Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Videos

  • 560757678.mp4

Downloads

Content

November office hours episode! I'm enjoying having this be a monthly thing. Ask questions for the next one (including follow ups to any of my answers here) at this link.

Files

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

Faith and fashion fathom their depth in relationship. Pragmatism keeps them real. Modesty lost in the emperor's new clothes.

Tyler Evert

Of the couple of future video ideas you mentioned, I think a deeper examination of DOGE's impact and how to rebuild is the most interesting IMO

Atmosweeper

Thank you for the thoughtful discussion on generative AI use by academics! Indeed, maybe "ethics" wasn't exactly the right word for me to use in posing the question, but in that case your response got exactly to the heart of what I was trying to ask. As an early career academic I'm definitely feeling the pressure to find shortcuts, and I have experienced explicit pressure in certain environments to incorporate generative AI into research and into the classroom. So far I've been resisting this pressure, and your points about needing to *learn* how to write grants and papers — the long way — really resonated with me. I've heard similar points in the context of AI use by students but not in the context of faculty and researcher development. Some of the other ethical issues, like intellectual property theft, privacy, the environment, the elimination of entry-level jobs, and even inheriting/perpetuating the biases of the training data, feel sort of obvious at this point by comparison. It feels taboo even to raise the *possibility* that academics would use AI in certain contexts, and I fear these conversations are simply not being had (at least in my circles). Some journals and funding agencies at least have guidelines now on generative AI usage for manuscripts, grant proposals, and reviewing, but I have yet to see any guidance on what is or isn't acceptable for things like academic job applications or tenure packets. Very few applicants are probably asking HR or search committee chairs for the AI policy — how can you ask when to do so risks arousing suspicion of misconduct or not being a serious scholar?! — but that doesn't mean it's not happening. I completely agree that we may be deluding ourselves if we insist we'll be able to spot it, and maybe tenured academics are *especially* prone to insist on their own infallibility.

Raphaël Royer

beeing nice is not a mathematicaly provable concept, I just know it's right.

Alexandria U

I've been going through the exact same pressure! Thanks for asking the question, it's nice to not feel alone in this.

Alexandria U

Hello, thank you for answering my question. I was the first Alex. I think I'm facing an existential crisis as a black woman scientist. Unfortunately, I cannot divorce my blackness and my gender from the science I do; my identity inherently makes me political. And so I end up having to pretend I'm not black or I'm not a woman in order to get some semblance of respect in my field. And sometimes the act can be exhausting. I just want to be a scientist in an environment that recognizes who I am. I also want science to be a tool used for good in society. I think that if science is treated apolitically, it ends up being either being dismantled by the government or used by the government, for purposes that are imperial. Recognizing science as being political actually saves it as an institution, in my opinion.

Alexandria U

Your answer to the last pateron question makes me feel a bit better haha. My values lie in the realm of every human on Earth deserves the right to live dignified life, right? And so I approach science that way. But the objectionist would argue, "what do the rights of humans have to do with science?" And this viewpoint is exhausting and alienating to be around. Because, as you said, the objectionist standpoint leads to the issue of "stand for nothing, fall for everything".

phil e the theyby

My mind also immediately went to philosophical pragmatism for the last question. Dr. Fatima’s description of it was really solid. I interpreted the person asking the question to focus not only on their own doubt, but also on rhetorical power; that is, you’re much less convincing in an argument when you’re analyzing and questioning the assumptions of everything you say. And while my first thought is, “don’t have arguments, no one ever wins and it just increases polarization,” I do think that a more pragmatic rhetoric strategy (and a better way to engage in discussions with folks who have different perspectives) is, rather than focusing on defending YOUR position, focus on understanding THEIR assumptions. Don’t assume what those assumptions are, and don’t treat the assumptions as stupid. Ask questions to understand how they came to those assumptions. And when you find out the assumptions you don’t agree with, just say that you don’t agree, and why you don’t agree. And who knows? Maybe you’ll actually change or expand how you think by hearing the other person’s perspective. But don’t play the rhetorical game of trying to have the most confidence; try to get to the level of underlying assumptions, because that’s where meaningful attitude change happens (either for the people in the discussion or for other people listening), and that’s where a pragmatic approach is most effective. For example, my understanding is that Jordan Peterson (who brands himself a pragmatist) says that Orthodox Christianity is the most “true” belief and value system because it has had the most cultural influence, dominance, and longevity (essentially, it has thrived and “killed off” or diminished other belief systems’ prevalence), and the fact that it has strayed from its roots and interwoven with neoliberal capitalism isn’t a weakness, it’s a sign of its strength and flexibility. This is because, for JP, the survival and dominance of a cultural value system is the primary measure of its worth. I don’t agree with him; I believe that a cultural value system derives its worth from promoting harmonious and sustainable relationships between all kinds of humans, as well as the non-human natural world. I do not think that a value system that dominates the world and then kills most of the global population and makes it much harder for humans to live on the planet is a “good” value system, even if it is very prevalent and “dominant” for that very short (ecologically speaking) time period that it exists. But I can at least look at what he’s saying, see the assumptions he’s making, and say, “I disagree with these assumptions, and here’s why.”

phil e the theyby

It IS a really exhausting viewpoint to be around, because it’s also deeply dishonest. Like anything we do, science always serves a purpose. Our nervous system is wired to either care for those around us (particularly when we are calm and regulated) and/or to care for ourselves and our own needs (particularly when we’re stressed or threatened). But how to scientists decide what to focus their work on, and what assumptions they’re working from? If they deny their responsibility to broader human needs, then the motivation and focus of their work will always be (on a neurological level) serving THEMSELVES. In the best-case scenario, this is benign (just study what you naturally think is cool and interesting), but more often, it tends to serve people’s needs for status and resources (usually money). And who confers status and resources? It’s almost always people who already have power within the system. Uncritical science almost always works to serve the status quo, and most people who are doing so don’t realize they’re doing it, because they won’t acknowledge how their own basic human needs are making it very easy for those in power to manipulate them into studying the things they do and working from harmful assumptions.