Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

our last essay! before getting into my thoughts, I wanted to check in on how we can conclude this book. in the past we do collaborative live writing sessions, where we all get on the same google doc at the same time, give each other prompts based on the reading, and then spend an hour responding to each others prompts/responses. We could certainly do that again, but i had the idea for something different: since there are so many essay we didn't get to, I thought we might do a live writing session, but instead of it being about what we all already read, we have each person read one of the essays we DIDN'T get to, write a synopsis, and then in the live hour time we can ask questions about/share thoughts on each other's synopsis---kinda like getting a taste of the rest of the essays without having to read all of them. If this sounds like something you'd participate in, fill out this when2meet so we can find a time. and if you want to participate but just want to do our normal live writing session, idk leave a comment saying so? i'll announce what we'll do next week based on feedback.

~~~

first off, love a Feyerabend mention if for no other reason than the sense of intellectual world building i get from the explicit connections between things we've read in book club (even if the mention is to position this text under different premises lol)

but more seriously, there was one passage towards the end of this essay that. had me reflecting most about our current moment:

In Adam Hochschild's chilling book on King Leopold II's regime of rubber and extermination, which resulted in the deaths of 10 million people in the Belgian Congo in the 1890s-1900s, the final chapter is titled "The Great Forgetting". Through the systematic destruction of state archives in Brussels---"the furnaces burned for eight days"---and the deliberate non-commemoration of the African victims--"in none of the Brussels Royal Museum of Central Africans twenty large exhibition galleries is there the slightest hint that millions of Congolese met unnatural deaths"---a "deliberate forgetting" as an "active deed" was achieved, a purging of official memory so thorough and efficient that a Belgian Ambassador to West Africa in the 1970s was astonished by the "slander" on his country in a Liberian newspaper's passing reference to the genocide....Similarly, and closer to home, James Loewen's critical study of the silences and misrepresentations of standard American history textbooks points out that "The Indian-white wars that dominated our history from 1622-1815 and were of considerable importance until 1890 have disappeared from our national memory," encouraging a "feel-good history for whites": "By downplaying the Indian wars, our textbooks help us forget that we wrestled the continent from Native Americans.

so obviously "history is written by the victors" is so often said it feels almost trite, but reading about the ways in which victors have rewritten history hits different when you can see the government re-writing reality in real time. There are so many examples I can think of of the Trump administration just erasing knowledge and rewriting narratives: the CDC website was scrubbed of information about vaccines and STIs, scientific institutions like NASA and NIST took down resources on DEI and anti-harassment policies, the Department of Justice removed pages on research like a study showing that citizens commit more crime than undocumented immigrants. There is in fact a whole wikipedia page dedicated to tracking information the the government has taken down in the last year, which I'm so grateful for, because at least we can know what they're trying to hide from us.

I've been thinking about these kinds of efforts a lot recently, and this passage had me wondering, how effective will they be? Like, is this scrubbing of government resources going to function like King Leopold burning government archivevs for 8 days? It's hard to make the comparison confidently--on the one hand there are obvious similarities, but on the other, the ecosystem and means of recording/sharing information is so different now. At this exact moment, most of the resources that the government is taking down are being tracked, but is that enough to prevent longer lasting ramifications?

It also reminds me of an effort I've seen by activists to archive the genocide in Gaza---given the immense suppression from mainstream media, it is a legitimately valuable thing to just document what has been happening for posterity. These kinds of efforts feel increasingly important in a moment when the government is suppressing information (not to say anything of generating misinformation...), and I'm just so curious how these battles for writing history will play out from here. I want to be optimistic---removing anything entirely from the internet feels like an uphill battle. But I also don't want to pretend like what's happened in the past isn't completely possible to happen again, just because it's happening in modern mediums. scary shit

Comments

Paul Z

Hell, yeah. Agnotology is a study that I’ve had to deal a lot with in the research I’ve been doing for my book on the moral philosophy of authoritarianism. I’m looking forward to your video.

Anthony Perez Eisenbarth

I like the proposed format for wrapping up. I'd be into reading one of the essays we skipped and doing the synopsis exchange. Of all the chapters we've read so far this one resonated the most with me, both theoretically and personally. Mills quotes Jefferson's "merciless Indian Savages" from the Declaration of Independence and traces how that category made it possible to speak of "empty" lands teeming with millions of people, of "discovering" countries whose inhabitants already existed. I'm Lakota and an enrolled member of Standing Rock, so this isn't abstract for me. I grew up inside the gap between what Mills calls the "guiding conceptual array" and the reality it overwrites. The countless broken treaties, impoverishment and economic isolation in reservations; there is a reason Hitler admired what white Americans did to the indigenous people of the land. The fact that the murderers at Wounded Knee were given Medals of Honor for slaughtering women and children doesn't weigh on white Americans' minds. And if you asked them they probably never heard of it. Hegseth's comments on this were almost a kind of double consciousness, "We honor their service, and we will never forget what they did." The truth is, white America has forgotten what it did and actively resists relearning what it did and why it was done. For most of my life I had only my mother's last name, Eisenbarth. And I grew up in what is now a MAGA stronghold in Eastern Oregon where the white teachers and kids were routinely unable to reconcile brown skin with a name more suited to a Midwestern football coach. That inability to reconcile is itself a small instance of what Mills is describing: the conceptual array has no place for it, so it just becomes a source of confusion rather than an opportunity to revise the framework. The section on testimony is where it gets really concrete. Mills describes how nonwhite testimony is structurally discredited; how black and brown counter-testimony is "epistemically ghettoized" even when it made it into respectable venues. I experienced a version of this firsthand. I was once a research assistant at a progressive economics think tank: the kind of place where you could propose working papers and op-eds. During the DAPL protests at Standing Rock, I wrote an op-ed about the potential economic and environmental impact of the pipeline on top of the brazen violations of treaties my people signed with the United States government. It was never published. I pushed several times, to no avail. That was one of the moments that really drove me to leaving academia. This wasn't some reactionary outfit. Mills is very precise in his fourth clarification that white ignorance operates through "impersonal social-structural causation, which may be operative even if the cognizer in question is not racist." My colleagues weren't hostile to Indigenous people. But the institutional logic (what counts as a legible economic argument, whose testimony registers as expertise rather than advocacy, what topics feel like they belong in a policy shop's portfolio) all of that is shaped by exactly the white normativity Mills describes. The conceptual apparatus determines what's visible as a serious knowledge claim before any individual even makes a decision about it. The connection to the current moment really resonates, and I think the Leopold/Loewen passage you pulled is one of the most powerful in the essay. Watching the CDC get scrubbed, DOJ studies disappeared, is seeing that echo in real time. But I want to pick up the thread that's been rattling around in my head most, which is the Roediger material: the "wages of whiteness" argument Mills borrows from Du Bois via Roediger. What Mills does there is really crucial and I think it actually undergirds everything you're describing: the forgetting isn't just imposed from above, it's motivated from below. Mills moves from the analytic philosophy literature on individual self-deception to a structural account of group-level motivated irrationality, and what makes it post-Marxian rather than straightforwardly "Marxist" is that the "interest" driving the distortion isn't reducible to class position. Roediger's whole project was showing how the white working class chose racial identification over class solidarity; that whiteness itself functioned as a compensatory wage, a psychic and material investment that made accurate cognition about the social order against your perceived interest. And that logic of identification with the dominating structure doesn't stop at the color line. It doesn't really surprise me that so many ICE agents are Latino, especially Alex Pretti's killers. The compensatory wage is available to anyone willing to collect it. This is where the question about effectiveness gets really interesting. Because if Mills is right that white ignorance isn't just a top-down propaganda project but is structurally incentivized, if people are motivated to not-know because knowing would threaten their position in the racial hierarchy, then the question isn't just "can the internet preserve the archives" (it probably can), it's "does the availability of information matter" when the motivated irrationality is still operative? The Tulsa massacre wasn't unknown because the evidence was perfectly destroyed (Ed Wheeler found the photos, the survivors were alive) it was unknown because white Tulsans and white Americans needed it to be unknown. The supply-side account of ignorance (they destroyed the archives, they control the textbooks) has to be supplemented with a demand-side account (there is a constituency for not-knowing). I think about my DAPL op-ed through this lens too. The demand for that particular knowledge simply didn't exist in that space, because integrating it would have meant reckoning with the ongoing structure of settler colonialism in a way that disrupted the institution's self-understanding as already progressive, already on the right side. This doesn't make me pessimistic exactly, but it does make me think the archival efforts (documenting the atrocities in Gaza, tracking ICE deportations) are necessary but not sufficient. The harder problem is the one Mills identifies through Kinder and Sanders: that the perception of zero-sum group competition generates the cognitive distortions. We can't just make the information available; we have to disrupt the interest structure that makes ignorance feel rational. scary shit indeed

Kurt Mendez

It truly takes an artist's hand to strike our hearts and make us remember the most difficult truths. But obviously, challenging art is for the brave. And since despots are invariably cowardly senseless creatures, artists can hide truths in plain sight and then laugh about it later. Think of Nikolai Gogol's Dead Souls. Or even the movie Django Unchained.

AJ Biffl

There's so much in this chapter. I went on sort of a tangent spiral about the bit about how "whites tend not to see themselves in racial terms," and some related thoughts I've been having about my whiteness and white culture in the last year or so. I've also re-written this comment a bunch of times because I keep wanting to say things differently. I think I've reached a point where I can finally articulate my thoughts. I think that white (western hegemonic) culture is fundamentally different in character from nonwhite cultures after its long history of colonization, conquest, and bloodshed. (I should also express at the beginning that it's possible I'm fundamentally misunderstanding or romanticizing or misinterpreting nonwhite cultures as an outsider looking in, and people feel similar ways about other cultures as well - I'd love to hear) In Pedagogy of the Oppressed, Freire talks about how playing the role of oppressor dehumanizes the oppressor class, and I think in parallel white culture has been "de-cultured" by playing the role of dominator/oppressor for so long. During its history of conquest and destruction, hegemonic western culture has subsumed and destroyed a number of distinct cultural traditions. The lack of continuity with prior cultural heritages leaves the people living there now cut off from a past beyond the cultural leviathan which now exists. I personally have no feelings of connection to the history of my ancestors, connection to any community (beyond my immediate family) or place (I literally don't know where my family lived more than a few generations ago). The traditions and celebrations and beliefs that I grew up with feel hollow and soulless, centered around consuming and purchasing, constructs of modern western hegemony and not the vibrant, natural interactive processes I usually associate with "culture." On a reading a while back someone used the word "necrophilic" to describe western hegemonic culture, and I agree with that wording. I think that its necrophilic character (its willingness to use violence, its insistence that it must kill in order to survive, the way it positions itself to thrive as a result of that killing), sets it apart (and I don't know whether its necrophilia is a coping mechanism to justify its domination or if a necrophilic tendency in its beginnings encouraged its destructive behaviors later - chicken or egg?). The soulless, violent, necrophilic nature alienates and dehumanizes even its own people, the people who live within the walls of hegemony, and its cultural standing becomes invisible because it is constituted by the fabric of the social hierarchy. Those outside of that hierarchy experience a continuity of cultural identity in contrast to the leviathan - easier to recognize and infuriating to try to point out to those within the walls. I don't have an answer to Mills about whether that ignorance is inadvertent or willing based on racial interest, but it's so difficult to talk about hegemonic culture and any other culture on the same footing because hegemonic culture is on fundamentally different footing - it is the destroyer.

AJ Biffl

Also, to be clear, I don't think white culture is the only one that has been pave-paradise-and-put-up-a-parking-lot'ed. I think it's happening everywhere Edit here because the last edit to the above is the longest version of that comment yet: European cultures were the first to become subsumed by the leviathan, but think about also displaced African slaves who were taken from their homes, families broken apart for generations, their cultural heritage deliberately shattered and scattered across the continent, and who have been forced to rebuild a cultural identity in the new world. Think also about American Indians whose cultures were systematically destroyed or who were "re-educated" to assimilate to the leviathan.

AJ Biffl

The line "the mystification of the past underwrites a mystification of the present" also jumped out at me. Reminds me of Freire's "mythicization," a tool of oppressors "precluding any presentation of the world as a problem and showing it rather as a fixed entity, as something given — something to which people, as mere spectators, must adapt."

Jacques Vincelette

Thank-you for the Joni Mitchel reference, my second favorite in the flesh mythical Canadian mystic (after Margaret Atwood). The digitization of lives and cultures happens everywhere given the outreach of mass markets and embargo on other ways of life. Necrophilia denies life agency and reduces beauty to commodity. Deepak Chopra and John of god endorse the Freudian slip as "God is a construct but your girls are real." We lose the landscape behind our own erection. "This is HUGE!" Mills points out in point six: "Moreover, the social dimension of epistemology is obviously most salient here, since individuals do not in general make up these categories themselves, but inherit them from their cultural milieu. "The influence of social factors begins at birth, for language is not reinvented by each individual in social isolation, nor could it be. Because language acquisition is socially mediated, the concepts we acquire are themselves socially mediated from the very beginning." As meaning is established through relationship, the Cartesian reduction "I think therefore I am" collapses in isolation. This cultural wound of isolation predates Descartes with long lineages of elite's commodification of the Mystery of Life in all beauty and sorrows.

personhood for pigeons

This line struck me: "the dynamic role of white group interests needs to be recognized and acknowledged as a central causal factor in generating and sustaining white ignorance." This reminds me of concept first described by the Critical Race Theory writer Derrick Bell of "interest convergence." Interest Convergence posits that the political gains of minoritized peoples happen when their demands align with the interests of the dominant (white) group. Bell claims that the 1954 Brown v. Board of Education decision (desegregating schools) occurred because the US had an interest in its outcome - Communism was becoming popular globally, and the USSR and other communist nations criticized American apartheid as a reason to avoid the country's racial capitalism. The harms of segregation only became acknowledged by the highest court because outside interests pushed it there. Further, the white ignorance of segregation continued after Brown v. Board, since the solution of bussing Black children to white schools did not improve education outcomes for Black children - good Black teachers were fired, and Black children were exposed to many white children's racialized violence. The white ignorance continues today - Brown v. Board is taught as the end of school segregation, but segregation continues and by some measures, has increased. Today, I see interest convergence chipping away at the white ignorance surrounding immigration. But mirroring the limited and ineffectual desegregation of schools, I fear that it's only to the extent that white people and US citizens don't want to live under fascism, and are being embarrassed globally. Institutionally, ignorance remains: immigrants, especially H1B immigrants, especially undocumented immigrants, have lived under a sort of fascism for decades. US imperial, capital, and societal power structures, and the people and communities who benefit from them, only have the interest to lift the veil of white ignorance enough to regain their dominant status from the fascists. At best, this could result in us abolishing ICE, but it'll take a lot more to abolish the borders.

Zindagigi

This was--for me--the most interesting (or maybe just most readable?) of the chapters we read for this. It also did the best job of articulating what the collective production of ignorance is and is not. There is a difference between simply not knowing something and being culturally conditioned to never know a thing, even when people are telling you about the thing. I've mentioned elsewhere on here that I'm a linguist and by sheer coincidence "epistemics" is something I've had to educate myself on to understands certain facets of the phenomena I've been researching. Specifically, some languages have very prominent requirements to overtly express "how the speaker knows the thing they are saying"--I put that in quotes because this is the way this system of grammatical markers is almost universally explained and in reality it's much more complicated. For one, there are contexts in which the markers very clearly must track the perspective of the listener--not the speaker--or someone else. But, I digress. An important problem that I have been working on is what it means to "know" a thing, especially in the context of linguistic exchange. Mills' chapter very concisely and coherently explains how knowledge (and conversely, ignorance) is to a large extent socially mediated. It has given me some really useful ideas. We get knowledge from others but, also, knowledge has a social value--hence ignorance has a social value. There is social pressure to know certain things and not know others, and there is also a socially-constructed body of knowledge that individual pieces of knowledge have to fit into. This is why learning (or, rather "accepting") one piece of knowledge can cause a person's world view to undergo a dramatic shift. This is where the linguistic expression of knowledge is not being properly accounted for, in my opinion. The evaluation of a piece of knowledge will differ depending on who the "knower" is, their relationship to both the person talking and the person listening, and the particular relevance the piece of knowledge has to the greater conversation.