Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi guys, BigB here. I've a little confession to make, after being called out on this online.

The graphics from our first release, "My Housemate is a Maid", is mostly (almost entirely) made with graphics lifted without permission from a 10 year old little-known Japanese-only game called Enmusubi.


It's a really shitty excuse, but I had at the time no idea this Patreon would end up so successful. I was being risk-averse, and after having talked to a couple of Japanese VN artists, the costs of getting started was quite daunting (we found other ways to offset this for "Crusoe Had It Easy"). My idea, then, was to contact the developers of any old defunct Japanese-only game I could find and buy the assets off of them cheaply. However, this particular game was almost too old - after several weeks, they still hadn't responded to our e-mail... so I figured, well, suppose I just... use the graphics anyway? What's the harm? They've obviously disbanded. They probably haven't made a profit in forever, and they're not selling the game any longer (actually they are, but I missed this back then). 


This was extraordinarily shitty of me, but it's what went down. I didn't let this on to Taxcup (who wrote the completely original script) or anybody else on the team, which was also very shitty.


Obviously this is not something I'll ever do again. Actually I regretted it as soon as the pledges started coming in (and fast) after "Crusoe Had It Easy", not necessarily out of guilt but because I was worried it would come and bite me in the ass (if I'm being completely honest here). I've now contacted the original artist and hopefully I can make things right by him. I owe all of you guys an apology, as well as one to my team mates. Obviously this doesn't change what we, Marble Syrup, are doing right now, at all - all the scripts and games we're working on are still being worked on, and all graphics are original commissions. We're still aiming to do a sequel to "My Housemate is a Maid" with original HD and HQ art, and possibly re-make the original too with new graphics too, depending on what the Japanese artists wants us to do.


Sorry about this fuck-up! I hope you don't lose your faith in us.


EDIT: So I got a hold of the original illustrator (Luna) who was very gracious indeed and accepted my apology and basically said he was only flattered I liked and used his art. However, since he has signed over the the copyright to Haikara Kissa (who remains unreachable), he suggested it might be best to take down the game, which we've now done. We've also e-mailed those of the other couple of sites that have uploaded it that have an e-mail address listed, and requested they take it down. We've contacted a couple of artists though and we hope to have the game re-made with HD graphics very soon. We'll also take this opportunity to switch over the game to our upgraded engine, making it among other things easier to implement cheats, which we aim to do much in the same vein as we did for Crusoe Had It Easy.

Comments

Anonymous

You may or may not have a problem. You owned it, which was a plus, but only after being called on it. You didn't actually mention the game you stole from or the studio that produced it, which is not all that great either. But, truth be told, this happens with anime exceedingly often, you're not nearly the first to do it. However, patreon exists to support artists, not steal from them. So, this could be a problem, depending on the type of patron you've cultivated.

marblesyrup

Good point, I'll add the name of the game and a link to where you can actually buy it, to the post. Yes, I wouldn't have fessed up without being called out first, so I can't claim any moral high ground, in any sense. It won't be (and hasn't been) repeated, is all I can say.

Strahan

I suppose it's a similarly crappy attitude to have on my part, but honestly IDGAF so long as you keep putting out good stuff like Crusoe lol.

Anonymous

Everybody screws up BigB, nobody can be perfect all the time. I'll be the first to admit that I haven't exactly purchased all of the music and games that are on my hard drive. Though I don't condone what you did in any way, you did own up to it, which is more than most can say about their own actions. In the end, both Housemate and Crusoe were excellent games, and I really hope you gain the support to keep the content coming!

Ginger Faux

Eh? I don't gib a damn. I've seen worse creations here on Patreon (namely a game that was LITERALLY just stock photos of random anime pictures or pictures of, not even Tokyo or Japan, but freaking Dubai found around on the Internet with some dating sim text over it. Talk about lazy, right?) and, as an aspiring game dev, I understand the sentiment. As a dev company/group/whatever, it was y'alls first real game out, right? It's not like you absolutely ripped it off all the way, but something had to be made to help grow your experience and trade as a team. I could excuse something like that. Besides, the pledges aren't necessarily for funding the games specifically. They're funding y'all making the games. It's kind of a different story than if you put up Housemate for sale somewhere. Don't beat yourself up too hard. Mistakes are made to be made. The fact your willing to grow from it is good enough for me, for whatever that's worth.

Mai Ballzich of Korse

While that was an incredibly stupid thing to do, I can see you are at least trying to make amends to the original owners. Just don't do it again, if only to protect yourself and your team from a legal stand point. That said keep up the good work.

Arcana37210

I see. Well, I understand your viewpoint of "where's the harm" after not receiving an answer from the original creator for several weeks. While it WAS still risky, you acted to the best of your knowledge. Not telling the rest of the team about this particular bit, however, was quite a stupid and bad thing to do. If you would've decided this together, you wouldn't have to be the only one feeling bad now. That being said, we all make mistakes. The only thing counting is wether or not we assume responsibility for the actions we took. So while I'll admit that I'm not exactly thrilled with what you did, it doesn't overly disturb me either - and I most definitely am not going to view you any different because of a past mistake that you already apologised for! As long as you guys don't get trust issues because of this and keep on being the good team we owe C.h.i.e. and the script of M.h.i.a.m. to, my faith in you remains unshakable! P.S.: If you redo M.h.i.a.m., I'll be the first one to play it. Just love that plot!

Stangmar

I am kind of on the fence at the moment. I have enjoyed your games, but I really do not feel right about your art theft. Yes you apologized, but as you said you are only doing so because you were caught. I certainly hope you purchasing the assets for Crusoe is true.

marblesyrup

There's nothing untoward whatsoever with the graphics in "Crusoe Had It Easy". I hope you choose to remain a patron, but it's your decision, of course.

Gideon

I personally don't condone piracy and my general impression of anyone that participates in such activities tend to be rather low, and, if I thought it was going to continue I would drop my support immediately (although I am a small supporter, I had thought to up my monthly support. I think I'll wait for a bit to see how this all shakes out now). That being said, I ain't yo' momma. It isn't for me to chastise your illegal activities. I'm in this for the art. As long as everything is on the up and up from now on, fine by me.

A Shapeshifting Mass of Cinders and Ash

I'm feeling really conflicted about the whole art theft thing. On the one hand, I really like the writing, and I really want those cheat codes. On the other hand, I really don't support you making money off of that art, even if it was only a small amount from your initial few patrons. But since it's one member of the team, I don't want to screw over the rest for his dumb decision. So I'm in a bit of a conundrum.

Fawkes1989 Productions Youtube

Well, whilst I do not condone the stealing of the art, the story itself is original, and once it is re-released with original art, there should be no more problem. Everyone draws inspiration from somewhere, so it's not that hard to see why one would want to, for example, copy the art style of someone who inspires you, but no more stealing art, okay? *slaps wrist*