Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • 238386923.mp4

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 video. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

resources on palestinian solidarity 

q3: Shall We Overcome? Transcending Race, Class, and Ideology Through Interest Convergence

Q6: Shaping the macro-ethical reasoning of engineers through deliberate cultural practices 

Q7: Leaving the “One True Path”: Teaching physics without single correct answers 

Files

Comments

MyPperIsBigger

One physics teacher I remember doing a great job at taking our minds out of the memorize mode and to actually relativize physics to our experience of reality was very early on. She noticed the whole class was having difficulty in application because we were just seeing it as numbers so she took two spheres with her. One made of cast iron the other made of wood. Both of the exact same shape and size. Both very smooth basically equal in all but mass and she asked us if she let both of them fall at the same time. Ofcs most of us went with the intuition of the heavy one falling faster cause even if we knew that gravitational exceleration has nothing to do with mass we hadn't yet realized it. Our minds were kinda blown and years later I still haven't decoupled theory and practice in the regard of physics.

Javier F

Response to Q2: Thank you for your thoughts on keeping things sustainable, I 100% agree! It's something I've been trying to figure out, and something I've noticed a lot of fellow volunteers struggle with. To use a metaphor, we need to remember that changing the world is a 1000-mile journey. If you try to rush to the end you'll either quickly have to give up or run into serious trouble while out in the wilderness. That aside, the only thing I'd add to your response is that preventing burnout is an ongoing practice. Treating activism as a hobby is a good foundation (and it's the way I do it), but activism is tricky because there is always a pressure to do more, to commit more time and energy. So for everyone reading this: Work smarter, not harder! If you're passionate about making a better world, then you don't need to worry about "doing enough". Instead, develop strategies to make sure you're using your strengths instead of your weaknesses. Try different forms of getting involved and see which ones come more naturally to you. Then practice setting boundaries and saying "no" for work that drains you too quickly. It's okay, I promise! That's the beauty of activism in your free time. YOU get to decide how to do it. And in the process we will all move forward, one step at a time.

Wami Ogunbi

The "should I stay in academia" question is so prevalent in academia and speaks volumes about its toxic culture. Why am I choosing to stay in academia? Well, my initial reason was complex and had multiple layers similar to yours (e.g., I wanted to be a professor and you need a PhD to be a professor, external family pressure, etc). Then I went through a phase of jadedness where I was ready to yeet away to industry. But now I am back in my academia phase. I am still 100% jaded. But the way I see it, industry can be just as bad as academia. The difference being, you get paid 3x more and you tend to have better work-life balance in industry, so those perks can offset the negatives. But academia offers a level of flexibility that industry cannot compete with. It also helps that I have started to learn "the game" better, so academia no longer seems as impossible as it did before. A sobering thought, because now I worry that I have lost a bit of my humanity just so that I can "fit in" and be accepted. Can I still enact the change that I am striving for? Only time will tell at this point. Since I am on the academia job market, I would love to see a video about you talking about the dumpster fire that is the tenure-track (and adjunct) professor hiring process. I've been consuming a lot of resources to prepare me to be a better candidate and dear lord! Even the help resources admit to how bad things are. I bet you have a spicy take yourself. Oh, or since I don't want to be that one follower to tells you what videos you need to do (because obviously that is your choice), I will leave this as an office hour question for next time: What are your takes on the academic job market. I'll bring my tea to sip as your answer.

Dr. Fatima

tbh i'm not sure i have a spicy take, I've never applied for professorships yet! I could still try to come up with something, but heads up I don't actually have any experience with it, just in case you want to ask something else lol

Wami Ogunbi

Aww, that is okay. I do have another burning question, but it is a heavy one, especially in light of current events: What are your takes on activism within academia? Thank you so much for sharing those resources on Palestinian solidarity by the way. I went to Israel a few months ago through a school program. The program was skewed Pro-Israeli, even though they tried to present themselves as neutral. Having grown up in the States, my understanding of the conflict was extremely limited and misinformed. As biased as the trip was, it did at least help me finally start contextualizing the information that I was receiving from media and social media. To me, it seems obvious that Israel is a colonizing nation. And yet a lot of my Israeli contacts would deny this assertion. But then I listen to Palestinian people and I cannot help but relate to their struggles on some deep level (the ties that join oppressed groups run deep). The disjointed narratives going around feels a lot like--and I do not use this term lightly--gaslighting. "We aren't colonizers!" the Israelis say as they cut water and power off from over 2 million people literally trapped in a small segment of land whose border is controlled by the Israeli government. "Palestinians are too violent to trust!" they say as they created structures that put Palestinians in poverty and wonder why people are upset? And I met a lot of great Israelis when I went to Israel, some are even pro-Palestinian. But I wonder why news is so polarized in its coverage of the conflict. I also struggle to figure out how much support I can lend as an academic. Standing up against injustice is one of my core values. At the same time, losing favor in the academic community due to my activism can backfire, especially if I get kicked out of the community, and there goes my goal of trying to change things from the inside. Resources like the one you shared are helpful because it helps me more strategically plan on ways that I can help. Sorry for rambling. I have so many thoughts but not many outlets that I feel like I can speak freely on.

Dr. Fatima

ooh yeah, much more up my alley lol. reminds me of a book thats in one of the free ebook collections on the doc i saw called “Uncivil Rites: Palestine and the Limits of Academic Freedom”--gonna read this so hopefully i have a good take for you by the time i get around to recording another office hours. and thanks for sharing <3

Wami Ogunbi

And there is an audiobook version of that book! Excellent, I can give it a listen to ahead of the next office hours too. Pro tip for peeps out there: you can get free access to audio books if you have a library card, at least in the States.

Doctor Qcumber

Maybe you didn't fully answer my question, but hearing additional details about your experience is quite helpful. It's different than my experience, but it helps contextualize it a bit better. So thanks :) On Edison's question, a few ideas came to mind for areas of calculus that maybe involve a bit more exploration than memorization. You can explore thinking of the quotient rule as a combination of the product and chain rules, or integration by parts as the reverse of the product rule. I think there's room to play with these ideas rather than just memorizing them, and I think it leads to a more grounded understanding. If you're ambitious, you could also try to do something like encourage students to build up to a rough idea of Lebesgue integration alongside Riemann integration as different ways you can approach the problem of "find this area." Just some extra thoughts to maybe get the ideas flowing. Also, I basically never see YouTube community posts, so thanks for mentioning the Google doc here. It's nice to go through something well-organized after my thoughts have been so chaotic about this mess over the past couple weeks.

Kevin Hengehold

What happens to the engineering students after they're taught to feel feelings? I scoff at the idea of a professor coming in and saying "how is everyone today?" As we're miserable and bleary-eyed from not sleeping for a week. Which - the change is necessary, it's just hard to picture. More to the point, I really liked software defined radio in the mid to late aughts. Then it came time to interview for jobs, and I got a lot of attention from "defense" contractors. Turns out SDR was how we told drones where/who to bomb back then, so anybody who knew that was a hot fucking commodity (drones were really only for killing and spying back then). Being an undergrad engineer, I believed history and sociology were for weaker minds, but I didn't love the idea of killing people I didn't know/didn't have good reason to kill. So I freaked out, ghosted on a bunch of interviews, went back for a grad program that didn't make any sense, and worked in commercial electronics for a year and half until I left engineering altogether. On the other side of the coin, I can't tell you how many people I DEFINITELY didn't smoke week with in college were able to rationalize their work at Lockheed Martin or Rincon or Northrup Grumman - "If I don't do it, somebody else will," or it's just the best way to pay off student loans. I guess I'm asking if there's any ethical engineering under capitalism, and why bother teaching the kids ethics if it just makes them hate the choices they eventually have to make? Er, what are the impacts of an entry level engineer's ethical code on whatever the billion dollar company is making?

Edison Hauptman

These are good ones! I've taught integration by parts that way every semester; the idea of u-substitution undoing the Chain Rule leads into it nicely. (Bonus question: why don't we learn a way to undo the quotient rule in the same way?) I also try to work with my students' logic when they solve a problem the long way: for example, the derivative of xln(2) is ln(2), and if you didn't realize that ln(2) is a constant, you could do it by calculating 1*ln(2)+x*1/2*0. The extra steps show how specific cases of the general product rule and chain rule are still consistent with everything else.

Doctor Qcumber

Yeah, I think most people teach it that way, but there's a difference between telling them it's undoing the product rule and having them puzzle out how to undo the product rule themselves. That being said, in my experience a lot of times I'm very limited in how I can teach it based on time constraints, but it's still important to think about how you would teach it given infinite time. Then you can pare down that method to fit into your time constraints. It also depends on your audience. I've taught business calculus courses where the students' entire conception of math is "practice this method for this one type of problem, then the next method for the next type of problem, etc." They're only doing pattern recognition. There's only so much work you can do to undo that if you also have to get through a lot of material. (If your bonus question isn't rhetorical, I suspect it's because we already have substitution and integration by parts to undo the chain and product rules, which combine to form the quotient rule. Teaching another integration technique would be fun, but probably not the best use of time. I'd be interested to see if an inverse quotient rule might be a bit faster to use in certain situations, though)

Greg B

I remember Friére as providing public health needs. In other words can you find a population in need to whom you can offer assistance getting an unmet need.

Gnome Choomsky

Dr. Fatima! I know how this sounds, but how do you think it could be shown that, in some sense, time evolved from a flat circle into a spiral?

Dennis Keister

Thank you for these resources that provide the information I have been looking for. You are a good person doing good. ❤️