"AI Snake Oil" Chapter 8: "Where Do We Go From Here?" (Patreon)
Content
NOTE: If you want to participate in the conclusion of the book club, which is a live collaborative writing session (more details later but tldr we all get on the same google doc at the same time and write stuff together) fill out this when2meet that I'll use to schedule it. I'll announce the date/time on Saturday June 6 so fill it out before then!
~~~~~
So the thing I was most looking forward to getting out of this chapter was potential avenues for affecting the direction of AI, and I think the main examples we got were:
Advocacy against the problematic use of AI in your workplace/field (e.g. Karla Ortiz w/art)
Participate in local democratic processes (e.g. San Diegans vs. city surveillance system)
Push back on reactive AI policy (e.g. the students at River Dell High School)
I definitely appreciated these specific examples---I think it's useful to see specific types of collective action in different settings to get a better sense of what is possible, and hearing success stories is always nice and motivating.
I guess I was a little less moved by the stuff on regulation. It was interesting to learn about the different structures of horizontal/vertical regulation in different countries approaches to dealing with AI, but something about the whole analysis felt off to me. I think it hit the hardest when reading the last line of Kai's hypothetical future:
Big Tech companies have gotten so rich off of AI that they can easily mold public perception. Academic research and tech journalism are both completely dependent on industry funding, and companies heavily lobby for regulation that keeps new entrants out in the name of safety.
So this is supposed to be the theorized worst case scenario future where we're reactive and fearful towards AI but... it doesn't feel that far off from where things are now? Big Tech companies already have a lot of influence of public perception (I can think of plenty of successful proposition in recent California elections that were totally driven by tech interests but presented as 'for the people' that many people bought into). Idk so much about tech journalism but between DOGE and the Genesis Mission, academic research is rapidly becoming even more depending on industry funding than it was. And last year Open AI was one of the biggest donors to Trump's super PAC, and Trump's willingness to support AI companies has already been pretty clear.
Basically, I feel like the author's conception of the potential for regulation is based in an imagined version of the US government that isn't yet compromised by incentives from the tech industry, which is...not super grounded in reality? That's not to say regulation is a hopeless method for improving things, but I guess I just expected them to actually contend with the barriers that exist to productive regulation instead of just imagining a future where it existed.
Speaking of imagining a future where we've somehow figured out how to manage everything, did anyone else find Maya's imagined future scenario strange? I thought it was weird how many of the differences from Kai's scenario didn't really have anything to do with AI (like getting rid of legacy admissions? I'm all for it but...what does that have to do with technology?) My most charitable reading of this section is that they're trying to say that the version of the future where we figure out how to mitigate the risks posed by AI requires addressing the underling problems that AI exacerbates, which is probably true, but...idk I just finished this chapter wanting more.
That said, I do think I got a lot out of this book, and I think the technical knowledge that it focused on will be well complemented by the more critical analysis I'm expecting from Karen Hao's book next. Anyways, curious to hear yalls thoughts and v excited to discuss the book as a whole in our writing session next week!