Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

*NOTE: I changed the choice of essays we'll read in the coming weeks from when I first made the schedule post for this book---next week's reading is Essay 10 - “White Ignorance"

~~~~~

I found this essay to be as interesting as it was upsetting. First, the interesting:

"The curious history of Merian's peacock flower shows, then, how voyagers selectively culled nature for knowledge responding to state policies, patterns of patronage and trade, and moral and professional imperatives. Gender politics both in Europe and its colonies gave recognizable contours to distinctive bodies of knowledge and of ignorance. The same forces feeding the explosion of knowledge we commonly associate with the scientific revolution and global expansion led to an implosion of knowledge of herbal abortifacients"

On the side of interesting, I think it's such a fantastic example of what I'm trying to get at in this video---how the social constructedness of scientific knowledge can be leveraged as a tool of power to suppress just as much as it can be to create. The examples that I usually hear cited to illustrate the significance of science's constructed nature are things like military interests driving the development of weapons or surveillance interests driving the development of AI---the making of new knowledge to exert control over people. But what I think is a lot subtler is the inverse, like we see here with the suppression of knowledge that could empower ppl who can become pregnant , thereby exerting control over them. Again, I have a main case study in mind that 'll be examining in the video, but I wonder if anyone else has examples of this latter kind of power via construction of scientific ignorance.

~~~~~

As for the upsetting (not to say the previous point isn't also upsetting, but whatever):

"European awareness of antifertility agents declined over the course of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries largely because the development and testing of such agents did not become part of academic medicine or pharmacology in the eighteenth century. Many drugs no doubt were dangerous because they were not submitted to rigorous and systematic testing. The notorious hazards of abortion in the twentieth century must be traced partly to this process of forgetting and failure to test."

I have this very particular kind of rage I get when I read something about history that shows how timeless the oppression of women is. Whether it's reading a poem of a woman lamenting the normalness of sexual violence thousands of years ago or learning that the modern supression of reproductive rights in the west can be traced back to a need to control enslaved women in europe's colonial heyday, there's just this sense of like, will this ALWAYS be a problem??? I don't want to go too rant too hard rn, but it was hard for me to read this essay and not be overcome with a sense of hopelessness. Obviously there have been advances (and regressions...still hard to believe the US is post-roe v wade), and I can remind myself of the contributions of women throughout history who have gotten us to where we are today to help myself stay committed to the struggle, but goddamn sometimes it just feels like humanity will never kick this whole patriarchy thing.

hate to end on a downer note but such is life sometimes 🙃

Comments

Anthony Perez Eisenbarth

What Schiebinger documents is genuinely enraging: the deliberate non-cultivation of knowledge that could have spared generations of women suffering and death, knowledge that existed, that was observed and recorded by European naturalists, and that was nonetheless allowed to "languish increasingly in rumor and innuendo." That this continues to reverberate into the present (as Schiebinger notes, "the notorious hazards of abortion in the twentieth century must be traced partly to this process of forgetting") only compounds the outrage. What is really striking about Schiebinger's analysis to me, however, is its reluctance to engage with the structural dimensions of the ignorance it so carefully documents. The chapter lists contributing factors (the male composition of colonial enterprises, mercantilist population policies, the professionalization of obstetrics) without synthesizing these into a coherent theory of how power operates through knowledge production. In other words, the analysis remains descriptive rather than explanatory; it catalogues the conditions of possibility for this ignorance without theorizing the social totality in which these conditions cohere. This chapter doesn't fully theorize how the suppression sits at the precise intersection of capitalism and patriarchy. Enslaved women using abortifacients to refuse reproduction weren't just exercising "reproductive choice" in some liberal sense: they were withdrawing their reproductive labor from a system that literally commodified their children. The suppression of this knowledge served both the accumulation logic of the slave economy (you need enslaved women to reproduce the labor force) and patriarchal control (men governing women's reproduction). The Humboldt passage is actually the most theoretically important moment in the chapter, and Schiebinger somewhat undersells it. Humboldt knew the abortifacients were safe and effective; he acknowledged that European women needed them; and he deliberately chose not to transmit the knowledge because he feared it would harm population growth and led to "depravity of manners." This is power exercising itself as knowledge-suppression, but Schiebinger presents it almost journalistically rather than analyzing it as a paradigmatic instance of how Enlightenment science functioned as an apparatus of biopolitical control. Some examples that come to my mind about selective ignorance: • The tobacco industry's decades-long manufacturing of doubt about carcinogenicity (Proctor's other major case study, actually) • Similarly, the oil industry’s knowledge of climate change • The non-investigation of environmental illness in working-class and POC communities (what some call "undone science") I think your rage at the “timelessness" of patriarchal violence is understandable and justified, but there's a risk in that framing: it can naturalize what is actually the result of a historical process. The Humboldt passage is instructive here: he didn't suppress that knowledge because men have always sought to control women and their bodies. He did it because he was worried about population decline in a mercantilist framework where human bodies were national resources. That's not timeless; that's a specific political economy. If patriarchal control of reproduction is eternal and essential to human nature, then yes, despair makes sense. But if (as Federici argues in Caliban and the Witch) the violent suppression of women's reproductive knowledge was a specific historical project tied to primitive accumulation, the need to produce labor power for capital, and the commodification of enslaved people's children, then it's contingent. It emerged under particular conditions and could be dismantled under different ones.

personhood for pigeons

Dr. Fatima, to answer your question, the thing that comes to mind is generational knowledge that is suppressed or not passed due to trauma and fear, or maybe hopes of assimilation. Think immigrant parents who don't tell their children where they came from or what life was like in their home country, or don't teach their native language or dialect. This can also include traditional medicines, knowledge pathways, etc. For my own example, some of my ancestors (who were Jewish) fled Russia during the period of the pogroms, but my family doesn't know from what town, or any of their names, or even what specifically caused them to flee. This relates to the critique that Anthony Perez Eisenbarth raises above - the author doesn't examine structural dimensions of power in this agnotology case study. To expand on Eisenbarth's analysis, I was struck by the role Catholicism and its ideologies play in suppressing Afro-indigenous sharing of knowledge. Catholicism is so omnipresent in the Caribbean, Central and South America that the author presents peacock flower's medicinal value as suppressed today (or at least in 2008, the time of the article). This knowledge is taught seemingly in secret and with an associated risk of divulging it with outsiders. On attribution and framing - I wonder to what we can attribute this kind of knowledge loss, i.e. of the colonized, the victims of chattel slavery, and of the racialized immigrants. Is it suppressing trauma? Seeking assimilation? Fear of retribution for falling to assimilate? Can that knowledge even be translated into the dominant language? I bet research into how languages die would be fruitful in answering that sort of question. Glad I caught this discussion on time! Interesting read, if tough subject matter-wise and a not my preferred writing style.

Jacques Vincelette

On ‘fantastic example’, I apologise treading on women’s medicine. I tiptoe in recognition of my grandmothers, of my mother, of my five biological sisters, of my wife, of our daughter. The factors that influence the gender of our progeny remain sensitive information dismissed as old wives tales. Worst, under French Canadian/métis traditions, church used this insight for shame and misogyny. Sons were paraded as “children of duty” while daughters were shunned as “children of pleasure”. The beautiful poetry: empowered women aware of their cycle rise and raise their chance of carrying daughters.

AJ Biffl

Other comments mentioned the large scale structural & ideological roots to the cultural generation of ignorance here, but I was actually struck by how tangible and direct and personal this ignorance generation was. People who would otherwise be in positions to transfer this knowledge back to Europe either ignored it or deliberately decided not to pass it on, either because they just didn't care about this type of knowledge or because they thought it unseemly. Individual cultural perspectives on how much they care about women's health and how they expect women to conduct themselves were first in their mind. I'm still debating about whether or not a structural analysis is even helpful here. Colonial mercantilism surely contributed to these cultural attitudes, but it doesn't uniquely create them. The precise mix of patriarchal control and dehumanization can come from many different places, and fighting modern day capitalism doesn't intrinsically dispel them.

Zindagigi

This is really interesting! A similar situation is the knowledge of abortion science in Traditional Tibetan Medicine. A friend who is a Tibetan doctor told me that a lot of older medical texts contain recipes and explanations for how to induce abortion but when medical institutions moved into Nepal and India they received more direct oversight from the religious leadership and teaching abortion basically was banned. This also resulted in loss of certain other skills related to women's health, with the result that this area of medical treatment is handed over to western-style doctors, more. I meant to ask if a similar situation is found for those institutions that remained in China--TTM is not as centralized there, I think, and I imagine there has been a decoupling from religion under Communism.