Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I’m finding this reading hard to write about.  I don’t know what to say about the story with his sister, which I somehow didn’t know about until reading this? I remember getting a comment on my AI video saying ‘google what sam altman did to his sister’ or something, but I completely missed this story in the news, and I wonder if that’s just a me thing or they managed to do good PR .  It kinda feels like the reverse of what I wrote about for the chapters where we were introduced to Sam Altman the charismatic wunderkind—a layer of personal characterization humanizing the guy “leading us to AGI”, but now it’s horrifying instead of charming.  I mean, I guess Hao sprinkled some seeds hinting at Altman’s more sadistic side, but damn. I will say, she really knows how to tell a story. 

Another thing I’m feeling more appreciation for re how Hao writes: the chapters so far have seemed to me to be switching between spilling tea about the interpersonal drama of this cast of characters, and then recounting broader stories about the repercussions of those guys’ decisions in other parts of the world/society. I feel like those two threads are starting to collide as the book gets close to ending and I find it compelling af. like something about this weeks reading felt like it pulled all the interpersonal stuff about Altman and co into my experience as a consumer of news that talks about OpenAI, and something about that just makes it feel surreal to me. Take that moment where Elon chimes in about Altman’s firing.  we’re reading about the complex power struggle over a company that has immeasurable significance on the world right now, a feud over an empire—and then in the middle of this epic, this dummy logs on twitter to stir the pot. It gives me the same kind of weird horror of watching the show Succession and seeing the most trivial, petty bullshit between unimaginably powerful people driving decisions that affect everyone.  Except with the AI people, I can literally google these people and see what they’re tweeting or whatever because they’re real. It’s absurd and upsetting but clear and damn Karen Hao really was the right person to write this book

Comments

Jacques Vincelette

On the last week of September 2023, as I was signing Sinéad O’Connor Shuhada’ Sadaqat's interpretation of Marley's War, on the matter of Truth and Reconciliation. The IAEA cut me off at the line "Until the ignoble and unhappy regime that puts each and every one of us through child abuse, exploitation..." How can I push back on systemic misogyny and toxic cult of youth without normalizing it? Such backlash on sexworkers and token LGBTQ+ scapegoats. Isa ibn Maryam shared bittersweet yet practical humour on the matter.

Black EnviroNerd

Annie’s story was mentioned at the end of the Divine Right chapter! I’m glad the book circled back to her situation as I was a bit thrown off when it was just briefly touched on. It's interesting how the Altmans insist on her being financially independent as they withhold money from her. This of course being done while they are fully capable of supporting her for the rest of her life without second thought. I’m a bit curious about the political views of their mother as Sam struck me a liberal so it's interesting how bootstrapy they’re coming across. It seems to be a matter of principle for them but I’m really scratching my head at why they wouldn’t just drop 10 or 20 mil in a trust that would just pay out over 40 or so years. I get its a power and control thing but, it seems pretty irrational the way the family is going about it. I think part of the reason Hao draws parallels between Sam and Annie’s educational success is to illustrate Sam's inability/refusal to recognize the fact that he and Annie’s roles could easily be reversed if he was the one dealing with severe chronic pain. I like how this interpersonal dynamic really highlights the ableism of the Altmans. I do agree that her ability to connect the interpersonal with the wider societal implications is a great way to tell a story and give the reader a framework to analyze the events' intersectionality. Last thought on Annie is how issues of domestic violence, assault etc… are really ubiquitous among all economic classes and races in American society but we continue to associate them with poor people of color. It reminds me of Mackenzie Fierceton’s story. Part of her story was that she grew up white and wealthy but underwent extreme abuse from her mom who was a doctor. Unfortunately no one believed her until she had to go to the ER from her mom’s abuse. I believe she’s an advocate and researcher on the foster to prison pipeline now and I recall her recounting this in a podcast and making a point that marginalized people are more likely to be criminalized for these things but don’t necessarily perform these abuses at higher rates. Altman, as characterized in this book, is a really interesting case study on how manipulators are really able to take advantage of hierarchical systems no matter the setting. It might be overly cynical but I don’t think the board ever really had a chance against Altman. The best they could have done is replace him with someone less offensive. Regardless it seems like the combination of Altman’s charisma, manipulation and paranoia allowed him to become a fixture and almost synonymous with the OpenAI brand. Sam and Elon really do seem like two sides of the same coin (which makes it amusing that they don’t get along) in that their own personal brands are so attached to their respective companies that there's no way to hold them to account internally even by CEO standards. My last thought is its wonder OpenAI was/is able to get anything done with the leadership they have.

Dr Jennifer Burgess

It's so strange to hear the details retrospectively on something that I heard in the news at the time, but I remember the board trying to fire him and thinking at the time "how terrible that a board can do that to a founder". It seems like they had their reasons in the end. But the company has ended up buying into the view of Altman as a guru? I know nothing about business but surely these companies should be doing the type of work that can survive the departure of the CEO? The situation with Annie Altman and finances is also a little strange - they're talking about her as if she is completely irresponsible with money or if she has a type of addiction (for example) which would warrant considering withholding money. But I'm just hearing about a woman who has health problems causing understandable difficulty working (the type of job her family wants her to) and so she wants to pursue her art instead. Unless there is missing information here it doesn't really paint the family in a reasonable light.

Jacques Vincelette

Fog of war and taboo undermine reasonable light. Raises doubt on on the quality of training data and internet trolling obsessions.

Stentor Danielson

The thing that gets me about Annie's story is that she shouldn't have to rely on her family for help. As awful as the Altmans (Attmen?) are for not supporting her, I know a dozen people in similar circumstances who don't have rich family to even ask for help from. We should be taxing the shit out of rich people like Sam Altman and Elon Musk to ensure that all of the Annies of the world have a decent standard of living, without having to maintain any sort of relationship with an abusive family.