Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

unhinged pluto hot takes from a former astrophysicist 

Music: "Nisyan" by Ahmed Fakroun

Files

Who's Right About Pluto??

unhinged pluto hot takes from a former astrophysicist References: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VtvnF6cemhftWfPE-QnjFD5uqnZzbfWTczly7m-oIqs/edit?usp=sharing Music: "Nisyan" by Ahmed Fakroun Chapters 00:00 - Cold Open 03:25 - Introduction 04:23 - Part 1: What Is Pluto? 19:07 - Part 2: Who Killed Pluto? 38:12 - Part 3: Why Do You Care? 55:07 - Credits + Comment Response

Comments

Maya

I'm obsessed with the velvet pants and the music choice for this video, also to me the whole pluto debate always felt like pineapple on pizza. It's an occasionally fun way to start a fruitless debate, and I used to have a very strong opinion on it but now see the reasoning on both sides and don't really care all that much! Thirdly as a stem girlie I love hearing how you tie in the nuance/subjectivity of science in these videos, it's always helpful to remember how many different things factor in, including social and political motivations.

Shane E Noble

I think part of the problem is the failures in our education system. People I know who are relatively well educated do not understand the basics of how science works. I've had to do a lot of education in my peer group.

Shane E Noble

It's fascinating to me how uncomfortable people are with uncertainty or incomplete answers. Maybe it's because our lives are so chaotic and turbulent, we crave some sort of anchor.

Maya

so true, i think it helps a lot with the uncomfortable gut feeling to view “there are multiple perspectives” or “I don’t know” as the complete answer in itself

Colin Hubert

This is more speculative than scientific, but… Your astrophysics research on Pluto’s dust cloud chimes with my current enjoyment of Cixin Liu’s “Three Body Problem” and “Dark Forest” (will soon read “Death’s End” the third of this Chinese sci-fi writer’s “Remembrance of Earth’s Past” trilogy. I would love to see your takes on the Fermi paradox and the Dark Forest theory. Liu’s fictions are very social, too, with “Three Body Problem” tackling some of the Chinese Cultural Revolution perversions of astrophysical theory to suit ideological fanaticism.

Nadia Kumar

Why do people have such strong emotions about Pluto? I used to be a person who would say „to me Pluto is still a planet“ 😅. I guess I agree with Shane. We live in a time and world, where everything that you learned is „true“, is being revealed as rather relative which questions the existing of truth itself. I guess that’s quite tough for a human mind.

Nadia Kumar

I also love that you ask about the „Pluto in your field“. I do belong to that generation that grew up thinking that the world is made out of absolute facts you can know because mostly old white men said so. And as the opposite of an old white man I always felt a bit uncomfortable with it but couldn’t grasp it before. Will keep my eyes open for all the „Plutos“ out there.

kaetus

This was super good. Thank you.

The Baiterek Life System. Mind Gym.

Hello, Fatima. I'm pleased to learn that you're interested in a wide range of questions about the structure of the universe and life on Earth. I sincerely hope you'll be interested in learning about the results of my many years of research.