Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

"Unlike perceptions of engineering in Western societies, engineering students in Iran are widely understood to be the most politically engaged students. In fact, it is not considered unusual to be an engineering student and to also be an activist, intellectual, artist, or politician."

So this is an incredibly silly start to this book club, but this line in the Introduction reminded me of the Iranian musical group Barobax that formed when three former engineering students couldn't get jobs---gonna share this banger of theirs from the brief moment many years ago when I was learning Farsi, enjoy~

Ok but for real thought, I'm veryyy excited to read this book. I've mentioned in a couple videos that a few years ago I was a postdoc on a project about engineering students relationship to the political context of their work, so this is extremely up my alley (in fact, the intro cited some people I've worked with---not to flex of anything but how often do I get to do the academic equivalent of name dropping famous people lol). It's extremely well established that in the US, STEM education---especially engineering---is extremely depoliticized, and while it's easy to feel like that's just the nature of the subject, I've known that there are international counterexamples, and this one seems like it's gonna be even stronger than the one's I'm familiar with.

Since it's just the introduction, my prompt for y'all in our first discussion is, based on what the authors have outlined, what are you most excited to learn about in this book?

For me, I'm particularly interested by one of the author's background in engineering identity and how it related to all this. STEM identity is another topic I've worked on, and I have very mixed feelings about it (which I'm sure I'll rant about it on a future post), so I look forward to getting his perspective.

I'm also very interested in the chapter on women's role in everything; something super interesting about women in STEM in Iran is that the physics community there is split about 50/50 men and women, which feels wild in comparison to the US or basically any western country. Not to say there's no sexism in Iran, obviously that's not the case, but it really questions the naturalness of the way things are here.

alright that's all I got to start us off, looking forward to reading your posts!

Comments

Nanibgal

Thank you for including prompts, that makes it much easier for me to have a starting point to share stuff. I'm really looking forward into learning about this idea of merging engineering with political activism. I've been making my way through the list of references from the Technocracy video and reading the papers cited there (I really loved "The Amazon Effect" and "Examining the “narrow” and “expansive” socio-technical imaginaries influencing college students’ collaborative reasoning about a design scenario".). I grew up with a computer engineer father who... is very attached to the western standard of an "empirical rationalist", let's say. Even though I had an interest in science growing up, I was never encouraged to find a way to merge my interests of helping people, my creative passions, etc. This might sound really kind of silly, but I'm planning out a fantasy book series that has to do with an institution of learning. I feel like exploring different kinds of educational institutions will help me with this project, if that makes sense? Sure, I know what school *can* be, and what school is for a lot of people, but I feel like this book is going to show me possibilities I haven't considered or experienced.

Nanibgal

Also, writing this comment separately... So I mentioned in the previous post that I was interested in doing read-alongs. Starting from about the 1:13:00 mark, I read the Preface and Introduction for this book here https://www.twitch.tv/videos/2895061676 It should be up for a few days. Since it's twitch, I do add a bit of commentary and reply to chat as I'm reading, but if someone was hoping for an audio format...here is an option?

sabah

This book also hits close to home for me. I completed my undergraduate in the US in engineering, volunteered with engineers without borders (EWB) (i have mixed feelings about this now) and saw some of my friends some who i worked with in EWB go on to work for defense contractors. Engineering was genuinely a very hostile environment to any kind if political activism and while I attended protests and such ... much of my political understanding of the world was built in spite of and after my formal education. I also feel like even in the spaces where some ethical and political considerations are allowed in academia... it is of ... a very specific stripe. I ended up in a masters program in data science that had a sub group that focused on international development. And to be honest much of the project proposals felt v surveillance capitalism... albeit that we had plenty of discussions about surveillance capitalism being bad. It was just... it felt impossible for me to be in academia and also feel like my work was meaingfully aligned with my values. It always felt precarious. Any counterexample feels like...seeing a new world I didnt know was possible.

Jacques Vincelette

Every night juggles the precariousness of music. I struggle reading melody, harmony, chorus, verses, time, rhythm, accents, ornamentation; yet partition sheet offers some embodied memory... if only I had practiced.

Jacques Vincelette

p2 "the public, is largely unified in viewing engineering as a profession that is practically inseparable from corporate America and the military-industrial-academic complex." This gets repetitive but the same argument was provided by my manager and my union rep when I raised concerns that handing over Canadian Nuclear Laboratories to American military contractors Amentum and BWXT undermines Canada's commitment to Non Proliferation. "'Atoms for peace' applies to politicians." 1st clause of our union contract states academic requirements. 2nd clause affirms management's divine right to rule. Given precarity, many colleagues busk on the side.

Simon

"All of these examples are part of an even broader recognition that equity and social justice are deeply tied to questions of culture, power, and knowledge. Calls to decolonize the curriculum demonstrates that equity in education can no longer be viewed merely as matters of inclusion, diversity, or access. One must ask "Access to what?"" I think that's a very good question and I hope to find some answers in the book that I can use to help make my mostly white and very male-dominated workplace more accessible.

AlexTheTutor

First, thank you so much for having these book discussions. It is invaluable to be able to share ideas like this with a wide range of books, books I never would have been aware of their existence. When we walk down the street, we don’t need to constantly look at our feet, we just know where our body is in space, that sense is proprioception, it’s a sense the brain does without us ever thinking about it, it’s just a part of being human. The thing I am most excited to learn is this: what even is culture? Everyone else walks through life claiming cultural identities, being proud of being X, saying that being X means such and such, but in my entire life, I cannot say with any certainty to claim any culture. I have no sense whatsoever of what it means to be X. (I was born in A, but I barely speak its native language, I was raised in B, but don’t resonate with its culture, I enjoy culture C, although I never visited C and don’t speak its language, and then there’s D, in which I’ve been there many times and can speak its language but am not a member, and E… etc.) I suppose I can identify as an educator, but even that comes with asterisks. Once a wealthy family asked me to tutor their son for an entrance exam. The family said the 30 minutes of homework was too much for the boy, since it competed with the 20 hours of sports practice, but later the family was shocked when the boy failed the entrance exam. Pikachu shock face. The boy’s dream was to become a sports executive. Another family: a parent (a federal judge) claimed that math is useless and a waste of time, but still we ask you to help our kids to get through math. So, I am not surprised at all that the introduction of this new book states that foreign nationals make up about 80% of STEM graduate students in the US. Because, of course they do. I have taken many group photos of grad student labs: sometimes 100% foreign. People have made me feel a part of these groups. It’s very sweet. But, question: Does that make me a foreigner in my own country? Do I then identify as an academic without pursuing a degree? Look how blank my resume is: Am I to fill in the blanks with ‘graduate studies in self-academy’? Please, do not get me wrong: I am happy and truly blessed to have the life I have. Also, I am in no way shaming anyone who can identify with a culture or etc, so please do not take offense. It’s the same as a patient walking (with assistance) to the doctor’s office and explaining that they don’t have proprioception, but they want to learn more about it. In no way is the patient shaming anyone who can walk freely, nor is the patient blaming anyone. The patient just wants to understand and learn more about the normal fundamenetal experiences of others.

Alex U

This bit from the bottom of page 6 and onto 7 stood out to me: "... many efforts to promote DEI in engineering (and STEM education more broadly) have neglected to examine how the politics and ethics of the engineering profession itself may be a major “deal breaker” for students with marginalized identities...." It speaks to a discussion my friends were having a while back about DEI and filled in a piece that I think I was missing. It's not (just) a matter of excluding marginalized people from STEM. If the STEM fields are seen as serving American empire, then the advancement STEM offers might make a marginalized person feel at odds with their own community. I don't know if the bargain would feel so explicit that people who might want to pursue engineering or another STEM discipline would opt not to pursue one, or to drop out or change majors because they started to encounter the way the military industrial comples is integrated with acedamia. It's a lot easier for white folks, especially white men, to ignore or even embrace that integration. For one thing, our ancestors largely abandoned community and culture on our behalf in order to embrace whiteness, so there's little tension between individual advancement and community belonging. I don't know, maybe this is too grand a statment, and I'm projecting from my own path to the left as an engineer.

Anthony Perez Eisenbarth

Well, I guess this is my third time around. And I just want to say that I find these discussions to sometimes be the highlight of my week. (My Marxist sympathies are about as subtle as a CIA operated coup, so apologies in advance.) What I am most eager with reading this book is whether it can give deep insights into why students at AMUT radicalized. I just finished rereading Abrahamian's Iran Between Two Revolutions (a fascinating book that I recommend as a companion to this if you have the time for it), and I am already seeing some parallels between them. (In fact, I was incredibly stoked to see Abrahamian’s name in the bibliography.) A common mistake that’s typically done is framing the Shah's regime as “progressive.” Like Chile, Argentina, and Brazil it was a brutal, US-backed dictatorship that crushed the left in the name of modernization. In Iran’s case, that modernization took the form of rapid, oil-funded industrialization, which produced the contradictions that brought the regime down. This “progress” through land reforms left millions of peasants landless or on unviable plots, pushing them into urban shantytowns, while the state’s price campaigns and one-party push alienated the bazaar merchants. The Shah's state, through the secret police systematically destroyed the secular and union left, creating a political vacuum. AMUT looks like a pure case of this, the Shah built it to train the engineers (technocrats) his development program needed, and with legal opposition gone, it became a recruiting ground for the underground left instead. So I’m very eager to see if they do achieve one of their stated goals of the book, which is “to explore the ways in which the political identities of engineering students at AMUT were dynamically linked to the specific national, political, and cultural context of Iran in the years immediately preceding the 1979 revolution.” One of the most interesting things already is the juxtaposition between the American conception of what and who an engineer is and what the Iranian one is. The authors get right to this idea at the very start of the introduction. “Unlike perceptions of engineering in Western socie ties, engineering students in Iran are widely understood to be the most politically engaged students. In fact, it is not considered unusual to be an engineering student and to also be an activist, intellectual, artist, or politician.” I also love the little scathing jabs at American imperialism such as, “Tapping talent from poorer, and often browner, countries has been part of the US playbook for decades.” I hope the book continues to serve this sort of well-researched, academic vitriol.

Nanibgal

I really agree with this. In my own family these ideas of “progress” and “advancement” were implicitly (and at times explicitly when I began questioning American hegemony) tied to “western” and specifically US interests, and that those interests must necessarily come at certain costs, as to be determined by…it was never clear. I remember being told that science and humanities as having a naturally adversarial relationship,but I’m learning (and this book/your comment put very well) that it’s not only possible to merge the two, it is necessary and with precedent. I feel like if we question why that divide is imposed on the field, we find out who be benefits from it.

Nanibgal

I also loved that line you highlighted about America’s playbook. Also, now I’m going to see if I can read “Iran Between Two Revolutions” if I can find it. I am so hyped to keep reading!!! Dr. Fatima does not miss with the book recommendations!

Dr. Fatima

yeah this misalignment as a explanation for underrepresentation of black/brown students is really common in the literature on physics education. most of the 'solutions' i've seen posed seem somewhat superficial (e.g., culturally relevant scenarios as example problems) bc it's so much harder to actually redirect what kinds of things the students go on to work on, but I have seen at least one example of a(n applied) physics department that actually restructured the way they approach research problem defining that resulting in it becoming the physics department that graduates something like 10% of black physics PhD's in the US (I believe it's at the university of michigan, Julie Posselt uses it as a central case study in her book "Equity and Science")

Dr. Fatima

i feel like this is a super valid question to have---i remember one time i was leading a book club on anti-racism in my old grad department and when we got to a reading on cultural racism, everyone could very clearly articulate the way in which the text explained it as a mechanism, and that people/departments can unknowingly impose their culture on students in a way that is harmful, when i asked the group 'so what makes up that culture?' it was crickets. first step to knowing is knowing you dont know!

arcie m

I'm very glad to be aware of and to be reading this book now. Personally, I was finishing up grad school during the first year of the genocide in Gaza. The apathy and amorality of STEM grad students, postdocs, and professors really got to me though and I had to walk away. In my current work as a teacher, I'm finding incredible opportunities in my gen ed classes to have students discuss, analyze, and apply quantitative methods to sociopolitical issues. But with STEM-track classes, it feels like there's less that can be done. The introduction says something about people rejecting STEM because it would be a form of selling out. for such people, I'm inclined to support their position while offering up "STEM tools" for them to reappropriate to do some actual good. This book seems like it will illuminate the culturally-contingency of (a)politicization, which at worst would be nice to know about. I'm hoping that something here will help me reformulate my POV for actual organizing work. Maybe there's something we can do for or as STEM people here.

Mara Pyre

I'm really interested to hear more about what might inspire patriotism or acts of service for the US in immigrants, especially those from the middle east. Just, as someone who lives here and wants desperately to leave, hearing that one of the highest profile studies to assess the damage of 9/11 was spearheaded by an Iranian engineer took me by surprise. I also currently work in airport security and have for the last couple months (while trying to find somewhere to use my physics degree that doesn't have military contracts), and I was surprised at the ratio of middle Eastern immigrants to non immigrants in the staff. I just find it really interesting in a country and in industries with notable anti Arab sentiments and hope that the concept gets touched on more. I also just think it's interesting how a sector known for producing a large amount of military contractors still gets to be seen as somehow apolitical. I feel like that's changing more in recent years? I hear people talk about Lockheed and Raytheon more casually in recent years with the implication that they're obviously evil companies.

arcie m

the path for that iranian engineer to lead the 9/11 analysis project is something im hoping to learn about too, once the book starts disentangling the different political allegiances at Sharif. even in recent years, a high proportion of diaspora iranians in the USA expressed support for US military intervention in iran i always think of the self-selection bias for the immigrants who come here. a lot of them (including my own family) are pro-USA in the first place. this is extra true about iranian monarchists who came to the USA after the 1979 revolution

Mara Pyre

You know, that's a good point that I hadn't been considering lol I was forgetting that people who immigrate tend to be people who can afford to and aren't generally representative of their country of origin in politics. When put that way patriotism makes a lot more sense.