Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter 40

Sam Ribback was on a video call when the advance reviews for Remus Bennet’s album began rolling in. The label had done an internal review as well, and the general consensus had been positive.

The album was not perfect by any means. If one accounted for Remus’s age and how quickly he had made it, one could even call it great. Reviewers, of course, had no reason to make those allowances.

Music was a matter of taste, and Sam had learned long ago not to expect every critic to love a record simply because he believed in it. Still, he knew what a fair review looked like.

“Where is he?” Sam asked Amy Papalia, the woman on the other end of the call. Surely, she must have seen the thing for herself by now.

“No idea,” Amy replied. She was a newcomer to the music industry, but she came from a varied background and had wasted little time learning how to use it here.

“I have been trying to reach him, but he is not responding to my calls.” That was not a good sign.

“Perhaps you could reach out to Elliot or Billie. One of them might be able to get through to him.” Most of the reviews resembled the label’s internal assessment. One of them, though, seemed to have been written with malice.

“Yeah, I should do that.” In all the months he had worked with Amy, Sam had rarely seen her this anxious. She had kept her head even during the Coachella debacle. Now the worry was plain on her face.

The Guardian had given the record one star out of five. Even Ribback had been surprised by the sheer antagonism of the review.

The words were crueler than the score. The paper had called the music ‘trash’ and ‘slop’, but it had not stopped there. It had called Remus ‘Billie Eilish’s vanity project’, then accused him of riding on the coattails of a hardworking, naive singer.

The same paper had just given Ed Sheeran’s new record two stars out of five, so Sam was hardly shocked by a low score. The personal attack was another matter. This went beyond anything he could call ordinary criticism.

That was the part Sam could not get past. The boy had made the record himself. Billie had supported him, yes, and she had put him in front of her audience. The review treated her belief in him as proof that she had been fooled.

“Do you think he has seen it?” Ribback asked. Amy nodded at once.

“Of course he has,” she answered.

“He is not usually the kind to let words unsettle him, but this went a bit too far,” she pointed out, and Sam agreed.

“Yes. Definitely.”

“Pitchfork gave it a 7.1. The Needle Drop gave it a decent seven as well.” The other reviews had landed in a similar range, yet The Guardian’s piece read less like a review and more like a hit piece.

There was little they could do about it. The writer was entitled to his opinion, and the piece was already out there.

“Do you think it will affect him?” Remus Bennet might have enormous talent, but he was still young. He was not even eighteen. Words like those could cut deep.

“I don’t know. That’s why I’m worried.” Amy’s phone lit up, and she looked away from the call for a moment.

“Elliot’s just gotten back to me. They are at a studio near the hotel. He’s with him.” That was some relief.

“Remus has seen the reviews,” she added, reading another message from his best friend.

“He isn’t inside at the moment. He went out for a smoke.” Sam had not known that Remus smoked, but he could worry about that later.

“I’ll go and check on him,” Amy said.

“Please do,” Sam noted.

“And please tell him that we at the label think The Guardian’s review is rubbish. We believe in his music and in him.” Amy nodded.

“Thanks. I’ll see if I can get him to call you. It might help to hear that from you directly.”

“Of course. He can call me anytime.” The call ended, and Sam Ribback sighed as he looked once more at the article open on the screen beside him.

“Bastards...”

.

.

.

REMUS BENNET

Remus Bennet sat on the rooftop of the little studio they had rented for the night. The Australian leg of the tour had ended a day ago. Tomorrow morning, they were meant to fly to New Zealand for his two solo shows.

Billie and Finneas had flown out the previous night. She had almost two weeks off before the North American leg of the tour began.

His album was set to go live in less than seven days. Pre-orders were looking good, and according to Amy, the numbers were not far from Billie’s. Her first album had broken records. To be anywhere near it was a monumental achievement.

If the early numbers held, then the release might do just as well as everyone hoped. He was satisfied with how things were going.

The tour had been a massive success. Despite the added capacity, the venues had been packed, with long lines of people waiting to see them.

He was enjoying his time with Billie and Finneas. Elliot had just put out two singles of his own, both well received, and now his friend was set to open for him in New Zealand.

He and Olivia were going strong, and he planned to fly straight to Utah from New Zealand just to surprise her. Unlike Billie, Remus would barely have a week off. He intended to make the most of it.

They spoke every day, but he wanted to see her again. He wanted to drive around town with her. He wanted to hear her laugh and giggle in that unique, awkward way. He wanted to hear her voice crack in the music booth, and he so wanted to kiss her.

He had spent the last week collecting little things to tell her in person and then forgetting himself and telling her on the phone. It annoyed him every time. Seeing her face on a screen was not quite the same as having her in the passenger seat beside him.

Though he wondered if even that would be enough to get this out of his head.

He had known reviews were coming. He also knew that music meant different things to different people, and that no score could settle whether a song was worth hearing.

Most of the reviews had been good. The Guardian’s was the outlier. He might have shrugged off a one-star rating if the critic had stayed with the music, but the attack had become personal.

The critic could dislike every song. Remus could live with that. It was the suggestion that Billie had made a fool of herself by believing in him that stayed with him.

He had been nervous the first time he walked out in front of her audience. Billie had known and let him do it anyway. He could still remember her waiting just beyond the lights when he finished. To turn that into a story about a foolish girl and the boy using her made his stomach twist.

Billie Eilish’s charity case. Her vanity project.

He had seen those words before in the nastier corners of the internet. This was the first time he had seen them printed beside the name of a major newspaper.

He took the pack of cigarettes he had borrowed from Elliot out of his pocket and lit one. It had been a while since he had smoked, and the first pull made him cough. Then his phone began to ring.

He picked it up. His anger eased as soon as he saw Olivia’s face on the screen. He answered, and the video call began.

“Hey,” she called out, and he waved to her.

“What’s up?” he asked. Her eyes went straight to the cigarette in his hand.

“What is that?” she asked. Remus glanced down and cursed himself.

“It’s a cigarette,” he answered innocently.

“Put that away,” she warned him. “Don’t you know how harmful those things are?”

“It’s all propaganda,” he countered, but she refused to let him get away with it.

“Put that out, or I am never letting you kiss me again.” She knew she had him. He sighed and ground the half-smoked cigarette beneath his shoe.

“Happy now?” he asked.

“Yes.” He moved to a low ledge and sat down.

For a moment she said nothing. She just watched him, and it was obvious that she had seen right through his attempt to act normal.

Olivia shifted her phone, trying to get a better look at him. He angled his own camera away, towards the lights below the roof, but she was not distracted. When he brought it back to his face, she was still studying him.

She was the one who broke the silence. “It was a stupid hit piece.”

“You said it,” he added, and she nodded.

“I’ll say it a thousand times. I don’t know why that man went after you like this. Even people who aren’t your fans think he went too far.”

“Fuck The Guardian,” he said. He did not want to spend the whole call talking about the review.

“Fuck The Guardian,” she repeated, then burst out laughing.

“So, how’s the shoot going?” he asked. It was her biggest project yet.

“It’s going well, though keeping this a secret has become harder and harder.” He raised a brow.

“How so?” he asked, always interested in her life.

“I told you Sofia caught me humming that tune you sent a few days ago, right?” He remembered.

“Well, she told the whole team. Now everybody wants to know what it is.” He had never asked Olivia to keep the song a secret.

“A few of them already think you sent it to me,” she admitted. “And Sofia’s started asking questions about us too.”

“I liked having it to myself,” she admitted. “But every time I catch myself humming on set, someone asks where the song came from. I’m getting tired of pretending it came from nowhere.”

“Then tell them.”

She seemed surprised. “You don’t mind?”

He shook his head. “What is there to mind?”

A call from Amy appeared on his screen. He declined it and turned his attention back to Olivia.

“I like you. I would like to believe you like me too. And if they know you’re working on a song with me, that’s fine as well. What is there to hide?” Olivia’s mouth curved into a smile.

“I’ll tell them on the night your album comes out,” she decided. He had no objection.

“As you wish.” She shifted in her seat and asked him about his plans.

“How’s the Korean coming along?” In a moment of hubris, he had decided to learn the language so he could make a song in Korean as well.

It had sounded like a good idea on paper. Now he was beginning to realise the size of the task.

“Not good,” he answered honestly.

“I’m realising that taking inspiration from geniuses is not a good idea.” He had once read about a nuclear scientist who learned Dutch in six weeks just to deliver a lecture.

She raised a brow. “You’re realising that now?”

He had sent her enough practice recordings that she knew how badly it was going. He would say a sentence with great confidence, look up what he had actually said, and send her another voice message with a groan at the end of it.

“Yup. Good thing I already have an English song ready for the collab.” Olivia’s eyes lit up.

“You finished it?” He had settled the melody and lyrics yesterday. Tomorrow would be his first proper call with BLACKPINK.

“Yeah. Yesterday.”

“Do you ever rest?” she asked, concern slipping into her voice.

He pitched his voice down and sounded like an old man. “I’ll rest when I’m dead.”

“Remus!” she warned. He relented.

“I rest plenty,” he said. And he did, or at least he thought he did.

“Well, then you should do that now.” This was it, then.

“Already?” He was disappointed that they had to end the call.

“I’m sorry. I have an early start tomorrow.” There was nothing he could do about that.

“If you leave me alone now, who’s going to stop me lighting another cigarette?” he teased. Her finger rose in warning.

“Remussss! I’ll know.”

“How?” he asked.

“When I kiss you the next time we meet.” He took the pack out of his pocket and held it in front of the camera.

“Then these have to go.” He tossed the pack over the edge of the roof. Olivia blushed slightly at his antics.

“Goodbye, idiot.” She ended the call. He was about to head inside when the rooftop door opened.

His head snapped towards it. Amy walked out onto the roof.

“Amy?” She was not meant to be here. She shut the door behind her.

“Why weren’t you answering my calls?” she demanded as she came towards him.

“I was talking to Olivia.” The answer took the edge off her anger at once.

“Oh.” She studied him for a few seconds.

“Elliot told me you saw the article.” Of course he had.

“It was a shit piece,” Remus said.

“I know. I don’t want you taking it to heart. It was one man’s opinion, and it was a stupid one. Sam asked me to tell you the label believes in your music. You can call him yourself if you want to hear it.”

He did not answer at first.

He remembered Billie asking him onto the tour. He remembered the two of them working until they could barely hear straight. The man who wrote that review knew nothing about either of them.

The good reviews were still there on his phone. So were the pre-order numbers, the packed shows and every message from someone who had loved a song. He knew he ought to look at those instead. But the one line about Billie kept pushing all the others out.

“I am going to make him regret writing it,” Remus said. Amy’s shoulders slumped.

“I knew it,” she muttered. He felt bad for lying to Olivia, but he was not going to sit back and take the insult.

“For the next year, my songs are going to be everything he hears. Everywhere he goes.” That would be the perfect revenge.

“Remus...” she began, but he was already shaking his head.

“We are doing a second album,” he declared.

Just then, the door opened once more and Elliot poked his head out.

“Hey, can I have my cigarette pack back?” he asked. Remus took a second to answer.

“I kind of threw it away.” His friend’s face fell.

“Why the hell would you do something like that?”

Remus thought about it for a moment, then raised his hands.

“Would you believe me if I said I did it because of love...?”

0000

0000

Pitchfork — 7.1

Remus Bennet tries to sing his way from mourning into morning

The first time many people heard Remus Bennet, there was no label campaign to explain him. There were three songs, spare videos, and a voice that seemed to have arrived at the end of an argument the listener hadn’t heard. “Before You Go” asked a question it could never have answered; “Bruises” wanted to keep the mark a lover left behind; “Another Love” sounded almost angry at its own exhaustion. By the time Billie Eilish invited him into her orbit, those songs had already found an audience.

Then came the charts, a record deal, and the night he walked onto a malfunctioning Coachella stage to hold an increasingly restless crowd together for her. He sang until his voice gave out. His debut has been assembled in the wake of all that attention, largely with his longtime friend and producer Elliot Bane.

The title puts morning and mourning on top of each other, then strikes through their shared U. It is the sort of visual conceit that can look painfully pleased with itself. The music is less glib. Bennet understands how a song can keep someone company without finding a solution to their problem. On “In the Stars,” the distance between remembering a person and having them beside you is almost unbearably plain. “Someone You Loved” has the scale of a crowd singalong, but its real force comes from how small its central want is: to be known and held by somebody. These are feelings pop music has always known how to use. Bennet sings as if he has no interest in disguising that fact.

His voice is the obvious attraction, a rough-edged instrument with surprising control. He can press a chorus until it threatens to break, then retreat into a phrase that sounds barely protected at all. But moUrning works best when he trusts something besides volume. “Grace” lets gratitude sound precarious rather than triumphant; the lighter “Maybe” gives the album a glimpse of a young man who might have a life between catastrophes. “Say You Won’t Let Go” is one of its few songs willing to imagine a future with someone still in it. Its placement matters. Without such moments, the album’s promise of morning would be little more than cover design.

The record’s sharpest turn comes when Bennet stops being the only person permitted an account of what happened. “Somebody That I Used to Know” gives Olivia Rodrigo a verse that challenges his. Her relatively unadorned delivery is crucial: the song grows more complicated the moment the person on the other side can speak. “Dancing on My Own,” meanwhile, takes the supposedly communal space of a dance floor and makes it feel horribly private. Across those two tracks, Bennet looks beyond bereavement and into the lonelier fact that somebody can still be alive and simply no longer choose you.

There are limits to his approach. Several songs head for the same towering release, and after a while the climbs begin to soften one another’s impact. “Hold Me While You Wait” has a convincing plea at its centre, but the record does not always leave enough quiet around such pleas. “Forever” and “Ghost” extend the album’s preoccupation with staying and leaving; by its final stretch, one wishes Bennet had allowed a feeling to remain unresolved without singing it to its highest possible pitch. The songs, made across a startlingly short ascent, still bear the seams between a first batch of viral recordings and the record he subsequently decided they belonged to.

Those seams are interesting. Bennet’s early hits precede Eilish’s public support; her invitation to tour gave an unusually fast-made debut an audience the label could not have assembled in time on its own. The record itself makes a better case for him than either the miracle-child headlines or their backlash. It is overfull, occasionally obvious, and capable of making the obvious hurt all over again.

The Needle Drop — 7/10

Remus Bennet — moUrning | Video review transcript

New Remus Bennet album. It is his debut, although calling it a debut almost feels strange when “Another Love” has been hanging around the charts for weeks and three of these songs were already big before there was an album to put them on.

And yes, he’s the kid on Billie Eilish’s tour. He’s also the kid who sang through the Coachella delay and apparently wrecked his voice doing it. That is a compelling story. A compelling story does not automatically make thirteen songs good, so let’s talk about the songs.

The first thing I like is the sequencing of those early tracks. “Bruises” clings to a hurt because losing the hurt might mean losing the person; “Before You Go” turns regret into a question with nowhere to land; “Another Love” sounds like somebody running out of emotional fuel. There’s a progression there. It isn’t just SAD SONG, SAD SONG, SAD SONG, even if the album occasionally threatens to become exactly that.

Bennet can really sing. I don’t mean that he can hit a huge note, although obviously he can. I mean that he knows where to put the roughness in his voice, and when a line needs to stay small. Elliot Bane, who has worked with him since those early recordings, generally gives the vocal room to do its job. “Grace” is a good example: the repeated appeal might have turned into a blunt instrument, but Bennet lets some uncertainty into it. “Hold Me While You Wait” is effective for much the same reason. It asks for something temporary and sounds afraid even that might be too much.

There are welcome changes in temperature. “Maybe” is lighter, and the record needs that. “Say You Won’t Let Go” actually pictures the possibility of staying with someone instead of only looking back at their departure. That song debuted under pretty unusual circumstances at Coachella, alongside “In the Stars” and “Someone You Loved,” and I think you can hear why those songs worked for an unprepared crowd: their melodies communicate their entire premise very quickly. On a record, though, immediacy is a double-edged thing. When three or four tracks in a row are trying to be the moment, the moments start competing with each other.

My favorite here may be “Somebody That I Used to Know.” Olivia Rodrigo doesn’t come in to decorate his breakup song. She disputes it. Her part is restrained and conversational, and suddenly his hurt is one account rather than the truth of the whole relationship. That is a smart choice, both as writing and as a performance decision. “Dancing on My Own” also gets mileage out of that gap between what is happening in a room and what is happening inside somebody’s head. It is a familiar sort of lonely, and he sells it.

The record loses me a little toward the back. By the time we get from “Forever” to “Ghost,” the accumulation of absence is doing less work than any one well-placed song about it. I also think Bennet and Bane sometimes treat a rising vocal as the answer to an arrangement problem. I’d like to hear what Bennet does when he doesn’t give himself the option of making the chorus bigger.

Still, the striking thing here is that the famous backstory isn’t carrying an empty album. These songs got him noticed before the Eilish tour; the tour amplified what was already there. moUrning is ambitious, a bit crowded, and unusually sure of what a voice can do. It also leaves me curious about what he might make if he stops feeling obliged to prove that on every track. I’m feeling a decent seven out of ten on this one.

The Guardian — ★☆☆☆☆ (1/5)

Remus Bennet: moUrning review — adolescent sorrow on an industrial scale

The capital U in moUrning has been crossed out on the sleeve. Is it morning? Is it mourning? The typography bravely declines to choose. Remus Bennet’s debut takes the same approach to restraint: whenever a feeling can be sung once, he sings it until it has been certified important.

Bennet is seventeen, a fact repeated so often in the publicity that it begins to function as a defence against listening closely. He has a formidable voice. So do many people. What matters is what he uses it for, and here he uses it to drag a series of familiar sentiments up the same steep hill. “Bruises” cherishes an injury; “Before You Go” asks the absent person whether a different sentence might have saved them; “Another Love” discovers that heartbreak is tiring. His throat takes each commonplace and inflates it until ordinary criticism feels indecent. That is a neat trick, though it is not songwriting.

The later material offers little relief. “In the Stars” aims directly for the tear ducts. “Someone You Loved” takes loneliness, strips it of complication and builds a chorus large enough to hide the absence. “Forever,” “Hold Me While You Wait,” “Ghost”: the titles could be shuffled without disturbing the record’s governing idea that wanting someone very badly is itself a revelation. “Maybe” suggests a little air might enter the room. Bennet shuts the window before it does.

The exception ought to be “Somebody That I Used to Know.” Olivia Rodrigo arrives with a reply to the wounded narrator, and for a moment another person’s version of events threatens to unsettle his. Then the record returns to its preferred subject: the sound of Remus Bennet feeling. “Dancing on My Own” does at least put him somewhere other than an abstract chamber of grief, but even a crowded floor becomes another audience for the lonely boy at its centre.

His defenders will point out, correctly, that Bennet’s first hits charted before Billie Eilish brought him onto her tour. She did not invent him. What she lent him was her stage, her audience and, more damagingly, her credibility. It is hard to watch a hardworking star extend that kind of trust and then be told that questioning the recipient is somehow a failure of empathy. Eilish appears to have mistaken a powerful voice and a gallant turn during a technical failure for a fully formed artist. That is her naivety; it should not have to become the listener’s.

Call him Billie Eilish’s vanity project and the inevitable retort is that she does not sing on this album. Exactly. A vanity project need not have its patron’s voice on the tape. It needs the glow of her approval while its beneficiary rides her coattails into rooms his work cannot yet fill. The campaign around moUrning asks us to regard that arrangement as proof of friendship. It is also excellent marketing.

There is trash here presented as testimony, and by the time one reaches the final stretch there is slop presented as catharsis. The cruel thing is that Bennet has the raw material to make something better. He can make a line tremble without forcing it into a climax. He keeps choosing the climax anyway. Cross out whatever letter you like; it will not give this album another idea.

0000

A/N: The reviews were kinda created by AI. I gave it like what I wanted said, and had it create them. I tried to write them myself, but I couldn’t.Music Reviews are very iffy. I personally don’t think they hold any value, given musical taste is very subjective. But, I do think they can be a good plot device. Honestly 3 weeks ago, I didn’t even know there was a thing called album reviews. 😊. I read up some articles, watched a couple of ideas to see what this was about.

Still don’t get it.

Read them if you like, don’t if you want. I just wanted to give you the full story.