Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Last part of the paper! I've been most curious to see what people think of this final section, as it was the part I referred to most heavily in my video.

As we've done in past reading club sessions, I want to gauge interest in a collaborative live writing session to finish off this paper. For new participants, whenever we've finished a book/essay, we've set an hour long block of time to all join the same google doc where we collectively respond to prompts we came up with about the reading, simulating a closer-to-real-time conversation and also making a cool document artifact with our thoughts that other patreon members can check out after the fact. I've only hosted these when we've had a critical mass of participants, so if you're interested in joining, please fill out this when2meet before next Wednesday Dec 24. If we get enough people I'll announce the date/time that day, and we'll have our little writing time. Otherwise we'll just call it a wrap after this discussion post, and I'll announce the next reading that we'll start in the new year (I've already picked it out and am quite excited to read it!)

Alright, go ahead and leave your thoughts on the last part of the paper, looking forward to reading what you have to share!

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

On distribution: "The term ‘ethics’, moreover, does not cover the whole range of social and economic realignments that accompany major technological changes, nor their distributive consequences". "The enormous growth and success of science and technology during the last century has created contradictions for institutions of governance. " We gladly sadly handoff burden to our proverbial ghost fawn: "AECL acknowledges with gratitude that our Sites are situated on territories that have since time immemorial been the traditional lands of Indigenous Peoples in Canada. We deeply appreciate their historic connection to these lands, while recognizing Elders and Knowledge Keepers, past, present and future. We recognize that we still have much to learn and that reconciliation is an ongoing process for us all." [https://www.aecl.ca/wp-content/uploads/2025/06/CNL-Statement-of-Work-2025.pdf]

AJ Biffl

I resonated with a ton of her ideas in here! And really appreciated how concrete she made this framework of 'technologies of humility' to address the hurdles she pointed out in the first few sections. I did think the "distribution" section was a little lacking. Although maybe I was wanting to think about the "who benefits" question from a 'power-corrupts' angle where we ask if people proposing policy have ulterior motives, whereas the actual paragraph seemed to mostly be about the need to consider the consequences of actions (which may have some overlap with the "vulnerability" section). Looking back at the technocracy video, your interpretation was a combination of consequences and connivery which I like ("who gains power and profit from this innovation, and who bears the burden?"). But I wish SJ had gone into more depth here. The descriptions and examples she gave in some of the other sections were so visceral and illuminating -+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+-+=+- Thinking about the paper as a whole in the context you talked about in the technocracy video, about helping transition from mechanical to social thought processes in general, not just in shaping policy, was super helpful! I greatly appreciate the ideological underpinning of 'technologies of humility' over 'technologies of hubris'. This was an awesome read! (also some whiffs of Against Method in there! alas still I live with the Feyerabend Fever)

Emiel

Something that really stood out to me is how in the Framing paragraph the author very matter-of-factly throws in curbing population growth as an example of policy goal, as though it's something we all clearly want but we still disagree on the best methods. Would love to know more about the historical context, was there a scientific or political consensus about this in 2003?

Eric Mills

[Edit: I keep hitting enter while trying to start a new paragraph, sorry for all the edits] Finishing this article, I'm struck by how we have not only failed to build Jasanoff's technologies of humility in the 22 years since this article was published, but the foundations on which Jasanoff proposes to build those technologies have themselves been undermined. Jasanoff operates with the idea that the apparatus of state control over scientific knowledge production --- the NSF for basic research, the NIH for biomedical research, a bevy of federal regulatory agencies such as the EPA to direct the regulatory research discussed --- is flawed in its ability to deliver accountability to the public, but could be given new frameworks (her technologies of humility) in order to be more accountable and better able to handle uncertainty and the recognition that the deployment of knowledge must necessarily have a political dimension. What Jasanoff does not anticipate, but what has become very relevant in the past few years, is the possibility that political actors could capture the apparatus of state control over scientific research for their own ends. And unfortunately, with the second Trump administration in the United States, that is exactly where we are. It's a trend that has been a long time in coming --- for a 2010 discussion of earlier efforts by industry and political groups to use participatory avenues of science to benefit powerful corporations at the expense of the public's ability to understand the consensus results, see *Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming*, 2010, by Oreskes and Conway --- but the trend has reached new levels with the second Trump administration and the explicit takeover of US scientific funding and regulatory bodies by political actors who are openly admitting that they intend to use their positions to push particular views on vaccines, climate change, and industrial regulation. So one big issue I see here is that, after 2025, the scientific community will not see greater public participation in deciding the direction of scientific research as a good thing; or to the extent that there was always a component of the scientific community who thought this, that component will be larger than ever. The question of, "how do we implement technologies of humility in the bodies setting US scientific policy" has become "are the bodies setting US scientific policy even salvageable?" Outside of the US, Jasanoff barely mentions China --- her other example of scientific policy making is European bodies. That made sense in 2003, but in the time since then China has multiplied its scientific output to the point where it is now the largest producer of scientific research by a number of metrics. This is another area that challenges the fundamentals that Jasanoff assumes. In an increasingly globalized scientific community, Chinese policy matters, even to scientists working in the United States and Europe. And, similar to the situation in the US, the increasingly dominant position of China in the world scientific community calls into question whether state direction of science is a good thing with regard to public accountability and participation. So my final thought on all this is that we are left wondering if the institutions we have are even feasible allies of a movement to increase the accountability and effectiveness of science in promoting the good of all, even the most vulnerable.