"Agnotology" Essay #10: “White Ignorance”, by Charles W. Mills (Patreon)
Content
our last essay! before getting into my thoughts, I wanted to check in on how we can conclude this book. in the past we do collaborative live writing sessions, where we all get on the same google doc at the same time, give each other prompts based on the reading, and then spend an hour responding to each others prompts/responses. We could certainly do that again, but i had the idea for something different: since there are so many essay we didn't get to, I thought we might do a live writing session, but instead of it being about what we all already read, we have each person read one of the essays we DIDN'T get to, write a synopsis, and then in the live hour time we can ask questions about/share thoughts on each other's synopsis---kinda like getting a taste of the rest of the essays without having to read all of them. If this sounds like something you'd participate in, fill out this when2meet so we can find a time. and if you want to participate but just want to do our normal live writing session, idk leave a comment saying so? i'll announce what we'll do next week based on feedback.
~~~
first off, love a Feyerabend mention if for no other reason than the sense of intellectual world building i get from the explicit connections between things we've read in book club (even if the mention is to position this text under different premises lol)
but more seriously, there was one passage towards the end of this essay that. had me reflecting most about our current moment:
In Adam Hochschild's chilling book on King Leopold II's regime of rubber and extermination, which resulted in the deaths of 10 million people in the Belgian Congo in the 1890s-1900s, the final chapter is titled "The Great Forgetting". Through the systematic destruction of state archives in Brussels---"the furnaces burned for eight days"---and the deliberate non-commemoration of the African victims--"in none of the Brussels Royal Museum of Central Africans twenty large exhibition galleries is there the slightest hint that millions of Congolese met unnatural deaths"---a "deliberate forgetting" as an "active deed" was achieved, a purging of official memory so thorough and efficient that a Belgian Ambassador to West Africa in the 1970s was astonished by the "slander" on his country in a Liberian newspaper's passing reference to the genocide....Similarly, and closer to home, James Loewen's critical study of the silences and misrepresentations of standard American history textbooks points out that "The Indian-white wars that dominated our history from 1622-1815 and were of considerable importance until 1890 have disappeared from our national memory," encouraging a "feel-good history for whites": "By downplaying the Indian wars, our textbooks help us forget that we wrestled the continent from Native Americans.
so obviously "history is written by the victors" is so often said it feels almost trite, but reading about the ways in which victors have rewritten history hits different when you can see the government re-writing reality in real time. There are so many examples I can think of of the Trump administration just erasing knowledge and rewriting narratives: the CDC website was scrubbed of information about vaccines and STIs, scientific institutions like NASA and NIST took down resources on DEI and anti-harassment policies, the Department of Justice removed pages on research like a study showing that citizens commit more crime than undocumented immigrants. There is in fact a whole wikipedia page dedicated to tracking information the the government has taken down in the last year, which I'm so grateful for, because at least we can know what they're trying to hide from us.
I've been thinking about these kinds of efforts a lot recently, and this passage had me wondering, how effective will they be? Like, is this scrubbing of government resources going to function like King Leopold burning government archivevs for 8 days? It's hard to make the comparison confidently--on the one hand there are obvious similarities, but on the other, the ecosystem and means of recording/sharing information is so different now. At this exact moment, most of the resources that the government is taking down are being tracked, but is that enough to prevent longer lasting ramifications?
It also reminds me of an effort I've seen by activists to archive the genocide in Gaza---given the immense suppression from mainstream media, it is a legitimately valuable thing to just document what has been happening for posterity. These kinds of efforts feel increasingly important in a moment when the government is suppressing information (not to say anything of generating misinformation...), and I'm just so curious how these battles for writing history will play out from here. I want to be optimistic---removing anything entirely from the internet feels like an uphill battle. But I also don't want to pretend like what's happened in the past isn't completely possible to happen again, just because it's happening in modern mediums. scary shit