Empire of AI: "Dawn of Commerce" and "Disaster Capitalism" (Patreon)
Content
halfway through the book! been sick this week so my notes are on the minimal side:
there was a part of "Dawn of Commerce" about Altman's investment in a startup interested in UBI via a "collectively owned" cryptocurrency that reminded me of a video I saw recently by youtuber Hazel Thayer analyzing various tech billionaires' interest in UBI---I had initially been surprised that tech CEO's would be genuinely interested in supporting UBI, but hearing Hazel's analysis, this interest seems similar to their interest in 'regulation' or 'safety', where it's more about seeming like they're already solving the problems they're creating to get ahead of solutions that would hurt their bottom lines (which we can also see in this chapter, with, e.g., OpenAI's "red-teaming"). the videos a short and good explanation that gives a lot of context to this point, if anyone's interested.
~~~
re "Disaster Capitalism", I think my big takeaway here is that the issue of data labor exploitation didn't have to be a problem (see the counter example of CloudFactory) but because of the economic context/incentives companies like OpenAI are operating within, it of course would be. i like to imagine (maybe naively?) that you could make a completely unproblematic llm: trained on data that's not stolen, run on renewable energy, and as per this chapter, moderated by workers who have dignified working conditions, job stability, and whatever required support, etc etc. and while the existence of more ethically operated data labor firms like CloudFactory makes me think that's possible on a technical level, the dynamics explained in this chapter make me wonder if 'technically possible' matters if something is economically unviable.
also, the in depth personal stories from this chapter were of course very sad and affecting, but the bit that hit me hardest wasn't any of the long personal narratives, but that aside about Venezuelan former software engineers coming up with helpful plugins for annotation work. it's not that software engineers in the Bay exploiting software engineers in other countries is somehow worse than exploiting anyone else, but idk, there's something about only the difference in their location on earth dictating where they are in this fucked up collaboration that really got me.