Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

note: these are just my first impressions of the reading---in the comments, feel free to engage with this or start completely unrelated threads~

"Over the years, I've found only one metaphor that encapsulates the nature of what these AI power players are: empires. During the long era of European colonialism, empires seized and extracted resources that were not their own and exploited the labor of the people they subjugated to mine, cultivate, and refine those resources for the empires' enrichment. They projected racist, dehumanizing ideas of their own superiority and modernity to justify---and even entice the conquered into accepting---the invasion of sovereignty, the theft, and the subjugation. They justified their quest for power by the need to compete with other empires: in an arms race all bets are off...In the simplest terms, empires amassed extraordinary riches across space and time, through imposing a colonial world order, at great expense to everyone else."

My first awareness of this book had been hearing Karen Hao make this comparison of tech companies to empires in an interview sometime last year, and I've been vying to read it ever since. I remember thinking it almost sounded to extreme at first, but the more she said and the more I thought about it, the more I feel like she's absolutely right: there is nothing else that compares in scope or scale of power.

Something I'm already enjoying a lot about this book is how much it reads like an actual narrative, almost like a novel (for anyone who's not participated in our other book clubs, I think this one is a first in that respect). And maybe because of the story-telling structure of it, my biggest impressions from these first few chapters are less about the tech or the culture---which are things I'm already pretty familiar with---but the personal stories. Like, you know, everything we know about Altman and what he's responsible for at this point aside, he's a fascinating character. I don't anticipate that my takeaway by the end of the book is gonna be 'huh Altman's just a normal dude', but I was surprised by how much Chapter 1 humanized him to me. Something about the line describing him as sitting "with a leg popped up or perched like a bird atop his chair" really had me feeling he's justlikemeforreal. But like, a far more ambitious and socially skillful me.

Kind of keeping in the theme of seeing more of the human side of these people for whom I usually...don't.... Chapter 2 had me curious about the earnestness of supposed good initial intentions. Things like OpenAI initially being intended as a legitimately open source resource or the Anthropic folks going their own way to try to be meaningfully better. On the one hand, I've been skeptical/outright disbelieving of say, Elon Musk's early stated concerns about AI safety as his motivation for pushing so hard to be involved in its development (it's something of a trope to have tech people express concern for possible harms in order to position themselves as the ones who will "handle it", as opposed to regulation, sometimes called "ethics washing"). On the other hand, I (maybe naively?) want to believe that when Google was still just a cool search engine, they really meant it when they said their overarching rule was "don't be evil". I suppose in the grand scheme of things, it doesn't matter much whether the initial good intentions were sincere or not if they're eventually deviated from, but idk, I find myself wondering how much was just fraud from jump versus the system pushing well intentioned people to abandon their values.

Besides all the humanizing, something that stood out to me was the uncanniness of how people not even a decade ago were talking about what would become our reality. To end on one such unsettling quote AI acountability researcher Deborah Raji wrote addressing the existential fearmongering around possible rogue super-intellgient AGI:

"It is not just the actions of an AI agent that can produce side effects...In real life, basic design choices involved in mode l creation and deployment processes also have consequences that reach far beyond the impact that a single model's decision can have. In reality, for AI systems to even be built, there is very often a hidden human cost."

yeah, pretty much.

Comments

Mx. Alba

The overarching feeling the first two chapters left me with is... Wow these people at the top are just one small inbread clique. Altman, Thiel, Musk, Gates and all the slightly more minor deities mentioned all seem to be cross-investing in each others' ventures, forging alliances, breaking up, waging war, making up again when that's economically viable... They're playing a game of Risk and all 8 billion "normal humans" are the pawns moved across the world map.

Mx. Alba

As to Musk's sincerity... I actually think that he truly believes that a rogue AGI is the most existential threat to humanity. Or at least that he did believe that at the time. He's definitely prone to delusions and has surrounded himself with yes-men who do nothing but reaffirm them. The involvement of the Effective Altruism movement also would hint in that direction - even tough Musk himself isn't an Effective Altruist, otherwise he wouldn't be sitting on his trillion dollar capital, unless of course he's convinced himself that in an Effective Altruist way, investing in AI and space travel is the best way to save humanity.

Jean Marrero

For sure, the greatest aspect of these two chapters is kind of humanizing Altman and the people around him and the interpersonal relationships. But let me tell you. They are so many sussy buckas. I think that was the most shocking part, because ultimately the people who were on these technologies, and create these "empires" are all connected to each other. (Thiel was also close to Epstein from what understand). i'm not gonna lie. I'm glad that this reads more like a novel, because although these are real events, I think the lay person would be more engaged and invested in the story, and how it plays out, and ultimately how it might all fall apart, eventually. We also learn more about the dependency on ketamine for the Silicon Valley head honchos. God forbid a black person was smoking weed in the wrong time, while at the same time, the rich is among us are very much addicts. It doesn't really surprise me that the addiction would also be connected to their addiction to power and influence. What I'm looking forward to learning more of the next chapters is a bit beyond the interpersonal relationships of the multi billion company heads, but more into the AI portion. Great start, but a bit too Joe Rogan effect on "these are just regular dudes bro with regular connections bro" for my liking, when some readers, like myself, know beforehand that there are many sussy buckas in this story connected to God only knows the full extent of atrocities.

Jae

the quote from Pete Thiel in a guest lecture to an entrepreneurship class really stood out to me: "If you have a structure of the future where there's a lot of innovation and other people will come up with new things in the thing you're working on, [...] that's great for society. It's actually not that good for your business." (p. 40) What's good for society and what's good for business being at odds really highlights and puts into perspective the way these tech companies operate. It's no secret that companies across industries try to establish monopolies. But the way it is presented here is chilling - it doesn't matter what is good for society, as long as the wealthy elites can continue their rule. In chapter 2 OpenAI's business plan & investment model is discussed in more detail, and it's clear that long before ChatGPT was released these people were planning on economical and environmental apocalypse-level scaling: "Your bet is that you'll have a corporate structure which returns orders of magnitude more than Google... but you don't want to `unduly concentrate power`?" (p. 70) The hypocrisy was obvious even to their early investors, it makes me extremely skeptical about anything OpenAI tries to frame as beneficial to humanity.

Daniel Bui

I agree that the book reads like a novel. I think Karen Hao intentionally wrote this to be made into an Oscar-bait biopic, which is not necessarily a bad thing. She definitely leans into the personal drama and simplifies some of the technical details, but I think it serves the narrative focus and mass market appeal. I really like how she humanizes so many of the seemingly minor people involved, especially the ones that have only emerged in recent months as major players in AI. There are definitely a lot of people to keep track of though.

Jean Marrero

Yeah, people that make you wanna say: Im not suicidal! Sussy buckas im telling you

Laura Robinson

What struck me reading this is that these people are at the same time saying that AGI/ASI is inevitable and as such we need the right sort of people to build it, while at the same time doing possibly the biggest capital allocation for an unproven technology ever. I had sort of assumed that they thought that the compute scaling would work out better than it has, but the "OpenAI's Law" section suggests that they knew the scale of resources it would take back in 2012. It sort of reminds me of Latour's representation of science and technology as Janus, with one mouth speaking for the establishment and one talking for innovation. The former says "once the machine works everyone will be convinced" and the latter says "the machine will work once the relevant people are convinced."

Laura Robinson

While I acknowledge that making this more about the personalities involved make it a more inviting read, I do have a reflexive skepticism about this approach. Becoming a powerful person involves managing both your public image and your image to your clique of tech oligarchs and so I think actions tell the material story more accurately than what people say even in private conversation.

Jakob Smith

On Empires: My first notes in the book are also related to this. I wrote: "Find that piece you read in college about America's lack of geography/borders and the edge of its technological development being the new border for its version of empire". So I looked and it's David Harvey's entire body of work where instead of empire he names it "Capitalist Hegemony". This attached piece I think is ontological to what Karen lived through as an actual stormtrooper sitting at the console of this new empire: https://depthome.brooklyn.cuny.edu/aod/Text/Harvey.pdf . I’m not sure that generative AI qualifies as an Empire, in and of itself, but I can see the following to be true: “One of my teachers had said: Just a little while longer, just a little while, and people will no longer have to force their bones and squeeze out their sweat for so little result. Machines will replace all and every kind of work. People will have nothing to do except enjoy themselves. You are fortunate indeed, my students, he said, to be able to witness the beginning of the modern era here in the Indies. Modern! How quickly that word had surged forward and multiplied itself like bacteria throughout the world. (At least, that is what people were saying.) So allow me also to use this word, though I still don’t fully understand its meaning.” - excerpt from This Earth of Mankind by Pramoedya Ananta Toer Link That quote exists within the context of the Dutch colonization of Java. It is the same story Capitalists have been telling us, promising the working class that innovation will free them from the working class. And eerily and without any surprise on my part, is the exact same phrasing used to justify generative AI’s reach. On humanization and story-telling: I also felt that Karen has a good mind for story-telling as opposed to just simply documenting the rise of this new idea. She has focused on the human beings behind this version of this idea that is a public chat harness like ChatGPT. She talks about how so many of these people’s “empire building” happens on X, Slack, WhatsApp and house parties. Or when she includes the CEO saying the classic millennial discourse-marker, “like”, in his most professional speeches. On memories of these moments: I work in tech and this book had me reminiscing about my first Slack conversation with peers about the launch of a “box that anyone could type something into and send it to a black box model”. The more senior engineers in my chat scoffed: the “absolute hell that would be unleashed leaving an input like that so open and how many people would misuse it.” We then started a technical discussion on how an engineer could even wish to escape, sanitize and store such a sheer volume of inane, trite and strange but also abusive, dangerous and toxic string data if it was tokenized (transformed into numbers). How could you keep incorrect answers to incorrect questions from poisoning the tree (the relationship between tokens)? I remember us talking about OpenAI public politics, particularly the opening story, too, comparing it to things we had previously seen and heard, like WeWork or Theranos. We remarked that OpenAI’s marketing/PR team seemed under-cooked, “stiff and unrehearsed”, which gave them an almost innocence that was rare in SV. So weird to hear this mundane side of it. On Sutskever: I found Sutskever's character to be most relatable and felt the most shame about his involvement, as his boyish genius type is not uncommon at that level of novel technology leadership. I had sat in the office of a few brilliant Sutskever’s of my own who had taught me alot of free skills and simply, it seemed, for the love of the information itself. It is so important to realize that the empirical machine of private-market capitalism offers a challenge of novelty that child-like geniuses flock too out of a sometimes naive joy for the opportunity itself. And so much suffering can be built from their innovation that they slowly transform into a Murati or Shear or, Goddess forbidding, a Musk.

Jakob Smith

I can tell you first-hand that not only Ketamine is abused to dependency but also Benzodiazepines, Amphetamines, Caffeine, Nicotine, and Ethanol play a crucial role in the building of software companies, with severe consequences, to the extent that every person in tech knows someone who died as a result of misusing each of these chemicals.

Jacques Vincelette

Incest particularly painful when parents support perpetrator.

Jacques Vincelette

Sutskever, "Mystic goofball" and "amateur painter". "When considering the criticisms leveled at OpenAI for its pursuit of AGI (...) It was, as science writer Arthur C. Clarke in the book Profiles of the Future called it, “ a failure of imagination.” With wealth in the hands of the few, Canadian Nuclear Laboratories recognizes a market for small modular reactors. We are looking into AI powered surveillance drones to address security needs for remote isolated customers.

Jacques Vincelette

Bell Hook's 'Will to Change' recognizes how child abuse reenforces patriarchy in place.

Dr Jennifer Burgess

I guess I knew, but it confirmed, the total belief of this industry in the "boy genius" myth. The fact that they were so focussed on getting particular people and paying them so much money (I think sometimes before they'd even really done anything?). When in reality I'm sure there are lots of people who could do this work. But it ends up justifying the whole "we are really special so we should be in control of this existential threat" line of thinking.

phil e the theyby

I didn’t particularly read this as saying, “these are regular dudes with regular connections.” I think it’s painting the picture of these relationships “from the inside,” while also setting up that there actually very much IS an outside that isn’t allowed to be a part of it. The section on Timnit Gebru feels like the first point where Hao really makes that insularity explicit and highlights it’s specifically racist (and sexist) impact. To me, what’s made the book really compelling is how it demonstrates (though not always explicitly) that the main players here are demonstrated by understandable human motivations, but how their warped belief and value systems and fucked up systems of power can lead normal human motivations to have *incredibly* harmful effects.

AJ Biffl

Re: "just fraud from jump versus the system pushing well intentioned people to abandon their values," I definitely think the mechanisms that make people abandon their values are extremely powerful, and shaped so that you don't think you've abandoned anything. You find some justification to call yourself the good guy, and just so happen to benefit by unbelievable amounts of wealth. That quote from Musk, "climate change is bad, but it's not going to kill everyone. AI could render humanity extinct," is astonishing, and I think an example. I can't fathom a more convoluted reason to ignore climate change, but clearly it's a mode of justification that works - so many of these tech holes share the sentiment. AI is this convenient boogeyman that requires zero introspection, zero structural change, and zero sacrifice to combat. It's the most self-aggrandizing, narcissistic, romanticized way to construct a savior complex possible. They read Frankenstein and reach the profound insight that Man should not play God, and then in the next breath concoct every possible reason that they urgently need to start pilfering the graveyards, and deep down they enjoy sewing the bodies. Musk does this savior complex stuff all the time: buying Twitter to Save Free Speech, starting DOGE to Save the American Taxpayer. And there's such disgusting levels of wealth involved that the insular, sycophantic communities surrounding them encourage them and reinforce the ridiculous idea that they're doing anything good. Musk even has a relapse where he's like, 'the only POSSIBLE way forward is for me to absorb OpenAI into Tesla,' (and actually they're underdogs against the big evil Google!), like dude get over yourself. But there's literally no mechanism where these people can recognize that they're strayed so far from their intentions. Every little individual step is justified, and their lives end up so comfortable that abandoning their choices is unthinkable. I didn't feel particularly endeared or humanized to Altman. Yeah, there were moments where human features shine through (and Hao is a great storyteller), but I read these first chapters as a pretty unflattering depiction of a Machiavellian, borderline sociopathic pursuit of power. I'm probably projecting some of my already-opinions here, because of course I'm not surprised that that level of obsessive chauvinism is present on this road to extreme wealth. I also read this starting chapter as a really emblematic story of how power accumulates in all boys-club social hierarchy. Tech age just sort of amplifies the wealth involved and the pace that it grows. The contrast between Amodei's essay about alignment, and then Deborah Raji's essay feels suuuper prescient (and another example of these people finding the most detached savior-complex obsessions). I'm curious to see how the contrast between OpenAI and Amodei's Anthropic develops, if at all, because they don't seem to start in terribly different places. Altman was just a few steps ahead on the path to pouring all his money into a swimming pool.

phil e the theyby

I'm LOVING this book; the novel-like format makes it really engaging, and I think it does a beautiful job at providing a narrative around Sam Altman and co that puts their actions within the broader context of the tech economy and Silicon Valley. A few thematic things really stood out to me: 1) I think the story of how Sam Altman was reinstated is an incredible tale about how power *actually* works. Because Sam Altman's power came from *how people saw him*, and this power was enough to overcome the policy structures *that he helped create* to limit himself. Even as someone who (ostensibly) recognized his own fallibility and was more committed to the mission than maintaining his power, at the end of the day, he still came back on as CEO. Jason Pargin made a video recently talking about the corrupting effect of having that sort of power, and this feels like a very obvious example of how accumulating that much power basically always leads people down a problematic path to hold onto power. 2) The complete willingness for tech oligarchs to believe they should be trusted with (what they genuinely believe is) the fate of the world is MINDBOGGLING. This quote in particular stood out: "'The technology would be owned by the foundation and used 'for the good of the world,' and in cases where it's not obvious how that should be applied the 5 of us would decide,' Altman said." (27) Translation: The five of us will own what we believe to be potentially world-ending technology, and WE ALONE can decide what is good for *the entire world*. HOOOOLY SHIT. 3) So I recently had this idea that I only believe more strongly since reading these chapters...is AGI essentially "the rapture" to these people? Because it feels *remarkably* similar. It's painted as this essentially inevitable "end of this world," only instead of having to do whatever we need to be in God's good graces and be saved, it's them (the tech oligarchs) "doing the right thing" to ensure that we're on the "right" side of the AGI superintelligence. And in the face of the AGI rapture, all mere mortal concerns (climate change, racism, environmental damage) are irrelevant. I mean, Jeff Bezos basically came out and said recently, "why would you fight the construction of a data center because of environmental harms when the thing the data center is building the thing that will solve all of those problems for us anyway?" The fervor with which AGI is approached and discussed, seemingly in violation of capitalism's basic interest in...ya know, PROFIT...just feels deeply religious to me, and the rapture was the main thing that came to mind. Regarding some of Dr. Fatima's comments, I read their actions as the way that their "good intentions" are filtered. Even from the beginning, it seems like they feel that "doing the right thing" involves them making all the decisions because they're the bestest smartest boys, and foolhardy systems like "democracy" or "policy experts" can't be trusted to make these really important choices. Like, the foundation of what they take it to mean to be ethical and responsible is informed by the same technocratic shit Dr. Fatima has discussed many times. Couple that with their inability to actually identify and name their own emotional needs and desires, and you have a formula where power-hoarding and dismissal or outright attacks on vulnerably communities run rampant among people who (I think) genuinely believe (at least some of the time) that they're doing the right thing and making the world a better place. The racism, sexism, ableism, and more within our culture obviously play a huge role in this as well.

Dr. Fatima

i'm gonna try to respond to more of this later but for now, thank you for alerting me that Jason Pargin has an active youtube channel??? i loved listening to him on the cracked podcast years and years ago, excited for him to be a present voice for me again!

phil e the theyby

He does! He posts shorts a few times a week and videos sporadically. I've found a lot of his videos super valuable, so it's cool to hear you're a fan and will be discovering what he's been talking about more recently :)

Soph

One of the sections in chapter 1 that really stuck out to me was the part where Sam Altman’s high school english teacher so wanted him to become a writer and *not* go into tech - specifically Altman’s reasoning for not going into writing was that “the world doesn’t need the seven millionth novel” That to me really gets into the anti-human sentiments that sit at the heart of a lot of tech bro philosophy. That the world only ever needs constant optimization, and there reaches a point where human stories/thought/creativity are useless. I personally think we *do* need the seven millionth novel. Someone out there would read it.

Dr Jennifer Burgess

Ironic that they've designed something that can write seven million crap novels that we definitely don't need!

phil e the theyby

I think that to me, the interesting thing about Altman is that it feels like he could have played a very different role in a different society. He does seem like he actually cared about people AND that he had an intense desire for power and status. In a society where no one person can accumulate that much power, and where status comes from humility rather than displays of certainty, it felt like he could have been good for the world. The quote about Altman seeing the way Elon Musk voiced absolute certainty in himself as the benchmark he needed to meet REALLY stood out to me, because it’s such an arrogant way of being, but it’s also one that’s so highly valued in American society. In a society where self-assuredness and wealth are the highest marker of status, Altman chased fanatical self-assuredness and obscene wealth (and other status markers such as luxury products). In a society (and an economic system) where humility and collaboration are the highest status, most valued traits, I can imagine someone like Altman living a much more prosocial life. But none of that is meant to downplay how absolutely awful and manipulative Altman’s actions feel in THIS society. I think Machiavellian is a very apt way to describe it.

AJ Biffl

It truly is tragic how many otherwise thoughtful, capable, caring people have pursued wealth and power because it was the biggest lighthouse that our society built. Feyerabend uses this phrase "nothing succeeds like success," and this isn't even the context he uses it in, but I always think about it in the context of how hegemonic society, purely by virtue of its domination, can dictate what is desirable and what is acceptable by rewarding those things, to make those people "successful," and others see that and emulate them

AJ Biffl

Another thing about that whole monopoly standpoint, is that isn't the whole argument of these super pro-capitalist people that competition is a hugely important part of the process? Like what's the difference between monopoly and totalitarian state control?

Justin Lee

True, and even hypothetically no one reads the novel, it still is such a worthwhile creative endeavor that can lead to a lot of personal growth. But the capitalistic-business mindset cannot fathom doing something for its own sake and everything should be done in service of climbing the ladder and outcompeting others.

Piochi

There's something about the humanization that has a double edge sword effect on me. On the one hand, I get uncomfortable with this sorta "he tried to be good but XYZ" trope we can see in like vilain arcs movies, because it's often time used to overlook their bad deeds. On the other, I do think it's important to remember that "evil" doesn't actually exist on its own. That the worse people in history were all fundamentaly human and it is human who do these things. Evil, is a collective responsability in a way, and maybe that touches on your video on shame and AI. We want to feel like we are fighting evil but evil is a little everywhere all the time and inside us too. Shaming is a reinforcement of individualism, and while I dont think caring about individuality is bad, always thinking the world in an indivualistic pov will not bring collective liberation. It's something I try hard to remember because if we stop humanizing "evil" people, then that's when I think they risk becoming "untouchable". Because we can imagine the reason they became like this is beyond ourselves, and we say things like "this is inhuman"... when actually, it is. So far, I am a bit less interested by the AI part then how can people gain so much power and what mechanism are allowing it. It feels like a cautionary tale. Hope I'm making sense, thank you for reading if you did.

Chervonne Lollis

just speed read the prologue to get a idea of the book and im very excited to catch up. my interest is politics ig, and lately ive been talking about accelerationism and other reactions to post structuralism. I fold that into analysis of economics and politics of the 21st century. tech bros are a very important piece of that analysis. its kinda heavy in retrospect tho and I have a hard time finding other people to talk to about my ideas. ive watched one video of Dr fatimas and I really liked it. I would have watched more ive just been tired. when I saw she had a book club I thought maybe I could meet other people interested in talking about things I like so its pretty darn funny to see that the current books topic. edit: also im a weird christian, tried looking at theology a while back to practice some african american spirituality from my mom. I liked being able to tell people im a christian and talk like a weird old insane sage so its my thing now point is their obsession with power and religion is also very important to everything im interested in. you would be surprised how much theology can help you understand power

Dr. Fatima

yeah I found the pro-monopoly take esp interesting in the context of how all the OpenAI guys seemed to resent Google for...being a monopoly. monopolies for me and not for thee i guess. though to AJ's point, idk if Theil could even be considered a capitalist---I think capitalisms at least ostensibly co-existed with democracy, where Theil doesn't exactly shy away from denouncing democracy

Dr. Fatima

this is making me really want to get around to reading Latour.... but yeah the circular reasoning does seem to be a bit of a theme in the AI ethos

Dr. Fatima

i agree there are lots of people who could do whatever kind of work, but I wonder if the "boy genius" selection criteria is also filtering for a kind of personality that's necessary to build these kinds of companies---things like Sutskever's singlemindedness, or Altman's manipulation super powers. to make a comparison to what I'd see highlighted as the 'ideal student' back in grad school, it's less about singular technical talent and more about being willing to play the game, so to speak---but they're still represented as getting to where they are because of their intelligence/ability

Dr. Fatima

so i know you brought up my tecnocracy stakes in regards to my comments, but I think it's actually relevant to your rapture analogy, which I think is really apt. i think the video after the one I'm writing right now is going to be about this sense of "technology will save us", and while I think there are more political/economic factors motivating the belief, the way it manifests does have a distinctly religious vibe to it. like I wouldn't think AI bros consider themselves having 'faith', but...what else explains their devotion to a thing that is unclear if it will ever exist? i think there was a line in the chapter where elon says something like, 'but what if theres even a 1% chance of AGI existing'? it's giving pascal's wager (which is just a math nerd trying to game religion)

Dr. Fatima

i feel like this is getting at why the distinction between 'fraud from jump' and 'system pushing value abandonment' might matter---people are always asking me things like 'should i try to change the system from inside or do we tear the whole thing down?' and besides the question of which might be more effective, i wonder to what extent trying to change X system from the inside is even possible because of how strong the pressures to abandon the values came in with can be. I wanna say it's possible because I've seen both the people who maintain and people who lose their values, but the scale of institutional power I'm thinking of doesn't really compare to that of the AI oligarchs, so idk

Dr. Fatima

now im just really curious what Altman's novel would've been like

Dr. Fatima

definitely agree with a lot of this, and really heartened to feel like I'm seeing more and more conversations on line that actually try to contend with people who do bad things (whether on the scale of AI oligarchs or their neighbors who voted opposite them) instead of just theoretically banishing them from our ideal of what the world should be. i think the discourse pendulum swung to far that way in the peak cancel culture years of like, 2016-2020 (?) but is now having something of a reckoning

Chervonne Lollis

lol I was ranting about popular ideology today and I wrote this: “you know that gollum charecter? well the ring doesnt fucking make you evil when you touch it, you just want it and that is disgusting in of itself. its like that, I do not know many people who dont want power you believe power is inevitable in it’s importance, if you do not chase it someone else will right? you feel me? power is nature, nature is inevitable, it is also good, and if you dont have it someone else will. those who have it deserve it. and those who dont, will be made to be subservient. so the only way to self actualization is to get the ring” I complain alot 🙂‍↕️. who is Latour?

phil e the theyby

I’ve sort of stopped engaging with the question of “change the system vs. tear it down” (which is easy for me bc no one asks me about it) because I largely don’t see it as practically useful. I play a significant internal role in my area’s DSA chapter (Democratic Socialists of America, for non-USAnians). I follow some folks who are critical of the DSA and it’s overall strategy. And while I don’t disagree with them, and I believe that building alternative power structures is probably more effective than trying to build power within the existing structure, I also know that *I have no idea what tangible things I would do to build a new system*. I’m aware of things OTHER people do, but I don’t feel I have the capacity to find and connect with those and fit them into my life. So I get involved in a way that is practical and sustainable for me given my current circumstances. So when people ask, “should we repair the system or tear it down,” I guess my response is, “what are YOU, PERSONALLY going to do?” Because I feel like so much political energy goes towards arguing (especially online) about what SHOULD be done, and not enough goes towards *actually doing something*. So get involved in whatever way feels sustainable and actually helpful. Look at the impact of the orgs you’re involved with, and if it consistently disappoints you, leave and find (or start) other orgs. So even though my larger analysis is “yeah we probably need to tear this whole system down,” I think that’s less of a priority for me than trying to get people to actually engage with the politics of the world around us. Because I’d much rather people be doing something “reformist” than doing nothing. A reformist might become radicalized through trying to reform the system, but someone who isn’t engaged at all will never get there until they start.

Chervonne Lollis

I have caught up to this part! 🥳 one thing that interested me is that AI tech bros had a very grounded understanding of the economy. growth is necessary under capitalism, and then monopolies are more stable (also true, any bell labs nerds out there ahah). they essentially used a grounded understanding of reality to make themselves look like 5 head geniuses. love that he talks about sams life like a story, I see people are confused by the humanization, but reality is people are people. you average dude is your average sam altman, well ig you were also autistic and nervous and interested in social patterns. I digress tho, something interesting about modern economy is that modern monopolies are not stable like monopolies of the olden days. because big companies buy other companies and leave the structure intact; but since the companies are their bitch they cant do anything till told. thats not great for getting things done. bell labs? pfft yeah right. these modern monopolies cant do development for shit. but now it makes sense why they keep buying even if its empty and useless. both they are too big to fail and the have nostalgia for past Monopolies I also noticed that early uh … resource wasters were decided on early on. namely alignment and the idea that AI could only become more intelligent with processing power. these two things are expensive and dont do alot, you think they would focus on changing the structure of the technology. but they set their own arbitrary deadline thats another thing, the startup model is resistant to change. you need constant funding, and you need to appear profitable. a core trait in or modern economy very cool and horrifying right? I love that everyone is thinking, how could this gay progressive man be so horrific! which is good, most people do not know that we share ideologies with the ruling class. my personal analysis of altman is he had a bit of the tism or a personality disorder (I dont think those are bad) and finding how easily people are manipulated made him realize how fake liberal ideology is. there are two popular choices: reject or accept. market forces and the tangled web of his lies gives him the incentive to accept. probably doesn’t help that people let him do this, that can make you misanthropic. every cruel joke you make that gets a laugh, every new cult member, every new worshiper. paying attention to people? really how easy!? putting on glasses and sounding smart? uh Ca Ching! free praise. making someone whos never paid attention to the intricacies of language believe they have control of the conversation? easy peasy lemon squeasy. lies also change the way you think, they jumble up, they effect your logic. I imagine especially in this society its easy to look down on people eventually you become so alienated by your own power. at least thats my guess thats another thing, these startups require alot of manipulation. people trust in this man so much they can stand the thought of him stepping down, hard cult vibes

AJ Biffl

Absolutely agree those "they tried to be good but XYZ" stories are important, because anyone can be the one to do bad, and there are many tangible sort of avalanches that can leave anyone in that position. That throughline with understanding how the accumulation of power actually happens, and this story being a terrifying and real-time example of that, is also super interesting to me in reading this. This story is precisely the beacon-for-you-western-man

AJ Biffl

That "what are YOU PERSONALLY going to do" reminds me a lot of the 'How To Systemic Change' video, where most of the advice boils down to just finding things that you yourself can meaningfully and sustainably do. What you say also reminds me of a vid from Barry's Economics, "The Wealth Tax Debate Is A Trap," that basically says that waiting until you find a perfect solution is a terrible idea, just try SOMETHING and move in a better direction.

Nanibgal

Hi everyone! I'm new to the Patreon, I'm going to try to catch up though I doubt I can by tomorrow. I'm really excited to be here and to start reading!

Nanibgal

Okay, writing my thoughts down for this part of the book. I'm not going to lie, while I like the writing a lot I'm finding it really hard to keep track of who's who in some respects. Like, in the moment I feel like I understand what's going on, but then if a point is referenced from the previous page I kind of feel like I have to refresh myself on the cast. Maybe this is just me, but when I read the parts about Elon Musk, I'm hit by the memory of his old public perception. Like, wow, I remember when I thought he was well-meaning and good at anything... I was just graduating high school when Obama took office, and I remember all of the techno-optimism re: social media. Also, like as a writer of fiction, the decision to start the story with Sam's firing was *chef's kiss*. It's so interesting because like I went into this already feeling that Altman was not a great guy, and then to see his "downfall" get reversed... it was absolutely chilling. I started getting into this topic to follow a kind of lead for a book series I'm planning, and the portrayals of some of these people are giving me a lot of inspiration. I've gotta get in the habit of reading with a paper and pen next to me to jot down notes! I've read up to page 87 of the book (in the middle of chapter 4) . I bought the audio book, but I'm also reading along with the words. ADHD fights hard, but I fight harder.

Nanibgal

The world may never know... but yeah, now I'm curious too

Stentor Danielson

Jumping in late on this one, hoping to get caught up soon. I'm interested in keeping track of how geographical features -- space and place -- play a role in this story, since those factors are so important to empire. The first thing that jumped out at me on this score is the insistence that everyone working for OpenAI had to move to the Bay Area. This is on the one hand a demand that people who are part of this project be placeless, able to uproot themselves from wherever they were around the country or world to come to this particular work location. Capitalism would love for everyone to be this kind of mobile fungible labor unit -- but not everyone is equally able to fit that mold. Notice how the transitioning of people to the for-profit arm was complicated by some people being there on a visa tied to the nonprofit. On the other hand, the reason to insist everyone come to the office in one geographical location is to leverage shared physical presence to shape the operation of the company in specific ways. When you're in the office, Sutskever can come look over your shoulder and ask you about your big ideas. The image of people walking around the office in socks was particularly striking, as an illustration of how a specific way of comporting your body in physical space serves to signal a set of cultural norms and a relationship to the corporate project -- "we're cool dudes doing cutting edge work, so we don't have time to worry about what those old fuddy-duddies in suits would think of us, and we're so dedicated to the mission that we've lost all work-life boundaries."