Empire of AI: "Reckoning", "A Formula for Empire", and "EPILOGUE" (Patreon)
Content
last chapters! as usual, we will conclude the book with a collaboritve live writing session. I'll explain more details for how it will work later, but for now, if you want to participate, fill out this when2meet so we can set a time.
~~~~
"This is where Te Hiku's story diverges completely from OpenAI's and Silicon Valleys's model of AI development. Intimately familiar with the devastating effects of colonial dispossession, Jones and Mahelona were determined to carry out the project only if they could guarantee three things----consent, reciprocity, and the Māori people's sovereignty---at every stage of development. This meant that even before embarking on the project, they would get permission from the Māori community and their elders, asking them if the endeavor was even something they wanted; to collect the training data, they would seek contributions only from people who fully understood what the data would be used for an were willing to participate; to maximize the model's benefit, they would listen to the community for what kinds of language-learning resources would be most helpful; and once they had the resources, they would also buy their own on-site Nvidia GPUs and servers to train their models without a dependency on any tech giant's cloud."
As I've mentioned in previous posts, something that I'm always thinking about re AI is, is it possible to do without all the garbage we've spent the last weeks learning about in great detail. The Chilean students imagining new ways of designing data centers was a nice little preview of that, but I think the epilogue's discussion of Te Hiku really exemplifies this ideal for me. Language is something that a "large language model" is actually extremely well suited to work with, and small models with specific and limited scope (as opposed to the AGI dream of an everything machine) are what all the examples of useful "AI" i can think of (e.g. scientific research) end up being. And based on the reading, they really did manage to circumvent all the big issues that the big-tech LLMS rely on.
I'm thinking of doing a video on the idea of technology/science being "neutral"---in the context of the AI discourse, I see this coming up in AI defenders saying it's just a neutral technology and the problems only arise in how it's used, and AI detractors saying that it was designed with exploitative premises in such a way that it can never be anything except evil. this is something I think about in more contexts than just AI (I get comments of people say the same things about science as a whole all the time), and I've been wanting to unpack it for a while now. i will say the book in general really drives home the many ways that the development of AI as we understand it today has been deeply intertwined with some pretty problematic practices/ideas, but i really appreciate that she doesn't seem to take this as a complete dismissal of any related technology. it's a hard needle to thread, but the truth is there's a part of me that is just impressed by and interested in developments in computing, and I'm trying to figure out how much of that I can be excited about without falling into the obviously evil parts of it. The Te Hiku example is really doing something for me in that respect, and I wish there were more conversations I saw around how people are re-imaginng this technology to exist outside of, or even push back on its imperial origins. for those who read "A Third University Is Possible" with me, it's giving scyborg energy.
if anyone else has examples of AI being co-opted by non-empire actors, please share!
also to that end, I'm really curious to read the book "Power and Progress: Our Thousand-Year Struggle Over Technology and Prosperity" that was mentioned in a previous chapter---anyone keen on it for the next book club?