September Suggestion Box Suggestions! #1 (Patreon)
Content
Andreas asked:
What's your most favorite - most interesting - mechanic, that you wish you could employ more, and how do you think it's employed "right"?
My easy answer is 5th edition's Advantage/Disadvantage. That may be a bit of a cop-out, since that's 5e's signature thing, but I really do love it. It's strong enough of a bonus/penalty that my player's don't feel like it's insignificant -- hell, they can immediately see the results right in front of them when they roll those 2d20 -- but it's not so huge that it guarantees success. So I as a DM don't have to be that worried about handing it out too liberally.
This makes things great for both DMs and players, since players get an easy and "tangible" reward for clever thinking, and DMs have something they can give out in those situations without having to think about the ramifications too hard. It really is a win-win.
As for what I wish I could do more, I don't really think that I wish I could give advantage out more (because I do it plenty), but I wish I could do more with it! It's such a great system, I wish I could replace all +/- modifiers with it.
I've heard of DMs doing "degrees" of advantage, like double or even triple advantage (roll 3 or more dice and take the highest/lowest), and I could see that working in some circumstances, so I'd perhaps like to try it, but I'm leery of the auto-success/fail nature it seems to have, so who knows?
I personally have taken advantage even further in the past, and have applied some middle-ground effects that only occur on an advantage/disadvantage check where one result fails and one succeeds (See my Trash Panda entry for an example). And I noticed that Wizards of the Coast also included such an effect in their "Feats" Unearthed Arcana article a little while after that, so I have a tinfoil hat theory that they're watching me and taking inspiration from my ideas. :D
Stay tuned for more, as I go through my September suggestions and do as many of them as I can! :D
~IADnDMN