"Technologies of Humility", Chunk 1: "The Perils of Prediction" and "The Post-War Social Contract" (Patreon)
Content
in doing "journal club" rather than just "book club" for the first time, I want to give a little support on reading academic papers for those who don't have experience, so i present to you:
dr. fatima's top tips for reading papers
annotate! marking up a text while you're reading it keeps you more actively engaged and gives you good notes for later. my standard annotation scheme is three colors of highlighter/pen: one for key points, one for questions i have, and one for references that i want to look up later. you might want to mark up different categories (e.g., things you didn't understand, or things that connect to another text) but just start annotating and see what feels good for you
speaking of not understand things, there will absolutely be chunks of text you read that will not absorb the first time through (or maybe even a few times through). If a section is especially hard to get through, just keep going---sometimes it'll make more sense in the context of what comes next, and you can always loop back around later to give it another shot with more overarching knowledge of the text
write summaries after you've read. whenever i do research for a video, i have an annotated bibliography that's just a running list of all the sources I read with a paragraph or two summarizing it written immediately after reading. it's a good habit for research, but also it's just a good learning practice to synthesize what you've absorbed. you could do this at the end of the whole paper, or a little synopsis of each of our "chunks", or each section, or even a one sentence sum up of each paragraph
the comments of these posts are usually jsut for discussing the text, but in this case, feel free to ask/share about challenges of reading an academic text and I'll support where I can
~~~~
All that said, I'm just going to share one note from my annotations, marked next to the very first paragraph. For context, I read at least a dozen journal papers on technocracy while researching my last video, and one of the starkest divisions in that set was the difference between pre-big tech and post-big tech. Reading the opening paragraph of this paper, where the technological concerns for our society are space shuttle explosions and nuclear plant meltdowns, the absence of tech is sooo loud. it almost feel quaint. that's how all the pre-big tech papers read to me, while anything written after 2013 or so basically equated technocracy with silicon valley. it's interesting because the idea of technocracy is still relevant in more spheres than tech, but the tech one is so new and impactful and tied up in the biggest power structures that it makes sense to give it so much attention.
that said, this Jasanoff paper (from 2003) still feels very relevant, so i'm curious to see what connections yall might make to post-big tech issues
happy reading!