"Technologies of Humility", Chunk 2: "Science in Society - New Assessments" and "The Participatory Turn" (Patreon)
Content
(a quick note: i'm seeing that patreon has blocked some comments from last weeks post, idk why, they look fine, I'm trying to fix it this week to not do that...)
alright, week 2! gonna try something a little different here (dont mind me constantly iterating on this format) and give some thoughts on your comments from the last chunk before sharing my note for this one:
to speak just to confusion Lidija and p.m.pilgrim expressed as to why the opening examples include both technical accidents like Chernobyl and motivated actions like 9/11: I think it's that both illustrate the limitations of prediction and control of risk in highly complex systems enabled by science/technology. Whether accidental or intentional, they're both negative and unintended consequence made possible by some advancement (nuclear physics/aeronautic engineering) . I might also add that that risk existing isn't the problem, so much as how that risk is negotiated. While I understand Craig's suspicion at designating harmful side-effects as an inevitable fact of science that justifies exploitation, I'd add that the inevitability of risk in the application of science is analogous to (or maybe even an outcome of) the inevitability of uncertainty in the knowledge-building of science: it's always gonna be there in some amount, so we should remain aware of/reflexive to that reality rather than think we can control/transcend it. Like AJ said, "our ability to create new and shocking horrors will always outpace our ability to handle them"---i'd just add that I think Jasanoff's thinking through how we can improve our responsiveness and democratic-ness in handling them.
ok, now for this weeks text. if the first reading was establishing the problem of risk in scientific modernity, this reading is looking at how some have attempted to address it (curious how it will connect to the paper you referenced, 'personhood for pigeons'). Something that stood out to me in this reading that I didn't think twice about first time around was this paragraph towards the end of the chunk:
"The Monsanto Company’s experience with the ‘Terminator gene’ suggests that political activists may seize control of decisions on their own terms, unless governance structures provide for more deliberative participation. In this case, the mere possibility that a powerful multinational corporation might acquire technology to deprive poor farmers of their rights, galvanized an activist organization – Rural Advancement Foundation International (RAFI) – to launch an effective worldwide campaign against the technology. Through a combination of inspired media tactics (including naming the technology after a popular science-fiction movie) and strategic alliance-building (for example, with the Rockefeller Foundation), RAFI forced Monsanto to back down from this particular product. The episode can be read as a case of popular technology assessment, in a context where official processes failed to deliver the level of accountability desired by the public."
Did anyone else's head go to anti-AI organizing efforts when reading this? Maybe my minds just here bc of the AI discourse stuff I was talking about in the last office hours, but the roll out of gen-AI is certainly a case where governance structures aren't providing deliberative participation to some exploitative tech, and there's definitely a clear desire in some section of the public to push back on it. Makes me want to look into RAFI and also what modern equivalents might be taking shape in our current tech landscape--I know about organizing efforts against the construction of data centers in various cities, but I'm curious if anyon'e heard of other organized campaigns that are going on?
happy reading, and looking forward to hearing your thoughts!