"Agnotology" Essay #6: “West Indian Abortifacients and the Making of Ignorance”, by Londa Sheinbinger (Patreon)
Content
*NOTE: I changed the choice of essays we'll read in the coming weeks from when I first made the schedule post for this book---next week's reading is Essay 10 - “White Ignorance"
~~~~~
I found this essay to be as interesting as it was upsetting. First, the interesting:
"The curious history of Merian's peacock flower shows, then, how voyagers selectively culled nature for knowledge responding to state policies, patterns of patronage and trade, and moral and professional imperatives. Gender politics both in Europe and its colonies gave recognizable contours to distinctive bodies of knowledge and of ignorance. The same forces feeding the explosion of knowledge we commonly associate with the scientific revolution and global expansion led to an implosion of knowledge of herbal abortifacients"
On the side of interesting, I think it's such a fantastic example of what I'm trying to get at in this video---how the social constructedness of scientific knowledge can be leveraged as a tool of power to suppress just as much as it can be to create. The examples that I usually hear cited to illustrate the significance of science's constructed nature are things like military interests driving the development of weapons or surveillance interests driving the development of AI---the making of new knowledge to exert control over people. But what I think is a lot subtler is the inverse, like we see here with the suppression of knowledge that could empower ppl who can become pregnant , thereby exerting control over them. Again, I have a main case study in mind that 'll be examining in the video, but I wonder if anyone else has examples of this latter kind of power via construction of scientific ignorance.
~~~~~
As for the upsetting (not to say the previous point isn't also upsetting, but whatever):
"European awareness of antifertility agents declined over the course of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries largely because the development and testing of such agents did not become part of academic medicine or pharmacology in the eighteenth century. Many drugs no doubt were dangerous because they were not submitted to rigorous and systematic testing. The notorious hazards of abortion in the twentieth century must be traced partly to this process of forgetting and failure to test."
I have this very particular kind of rage I get when I read something about history that shows how timeless the oppression of women is. Whether it's reading a poem of a woman lamenting the normalness of sexual violence thousands of years ago or learning that the modern supression of reproductive rights in the west can be traced back to a need to control enslaved women in europe's colonial heyday, there's just this sense of like, will this ALWAYS be a problem??? I don't want to go too rant too hard rn, but it was hard for me to read this essay and not be overcome with a sense of hopelessness. Obviously there have been advances (and regressions...still hard to believe the US is post-roe v wade), and I can remind myself of the contributions of women throughout history who have gotten us to where we are today to help myself stay committed to the struggle, but goddamn sometimes it just feels like humanity will never kick this whole patriarchy thing.
hate to end on a downer note but such is life sometimes 🙃