Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

10/11/2026 Progress Update: Too... Many Variants?

  • I like this new style of writing. I'd prefer more choices and reactivity 93
  • I don't like this new style of writing. I prefer seeing more on one playthrough 27
  • I'd prefer a middle ground. I'd like more reactivity than previous updates but not to this level 255
  • 2026-10-11
  • 375 votes
{'title': '10/11/2026 Progress Update: Too... Many Variants?', 'choices': [{'text': "I like this new style of writing. I'd prefer more choices and reactivity", 'votes': 93}, {'text': "I don't like this new style of writing. I prefer seeing more on one playthrough", 'votes': 27}, {'text': "I'd prefer a middle ground. I'd like more reactivity than previous updates but not to this level", 'votes': 255}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 10, 11, 1, 50, 45, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 375}

Content

Hello Meerkats!

I mentioned in previous progress updates that Week 5 would change a lot for A Mirror's Curse. The most important points were that stats would matter more and there would be more reactivity to your choices.

I achieved that so far! I think what's there so far of Day 29 is very good and has a lot of reactivity. The issue is there may be too many?

Here's a chart to demonstrate what I mean.

As you can see, the latest section in 0.39 (Flag Rush + Dodgeball) is insane. There's 26k words but the average player will only see 2150! That's an 8% visible text to written text. 0.34 had a 47% rate and 0.38 had 38%. You could do 10 playthroughs of 0.39 and see less than you would have on one playthrough of 0.38.

The result of this is that your choices really have weight. The game is better able to account for past decisions, stats, relationships, etc. The trade off is that updates may seem much shorter since you won't be able to see most of text.

So I was wondering if this was too much. I can keep going like this, I don't mind, but the average playthrough would become much shorter. There'd be just as many words, maybe even more, but it'd be spread across many variants.

What are your thoughts on this? Vote on the poll please. I'm trying to figure out how to write the rest of this update. Thank you.

-amaty

Files

Comments

Jurgen

I know It might sound lame but you dont need to make every update with the same level of reactivity. If you write 1 of 3 update with lots of choice the game will still feel like your choice matter with the whole game done. (Sorry I dont speak nor write very well in english and I dont want sound rude I love the game.).

UserEl

I think this is...a bit much, in reality, I don't think most people are going to do 10 playthoughs of the game, and while meaningful choice IS a good thing, you have to ask at some point if each choice is worth the work put in to include it, compared to putting the work in elsewhere I can also see this very quickly turning into a scope creep hell. Especially since the game has had issues with getting out of hand before from what I recall. The more choices you add, the more game-states you have to then account for going forward, the more choices you need to include, etc

Monkey Cottrell

I'm working on a choose yoru own adventure for a class actually and yeah thats how i feel too on it. like its important to not only have meaninfuk choices but also have choices that make the audiance feel likeir making a choice even if in the end it doesn't change the story as much. but yeah. idk its really up to Amaty. I think it can be good or bad its just making sure you have fun with it esp with a lot of work load.

Eric Tahtinen

I'm in agreement a middle ground choice. I am currently maintaining 2 save states with different romance options. My usual playstyle when dealing with a story-rich, multiple choice storyline ends up with the same main choices, but different ROs. My Mass Effect runs are a testament to running the same choices each time.

sseven

I'd advise the middle ground as the option to focus on -- mostly to keep yourself from burn out that's pretty much inevitable when the scope grows too large. Especially if you spend a lot of your time on making large amount of "wide" content, only to see players blow through small part of it in a few minutes and then complain how the update was too small, it's bound to feel unfair/demoralizing.

Matty

I think a big part of the question has to be what do you, as the writer, feels works best for the story you want to tell? Do you have an end point that you're looking to reach and how to get there? I suspect if you're happy in the method, it'll create a much richer experience for us.

Liamélia

Being shorter or not, to me it is the experience of what it it that counts and if I have to do multiple playthrough to read and see the other written words, I say why not. The game is most reactive, the choice matter and the impact may be even more gratifying and/or emotional thanks to that? It is imo at least a really good tradeoff in the end. I get making the update more worthwhile for those reading it as it goes would be nice, but should the final product and the way it comes across when everything will be done, got limited in its application of the stats to favor that? I do not know. To me it feels like limiting the potential impact of your choice to matter in favor of the early access reader's need to have more of it each time, when the experience, in my opinion at least,come from all the choice you are making and not just the reading part of it. To watch and see the choices unfold is my own pleasure in these kind of game, but I also get that other people might prefer something else so 🤷‍♀️ that's pretty much all I can say on this subject. The rest is up to you, your vision and the voting poll at that point :)

Crankie

I do really love the reactivity in the most recent updates. They've felt very climactic with the events with Dad and the Madame being built up. They feel really rewarding but I don't think every day needs to be like that. More reactivity as a baseline would still be great, but I don't think it needs that level of depth all the time. I think them being occasional would also highlight especially reactive days as more special. You've also discussed burnout before so I worry if this higher workload as default would be hard on you.

Monkey Thief

As a few others have said - write what's best to tell the story you want to tell. Sometimes that will be lots of variance, sometimes that will be pretty linear. But importantly, don't burn yourself out doing it! You've got a wonderful story here that I'm sure a large number of people are very interested in seeing to completion.

Nicole Storm

Middle ground choice would be best. Reactivity is good but it does not need to be every update, you can successfully make a game feel reactive even if you sporadically do this (and many of us, myself included, will never play every possible route in this game. Where due to orientation, tastes etc. Or simple interests). Also you need to keep yourself from burn out

Trolldrool

Lack of choices is only a problem if it feels like the story is dragging on, and that's one thing I haven't encountered in your game. Have there been times where it felt like more time passed between choices in one update than the previous one? Yes, but the story flows so smoothly from one day into the next that it doesn't develop into frustration or boredom. I agree with what other people have said about not pushing yourself to the point of burnout, which is why a middle ground might be best. I know of writers who set standards for themselves they couldn't reach, because they tried to make each chapter more impressive than the last. A story is an expression of the writer's vision, and while I'm excited to see your vision when it's complete, the most important thing is that you have fun writing it.