Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

My father was smoking a blunt out of the window of his car when he told me that he was moving to China.

I didn’t have any strong feelings about this because I had only just met him. But I asked him why he was going there.

He said:

“To hide.”

He died there a few years later and we weren’t able to get his body back for the funeral.

He was a bad guy. Kind of the prototypical bad guy. Beat his wife, abandoned his kids, had a temper and an ego. He liked to get drunk and high and drive around, and he spent a lot of time telling you his opinion.

When my ex girlfriend met him she said “He’s like you without all of the good parts.”

My mother was always careful to tell me the truth about my father. He’s violent, and that is why we left. He’s unreliable, so don’t trust him when he makes a promise. He could see his kids but chooses not to. My little 3 year old ears learning to listen with words like these.

But she was also careful not to demonize him. He wasn’t all bad. He was charismatic and generous. He was handsome and smart. He was funny and he could dance.

You look just like him.

The unrivalled star of the funeral. You look just like him!!! Knocking family members flat with a face I inherited from a stranger. I met dozens of relatives I had never known, barred from my life by a lie, and they told me their favourite stories about my father, as though it were camaraderie, as though it were communion, unaware that I didn’t know him like they knew him.

You look JUST like him. Spitting image. Reincarnation.

So casual, the way he invited me out. After 20 years I was only given 1 days notice. “I’m in town, wanna get dinner tomorrow?” As if we do this all the time.

When I opened my front door his first words to me were “Can I use your bathroom?”

… sure.

He just rambled on about his opinions and theories about everything and everyone until at some point I snapped and went for his throat. How do you live with yourself? What were you thinking?

He said if he didn’t leave us he would have killed me. Not my mom, not my brother, but me. Because unlike them, I’d fight back.

I would.

Later my mom reminded me that she left him, not the other way around.

Then I saw him that second time, a couple years later. Why does he never make eye contact with me? The only time I remember him looking directly into my eyes was when he said he would’ve killed me.

He had this skittering conversational style where it seemed like he was never really listening until an hour later when he references something you said verbatim. So you were listening, you just don’t make me feel listened to. Why don’t you make eye contact?

“I would have killed you.” No apology, just a statement. As though it weren’t up to him, and he did the most moral thing there was to do.

I didn’t grant him clemency. I gave him nothing.

I suppose being confrontational doesn’t make people particularly want to make eye contact with you. But I didn’t open like that. He was slithering as soon as I opened my door, but I was cordial until I broke. More than anything I was just trying to pin him down so I could actually learn something about him beyond his affect. Like a biologist trapping a cockroach in a glass.

I was doing recognizance. I wanted information. I wanted to study the foreign half of my DNA.

That’s why I asked why he was going to China. A lover? Certainly not. Not about to start sacrificing for others now. A job? Kind of. He was teacher, or something like it. He said he taught English in Thailand, but it always seemed like he was lying or leaving something out.

“To hide.”

I felt in that moment that I had finally learned something, but I didn’t know what.

...

How revealing. That’s a statement of fear. Or exhaustion.

You hide when something’s coming for you, and you can’t defeat it or you don’t want to try.

Fight or flight, hide or seek.

What would be coming for you that you need to hide from it on the other side of the planet?

Guess it got him. He died a year ago and no one knows how. He had a pacemaker, so probably a heart attack. He was fifty-something.

My grandfather also died of a heart attack at fifty-something. It happened after an altercation with his son. The story goes, the son screamed something nasty at his father and then stormed out of the building, unaware that those were the last words his father would ever hear. Grandpa dropped dead right as dad left.

I heard from others that my father harboured tremendous guilt about that. He felt responsible. Guilty, responsible. Those are funny words for him.

So that’s two generations of willful sons dying at fifty-something of a heart attack. I turn 25 this month. Spitting image. Halfway done.

Maybe that’s where this sense of urgency comes from. All that anxious energy and intensity. I’m running out of time and my body knows it.

Fight or flight. Always life or death, always high stakes, always fighting.

People admire me for that but they also resent me. My mother says it’s jealousy. My passion intimidates people and they want to shut it down so they feel less insecure about their lack of passion, or their fear of taking action. But that’s a very Mom thing to say—Child, the reason people dislike you is because you are so incredible.

There are other reasons to dislike me for that intensity.

For example, I am more familiar with lengthy confrontational texts than one should be. I am a craftsman of apologies from sheer practice. In this never-ending mission to be as interesting as possible I bruise egos and hurt feelings and violate unwritten emotional boundaries. I can only imagine the mild ache of anxiety that comes with being my friend. I might be incredibly supportive and funny and fascinating, but I also might be rude and insensitive and domineering. All that wild unearned confidence. You must never know which way it’s going to go. You must feel affection tainted by apprehension.

I have incredible friends these days. They confront me directly if they have a problem with me. They are communicative and I can correct. My heart is good and they know it. But I wonder about the conversations they have with each other, in between the harm and correction. I wonder how much negativity I bring into their lives that they then shield me from. I wonder if I’m the only friend they feel this way about. I wonder if I’m worth it.

It makes you want to hide.

My lovers tend to say they feel like a lower priority than my work. They might feel that way because they are. I want to finish all of this before I die, and I’m already 25. Tick tick tick.

When you get older, you garner more responsibilities. I will owe my wife or husband more than I owe my girlfriend or boyfriend. I will owe the partner I live with more than I owe a partner who has their own home. Then when you have a child, your life is fucking over. Nothing is higher priority than a screaming shitting crying pissing baby.

I mean it with reverence. Love takes you away from yourself. The center of the universe shifts from you to another. Reincarnation.

I look forward to it.

But he was immune to that.

He was immune to all of it.

…

“Your father used to say that exact same thing.”

On the phone with my mother, I say something that triggers a memory she never ascribed much importance to.

He was always urging her to be more independent. Get out of the house! Go see your friends! Do something for yourself! But she only ever wanted to stay home with her baby.

My mother says wistfully, lovingly, guiltlessly:

“Perhaps that was something that I did wrong.”

An ocean of empathy surges through me.

Over dinner my father asked how I could miss something I never had.

I have done nothing to you, and still it is not enough.

My lover suddenly bursts into tears, and I look up from my writing. I have been so distracted all day they feel invisible.

I have done nothing to you, and still it is not enough.

My friend tells me that I hurt their feelings. I apologize and modify myself.

My absence would be a gift.

I imagine my mother in my home all day with a screaming shitting crying pissing baby. 

I see myself through my fathers eyes.

I want to hide.

Comments

mango

so many thoughts but one that keeps popping up is I feel like story in this prose could parallel the story in the song Thumbs by Lucy Dacus, what with the anger towards someone who is both in and out of your life, towards a self-destructive force you can’t help replicating, the want to kill someone, etc. etc. it’s very interesting and well done and I’m going to be thinking about this for quite a while

Katy Gravenor

I pray for your continued course of healing. Your words echo those of a close friend of mine, also wrestling with a resemblance to a drunk and violent father who has since passed with a narrative that satisfies no one. Thank you for sharing your heart, your pain, your art, your soul, and know that we hold it gently.

dn.agfn

I read this more than a year ago but I always come back from time to time to feel understood. Thank you!

zooey

Jesus. I want to sit with this for an eon.

Kat

Reading this made me feel like I just got punched in the gut (in a good way)

Lux ❤︎

In response to “my absence would be a gift,” a tough thing to hear that helped me in with this thought in the past: The people in your life are there because they choose to be. Thinking they’d be better off without you assumes you know what’s best for them. Thinking your absence would be a gift robs them of their agency. Who are you to think you have magic powers that can force people to be with you against their will? That you know their decision to spend time with you is wrong? How can you possibly know that they would be better off without you? The people who choose to spend time with you do so of their own accord. I was going to say the exception might be family, but if anything you father has proven that even family is no exception to this rule. Being present is a choice. As for those who stay when they don’t want to, their choice is their responsibility (provided you’re not coercing them.) The friends and lovers who have called you out on things and shared discontent have shown that they give a shit about you and the relationship, that a part of them would rather stay and work things out rather than walk away and leave things unspoken. /unsolicited parasocial internet advice

BestStressed

This was beautiful, and makes me want to write something equally personal back, which I think pretty much perfectly encapsulates the danger of parasocial relationships. :) Regardless, I hope you're doing okay, and generally living in some middle ground between unrelenting effort and hiding until you die.

Suave Klutz

Are you having a mid-life crisis?

John

Beautiful writing

Emma Privett

This is brilliant. I often ponder the good and the bad I have received from my parents, and I feel like you really hit that hard in this piece

annie liz

Tethers to those that gave us life can either fuse to us or snap. I don't know what has become of mine yet, either. Thanks for having the audacity to stay

Ryebread

I wrote something very similar to this in college, only I have two dads. One by birth who I look exactly like who denied paternity & the other by adoption who I also look exactly like somehow but the lord works in mysterious ways. I notice I have more reverence for my paternal relationships & a lot of resentment for my mothers, birth & adoptive. I’m close with them, but I resent more what of them I see in me. “Weak women” make me wanna die. Being weak myself bc of them - even worse.

TzaraSchmara

It's strange attempting to opt out of what feels like a genetic destiny. When people tell me I am so much like my mother, it terrifies me. I only see her now, a person so destroyed by mental and physical trauma that she can hardly leave her room and engage with the world. Sometimes she can only engage with me to gift me anecdotes about her horrible life, attempting to assure me that it could always be worse. As my health continues to fail me, I witness my mother funneling what little energy she has left into caring for her abusive parents. I don't understand it, truly. How can she continue to neglect the needs of adult children in favor of people who traumatized her and laugh about it? And yet, I think about how I've planned the entire trajectory of my life one the assumption that I must care for her. For my father. For my brother, who is far less adjusted than I am. I'm 27 and have already had organs shut down. A recent surgery that sterilized me for fear that my quality of life would continue to decline due to my illness. I've spent more time in hospitals than I have classrooms. I think my mother fears that I will end up like her as well. Pushing my mind, body, and spirit so far past their respective breaking points by taking care of others. One day, I may no longer be able to take care of myself. She spent today alone in her room with the TV again. A day off from the nursing home and her ungrateful parents, and from anyone who could possibly help. She says she's tired. That she's given up and she's ready to die. I can only bore my friends with scholastic ramblings. I have no time to invest in a lover, and my womb can no longer carry a child. The only people I can potentially be of use to are people that already view me as a liability. I try not to speak up about the crushing weight of self-imposed responsibility. About the fears that my body will complete its betrayal of me long before I can become a person that my loved ones can rely upon. I see myself from my mother's eyes and I want to hide. To duck and cover from the ticking time bomb. Who will bear the shame, in the end? Me, for not fighting harder, progressing through life faster, becoming one of those full-fledged adults I keep hearing about sooner? Or her, for fighting so hard for so long that she can no longer offer guidance to her children? It depends on who ends up in hospice first, I suppose. I don't want to be like my mother. I'm not ready to die.

Seoyoung Park

Was crying before this, but now I’m crying even harder. Feel this so deeply

Yonbon

Beautiful, heartbreaking; thank you for writing and sharing.

Ray Goldberg

hey uh. damn. very cathartic to read the stories of other nonbinary mixed race weirdos w family trauma. thank you.

Nick Ha + Swan Song

ngl I was not expecting you to circle back and empathize with your father by the end of this. Love is a heavy responsibility. It makes us want to give so much, but fear that what we have to give won’t be enough, or might even make things worse. And sometimes that responsibility is… terrifying. All I can think of is: “servitude requires, yes, humility, but it also requires your self-esteem”. You have so much love to give to the world. I hope you can see that the world is better off for it.

Anh Pham

What a great ending lyric.

Chizzle

I really enjoyed that Thanks for sharing dude

Robin!

I both can and can't relate to this in significant ways. I guess thats the effect of powerful writing. I also see parts of himself in myself, fear those parts, and resent him. But he does live, and as far as I know still interacts with my siblings. As far as I know, because I don't talk with them much anymore either. I also feel a fire for creativity in myself that takes precedence most of the time, but I am not so social to even have close friends or lovers. No resentment on my end, not anymore anyway at 31 years of age, just not the seas I was built to weather. But I do worry that I don't think enough of others, don't spend that time building up knowledge of them and warmth with them. Anyway, exceptional writing, as always. I hope, for both our sakes, we find out how to best be ourselves in whatever time we have left

Tegan

holy shit.

Laura

My alcoholic father though not hitting me and my mother was love, the absence of physical violence is love and his presence was enough. How can you miss a father you never have, I search for fathers all around, not in my partners but in profesional father figures in older male friends. I search but they are nowhere to be found, my search continues

Alnomds

I read this while listening to eradicate and honestly (not to ignore the heavy topic or anything) a vibe

Ang

This hit dead in my heart. Especially the confrontation and apology cycles. I'm glad there are people in the world besides myself who are confrontational. We're the ones who call BS when we see it. We're the ones who share the truth with others, and truth born of love is the highest gift and respect you can give to someone else, imo. I'm glad you exist. Your existence has been more of a blessing in my life than you may ever know. Thanks for writing and sharing this beautiful prose with us.