Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

in doing "journal club" rather than just "book club" for the first time, I want to give a little support on reading academic papers for those who don't have experience, so i present to you:

dr. fatima's top tips for reading papers

  1. annotate! marking up a text while you're reading it keeps you more actively engaged and gives you good notes for later. my standard annotation scheme is three colors of highlighter/pen: one for key points, one for questions i have, and one for references that i want to look up later. you might want to mark up different categories (e.g., things you didn't understand, or things that connect to another text) but just start annotating and see what feels good for you

  2. speaking of not understand things, there will absolutely be chunks of text you read that will not absorb the first time through (or maybe even a few times through). If a section is especially hard to get through, just keep going---sometimes it'll make more sense in the context of what comes next, and you can always loop back around later to give it another shot with more overarching knowledge of the text

  3. write summaries after you've read. whenever i do research for a video, i have an annotated bibliography that's just a running list of all the sources I read with a paragraph or two summarizing it written immediately after reading. it's a good habit for research, but also it's just a good learning practice to synthesize what you've absorbed. you could do this at the end of the whole paper, or a little synopsis of each of our "chunks", or each section, or even a one sentence sum up of each paragraph

the comments of these posts are usually jsut for discussing the text, but in this case, feel free to ask/share about challenges of reading an academic text and I'll support where I can

~~~~

All that said, I'm just going to share one note from my annotations, marked next to the very first paragraph. For context, I read at least a dozen journal papers on technocracy while researching my last video, and one of the starkest divisions in that set was the difference between pre-big tech and post-big tech. Reading the opening paragraph of this paper, where the technological concerns for our society are space shuttle explosions and nuclear plant meltdowns, the absence of tech is sooo loud. it almost feel quaint. that's how all the pre-big tech papers read to me, while anything written after 2013 or so basically equated technocracy with silicon valley. it's interesting because the idea of technocracy is still relevant in more spheres than tech, but the tech one is so new and impactful and tied up in the biggest power structures that it makes sense to give it so much attention.

that said, this Jasanoff paper (from 2003) still feels very relevant, so i'm curious to see what connections yall might make to post-big tech issues

happy reading!

Comments

Excrubulent

Hey, I'm new here so sorry if I'm missing something, but is the paper and the note that you're going to share coming up in a future post? I don't see anything attached to this post. Thanks!

Craig

I understood the note as the identification of this paper as a "pre-big tech" (pre 2013) example that has an absence of reference to the current concerns society has about the implications of "big tech" across multiple domains of life. The paper itself is in a prior post, or searchable on google scholar - jasanoff 2003 TECHNOLOGIES OF HUMILITY : CITIZEN PARTICIPATION IN GOVERNING SCIENCE

Craig

I made a bunch of notes in these sections as it was quite provocative (probably unintentionally). I'll just mention a few of what I think are quite important, if a little tangential to the actual paper. (1) "Scientific and technical advances bring unquestioned benefits, but they also generate new uncertainties and failures, with the result that doubt continually undermines knowledge, and unforeseen consequences confound faith in progress." The less that people understand scientific methods and how knowledge is formed, the more enhanced the conditions are for doubt and loss of trust to influence beliefs. Education policy has eroded that understanding since the neoliberal coup in the late 70s. (2) Defeat in war similarly endangers the powerful along with the disempowered. This is borderline offensive. From a cursory search, it looks like you have to go back to 1718 to find a European example of a monarch or high power individual losing their life in war. We could arguably include the Tsars in that, but you get the picture. Exposure to and experience of the dangers of war are overwhelmingly weighted to the poor and disempowered, even in defeat. (3) "[Risk] is part of the modern human condition, woven into the very fabric of progress." On the one hand this could just be a fairly benign truism. But on the other, it seems like apologism for capitalism. The modern human condition is just to be taken for granted as is, and the risks for humans is just an inevitable fact of the matter. One topical risk that comes to mind is the collection of nanoplastics in our brains. "Is it sufficient, for instance, to assess technology’s consequences, or must we also seek to evaluate its aims? How should we act when the values of scientific inquiry appear to conflict with other fundamental social values?" And rather than simply accepting that inevitability, the answer, I'd argue, is always to aim for maximal development of the scientific literacy necessary for people to make their own evaluations and understand others. This ought to be the foundation of democracy.

Jackbkwiq

I'm excited to chat about this paper! I've found it easy to digest so far. I agree with Dr. Fatima that the disasters caused by technology they refer to at the start seem quaint in contrast with the risks being taken (and harm being done) today. They do a good job of laying out exactly what question they're trying to address, and why those questions are important. - "Will some of our most revolutionary technologies increase inequality, promote violence, threaten cultures, or harm the environment? And are our institutions, whether national or supranational, up to the task of governing our dizzying technological capabilities?" It feels obvious to me that yeah, most of the revolutionary technologies were obviously going to be used to further intrench Power, at least in so far as Power had the ability to direct their use. Similarly, I think the authors are pointing to the fact that as they exist, the institutions in place were not designed with a goal of governing our technological capabilities. They were created to mitigate the risks their creators were exposed to, either by insulating those in power against much of that risk, or by directing the consequences of risk taking onto those without power. "...regulatory science, produced to support governmental efforts to guard against risk, was fundamentally different from research driven by scientists’ collective curiosity." This really clearly demonstrates how the goals of science can have huge implications for the discoveries of any particular endeavor. It's all science to me, but it seems clear to me that there should be a science of "the goals of science", which would include but not be limited to scientific ethics. It sounds like that is what this "Science of Humility" is going to try to achieve.

schlltchrn

Hm... I found some points in these few pages to be... strange. Like talking about 9/11, it sounds like it was a failed engine or some other random accident of a technological system, like any other mentioned event. Then she is taking it as an example that "rich people die in such occasions the exact same way, undiscriminated, like poor people. This is also the case in a war", I agree with Craig below, is offensive really. Obviously, poor people die MUCH more in any war. Also, nobody thinks that if they are technologically advanced, they cannot die in a terrorist attack. So I don't understand the reference in this context. The only way for me to understand it as relevant is to discuss in the context of our scientific and technological advances and our consequent dependence on oil and the whole geopolitical thing of it, but it is a controversial topic. "The European Union’s 2001 White Paper on Governance drew on the activities of a working group on ‘Democratizing Expertise’, whose report promised new guidelines ‘on the collection and use of expert advice in the Commission to provide for the accountability, plurality and integrity of the expertise used’." Another thought that I had is how the risk assessment is a very broad term. For example, the EU assesses a risk regarding a technological development very differently when the regulation influences people outside its borders. In the past decade or so, more and more people are buying electric cars in the EU, which is how this new technology is good really. However, getting the lithium needed for the batteries, in the quantities that the market needs to satisfy the demand, since everybody wants the environmentally friendly gadget, is incredibly bad for the environment. It can poison a lot of fresh water, make the soil unusable for agriculture for decades, it displaces many people etc. So the EU forbids this kind of mines in its own borders, however, makes it an official strategic priority to get the lithium from other countries, and cause all these horrible things to happen in its neo-colonies. This is the case for any kind of raw materials needed for the new technology, or research in general. So basically "democratizing expertise" for the technological progress sounds like a utopian pretend play, since the countries that are not in the EU, but financially and politically dependent on it, are not ever a part of this democracy, where any number of experts decide on their lives.

Jackbkwiq

Re: your second quote/note I get what you're saying, but that wasn't how I read that part. I saw it as more of an acknowledgement that war, particularly *defeat* in war, has a particular ability to penetrate the bubbles in which the rich and powerful insulate themselves. I don't think they're necessarily arguing that the nature and degree of suffering amongst powerful vs. disempowered people during war are similar or equivalent. The next sentence further clarifies that in many (i'd argue most) other contexts, "vulnerability remains closely tied to socio-economic circumstances, so that inequalities persist in the ability of social groups and individuals to defend themselves against risk.", and I'd take that to include the risks of going to war in the first place, which I agree fall mostly on the poor folks who end up doing the actual fighting.

schlltchrn

I also understood it the way that Craig describes. Even a defeat in a war, while it may penetrate in more powerful structures, still does so in a limited extent, and a very discriminating way. Especially as this sentence follows the explanation how the collapse of the World Trade Center did not discriminate between corporate executives and restaurant workers. In my opinion, both examples are wild.

Excrubulent

Ah okay, so that paragraph is paraphrasing the note rather than quoting it, I see. I just wasn't sure, thanks!

personhood for pigeons

It's interesting reading this paper in conjunction with a paper I'm rereading, "The Challenges of Participatory Administration" by Sharon Jacobs. Jacobs describes the challenges of "democratizing" regulatory agencies through public participation, when those agencies have goals that can compete with democratic participation (goals like expertise, or ensuring agency decisions aren't arbitrary). Jacobs presents alternatives to participation, like focusing public pressure on passing laws, creating public advocate offices, or creating stakeholder groups to set broader agency policies. I have mixed feelings on Jacobs's article and proposals, but it does highlight the competing values inherent to regulators. I feel like I need the full picture of what Jasanoff is arguing to properly synthesize both articles. My initial thought is the extent to which the "framework of accountability" that Jasanoff presents can reconcile the competing interests of scientific institutions. Such competing interests include the "public good" aspects the Jacobs describes for regulators (democracy, expertise, non-arbitrariness) but also for interests present in science that don't advance social progress - money, prestige, and power (including advancing structures of power like racism and sexism). Looking forward to reading the rest.

Jonas Ladefoged Holm

I did a fun drawing to summarize the journal.. How would I post that?

Craig

Grim reality, but well said nonetheless. For me it's a reminder that it is not and never has been the electorate who run states, and neither is it any shadowy cabal, but rather it is the supranational corporations and the owners of their stock - executives, institutions, funds - who are dictating everything. Borders are for electorates, physically, and conceptually. They keep electorates siloed and limit both their physical movement and their thinking.

Craig

Interesting comment. I always come back to the point that what creates the challenges in the first place is a lack of adequate education that develops scientific literacy.

phil e the theyby

Other folks have touched on some of the more specific points made, but I want to try to keep my focus on what seems to be the central thesis here, which is a call for building the infrastructure for critical analysis of the consequences of our technologies and their effects, starting with a historical look at the belief systems that led to the historical moment in scientific thought at the time the paper was written. The picture I'm getting is that there initially seemed to be clear, hard boundaries between "basic" and "applied" research, and that we could trust that basic research would in time translate to measurable benefits. Peer review and independence were taken as trustworthy paths for the reliable production of research that's beneficial for society. Jasanoff then paints the picture that cases of fraud shook that trust in peer review as a process. This point was particularly interesting to me: "At the same time, observers began questioning whether the established categories of basic and applied research held much meaning in a world where the production and uses of science were densely connected to each other, as well as to larger social and political consequences." (229) I took this to mean that, essentially, "there's no such thing as basic research"; that is, all research was so intimately connected to the proposed outcomes and so tied to its funding sources (even within universities) that ALL research was tied to the intended "applied outcomes." I also took the "social and political consequences" piece to mean that the political interests and goals of funding sources (whether that be universities, government, or industry) were increasingly recognized as having an influence on the research process, thus breaking the illusion of free, "basic," "curiosity-driven" research that exists independently of outside influences. And while I'm not sure I can track the historical accuracy of the claim that folks became increasingly aware of those dynamics, I DO think that, to the extent that this is true, Jasanoff is describing the breaking down of an illusion of "scientific independence and objectivity." Folks can no longer credibly claim that science is unbiased and non-political (obviously people still do to this day, but there's a lot more skepticism towards this idea), so it leaves us in a position of having to figure out how science is supposed to interact with our politics. This seems to be the point of the paper, so I'm all about it. Regarding Craig's point around the erosion of scientific education, I'd say the point is true, but I don't think it's actually a main driving force in the shifts Jasanoff is describing. If I'm understanding the argument of this part of the paper accurately, the distrust comes from social events revealing fundamental contradictions that always existed within our scientific systems: that even relatively "independent" research still isn't free from "bias" or a political agenda, because science is always guided by human subjectivity. So while I do agree that there's been an intentional effort by a certain wing of the American Republic Party to undermine the credibility and cultural impact of scientific research that's independent of industry and the military, I believe that the lie inherent in our previous (and sometimes still current) narrative about science -- that science CAN be fully independent from human and social factors -- can and did reveal itself independent of that conservative effort.

AJ Biffl

I like you mentioning that "no such thing as basic research" is tied to funding sources! I think you're right: I think there ARE genuinely 'basic' (decoupled from utility) scientific questions, but any and all active researchers ALWAYS frame their research as having some "use" for purposes of securing funding and attention

AJ Biffl

This essay is screaming in my ear. It makes me think of a quote from The Prestige (which is apparently a misquote of poet Robert Browning), "man's reach exceeds his grasp." To me it's always meant that our ability to create new and shocking horrors will always outpace our ability to handle them - we are simply not prepared, because we don't know them yet. (Apparently the original quote is "Man's reach should exceed his grasp, or what's a heaven for?" which is a complete 180 lmao) But I've been thinking about Jasanoff's point in this vein, that our tech was outpacing our regulatory reach, and that still rings extremely true to me, despite the fact capital-T Tech isn't mentioned explicitly. The "normative questions that were sidelined in celebrating the benefits of technological progress" (226-227) definitely brings to mind the millions of lives chucked into the teeth of social media and now AI. It's also interesting that she seems to be leading up to some of the same points Feyerabend made about needing increased state control of science... I didn't make this connection on first reading, but Craig and Lidija made really good points elsewhere about how hierarchical privilege *does* meaningfully divert the consequences of catastrophes away from the rich and powerful. I think Jasanoff was trying to make the point that no amount of social privilege can fully protect against sufficiently great catastrophes (I'm reading "Seveneves" by Neal Stephenson right now, which feels relevant to mention here as a good story where this would be relevant), but the reality is that the greater our reach as a society, the greater our ability to shield the rich and powerful from harm (I'm about halfway through reading "Seveneves" by Neal Stephenson right now, and some stuff just happened that also feels relevant to mention right here). There's a non-negotiable part of "progress" that says that the rich and powerful are first in line to exploit whatever new toys get invented. I also just watched Veritasium's new video on criticality and risk and that feels relevant. "The House of Lords Select Committee on Science and Technology in Britain issued a report on science and society that began with the ominous observation that relations between the two had reached a critical phase" (pg 227). Propagatory systems reach criticality under the condition that their propagation is limited by (near-)vanishingly-rare catastrophic failure modes. I doubt this is exactly what the British Whatevers meant by "critical phase" but I think it applies. I also took issue with Jasanoff's focus on "accountability." It feels like they're wanting a higher level of care-taking and thoughtfulness to ensure humanistic tech and associated policy, but "accountability" sounds like it implies a central authority which is responsible for distributing punishments if those measures to ensure humanization fail. There's a quote a few paragraphs later that maybe partially breaks from that enforcement-oriented framing, but only partially: "Accountability can be defined in different ways, depending on the nature and context of scientific activity – for example, in demands for precaution in environmental assessments, or in calls for bioethical guidelines in relation to new genetic technologies" (pg 226). The latter "bioethical guidelines" seems enforcement-oriented, but the former "precaution" may not be.

River

I had to look up "Mode 1" and "Mode 2" framework for science in society. I wasn't aware of the terms and had to look them up to understand. I am returning to academics after a 6 year break and am trying to re-familiarize myself with academic writing. That is why I appreciate this club so much !!!!! I looked up Jasanoff and was thrilled to know she has done some work on the Bengali language!!! I have to look them up for sure............ This paper is relevant to me right now. For me, the biggest concern of present-day tech is how innocuous and cutesy-looking platforms like tiktok is aiding terrorism. I think biotechnology, and social media is probably the two most prominent areas that need emergency regulation. I do not have any social media account other than Facebook (which I rarely use). I work in education, and some recent events have encouraged me to use social media a bit more to understand my students. And , what I can see from my non-scientific, random use of it, is that it heavily favors extremism. It targets kids and the future generation. The funding into regulations in social media is a curuios case to look into.