Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Choosing what comes after Semblance of Emotion!

  • Option 1 247
  • Option 2 138
  • 2025-09-09
  • —2025-09-12
  • 385 votes
{'title': 'Choosing what comes after Semblance of Emotion!', 'choices': [{'text': 'Option 1', 'votes': 247}, {'text': 'Option 2', 'votes': 138}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 12, 3, 35, 13, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 9, 9, 0, 45, 36, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 385}

Content

Poll time has come again, and this time you will get to choose which of these two ideas will take the slot of Semblance of Emotion when that story finally ends. Now that isn't to say that Semblance of Emotion is ending soon because it isn't! It still has a long way to go before completion, but I thought I'd get this out there now, so I have an idea where I'm going next.

These two ideas have some similarities. They're both complete AU's and have fantasy settings, though one is inside a game and one isn't.

Here are the options.

Option 1: Fantasy Remnant AU. Your typical monsters and knights and mages story, with adventurers and guilds, and potential world ending threats. May have very light RPG elements. Things like levels or classes, abilities, that sort of thing. I actually have a ton of different ideas for this one and may need a poll of its own to figure out which one I write, but here are some of them so you have an idea about what will be written.

Idea 1: Jaune flunks out of his prestigious adventurer school when he is unable to unlock his semblance(unique magic power/class) before graduation, so he gets left behind by all his friends. Story of Jaune finding his way in the world the hard way and clawing his way to the top despite all the obstacles that are put in his way.

Idea 2: A story of revenge. Jaune is taken under Pyrrha's wing when he is a budding adventurer but a year into their travels, tragedy strikes. Pyrrha is killed(?) before his eyes, and he almost dies too. But he survives and vows to avenge her death, and take down those who were involved. But it is a lot easier said than done, because there are powers and politics at play well above his station, and the only thing keeping him safe is the belief that he also perished that day.

Idea 3: Jaune Arc is a Paladin, though the deity he swore his vows to isn't your typical one. Salem, the Goddess of Love and Lust, Light and Dark grants him many blessings, and in turn, gives him the ability to bless the world in her name; be it through love, or through lust. A much more lighthearted story.

As of now, they would all be Jaune/Harem but could change for the first two.

Option 2: Modern AU/Game Fantasy World. Jaune has been playing the massively popular MMO 'World of Remnant' for years now, and the latest expansion pack is due to drop. But when the countdown reaches zero, he finds himself waking up in a foreign yet familiar world.

It's hard to say much more about it without spoiling major plot points, but I think I have some pretty cool ideas for it that will tie back into RWBY canon; Ozpin and Salem, and the Brother Gods. Obviously similar to many isekai ideas. If I had to point to the biggest inspiration, it would be Log Horizon. So think of that rather than something like Sword Art Online. A story where game systems begin to blur and even fall away as time goes on.

Comments

thevolunteer

Option 1 only if Idea 1, otherwise 2.

DB

man this isn't an easy choice in the slightest

Rhett Sellers

Either would work, but I must say the idea of a remnant 'reverse' isekai sounds pretty interesting.

John

Idea 3

Paladin'sReach_99

I like Option 1, Idea 1. But are his friends any of team RWBY, and JNPR, or is it something else? But, I do like Idea 3 of option 1 too.

Green One

I like Option 1 Idea 3. The idea of Jaune being torn between duty and temptation would be amusing. Though I wouldn't object to Option 2.

JauneD’Arc

You had me in the first half, ngl. I was gonna vote on the first one just cuz of the blessed by Salem idea, but MAN if I don’t like gamer-style stories done right/well. Just a quick question for clarification: is this “he’s in the game that is now his reality/is real” ala Overlord, or “trapped in the game, but it’s still a game?” I watched a couple of episodes of Log Horizon forever ago and don’t remember the distinction. That bit at the end makes me think the former.

Jcrime

Option one idea 3

lightweaver89

I would prefer Pyrrha not die....but i understand if she has to for the plot. Idea 3 sounds great and more room for fluff

Hanaba

Option one idea 3 tbh

BA

I saw log horizon and I was immediately in for that one

Cory

Option 1 Idea 3. Keep Pyrrha alive.

BCh33s3

Option 1 idea 3

Fortunekuger

I pick option 4, continue Dolls

ch8246

Either AU sounds good. Though for the second one would it be just jaune getting stuck in the game or would the others also get stuck in with him? I could see some funny moments when they realize who the other is! As for the fantasy bit they all sound good tho id want pyrrha to be alive if possible. Would be interesting seeing weiss as a mage or nora a barbarian ( tho they already act like they tbh)

erised fiction

Yeah, other people are also stuck in there as well.

erised fiction

Basically it becomes their reality, yeah. It has 'game systems' in place but over time, those will erode until very few or none remain.

erised fiction

Yeah, they'll be Team RWBY, JNPR, etc. Though maybe some of them are absent because they go to other adventurer schools.

Paladin'sReach_99

Would he be able to see them again, like getting stronger, and hopefully he doesn't become bitter, and become a jerk

JugHerKnot

I would love for a variation of Idea 2 where instead it's the game world that comes to life and superimposed itself over the 'real' world. Like those dungeon manwha

LuckyPickl3

Option 1 idea 1 and 3 don't like 2

theman

Option 1 idea 1 would be really cool imo.

Kottadarc

Option 1 idea 3 sounds great

Crispined Glover Potato Snacks

I like the idea of the light hearted 1/3 idea with the extrapolation of Paladin Jaune being the champion of Salem in her eternal war with her ex-husband Ozpin, The God of defined relationships and moral shades of grey. With Jaune as Salem's champ, Oz has Pyrrha as his champ. Both champs are constantly competing for the Immortal souls of the mortals they gain the devotion of through feats of the heart, mind, and body. In spite their professional antagonism, the two champs are secretly head over heels for each other, and every but themselves and their gods can see it plain as day. Partially inspired by the manga "Love after world domination".

N3wTO_p

Option 1 idea 1 sound very interesting

TheGameWalker 123

Option 1 but you should focus on one person rather than a harem

Roxas Ordic

I'm kinda sad it looks like option 2 isn't in the cards- that sounds a lot more interesting, even if it's not as... spicy... out of the gate.

Falvern

Option 1 idea 3 sounds the most interesting to me

Sundae

option 1/idea 3

Matt

Option 1/Idea 1

Slowchoke

Option 1 with idea 3 cause that seems like a fun whacky time.

Ninoyiya

Option 1 - Idea 1. Always love an underdog story.

Lisa Trevor

Option 1 Idea 3 sounds great. Mainly because the premise sounds ripe for another OC who, like Cerise and Crystal, will have a name starting with 'C' that becomes the dark horse fan favorite and gets ALL the hottest scenes.

mongoh

Option 1 idea 1 sounds like a fun premise

ecool

First: Option 1 - Idea 1 Second: Option 1 - Idea 3 All of them sound like awesome ideas but those 2 are my top picks.