Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

It's occurred to me that I haven't really done anything with the suggestion box recently, so I figure why not try to catch up on as much as possible right now? Now, this won't be the large, single-question dedicated posts I've done in the past, but I think most of the suggestions I've gotten most recently lend themselves more to this style anyway.

So here we go!


A looong time ago, Camille Witherspoon asked:

What about balanced feat variants for the playable races besides humans? I like playing things besides humans, but that additional feat is just so great that I have a hard time doing so. 

This is hard to do, since thematically, the whole reason behind giving humans the variant feat option is that humans are seen as the super-adaptable, jack-of-all-trades race -- that they can be just about anything; which the feats reinforce.

One thing I think might work is giving different races a feat variant, but having only one feat, or a small selection of feats available -- specifically ones that are thematically appropriate for that race.

For instance, we could have an elf variant that has the choice to start with the choice of one feat from either Alert, Mobile, or Observant. Or maybe a Dwarf variant that can start with either the Durable, Tavern Brawler, or Tough feats.

Now all of these would require further balancing, but I definitely think it's something that's doable. In fact, I'm going to experiment with these a little more, and make a full post on them later if I end up coming up with something I think is playable.


Also a long time ago, Andreas asked:

 What kind of creature is the most difficult to stat out? Monstrosity? Abberation? Fiend? etc. And what are your tips on how to differentiate between them all?

As far as difficulty in statting goes, I don't think any of those are inherently more difficult than the others; it all comes down to the individual monster as far as pinning down individual scores and abilities.

As far as differentiating between the different types, no joke, I once asked Chris Perkins more or less this same question on twitter, and he actually responded! His suggestion was to determine the creature's alignment, and use that as a guide, since devils are always LE, demons are always CE, and monstrosities are almost always unaligned. Aberrations are a bit tougher, since they can be any alignment, but again, I think that's more or less informed by the individual creature in that case anyway.

Other than that, here are my mental notes I keep in my brain to help me tell some of those ambiguous types apart:

  • Beast. This is an animal, plain and simple. If there are any magical or supernatural abilities involved, it's not a beast. The most miraculous thing a beast is going to get beyond natural weapons is the ability to speak a language.
  • Monstrosity. This is very similar to a beast, but monstrosities differ in that they either have magical abilities, or they have at some point at least been influenced by magic. In some cases, the difference between a beast and a monstrosity is simply a matter of lore, as is the case for the Owlbear, since they are creatures originally created by magic; otherwise I'd probably call them a beast.
  • Aberration. These baddies are also pretty similar to monstrosities, but they differ in that they have in some way been altered either by the Abyss, or by the touch of the Far Planes. This means that in general, aberrations are going to be more alien than monstrosities. They will be weirder, darker, and probably nastier than a monstrosity of similar difficulty. This also means that almost all of them are found primarily in the Underdark.
  • Fiend. If it's a devil or a demon, it's automatically a fiend; that's easy. But the creatures that aren't either, but are still fiends are where it gets tough. Fiend basically comes down to alignment: if it's LE, it's a devil, if it's CE it's a demon, if it's anything else, it's just a fiend (though fiends are pretty much unilaterally evil.


Most recently, Andreas asked:

Are there any creatures, posts, ideas, etc. that you have to stop yourself from making monsters of? If so, why?

Yes. Anything from the "Imaginary_____" subreddits, as well as /r/HyrbidAnimals and other fantasy art subreddits. The reason why is because virtually every single one of those posts would work nicely as a monster! If I started hanging out there, I wouldn't have time for anything else, and my account would change from turning random stuff on reddit into monsters, to just statifying every single post on those subs! I don't want that, and I think you guys don't want that either...


And that's all I have for right now. Keep entering suggestions and I swear I'll try to do better about actually addressing them! :D

~IADnDMN

Comments

No comments found for this post.