Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • 232782847.mp4

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 video. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

i meant what said, fight me  

References:  https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_oj64JAE7J4b6Hz-8xfNEgvH4j7tBHP9i-aj0Lii-Mc/edit?usp=sharing  

Music:  “Alech” by Carthago  

Editing Assistance by Costanza Polastri: https://www.youtube.com/@costanzapolastri

Script feedback and voiceovers by Costanza again and also a bunch of friends who don't have online presences to plug <3

Files

Comments

LIFEBOD

This might be the wrong comment section but nowhere is the institutional bias more obvious than in art - what even gets considered art and thus talked about, critiqued and taught in art schools is extremestestly malleable and very often a direct expression of political climate and elite interests. Check Brad Troemel‘s video on abstract expressionism and the CIA for more. I have less experience with this in computer science (I work as a software engineer but have an art degree), but the field is also rife with these things - early examples might be how programming software used to be thought of as secretarial labor and done mostly by women (and thus arguably wasn‘t as heavily invested in), while the manly thing to do was make bigger calculator.

LIFEBOD

Come to think of it, blockchains are another example - at their core they‘re really interesting epistemologically and could be used to vastly improve democratic processes - not to speak of the original intention having been to abolish banks. But this left-blockchain type thinking is usually laughed off as utopian by the people researching and building basically a reproduction of the current financial system and make line go up.

petros mavromichalis

I am a student of mathematics, and one cultural value I see in my community that I vehemently disagree with is that math is *supposed* to be hard. I often point to Lockhart's Lament and more recently Euginia Cheng's book "The Joy of Abstraction" when I think about how people are turned away from math very early on in school, and how to undo this wrong we inflict on students.

a funky duck

I'm a software engineer too, and this made me think about the cultural bias we have for open source software. Of course in this case it's a wonderful thing. But I only really noticed it because I was indoctrinated into it so profoundly (mainly because it aligns with my own values) and then I had a conversation with another software engineer about proprietary software and how it's easier to make money that way (this was before I became explicitly anti-capitalist) and I actually started considering the alternative. Even though open source is part of our culture as software engineers it's still something we have to fight for so that it stays that way.

LIFEBOD

Good point, especially because the incentives are pretty complex - open source burnout is very real, but the world simply wouldn‘t work without it. The internet was built publicly and then handed over to private corporations for mostly ideological reasons too - the book ‚Internet for the People‘ by Ben Tarnoff is a great read. I also remembered, psychology and how the disease model of mental illness has held the field back a lot - and how this is in large part due to health insurance wanting a clear diagnosis before they pay anything. Eva Illouz‘s ‚Cold Intimacies‘ is great on that, and recent efforts to go beyond it can be found in the Power-Threat-Meaning Framework.

Morhorgorgorf

The question of why we study what we study really resonated with me as a bioinformatician. While my group is involved with more basic research, a large proportion of my lab studies longevity and personalized medicine. I've gotten dirty looks when I answer a question like "what single intervention do you think would increase net longevity the most" with "access to basic healthcare." And fair enough I guess, the room was full of biologists and MDs, not lobbyists and social workers. They want to talk about the cool science because it is really cool, but they also don't ever acknowledge that the current or potential patients they're talking about already have the resources to ensure better lifespans, healthspans, or whatever. I've also observed a strong cultural bias against other fields. It's embarrassing to watch biologists and engineers grapple with the question of how to distribute the fruits of their discoveries to underserved populations. It should be clear, from history if nothing else, that the skills and tools to do good biomedical research do not necessarily transfer to other fields, but they sure do keep trying. All we'd need is a sociologist, geographer, or anthropologist on staff to work on a problem that everyone agrees is very important, but that can't or won't happen for whatever reasons. Sometimes I think that all the coolest scientific discoveries, like genomes or gravitational waves were actually the easy problems all along

MyPperIsBigger

Hey brand new supporter! Came in from the recent video and decided to join cause I loved everything you put out so far. It's kind of a bit jarring to listen to your essays on science since I am seeing a lot of similar statements and critics expressed as I have read in certain "slightly left wing" books that I got recently. Specifically love the focus on the critic of mechanistic understanding of nature and our relationship with it!

Asim A Deyaf

You are gonna hate me for this, but I made this video a while back as a possible way to explain what might be going on with everything. (It's unlisted because it's embarrassing haha.) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QWuZRBUCjgY It's the most simple possible theory of everything from a straight white man (I believe Libyan is technically white) who hasn't even bothered to closely examine other theories, like modified Newtonian dynamics. My theory also eliminates everything and replaces the entire universe with "space ether". Basically, I'm everything wrong with physics culture, and I'm not even a physicist. Haha. Anyway, at the very least, you might find it entertaining and can add another speculative theory to the dark matter / dark energy debate.

Ryan Messina

Love the massive hard hitting question! Systems science here, there is so many cultural issues with the creation of knowledge in western epistemology. In general the narrative of splitting STEM focus or Socially focused as two non intersecting paths is of my opinion one of the largest culture influencing the creation of knowledge. My opinion is that it conveniently sets up a career being linear like base expertise to management then to leadership being a very convenient narrative for participating in a large unchallenged power structure or leave to no mans land. The largest and earliest body of work I know is Ludiwig von Bertalanffy with General Systems Theory to really articulate the “artificial boundaries” of biology, chemistry and physics that society created called science. To solve problems of increasing complexity that does not fit into either of these 3 buckets more areas emerged all around the same time same time (Cybernetics (control theory), game theory and information theory). To cut this short and oversimplify the text introduced issues of cultural factors of pure reductionist ideologies (all problems are reducible into smaller parts, therefore the whole never needs to be considered), pure essentialism (everything has an absolute definition, so there is only black or white) that is within STEM. My opinion is that the framework that was proposed by Ludiwig wasn't very good but I think is interesting that it built on the idea of trying to do justice to the complexities, which would require a culture of integration not a single understanding.

a funky duck

I really like your explaination! It might be unorthodox but it's more interesting than what we have now.

Abject Abundance

My academic background is in sociolinguistics, and I’m a music teacher/musician by trade, and one of the common threads I’ve drawn between these two utterly dysfunctional educational fields is something I think might be typical of Western epistemology writ large: this tendency to conflate representations with the “things” they’re trying to represent. Re: “advancements” in epistemology doing as much harm as good tho, my father was a white mid20th century anthropologist who was literally still having to argue against eugenicists that race has no coherent basis in genetics. But because of that, that’s where his concept of antiracism ends, much to the detriment of his critical thinking about what the paradigm of race does/has done in historical materialist terms. This is why I have a burning hatred for Noam Chomsky, who, imo, is a false leftist icon—in linguistics at least he’s responsible for some of the most revanchist tendencies in the field, hand in hand with these sociobiology/evopsych fools carrying the eugenics mantle of genetic determinism of behavior. Chomskyan linguistics basically comes from that same mid20th century argument against the idea that nonwhite races are different species of human, but then consolidates that argument by universalizing Western subjectivities, which is a deeply racist tendency in and of itself, despite its intentions. And now the likes of Steven Pinker and Jordan Peterson etc have taken that and run with it, to do all the nasty little things they do. It’s ironic too bc his whole shitty reasoning is based on an idea called the “poverty of the stimulus” (the idea that babies aren’t exposed to enough information about communication to learn as much language as they do so quickly, so they MUST just have that stuff in their brain innately already)—-but faced with the erasure of 99.999999% of the data about cultural variety/variability in humans (due to global colonialist genocide and the histories of empire) he apparently had no problem extrapolating a universalist idea of human consciousness from his farcically limited armchair/paper research. …And he still only speaks one language—the caucacity!!!!

Abject Abundance

Yeah totally, this is especially infuriating if you consider the the pre-Boas legacy of white imperial anthropology, specifically about the scientific knowledge of peoples across the global south. Sooooo much condescending projective nonsense, talmbout “magic” and “savagery” and spitting on literally thousands of years of concerted scientific practice. A couple examples I like to draw from: in Thailand some white colonial stooge writes about these silly superstitions about bad ghosts and spirits, for which these people would perform this silly ceremonious ritual to stave them off—you have to sacrifice some fruit and light candles outside in the fields. Come to find out, all the parasitic crop-destroying insects are drawn to the flame, the birds are drawn to the fruit, and then the birds eat all the bugs and you have a successful harvest. Go figure. Another case like this was the racist dismissive view of “shamanic rituals” observed among a bunch of very different groups of people across huge swaths of the Amazonian rainforest, that in each case turned out to be extremely detailed ecological surveys taking into account thousands upon thousands of different animal and plant species, from which they would make recommendations to the rest of the group toward how to adjust their behavior for that period, to prevent any kind of harmful disequilibrium that (as we’ve seen in an overdetermined way with industrial capitalism) could create a cascade of devastating consequences to the ecological system as a whole.

Abject Abundance

Also vis a vis university administrations, I’ve heard from several professors over the years that this cordoning off of fields from each other (particularly STEM from social sciences and humanities), both epistemologically and in terms of physical space, must be viewed in terms of labor alienation as well—the corporate model of running schools is exacerbating that dynamic as a concerted effort to hamstring the labor power of faculty, and administrators are actually tailoring the schedules and locations of professors to hamper their ability to organize with each other across departments.

CrazyDiamond

I work as an energy efficiency engineer in California. We work with the state and utility companies (both municipal utilities and investor-owned utilities like SCE or PG&E) to implement energy efficiency projects, which give financial incentives to customers to install efficient appliances, like LED lights, new water heaters, refrigeration controls, and things like that. It's good for the state and utilities because it reduces load on the power grid; it's good for customers because they can reduce their energy bill and get better appliances in one swoop, sometimes for free; and it's good for the environment because less energy usage means less carbon emissions. But these programs don't really do a very good job of saving energy--at least, not in the places where it really counts. Part of the problem is these programs are entirely top-down. Statewide regulators determine energy use codes as part of the building codes. Building codes are structured kind of like textbooks: you'll have an edition in 2016, and then the next one will come out in 2019 that is mostly the same but will update metrics and requirements based on new data, or will have a few new lines in to account for new technology. They are unlike textbooks in that a few changes can actually have really huge impacts in what is allowed to be installed, and how much power buildings will end up using. Energy efficiency incentives, though, are usually designed to bring customers from the most recent edition of codes to be in-line with or better than the upcoming edition, with the assumption that they already meet the last iteration of energy codes. The problem is, they often don't. I'll give an example. Before about 2000, most offices and workspaces were lit using something called T12 fluorescent lamps. (The "T" designation is its diameter in eighths of an inch, so a T12 is an inch and a half wide.) They developed more efficient T8 styles in the 1970s that finally started seeing wider usage after 2000. But starting in 2010, we started seeing LEDs becoming actual viable alternatives to office lighting on a much wider scale. Between 2016 and 2020 the company I worked for implemented a savings program in Southern California where the main source of our energy efficiency savings would come from changing older T8 fluorescent tubes to newer LEDs, which use about half the energy and don't have mercury in them. The problem was, the program assumed everyone was already on T8s instead of the older T12s, and, while a majority of them were, it certainly wasn't everyone. I'd say a good 30%-40% of projects were made financially unviable because of this policy. And the reasons they were financially unviable? A lot of the businesses that were still using T12s were older, in poorer or more rural areas, or generally just didn't have the access to capital to keep up with code requirements in the past. They were the ones who actually needed the financial help to make the change! Everyone on the ground saw this as a gaping hole in the policy decisions of this program, but that communication was largely ignored by the utility we were working with, and never got addressed by statewide regulators. I think we have a tendency to organize everything in top-down hierarchies in this country, and this is one of the limitations of that approach. We have this fantasy that the "elite" at the top are the smartest and the best decision-makers, but more often than not they're actually very far removed from the realities on the ground. Any knowledge that does not feed back into capital or the hierarchy it is built around is discarded. And I think, ultimately, this is a reality in most industries here in the US.

Wami Ogunbi

I watched this video when it first dropped 3 weeks ago, but I was in the middle of a conference. I think I got back to the hotel at like 9pm that day, watched the video, absolutely loved it, wanted to give a thoughtful response but was not in the headspace to do it because my introverted self was exhausted from the 10 straight hours of networking and listening to extremely dense technical presentations all day and had to be up early the next day to do the same thing again. So I figured that I would wait to write a response when the conference was over...but then I found myself realizing that NOW was the time for me to apply for tenure-track faculty positions and postdocs so that I would have a job next year and the first deadline was just in a few days and... I swear, you only drop these videos when I am hitting major milestones in my academic career....which means...wait, will I be defending my dissertation when you drop the next one? Wait, when do you plan on dropping your next video??? I need to know when I will finally be done with this degree!! Not all of the above is completely irrelevant to what I wanted my original comment to be about. But it has been 3 weeks and my brain is still mush because I am still in the midst of applying to a bajillion positions. Conferences, what papers get accepted/rejected, and the faculty hiring process, who gets hired/turned down, have a big influence on what fields of research deem to be "important." I can't help but think of a peer of mine who submitted a paper to one journal and got badly rejected, but then submitted the same paper to a different journal with minor edits and it was accepted--the reviewers loved it! And since journal papers are the academia's equivalent to currency, it is a huge deal. Who decides what makes a paper publishable/who knows how to play the system well enough to produce many publishable papers? One would think the process is objective...but it isn't. Your video brings up an extremely important aspect of academia that has been hard for me articulate to others and even myself. It is adjacent to the problem of why we don't see academia actually being as diverse as all the diversity posters we see universities always showing off. All that to say...I actually don't know or remember. But if I don't leave my comment now, I don't think that I will ever get the chance to do so again. Anyway. I love your videos. The quality keeps getting better. The intro of this video alone was simply *chefs kiss*. Keep them coming so that I can keep sending them to random people. You are iconic. Keep slaying. Peace.