Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Chapter CCLXV: The Truth of the Incineration

“Lady Nimue…” Bedivere murmured.

So it was like I’d thought. This was Nimue. She looked an awful lot like King Arthur, almost like they could be sisters, but where Arthur’s eyes had been that bright, venomous yellow, hers were a soft, watery blue. Fitting, all things considered.

“Hold on just a second!” Rika interjected. She jabbed a finger at the sword sheathed at Bedivere’s hip. “I’ve seen Excalibur before — in Salter’s hand, sure, but still — and that looks nothing like it!” She narrowed her eyes on Bedivere. “Unless Merlin disguised it with a spell somehow!”

“Lady Rika,” Bedivere tried, but Lisa’s laughter cut him off again.

“Oh, not bad at all!” she said. “That’s one hell of an intuition you’ve got there, girl!”

I held in a sigh. “Lisa —”

Lisa shook her head, still grinning. “Oh, no, no, I’m being completely genuine here. She’s got the right idea, she’s just looking in completely the wrong place.”

“But if it’s not the sword…” Ritsuka trailed off, brow furrowed.

“It’s the arm,” said Shirou. His lips quirked to one side in something resembling half a grimace. “Sorry, but there’s no point in trying to hide it anymore.”

“No, I understand,” said Bedivere. “I appreciate your discretion before, but it seems I will not be able to avoid the truth now.” He sighed and looked down at his prosthetic right arm, stare locked on the palm. “Yes. The king’s holy sword, Excalibur… It is hidden inside this silver arm of mine.”

“I knew there was something suspicious about that arm,” Ishtar muttered triumphantly.

“How?” I asked.

Bedivere shook his head. “It is some sorcery of Lord Merlin’s. I could not hope to explain it. As I am ill-equipped to face my brethren on my own, he saw fit to fit me with this weapon — to help even the odds, as I believe the saying goes.”

“That’s not what I’m asking,” I said. “How do you have Excalibur? Why? The only part of your legend that involves handling it at all is you giving it back to…”

I gestured at Nimue, who was watching patiently.

“Yes.” Bedivere’s prosthetic hand curled into a fist. “I suppose it is high time I explained myself properly, isn’t it?”

He did not look up from it.

“Sir Bedivere?” said Mash. “Um, if it’s a personal question, it’s okay if you don’t answer it. If it’s not something we need to know, then you don’t have to tell us.”

Bedivere shook his head. “That is precisely the problem, Lady Mash. If we are to continue from this point, then it seems now that it will indeed be something which you will need to know. Surely, before we face the Lion King directly, at the very least, and there may not be time later to offer the fullness of the explanation.”

He paused for a moment, and then delivered the next part with all the grave solemnity of a dropped bomb: “I am responsible for the Lion King.”

The news rippled out across our group in a wave, and I could see the ones who had figured it out or already knew by their reactions or the lack thereof. Shirou, for example, did not seem surprised at all, but Emiya’s brow drew down and his mouth pulled into a tight line. The twins looked as surprised as I did, but there was something in their expressions that told me they had already figured out the same thing as I had: that there was more to this story than that simple, blunt announcement, and whatever he meant by it, he didn’t mean that this whole thing was his idea gone awry or something like that.

I wanted to say the idea of Bedivere as a schemer was ludicrous because he didn’t seem the type…but all of the best schemers were the kind of people who didn’t seem like it on the surface.

“What do you mean, Sir Bedivere?” asked Mash. “You’re not saying…”

“I’m saying that the Lion King’s existence is the direct result of my own decisions,” said Bedivere. “If I had not acted as I did… If I had merely had the courage to do what was necessary, then the Lion King would not exist.”

“Come now, Sir Bedivere,” said Holmes. “Do try and stick to the facts, would you? Taking responsibility is only a virtue when you are not ignoring the agency of others in the process. Tell us all more precisely what you mean.”

Bedivere was quiet for a moment, and then, at length, he began, “If you are familiar with events as they occurred in proper history, then you will know of the Battle of Camlann, where Sir Mordred and King Arthur wounded each other grievously. Sir Mordred died shortly thereafter, but my king… my king clung to life. Feebly, weakly, and by a mere thread, but he clung to life. As one of the sole surviving knights, I took him to rest beneath a tree in the nearby forest and prepared to seek whatever aid I could to restore the king to health, but…”

His voice broke. He couldn’t seem to get the words out.

“But she was dying,” Shirou said for him. Bedivere nodded.

“I did not want to accept it, although some part of me knew it to be true,” he said thickly. “Before I could leave to find help, however, the king spoke to me. He bade me to take his sword, Excalibur, and return it to the nearby lake.”

It was probably one of the most famous stories in Arthurian literature: King Arthur, mortally wounded, handing Excalibur to Bedivere and commanding him to return it to the Lady of the Lake. Twice, Bedivere deceived his king and hid the sword, and when asked what he saw, he spoke of grass and trees and the gentle waves of a tranquil lake. Only on the third time did he actually throw the sword into the water, only for an arm to reach up from the lake, seize the hilt, and sink back below the surface.

“I knew what it would mean,” Bedivere went on. “Excalibur was a symbol of the king’s rule, his life. To return it to the lake meant that the king’s life was ending. And so I hid the sword out of sight, where it might be retrieved later, and returned to my king. Thrice, I returned to his side and lied to him, and thrice did he command me to commit the deed in truth.” His head dropped. “It is the only order of his I have ever disobeyed.”

Hold on a second. “You said you returned to King Arthur three times and lied to him all three times.”

Bedivere gave a short nod. “I never returned Excalibur to the lake. My king’s final command…went unfulfilled.”

“A departure from history as we understand it,” said Holmes. “As the story is known, Sir Bedivere, you only lied twice, and on the third trip to the lake, you followed your liege’s command and threw Excalibur back into the lake, where,” he nodded at Nimue, “the Lady of the Lake accepted it.”

But what difference did one more lie make? If King Arthur was dying, then either he would hold on just long enough for Excalibur to be returned or he would die if Bedivere took too long to actually do it. Either way, it should have led to Bedivere doing what history said he did, or at least the version of it that filtered down through the myths. How did that result in the Lion King?

“When I returned for the fourth time, another lie sat upon my lips,” said Bedivere. “I was prepared to continue deceiving my king, only… King Arthur was no longer there. There was no body, no trace of the king. It was only much later that I understood: my instinct was correct. So long as Excalibur was not returned to the Lady of the Lake, King Arthur would not die, and so he did not.

“What terrible, unspeakable misfortune forged the Lion King from the noble King Arthur, I cannot say,” he went on. “Only that the Lion King would not exist but for that unforgivable sin I committed. This Singularity could not exist but for the same sin. That is why I say, it is my fault that the Lion King exists and my responsibility to correct it.” He held up his silver arm. “That is why Lord Merlin granted me this silver arm and hid the very sword I failed to return inside of it. That is why he sent me here.”

“To defeat the Lion King?” asked Ritsuka.

Bedivere shook his head. “To return the sword to its proper owner and undo my mistake.”

What? But, “That doesn’t make any sense.”

Bedivere looked at me, brow furrowing. “I’m sorry?”

“The thing you failed to do was return Excalibur to the Lady of the Lake.” I turned towards Nimue. “So if you’re going to correct your mistake, the person you should be returning that sword to is right here.”

“Indeed,” said Nimue. “And so, I will say again, Sir Bedivere: there is no need to continue fighting. There is no need to destroy yourself in this pursuit. Leave the Sun King to the Chaldeans, for they are well-equipped to do what they must against him, and return Excalibur to me, as you were meant to. You may rest at last. The mistake that is the Lion King will be undone, and history will return to its proper course.”

Bedivere did not answer right away. “Is it really that simple?” Ritsuka asked.

“If the distortion caused by a Singularity may be undone by correcting the circumstances which created that distortion, then it would stand to reason it truly would be, yes,” said Holmes. “Ergo, if the distortion that created the Lion King was caused by Sir Bedivere’s failure to perform the act which history says he was meant to, then that distortion itself should unravel through the completion of that selfsame act. Sir Bedivere, if you return Excalibur to the Lady of the Lake as King Arthur commanded on his deathbed, then the Lion King should cease to exist.”

“Unless the Lion King isn’t King Arthur anymore,” said Emiya.

Bedivere wasn’t the only one to turn to him. “What do you mean by that?”

Emiya shrugged. “It’s just a hunch,” he said, “but Romani and the Director have been freaking out about the Lion King’s Saint Graph just about every time the topic comes up, and that First Hassan sent us here to ‘discover the truth’ of the Lion King. If it was as simple as getting Bedivere to tell us everything he knew, then there wouldn’t have been any need to send us here first. He could have forced it out of Bedivere right then and there.”

That…was actually a good point. I wasn’t sure he was necessarily right, but the First Hassan had all but stated that the Lion King had somehow become a god, and depending on how that worked and how that was even possible, there might not be enough of a King Arthur left for it to count. On the other hand, returning Excalibur, the signature weapon of King Arthur, to her might conceptually make her King Arthur again, which would mean she was no longer the Lion King and therefore wasn’t a distortion anymore.

I wished that made less sense to me than it did.

“I…don’t understand,” said Bedivere. “I told you just now the cause of King Arthur’s distortion. Even if the Lion King has become something far and away from the king to whom I swore my allegiance, how could he be anything but King Arthur?”

“You’d be surprised how finicky conceptual things like that can get,” Emiya said wryly. “If whatever process she underwent after your failure transformed her radically enough, then she might not be King Arthur at all now.”

There was also another thing to think about. “We still don’t even know how it is she got here. It could be the thing the First Hassan sent us here to learn would tell us not only how she became whatever she is now, but also how she arrived inside the Singularity, too.”

“Oh, right,” said Ritsuka, “because Ozymandias said the original cause of this Singularity was the Crusaders getting ahold of the Holy Grail, didn’t he? And if he didn’t summon the Lion King…”

It didn’t make much sense. If she was supposed to be on the side of proper history, then either she had one hell of a way of showing it or she went rogue at some point and started doing her own thing. Neither of those possibilities really felt right, all things considered, although I didn’t have a better explanation of how the Knights of the Round Table we’d met so far seemed to know who we were and what we were doing here. Not unless they really did have Morgan le Fae on their side somewhere.

“There have been other instances where seemingly unrelated people were pulled in across time and space,” Emiya hedged, and then he acknowledged, “but seven hundred years would be the biggest gap we’ve ever seen.”

“I’m afraid I can offer you no answers on that subject,” said Bedivere. “However… Lady Nimue, I must beg your forgiveness and your understanding. Even if it was a certainty that returning Excalibur to your care would be enough to undo the consequences of my mistake…” His real hand went to his shoulder, to where the Airgetlám attached. “It would not be enough to absolve me of my sin. I cannot return Excalibur to you simply because it would be easier or more convenient. I will stand before my king, return Excalibur to his hands, and accept whatever punishment he sees fit to dole out upon me.”

My mouth twitched. I wanted to be more surprised. Objectively, the more correct decision would have been doing what made everything quicker, easier, and less dangerous for all of us. But I had to admit, if I was in his shoes…I think I would have made the same, exact choice. To do the harder thing because it felt more right, even if the easier choice wasn’t wrong.

Nimue’s face fell, and so did her arms. “I see.”

“That guy is going to be unbearably smug, isn’t he?” Lisa needled. Nimue shot her a warning glare.

That guy?

“Well!” said Holmes. “This was not an entirely unexpected outcome, I must say. Being the kind of man that you are, Sir Bedivere, I thought it more likely that this would be the choice you made, so I suppose the following course of action needn’t change to adjust, does it?”

“Yes,” said Bedivere. “The task bestowed upon us by the First Hassan, to discover the truth of the Lion King and the Incineration that has created this Singularity. I confess, however, that I do not quite understand how we are meant to do that. If we were meant to speak to someone here with knowledge of the subject, it seems rather…peculiarly empty here.”

“Now that you mention it,” Mash said, “I would’ve expected someone to come see what was going on when we started fighting the defenses, but there’s no one here.”

“And all of the equipment is still running smoothly,” Lisa said in that tone of voice that said she knew the answer already. “Isn’t that strange?”

Holmes sighed. “Miss Wilbourn, there’s no need to tease them.” To the rest of us, he said, “Although I would have thought the answer would be obvious, Miss Kyrielight. True, this Atlas Institute was pulled along when Ozymandias was summoned into this Singularity. Your mistake, however, was to assume that it was the Atlas Institute belonging to the same era.”

Wasn’t that the natural assumption? If it came along with the desert that was Ozymandias’ kingdom, shouldn’t it be the corresponding version of Atlas?

“You mean it’s not?” asked Ritsuka.

Holmes shook his head. “No, no,” he said. “Although I suppose I can’t blame you for assuming as such, considering you haven’t the eye for the details that I do. No, Mister Fujimaru, the Atlas Institute in which we now stand is none other than the very same Atlas Institute which exists in your own era. That is to say, this is the Atlas Institute from the year 2016 whence you came. Does it not only make sense, then, that there would be no one here?”

“They were all incinerated with the rest of humanity,” Mash whispered, understanding spreading across her face.

“Just so,” said Holmes. “An inconvenience for our purposes, of course, since there is no one available to assist us with accessing Tri-Hermes and utilizing its functions. Moreover, Tri-Hermes was designed with the alchemists of Atlas in mind, so it may take some effort to understand. It most certainly contains recordings of the data we desire — that is not in doubt — but the results will likely resemble something more like a complex mathematical equation than simple text that might be perused as one would a novel.”

Before we got down to that…

“You never told us what you were here looking for,” I said. 

Holmes smiled. “My apologies, forgive me for the oversight. I believe it will all make more sense once you hear my request for yourself.” He turned around, putting his back to us, and stepped closer to the central obelisk, the tallest of the bunch. “Tri-Hermes! Thrice-greatest scholar, collector of all knowledge, I desire an answer to my question! Tell us of what occurred in the city of Fuyuki, Japan in the year 2004! Tell us of the Holy Grail War whose records have all been erased from the annals of history!”

The symbols etched into the face of each pillar flashed with a brief buzz and a high-pitched chirp, and then, I had to assume, it began compiling the information for him. I might have thought it was instant or near enough to it, like looking up something on a search engine, but then, if the amount of information it had access to was as large as Holmes had implied it was, it had a whole lot more to sift through and collate before spitting out a result.

“The Holy Grail War in 2004?” asked Mash. “Um, Mister Holmes, could it be you’re talking about the one that took place in Singularity F?”

“Yes,” said Holmes, and he turned back around to face us, “or rather, not quite. What I seek is the information regarding the Holy Grail War that was meant to have taken place there, the one in which Marisbury Animusphere, the previous Director of Chaldea, took part and presumably won.”

“Wait, what does that have to do with anything?” said Rika, confused.

I couldn’t think of a relation either. We already knew Marisbury had participated in that Grail War and we had all assumed he won, and while it would have been nice to have more information than that and it seemed a bit more suspicious to me now that we didn’t, I wasn’t sure how it was relevant.

“You’re not saying that’s somehow the cause of the Incineration, are you?” asked Emiya, skeptical.

Holmes shook his head. “I have no reason to suspect as much, no. However, I am certain there is some information of vital importance in the records of this Holy Grail War, which have thus far eluded me. My previous searches availed me of no finer details regarding the course of the events or its conclusion. The only information I was able to find, in fact, was no more and no less than the identities of the participant mages, of which Marisbury Animusphere was one.”

“Yeah?” said Ishtar, folding her arms across her chest. “So?”

Holmes arched an eyebrow at her and his mouth quirked up on the one side into a small smirk. “I did promise that I would explain to all of you why it was I harbored my distrust of Romani Archaman, did I not? The answer to my question should itself prove enlightening on —”

Another chirp echoed through the room, and Holmes cut off. Behind him, a holographic display appeared, floating on nothing, although I couldn’t make out anything that was on it.

“Hm?” said Holmes as he turned around. “That quickly? I must admit, I was not expecting Tri-Hermes to return a result so soon.” He took barely a second to parse whatever information Tri-Hermes had provided for him before continuing, “It seems, however, that it confirmed my earlier assumption: Marisbury Animusphere was indeed the victor of the Holy Grail War that took place in 2004. Unfortunately, Tri-Hermes has no record of what he wished for. Under the circumstances, however, it isn’t difficult to imagine he must have wished for fortune or something of that sort, because subsequent to the Holy Grail War, Chaldea went from a mere observatory to a well-funded international organization with frankly impressive speed.”

“So he wished for money,” said Shirou, something complicated in his expression.

“A rather boring and ordinary wish, wouldn’t you say? From an otherwise rather boring and ordinary man,” said Holmes. “A great mage who built an incredible organization with an admirable scope, but as a man, he was nothing unusual or extraordinary.”

My pulse thundered in my ears. “Boring? Ordinary? After everything he did?”

To Mash? To Marie? To all of those kids who would never be born because they hadn’t fit what he needed of them? And that was just the stuff I knew for sure he was responsible for. What had it taken to refine the Master Candidate selection process? What had he sacrificed to build the FATE System? What had it cost to forge Chaldea into the organization we knew today in just a few short years, and who had been forced to pay the price for it?

“Oho, Holmes, you touched a bit of a nerve, there,” said Lisa. “Boring and ordinary? That guy? Sure, compared to Doctor Mengele, maybe. There’s no way you didn’t see his bloody pawprints all over —”

“Perhaps I misspoke,” Holmes cut across her, and for the first time since we’d met him, his composure cracked a little, and his voice came out terse and a little angry. “By the reckoning of the uninitiated, yes, Marisbury would be considered guilty of many crimes against humanity several times over. For a mage, however, he had no personality defects or peculiar fixations. His sole obsession was his magnum opus, the construction of the Simulated Global Environment Model CHALDEAS, and the necessary systems to ensure the success of Chaldea as an organization.”

He glanced over at me, frowning. “My apologies, Miss Hebert, and to you as well, Miss Kyrielight. I’m afraid I was a bit insensitive. Forgive me.”

“Insensitive, huh,” said Lisa, dry as bone. “Sure. We’ll go with that for now.”

I took a deep breath. The blood boiling in my veins didn’t quite cool, but it didn’t boil over either. I didn’t trust my mouth, just then.

“It’s alright, Mister Holmes, I didn’t take any offense,” said Mash.

Sanzang leaned in to Ritsuka and whispered, “What did this Marisbury guy do that got Taylor so upset?”

“I’ll tell you the full story later,” Ritsuka murmured back to her, “but… It was bad.”

Holmes sighed. “Regardless,” he said, “the matter of concern for me is not Marisbury himself, but the assistant the records say he brought with him to Fuyuki. The following year, this selfsame assistant was given a special exemption by Marisbury himself and invited to join Chaldea, where he quickly rose to the position of the head of the medical division.”

Wait.

“The Doc?” Rika squeaked incredulously.

“Romani was the assistant?” I asked.

“Indeed,” said Holmes. “By all accounts, a rather ordinary man himself. No special talent as a mage, no extraordinary lineage, no great accolades, and yet, Marisbury apparently trusted him enough not only to take him along to the Holy Grail War, but also to waive all standard procedures to elevate him to a position of great status within his own organization. The truly bizarre thing, however…” Holmes paused to take a dramatic puff of his pipe. “Prior to 2004, there is no record that a man by the name of Romani Archaman existed.”

What?

“What, like he’s a ghost?” said Rika. “Because he was pretty solid, last time I saw him. And he definitely needs to sleep more, because he was making himself sick staying up all the time to help us out!”

Nero shook her head. “I don’t believe it!”

“Doctor Roman is definitely human,” said Mash. She gestured towards her own head. “Um, his hair used to be much shorter, back when he first started taking care of me, so he’s definitely not a Servant or anything like that.”

Holmes shook his head. “Oh, I never said he wasn’t human. Perhaps I might be able to discover more, were I to spend enough time perusing the records of Tri-Hermes for his history. Unfortunately, scouring the billions of personal files for data on a single man is far beyond the scope of what we meant to do here today, and I have taken enough time from you all as it is. I would only ask that you keep this in mind.” He turned back to us. “This is the reason why I do not trust Romani Archaman. Until such time as I can prove or disprove his innocence, it would perhaps be best to avoid speaking of this topic with the man himself. After all, there was another who took an interest in Chaldea, and he is partly responsible for your presence here, as well.”

Lev Lainur. My hands curled into fists. Flauros.

Holmes blew out a thin cloud of smoke. “With that said,” he added, “Lev Lainur, who was most assuredly working under the King of Mages, arrived at Chaldea and completed his infiltration before the Holy Grail War, and therefore before Romani Archaman’s apparent involvement. At this moment, despite my suspicions, I cannot say that Romani is guilty of anything at all, save perhaps the fact that he has never told any of you of his presence in the Holy Grail War or his connection to Marisbury.”

“In other words, he’s got a whole lot of nothing,” Lisa said. Her trademark smile stretched her lips, sharp-edged. 

Holmes closed his eyes briefly, aggrieved. “Yes, thank you, Miss Wilbourn.”

“So the Doc’s just a guy who got caught up in a bunch of stuff way over his head?” Rika asked, something halfway between laughter and disbelief in her voice. “Because that…actually sounds a lot like him, come to think of it.”

Her brother sighed and shook his head.

“It really does,” said Mash, a smile slowly spreading across her face.

“Doctor Roman is an excellent human being!” Nero proclaimed, nodding to herself. “Mm-mm! A little bumbling and a little clumsy, but I have never once doubted his heart is in the right place!”

Rika held out her fist, and Nero bumped it with her own. “You tell him, Best Buddy!”

“I shall! As many times as necessary!”

“Yes, well.” Holmes cleared his throat. “There are still secrets in his possession that I would prefer to know before clearing him of all suspicion, but at this time, I cannot possibly begin to speculate what they might be. However, there was one particular secret that I managed to come across during my perusal of that information. Miss Kyrielight, would I be correct in assuming you have yet to discover the true name of the Heroic Spirit currently grafted to your body and soul?”

Mash blinked. “Um, yes? I…still haven’t figured it out yet.”

Holmes smiled. “Would you like to know it?”

Hold on.

“Wait, wait, wait, hold on a sec!” Sanzang physically interjected herself between the two of them, arms crossed in an x-shape in front of her. “You’re a mystery guy, aren’t you? What are you doing, flipping to the last page when she’s still only halfway through?”

“Mister Holmes, I really must protest,” said Bedivere. “This is Lady Mash’s journey, and the identity of the Heroic Spirit inside of her is hers to discover on her own time. To simply reveal it so casually —”

Would defeat the point. If it was that simple, I would have told her myself ages ago. Back in Septem, at least, when I first realized it myself.

“Nonsense!” said Holmes. “Come now, Sir Bedivere, there have been more than enough hints, haven’t there? I’m certain everyone else around her has already determined the truth by now!” He jabbed the butt of his cane into the sand the way someone else would have thumped it on a wooden floor. “No, no, it has gone beyond mere self-discovery and entered the realm of willful interference! Miss Kyrielight is no fool, not at all, and she is remarkably clever and well-read besides! There is little point in continuing this charade if it serves no one!”

“This is not how he would have wanted it,” Bedivere tried instead.

“Arash said that this was for Mash herself to figure out,” I said. “That’s why I never told her myself.”

Ritsuka looked at me, surprised. “You knew who it was, too, Senpai?”

“Since Septem.”

“You’ve been keeping it a secret since then, Miss Taylor?” asked Mash, sounding a little torn.

Somehow, she managed to make me feel a little guilty about it. “Because Arash asked me to. He told me it was your secret to discover on your own, when you were ready.”

Holmes huffed. “Pish-posh! At this point, she is either ready now or she never will be! If learning the name now and understanding the truth of her Noble Phantasm are not enough to complete her final steps into realizing her full potential, then waiting another three months will change absolutely nothing!”

“The thing I’m a little stuck on is why you even care,” said Emiya. “It’s not like this involves you at all, Holmes.”

“Because he’s a nosy busybody who can’t stop himself from teasing out every secret he stumbles across,” Lisa said.

Hypocrite, I wanted to say. From the bank and the mess with Glory Girl and Panacea to that moment with Jack when he sliced up her cheeks, she had never known when to drop a mystery of her own. There had to be some kind of grand irony that the Heroic Spirit she herself had been saddled with was John Watson, always the side character to the real Sherlock Holmes.

“It is not your business,” Altera said softly, but with a hard edge.

“I have made it my business!” said Holmes. “Only fools blind themselves to the truth of a matter! Fools, I say! And Miss Kyrielight is no fool, although I might say that the Heroic Spirit inside of her must be, to ignore her own growth! An ignorant, bumbling fool too prideful and too stuck in his own ways to see what a remarkable young woman she has become entirely of her own merit!”

Holmes took another puff on his pipe, as much to calm himself down, it seemed, as anything else.

“Besides,” he continued, quieter and much less intense, “it rather seems to me that this is not a matter of your concern, is it? The only one whose feelings on the matter are relevant is Miss Kyrielight herself. Am I wrong?”

Bedivere stared back at him for a moment, unmoving, and then the fight left him, and he heaved a sigh and backed down. “No,” he said, “you’re right. Despite my status as a former comrade of his, I have no right to decide whether or not Lady Mash is prepared to take up his mantle in full.” He turned to Mash now and bent at the waist into a bow. “My apologies, Lady Mash. If you wish to hear the name of the Knight of the Round Table who saved your life and granted you his powers, then that is your right.”

“Oh — no, no, no!” Mash waved her hands, uncomfortable. “There’s no need to apologize, Sir Bedivere, really! Please stand back up!”

A little stiffly, Bedivere did so. Sanzang looked at him, brow furrowing. “If you’re sure about this, Beddi…”

She let her arms drop and then stepped aside and out of the way again.

Holmes, a little smug, cocked one eyebrow at the display and asked, “So? Would you like to hear the name of the Heroic Spirit inside of you, Miss Kyrielight?”

Mash hesitated, and before she gave her answer, she turned to Ritsuka first. “Master?” she said uncertainly. “Do you think…it would be okay?”

“I think it’s up to you, Mash,” said Ritsuka gently. “But if anyone has a right to know, it’s you. So if you think you’re ready, then go for it.”

Mash hesitated for a second or two longer, and then her expression firmed up, her shoulders set, and she turned back to Holmes. “Right! I’m ready! Although I would have liked for it to be more of a special circumstance than this, I want to hear the name of the Heroic Spirit inside me! Please tell me, Mister Holmes!”

Holmes smiled. “Then allow me to indulge in some background first, will you? Firstly, what method did Chaldea employ to stabilize the process of their Heroic Spirit summonings? This, you should all be familiar with, seeing as several of the Servants now among you were only able to be summoned as a result of it.”

“Oh.” Mash shifted her shield and looked down at it. “My shield.”

“Just so,” said Holmes, “or more to the point, they possessed an object that gathers Heroic Spirits, because it is something around which heroes used to gather. A rite of vows known as the Round Table. Chaldea processed that relic, used it as a catalyst for summoning, and then buried it inside of the single, successful subject of their Demi-Servant program. I am sure it’s easy enough to understand — though it takes the shape of a shield, at its core, it is something entirely different.”

“I mean…” Rika gave the central part of Mash’s shield, the circular disc from which the metallic spokes jutted out, a dubious look. “Yeah, there were hints. But we’ve seen some funky weapons before, too.”

“I’m sure its relevance and importance in your summoning rituals provided further proof,” said Holmes, “that her shield itself provided the conceptual groundwork for the gathering of Heroic Spirits. Because the core of the shield itself is also the core of the Round Table, where King Arthur’s knights gathered as equals. Of course, an armament such as this should belong only to a very specific kind of knight, although one might think it within the realm of possibility that King Arthur himself would be able to make use of it to call his comrades to battle —”

“Oh, for the love of…!” Lisa rolled her eyes so hard her head rolled, too. “It’s Galahad! The Heroic Spirit hitching a ride inside her is Galahad! There! Did you really need all of that buildup?”

“Guy takes long-winded to an artform,” Ishtar agreed dryly.

Maybe here, I thought, but with magecraft involved, knowing more was generally better than knowing less. If we’d been talking about a grand ritual instead of the identity of a Heroic Spirit, the background and functioning of it would have been incredibly important to finding a way around it or how to dismantle it.

Just then, the gulf between the person I’d become — the world I’d left behind — and the person Lisa had become, stuck on whichever Earth the refugees from Bet had settled on, felt enormous.

Mash didn’t seem to hear Ishtar — or notice the almost pouting expression on Holmes’ face — too absorbed in what she’d just learned. “Galahad,” she said softly, like she was testing the name out on her tongue. “The Heroic Spirit inside of me…is Sir Galahad.”

Abruptly, she collapsed back onto the sand with a thump, and mine wasn’t the only heart that skipped a beat, not by the way half the room lurched in her direction. “Mash!” both of the twins cried.

“I-I’m okay!” Mash told us all. “I-I just… My knees felt weak, all of a sudden, and I had to sit down! I’m sorry for worrying you.”

Ritsuka and Rika both let out a sigh. 

“Don’t scare us like that, Cinnabon!” Rika scolded. 

“Are you sure you’re okay?” asked Ritsuka.

Mash laughed, smiling. “I’m okay, I really am! It didn’t hurt or anything, and…somehow, I don’t think I’m surprised either. I-I think…I’m happy. Happy that I finally know the name of the Heroic Spirit that saved me, back then, the one who believed in us enough to lend me his powers. The only thing I’m worried about… Would he be proud of me?”

“Of course he would,” said Nimue. “That, least of all, should not trouble your heart.”

Whatever tension remained in his shoulders left Bedivere, and Holmes took another puff on his pipe, trying very hard to appear nonchalant and not at all smug. He couldn’t hold it in very long. 

“It’s as I told you, Sir Bedivere, there was never any cause for concern,” said Holmes.

“Yes,” said Bedivere, “it seems so. Sir Galahad made the correct decision, it would appear.”

“Although he doesn’t seem too happy about her taking a shortcut,” Emiya added dryly.

No, he certainly didn’t seem like it. I wanted to feel better about Arash’s advice from so long ago being vindicated, but all I really felt was frustrated.

Bedivere blinked. “I don’t understand. What are you referring to?”

“Last time Mash had a breakthrough, her Saint Graph was strengthened and her appearance changed,” I said, and in lieu of Romani or Marie on the comms to tell us about the former, all I could go on was the latter. “Nothing like that happened, this time.”

“Oh, right, with Mo-chan!” Rika said. “Hey, Cinnabon, you don’t feel any different, do you? Because you’re still rocking the same fashion as before.”

“I…” Mash’s brow furrowed and her lips pulled into a thoughtful frown. “No… No, I don’t really feel any different, Senpai. Um, in terms of my strength or my Noble Phantasm, I mean.”

Holmes coughed pointedly into his fist. “Yes, well, I’m afraid the realization of your full potential and the full might of the power Galahad has lent you is a matter of your own discovery. Simply learning his identity was never going to be enough to awaken the entire breadth of what still slumbers inside of you.”

In other words, there had never been a point in keeping his name from her in the first place, not once she had really started coming into her own. Early on, back in Septem, even Okeanos? It might’ve been too much expectation to put on her shoulders. But by the time we Rayshifted into America, for sure, she would have been ready to take that burden and make it her own without crumbling beneath the weight.

“So Cinnabon still isn’t high enough level for her final evolution,” Rika summarized. “Got it. We’ll have to EXP farm those sphinxes or something before we get back to fighting Artie and her boy band.”

Nimue looked insulted, but Lisa just laughed. “Oh, I think I like this one, Taylor.”

“Give it time. She gets a lot worse.”

“Hey!” Rika squawked indignantly, even as Mash giggled.

“Now,” said Holmes, “I do believe all of you had your own questions for Tri-Hermes, did you not? I’m afraid I made something of a miscalculation on the subject of the system’s remaining power, so you will only be able to ask a single question. Might I suggest you focus on the most pressing issue? That is, the nature of the Lion King and the Sacred Lance?”

“A miscalculation, huh?” Lisa said dryly.

“Yes,” said Holmes, apologetic. “It seems I allowed my fixation with unsolved mysteries to cause a bit of trouble for you all, this time. You have my deepest apologies.”

“It’s fine,” I said. After all, even if the power went out now, that didn’t mean we couldn’t come back here later. We had several Grails we had taken from the previous Singularities and one more to retrieve here besides. I was sure Da Vinci, once we got her back, could cook up a plan to restore power to Tri-Hermes and find an answer to the question of Solomon and the Incineration.

Maybe we’d even be able to find a weakness we could exploit.

The only way losing access now would matter was if we couldn’t get it back later. In that case, we could be more suspicious of Holmes wasting a question on Romani and Marisbury’s Holy Grail War, because then, it would be more likely to be sabotage.

“We have to take care of the Lion King first,” said Ritsuka. “That’s the most important thing, right now.”

“Very well, then.” Holmes turned back to the obelisk. “Tri-Hermes! We beg your assistance on one further matter! We need to know the truth of the Lion King! We must understand the true nature of her sacred lance!”

Tri-Hermes chirped once, and then, a few seconds later, chirped again, returning an answer far faster than before. Holmes examined the results silently, pipe momentarily forgotten in his hand, and spent a minute or two going over the feed.

“Well then.” He turned back to us. “Tell me, Sir Bedivere, what do you already know about King Arthur’s sacred lance, Rhongomyniad?”

Holmes. Will. Not. Shut. Up. The last few chapters have been him yapping over and over, because there's so much lore to cover and he's the one with most of the details. Not all of them, but a good chunk.

I wish we had a better visual to go off of for Tri-Hermes and its console, but neither the Camelot movies nor the brief scene in the Babylonia anime that references this moment showcase how it delivers its information, so I had to just...imagine something up and hope it made sense.

Holmes' spiel about Marisbury feels a whole lot different here, though, after what we find out at the end of Part 2. I don't remember when exactly Holmes seals his memories of being a you-know-what for you-know-who, but Lisa definitely seems to have some idea of what's up with him, doesn't she?

Comments

Frank Hurtado

If I remember right, Holmes has his memories sealed almost immediately, but it's been a while since I played Traum. He was put into a plausible enough situation to assume his summoner was someone with Humanity's interest at heart and given two objectives. Go to the Mage's Association, and then go to the Atlas institute, before coming back. If it wasn't immediately then it was after this, when he is recalled. Because otherwise Holnes has a very unfortunate problem of figuring out what is going on sooner than he is supposed to.