisciplinary, closer to my liberal arts undergrad education). I really do love the impact the book club has had on my life, and I’m grateful for you creating that space and selecting such quality texts for us to work through.

AJcheste

Hi, hope your doing well. I think Alex is me. Just checked and noticed, to my embarrassment, that my email on Patreon is my old email I from high school that I rarely use. (Spa*****06@aol.com) And I probably put the email I currently use on the form.(Alex............40@gmail.com) Sorry for the confusion. It was still rad watching this office hours without my question since everyone else's were so cool and your answers enlightening. Thanks for doing these office hours sessions. I can appreciate that they are a lot, but it's kinda rad.

Dr. Fatima

got it, will add your q to the next one!

phil e the theyby

Don’t believe a word I say bc I’ve never made YouTube videos, but I feel like the “responsibility of scientists for bombs” would be a FANTASTIC video topic. It’s so much bigger than just the question of bombs; it’s about the broader responsibility of scientists to their communities, and can attack the broader “depoliticization” of science that only works to serve the interests of existing systems of power. Basically, I think there’s ABSOLUTELY enough there to make something really impactful. It seems like it might be helpful to add “What’s your Patreon username?” to the question submission form. I like a lot of Angela Collier’s videos, but I don’t see them as having any real similarity to yours (other than the fact that you’re progressive women and your work focuses on science). Most of people’s engagement on YouTube is driven by their emotional response to what they’re watching (rather than the words the person is saying). Your videos tend to trigger a lot of thoughtful reflection, and my emotional response to how you present the systems you’re critiquing is more one of sadness or wanting to support and uplift everyone who’s harmed by those systems. Dr. Collier’s discussion of harmful systems tends to lean more into frustration and outrage, so I imagine it attracts an audience that’s drawn to those reactions. In psychoanalytic terms (I don’t even like psychoanalysis, but it’s the best analogy I have), your videos reflect more of the “ego” of progressive scientific thought, while Dr. Collier’s feel like they reflect more of the “id.” Both are valuable and have their place, but they attract different audiences.

Djoran Keil

Some comments, with titles! Lone Genius Myth: I was reminded of how this was subverted in Rogue One: A Star Wars Story where Jyn's father, Galen, knew that anyone could do his job and so he turned the Empire's reliance on the 'lone genius' myth on its head by playing that role to delay the construction of the Death Star and leak the plans to the Rebellion. Parasocial Relation in Science Communication: I love the history of philosophy and the history of the philosophy of science so when the issue of parasocial relations came up, it made me think of how the academy developed across human history. Pretty much every culture has some form of it. An educated figure develops a following and promotes debate amongst students. Plato's academy, salons, universities, whatever form they've taken, there's a sort-of core universality to them. I think a lot of channels like yours are doing something similar. I know, for one, that I very much appreciate how you engage with your audience, especially through Patreon. Barrier to Entry: As someone who never finished high school and hasn't attained any tertiary qualifications, I understand this barrier all too well. But my love of philosophy hasn't stopped me from trying to learn about it. I highly recommend The History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps podcast as a great entry point to philosophy. Understanding the origins and development of theories and implementations is really enlightening and enjoyable.

Michael Roberson

Happy to hear your navigating new spaces and finding your way. Way to go!

David Lindes

33:31 / 33:50 - I'd love to see a "physicists and the ethics of the bomb" video (or whatever you ultimately title it)! Also, 1:04:04, revisiting feminism -- whether in quantum mechanics, or broader physics realms. That was what brought me to your channel! (And Angela's, for that matter. And also, yay for FD, Colormind, tirrb, etc. I watch all of those and more. :)) Anyway, fun Q&A stream; thanks! One minor request: would you be up for leaving the livestreams as "unlisted" on YouTube _at least_ for a while (maybe 24-48 hours)? I ask because I clicked in pretty soon after you started, but rewound to watch from the beginning, and so was watching somewhat delayed, and about half way through, it just cut off, which was a bummer. (Also, I prefer the keyboard shortcuts available on YouTube for controlling playback, so, I prefer watching there. And, it took a bit of time for it to show up here, so I couldn't just load this up right away from the moment when i got cut off. This is basically fine, you don't have to change things if you don't want to, just... letting you know that that was my experience, and making a humble request for a change if you're up for it. Thank you for considering this!

Jacques Vincelette

Working for a nuclear laboratory in northern North America, now run by American military contractors, I was told two weeks ago that "being politically engaged" is reprimandable as "time theft". The "core value" of "integrity" must be framed within our "duty to $hareholders". The arms race brings us back to the heydays of the Manhattan Project. Canada holds the longest undefended border... not pacifists but collaborators. Our new moto: "Foster a culture of compliance." (The share transfer is under investigation by the Canadian Business Bureau, but "there is no alternative", so we march along as sold little soldiers.)