Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

hello all.  I have figured out why patreon wasn’t working on my phone! So while typing is still irritating I can now at leas access my patreon page without using my bro’s computer. This is a good thing lol.  I noticed that there were a few questions and such recently in some of the other threads and I will do my best to hunt those down now. 

I can also say that I will be able to follow this thread as well.  For once again I have questions in some of my stories going forward. 

First is actually not about my own stories at all but one of the free high school DxD fics crossed over with naruto that I’ve bothered to read.  I have no idea what the name was hence my problem -it was really funny and I thought it was well written but i can’t find it anymore. It had a joke in it about issei being killed by Raynare due to his browser history lol.  If anyone knows this fic’s Name, please tell me.

 from There let’s go into my DxD crossover questions.

In GDWHOM:

1. Which villain in DxD would be most likely to set something up to create a zombie apocalypse?  I mentioned at one point that I might go that route, and since we’ll be dealing with Kokabeil soon it was on my mind.

2.  Should Rias still want to become head of her family in this doc free what her parents did to her?  Or should she want a clean break.  

3.  Oddly enough, I am struggling with placing Rias with Ranma.  is That just me being silly, or is their attraction coming off as forced to anyone else?

4.  I really don’t want to get involved with politics in this fic so would everyone be okay with me just covering the confrontation with the Gremory parents, and not the aftermath from the devil side of things?

5.  Would Devine dividing not working on ki be too OP?

FIlFy:

1.  Once more I have to ask the question:  what should I do about Akeno and Kalawarner.? I am honestly really torn on this point.  I have given them both a lot of growth but only a little of that growth has gone into actually making them more compatible with Harry. He and Kala are starting over, and Akeno is still having trouble with Harry putting Lily first.  It remains to be seen if Harry will be able to deal her love of pain too.

2.  Ddraig. What did everyone think about how I dealt with him in the last chapter and what does everyone think I should do with him, leave him in Harry’s care, or try to redeem Issei? What is more interesting, a character who thinks his way through problems or overpowers them?

3.  Does Koneko need her own love interest. My gut feeling is no but I was asked.   I might have her get with Gasper for the lulz.

4.  Should I introduce Gasper in the next chapter, or do I already have too many characters?  For that matter, are people interested enough in Kiba and Mittelt for them to get more screen time?

Horse for the Force:

1.  I think that Set Harth has nearly run his course as a character.  The question is then, should any of the team he’s assembled survive his death?

2.  I would like to bring in the Sith artifact that has that ancient soul in it that can create rakguls or whatever they are called, but I don’t think I can introduce another group of mindless drone like enemies given the upcoming masses of droids.  So would that ancient Jedi and the with in the artifact be interesting enough as characters if I dont introduce that aspect?

3.  How much are people interested in the world building beyond the Ranma centric portions of this work?  Specifically the politics. Leading up to the declaration of war.  Part of me thinks I need to show that debate and Padme‘s involvement.  Part of me thinks it takes away from the action and is boring.

4.  What did everyone think of the inclusion of the Mandalorians and nova guard?  Feel free to comment on anything here.

And now for some broader questions. 

I am thinking about splitting up the polls as I have the past few months, but in this case I would put the stories I think I could possibly finish in a separate poll.  This would be Anything Goes Game Changer and Semblance of Hope, plus possibly GDWhom, though I am uncertain there - it will depend on whether I want to make that fic into a full fixer fic or cut it short. Then I would update the winner of that poll alongside the single winner from the small story poll.  I could also stick any docs that haven’t been updated in a while here.

How does one go about soliciting someone to write a Reading: kind of fic?  Some of those are hilarious and i would like to see one of Semblance of Hope.

Comments

FateBurn

I would say Hades would be the most likely to do a zombie Apocalypse , and I would not mind that you glossed over the fallout on the devil side, rias taking or leaving her position I don´ t have a preference but I think she would stay as heiress, as for you having problems pairing her with Ranma then why not change her with Serafall, you are already planning to have him paired with Gabriel and that would at least make Levia-Tan curious and that would be the in for her I think. For the Filfy questions I would not mind seeing were this restart takes him with Kala but the Pain thing with Akeno I have never liked and I can´ t see Harry indulging in it so that may be their deal breaker. Koneko doesn´ t really need a love interest. For Ddraig while I prefer a character that thinks things in DxD escalation is a real problem so keeping Ddraig may be the wisest choice down the line, but I wouldn´ t seeing you fix Issei either. Or introducing Gaster next time but I really don{t care enough for Kiba and Milttelt to ask you to give them more screen time.

Blitz

Dragons of dragons: game of the year, by silentsongbird might be the fic your looking for. Been a long time since I've read it but I believe it had some comedy and raynare actually lived long enough to try something like that. Idk about gdwhom (never got into it, maybe I'll go back eventually), but I can at least provide my POV on question number 5. Divine dividing halves half your power, so logically it takes ki, touki, energy, magic, life force....basically anything you draw strength from. It not working on ki would make no sense, unless you have some reason that ki fights back against the drawing in of energy by divine dividing...and honestly that just sounds unreasonable. Now onto a fic I can at least say I've read, aka FILFY. 1: You promised a harem and gave us a dilf (in every damn sense of the word) Harry, he needs girls or this fic is too serious and quite frankly not dxd. Your developing the relationship fine and in terms of akeno not understanding direct family ties, she still has the unresolved tension with baraqiel who was her dad, that left her, her view on parent hood could easily change when that confrontation is resolved. Point is I want the girls, this is DxD and Harry has a demi god libido and super werewolf instincts, idc if he has occulemency he shouldn't be so reserved about this (dont let it reach the point where this becomes angst we cant be together because I can't adapt (srrsly harry is making everyone else improve and alongside less reservations he could easily discover the urge to dominate in the bedroom, which could transition to satisfying akenos kink (harem supporters back me up on this lmao). 2: Honestly I'd be happy with Issei dead or sent to the gremmory estate to be a butler. I thought this over after reading last chapter and Issei getting boosted gear back just detracts from the new main character...aka harry. I dont want issei in the spotlight it's fine when it's a regular dxd fic, I can read through perversion just fine, but Harry should be the center of attention for the baddies and having the red dragon emperor around is kinda a big deal in the dxd verse. I dont mind if harry doesn't wield draig and just keeps him in a box and occasionally talks to him, word gets out he has it and now all sorts of beings are after him, could lead to fun consequences. Hell him wielding it could be fun too, but sadly Harry's already at a level where doubling any aspect of him becomes seriously powerful (not even gonna try to factor scale mail) I mean just look at how OP vali would be if he doubled his power instead of divided the people weaker than him (actually its situation based in the case of divine dividing, but my point stands). As it is I want tiamat coming after him for having draig when he goes to the familiar forest, so my opinion is no, dont give issei the chance to be a mc. 3: Ya already gave kiba his spotlight in that regard could be a funny fluff moment, but I think ya should wait till kurokas around just to see her reaction knowing how big a tease she is. 4: Gasper would be sorta abrupt without sirzechs announcing rias is ready and therefore removing the seal he put up. Which would then lead to a convo with harry....so I guess if your ready for that sure, would probably be a big help against riser if that battle is still gonna happen. As for kiba he still needs development in regards to excalibur, but even in canon he wasn't really on screen beyond that arc. Mittlet could be interesting depending on how you develop her character, but other than that its totally up to you and if you feel everything is split in priority. Anyways I hope that these response sound reasonable. I know I'm a stickler for the harem, but its dxd and you gave me the perception harry is the hot for teacher, my friends hot dad....insert porn older guy title etc. He should be by the end of the story literally FILFY. Anyways I'm outie, peace!

schpariel

GDWHOM: 1) Why not have Valerie lose control of Sephiroth Grail due to Marius pressuring her to keep using it? That seems like the least convoluted way to do it. <a href="http://highschooldxd.wikia.com/wiki/Valerie_Tepes" rel="nofollow noopener" target="_blank">http://highschooldxd.wikia.com/wiki/Valerie_Tepes</a> 2) I can't see her breaking from her family name, though definitely the individuals. I still think the twirling-mustache depiction of the parents seems wrong. 3) It doesn't seem any more forced here than most of her relationships (including canon). Which is damning with faint praise, I suppose. 4) Showing the political fallout isn't necessary, but it may be worth having Sirzechs give an update after the fact with a summary of how the underworld is taking it. She is the heir of a family and sister to a Maoh, having her exist in a vacuum isn't realistic. 5) Yep, probably. If Ddraig can boost it, he can divide it. And I think there are canon examples of Ddraig bosting touki. FILFy: 1) It still feels too forced. Leave them alone, don't drive their narrative anywhere in particular, and see if something seems to develop organically. 2) I always found Guile heroes more interesting, and Ddraig provides too much temptation to simply boost your way out of problems. 3) Nope. 4) Nope. Too much going on, unless there is some plot requirement for it I don't see a need. I'm not interested in the star wars stories so no comment there.

Seraphim38

Keep rias with ranma and akeno and kalawarner with Harry

Druid

FILFy While I have no issue with multi-pairings on a story if done right, I really don't think Akeno and Kalawarner are a good fit. Akeno because I see her needing someone focused completely on her, at least at first. As for Kalawarner I just don't think it would be a healthy long term relationship. That being said if they don't end up with him I do hope that they end up staying good friends with Harry if possible. Ddraig, I liked what you did with him in the chapter. As for Issei, I acutally feel kind of sorry for him. While his lack of restraint is appalling, he seems to have gotten more than his fair of teenage hormones. I don't miss those days at ALL. I also like the idea of sending Issei off for a while, maybe sent to someone to help him get his head on straight, and maybe bring him back if you can get him to be less... overt with his hormones. Koneko, no need to anything on that front at this time I think. I'm a bit biased on the Gasper front as I don't care for him, but I also agree you've got a lot of characters to keep track of. So perhaps continue to keep him in reserve for now. HORSE Having a member of Set's team surviving could be interesting, the least of which being further warning of just how bad an idea it is to go against Ranma and his crew. It would be interesting to get an ancient Jedi's perspective on Ranma and his effects on the universe around him. For me the world building aspects are important, but not needed to be shown until it impinges on the main characters in some way. The addition of the Mandalorians and Nova Guard adds more versatility to what Ranma and crew can do, and for that I think it's a good addition. Especially the ones you've started to flesh out makes them more interesting in their own right. GENERAL Whiles the three stories you mention aren't my favorites in the potential to finish pile I still think it's a good idea. As a reader, and I would imagine as a write it's good to see something finished. Especially if you want to move on to something else.

Readm

GDWHOM: 1) Both Hades and Rizevim Livan Lucifer would be willing and able to use a zombie army without it being forced it all 2) I think even with what her parents have done to her Rias has her pride and she would definitely still wanna become the head of the family If for no other reason so that she has the ability to make a difference 3) I agree the attraction felt forced And I personally never liked them together I feel like there's no reason to try and go the harem route or imply the harem route pick one girl and run with it and in this story ranma has Saeko. 4) I personally don't feel a need to go in depth into politics just a quick overview from another person Point of view would be fine 5) Divine dividing can't Divide Touki so why would it be able to Divide ki (This statement is unverified but nowhere in any form have we seen Divine dividing be used on life force or touki) Also I saw statement above or someone said they thought they saw draig boost touki that's not accurate Iseas Physical body got boosted and it increased his amount of touki Horse for the Force 1. As far as set hearth and his team kill'em all 2. I personally think the ancient sith soul could be interesting but It would really depend on who it ended up with I feel like if it just ended up with Sidious it would be boring 3. I'm a big fan of the world building in this story And I think it would be important to add it. The action is awesome but seeing the changes that are wrot is also another really awesome thing about this story 4. I like the inclusion of the Mandalorians and the Nova guard

Teraseneste

I have never actually read GDWHOM, so I have to decline to say anything. Filfy 1. When it comes to Akeno and Kala, I think you are on the right track. Akeno has many a personal problem and issue to deal with and I think that at some point you are going to have to decide if she can overcome it or not. Kala I could see becoming a good friend, probably with some angst along the way as she wants more but it just doesn't work out, but she wouldn't truely fit in with Rias and Akeno or even just Rias if Akeno can't get past her issues. 2. I think I would have preferred that Issei had been rescued before the extraction had taken place, but since you didn't I think that you have gone the right route. I would say that if you want to redeem Issei than you are going to have to choose the method but not through Harry, as he already has three girls to look after already. As for Issei getting smart, I think that he wouldn't really be Issei if you did, and he should be the overpower it type that randomly spots weaknesses in the middle of a fight, but not the complicated solution type. 3. I think Koneko is fine as is. Turning her into a big sister is more than enough for now and only if you take the story forward a couple of years should you need to think about it. 4. Gasper has never been an overly interesting character to me, but I also haven't disliked him as some have. I think that at the moment you have more than enough to work with and adding Gasper now would only get in the way. Worry about integrating everyone you have for a chapter or two or three, then bring Gasper in out of left field to start it all over again. As for Kiba and Mittelt, I think they could use a little more screen time in the next couple of chapters, but more so that we can see how they are reacting and interacting with each other and everyone else with all that is going on. Horse 1. I agree that Set should go the way of the dodo soon, but then, I thought that bringing him in at all was pointless. As for his team, I am of two minds about it and would go with something along the lines of kill them all, and if there is a survivor, let it be one that will allow Ranma and Shak to interfere with another of Palpatine's long term plans, even if it won't lead them to him. 2. I would say that if you do decide to bring in that artifact, an incident that destroys a city, or a back-water world to piss Ranma off and he manages to destroy the thing once and for all. Otherwise, leave it for long in the future as you are right about there being enough mindless drone enemies already. 3. For world building, I think you have been doing fine. We don't need excessive detail from seeing debates and all that, but a conversation where Padme rants to Ranma and Shak about an outcome should be enough to make sure we know how the wider galactic political scene is running. Conversations with friends between fights is fine, watching politics is boring. 4. I think that you have used the Mandalorians just fine so far, but the key is going to be how they are used later in the war.

Slider

For FILFY: 1. I honestly think that Akeno is not even less suited to being with Harry. She actively seems to push back against Lily being number 1 for him which is basically THE thing to do to end any and all relationship prospects with a single parent. I've dated a single parent, you MUST understand and be okay with the kid coming before you. ALWAYS. For Kala, while I am more or less ambiguous now to her with Harry, I think she'd do well for Issei, plus Rias seems to dislike her which is not a point in favor of that grouping. 2. The only reason I'm against Ddraig not being with Issei is because it's such a huge plot difference. There's almost no reason to have Issei be in the story or the peerage without giving him something. That said...I really like the idea of Ddraig going to someone else. Someone who could actually do something besides think of breasts. I'd almost be interested in seeing him bond with Kiba or Xenovia. Both would be pretty cool with him. Harry is decent option as well though he already has his fancy sword and magic and demigod and phoenixwolf, he probably doesn't need Ddraig as well. Unless you plan to have him fight Ophis or Great Red in which case, he probably does lol. I had REALLY wanted to see Rias end up with him but since you made him require simpletons and previous humans, she doesn't realy fit sadly. 3. I would kinda like to see Koneko with her own partner though I'm not sure who would be good. I could actually see Koneko getting with a girl though since that almost seems more like her wheelhouse anyway with her personality. Please don't put her with Gasper... 4. I've been very much wondering whether Gasper is around. You seemed to have not written him into the story and while I'm not a huge fan of him, that's mostly because I'm mainly just watched the anime and he had very little to do. He's apparently bigger and cooler in the books. I do really like Mittelt though! She should get more screentime!

Treant Balewood

GDWHOM: 2. I could see it going both ways, her taking over the family always struck me as something she was 4. Yes. 5. Firstly it's 'Divine'. Secondly, I don't see why it should be ineffective, and also if it is than so should being boosted. Maybe since Ki is such a personal power adding someone else's to oneself's is... sub optimal? Isn't this just an opportunity to force Ranma into a corner, to get clever, to rely on other characters, or break out 3000 years of ancient amazon history. FIlFy: 2. I like the idea of Issei being forced to become a clever bastard if he's to have any effect on this, if you plan to explore and grow his character it could be very fun to not give him back Ddraig 3. Nah. 4. Sure, seeing what you do with Mittelt would be interesting, it's not super important to me or anything tho. Kiba yes but ill admit it's also not super important Horse, ill get back to you want read the newest release before I get back to you.

frank schellingerhout

FIlFy: 1 kala could have a shot with starting over but dont see the harry you have writing dealing with anko's love of pain let alone her inability to put lilly ahead of her self 2 liked what ya did with ddraig would like to see him in harry's care but sure about issei like story's where he is not the main 3 could be fun to see her with casper i say go for it 4 casper could be fun early as for kibba and millet could be fun to read as a side romance

schpariel

OK, I stand corrected re: boosting touki. I would _hypothesize_ that if boosting the physical body could increase touki, dividing it would do the same, and that ranma-ki and touki are at least closely related. At this point I think it is ill-defined enough that it would fall in the realm of author fiat.

Doraemax

Hi, not really into D&D, but i try to answer some of your questions. 1. On God and Devil... - Rias and Ranma... i am not really seeing it. Especially since he already has a stable relationship. Perhaps really good friend? - And yeah, no devil politics, please. For all intent and purpose, this is Ranma story, not the devils. And Ranma has to deal with soo much more, mainly the government and the other human-base groups. Having him deal with Devil politics too? I think Ranma will not have it 2. On FILFY... - Do remember, Harry, Rias, Akane and now Kalawarner are all long-lived. So, they don't have to be a full harem just yet. They can move as slow as they want. And i do mean tens of years, if needed. Perhaps Harry and Rias can go ahead, to provide a strong base for a family. When the time come, Akane can slowly join it. As per Kalawarner, i think it is going to take more time. She has to win over Rias (hard) and Akane (easier) and harry's daughter, and even Koneko plus the healing nun/new big sister...before Harry will even consider her inclusion in his relationship. While this going on, i would recommend she started as a friend and loyal ally to Harry. 3. On Horse of the Force.. - Yeah, Set has outlived his usefulness. kill kill die die. - loved the inclusion of new minions. But i think you need to flesh out their backstory because these will be a close-knit group, going forward and growing with Ahsoka under Ranma and Shiri. Though i keep wishing Anakin to benefit too from what Ranma and Shiri can teach...

Friendly Neighborhood Eldritch Horror

In GDWHOM: 1. Probably Loki, if I recall correctly, he wanted to speed up Ragnorok end of days type scenario, and a messy situation that fuels itself in a destructive manner would be a great distraction for him. 2. She’ll probably want to become head of her family, the situation in the underworld is unstable enough as it is without the loss of the political presence of the Gremony on the side of peace and against the Old Maou faction. She’d probably want to delegate managing things to someone trustworthy and powerful enough who is an adult pureblood devil who isn’t one of the 4 Maou though, as a sort of regent, since she’s far from established enough to jump into that and keep up with it and all the other stuff. It’s the only way she’ll manage to keep the traditionalists from siding with the Chaos Brigade and various war mongers and such. 3. The attraction seems natural, but the relationship potential is less so, Rias is a character built for indulging in one’s passions to be with, while Ranma is a character whose past is built around resisting his passions to avoid troublesome situations. Something would have to shake up Ranma’s outlook and situation a lot for a relationship to be able to develop there. Ero situations and fun teasing however can easily be kept up. 4. You don’t need to handle it openly, but it would be good to have someone be noted as handling it, even if it’s just some minor character, even an original character, set up as Rias’ regent or something to handle politics for her until she is ready, and say they are struggling to maintain Gremony alliances and keep their old allies away from the Chaos Brigade and the general populace of lesser status devils on the peace/alliance side with the loss of respect towards the Gremony for the fall of Rias’ parents and the fact that the current heir is young and untested and the regent, well, a regent, and perhaps pressure her to do more rating games and social events in the underworld to help make up for this a bit. 5. Divine Dividing seems to be conceptual reality alteration that can even theoretically do stuff like shrink someone’s breast size, so it SHOULD normally work on ki users. That said, that doesn’t mean it has to do so, especially if they have, for some reason, a trait to their energy/soul that lets them resist enemy reality warping. You could, perhaps, rule that ki is closer to the soul of the individual than some other kinds of energy, like devil power (connected to unknown sources similar to divine power and contracts) or normal draconic power (unknown source, possibly conceptual in nature) or angel power (heavenly system), and thus some individuals with stronger souls might be more resistant to it reducing their ki power. Or perhaps you could have it be that Jusenkyo curses are a similar form of reality warping that interferes with divine dividing to a degree, and make it so that when the curse is triggered the power resets to normal, or that while in cursed form individuals are immune to it, so long as the divine dividing user remains weaker than the power of the Jusendo source energy. FIlFy: 1. Honestly, Harry isn’t well suited to be a proper partner for Akeno, she needs someone into the same stuff as her. They can flirt well, but he’ll probably be turned off by the stuff she best gets off with and enjoys and performs most naturally. Kalawarner might have a chance with him, but I think her real need isn’t Harry himself, so much as a real emotional connection and loyalty. Perhaps this could be a problem that solves itself, if they perhaps both have bisexual potential, as while perhaps not into it the way Akeno is, Kalawarner seems less likely than Harry to be actually turned off by the S&M stuff, and once it is earned, Akeno’s loyalty is very solid and her emotional connections are strong. Some OC characters or previous minor characters could also prove to be good partners for either of them under the right circumstances. Akeno mostly needs someone complex enough to put her faith in and have a real connection with, rather than just some random S&M junkie, and someone who is in on the whole supernatural side of things, once her issues are dealt with with Harry’s help and her potential partner has earned the trust of Harry and Rias as gatekeepers of sorts who care about her and she desires the approval of and trusts the judgment of more than her own. 2. I’d go with redeeming Issei. Make it so that due to how the sacred gear was removed from Issei and he was made a devil in the meanwhile with less Evil Pieces than he would have with the gear means that he can’t survive re-integration until he powers up first, but he wants to do so because it would still be safer and easier to power him up this way than anyone else, due to him being the one born with it and assigned it by heaven’s systems, and thus properly attuned to it’s nature and able to use it’s full power sooner with all the conflict on it’s way and threatening those he cares about or would come to care about. He has to become at least 8 times stronger than how he starts out before he can integrate it, but this isn’t overly difficult or time consuming, because Devils can do some crazy training and he started out particularly weak and untrained, so he’s in for a period of rapid initial growth to adjust into his potential, with the help of some crazy training like an enhanced gravity enchantment room and extreme physical training resembling anime stuff and some methods to re-fuel him in between to keep training when otherwise exhausted, such as Rias providing energy to help him recover during his training using the Evil Pieces system and Asia healing him of minor scrapes and bruises and such, and maybe some potions from Harry to help recover physical fatigue, combined with a mystical side of things bit of magic training assistance from Harry to help him unlock his magic energy and find a way to train it up a bit sooner and faster. He might even end up stronger in the long run if he figures out how to control more of his basic devil powers before getting back his sacred gear, like common magical techniques such as teleportation. 3. Koneko’s love interest could easily be Issei, once he matures some and earns her trust, since he’s closer in age, and with Harry’s advice and warnings, he might mature a little more and get a better handle on his perversions. I don’t think Gaspar is a good fit for her, she seems more drawn to stronger personalities, particularly those brave enough to stand up to her sister for her enough to make her realize their courage and care for her. Koneko getting an interest in him would also be a good way to get Harry more involved with making sure Issei learns better behavior later on, since Harry wouldn’t want Koneko to end up with a hopeless pervert. 4. Gaspar should be introduced ASAP, he was honestly introduced far too late for Rias’ character traits that are otherwise claimed or shown in the original story. I don’t think Harry is well suited to getting him out of his shell though, and that could be another area where Issei gets a chance to redeem himself somewhat, as it’s his being a slightly older peer figure to Gaspar that helps his enthusiasm get through, and adult figure like Harry or a girl/woman figure who he’d have more trouble seeing as a role model wouldn’t work out as well for getting Gaspar out of his shell. Harry might try and fail initially, and then have Issei try and somewhat succeed, and Harry realize why, and coach Issei a bit as far as not teaching Gaspar anything stupid, but otherwise encourage him to help get Gaspar out of his shell. Horse for the Force: 1. Depends on who is on the team, what their skills are, and the circumstances of the setup, you should just try to handle it naturally as the situation best develops, but have the priority being Set dies, while the others might have chances to escape or merely be captured, especially if they aren’t overly evil or deadly or hard to contain, and circumstances present themselves to capture them AFTER Set is killed. Any who they have to deal with before that to get to Set are probably getting killed. 2. I’d actually consider some kind of ‘perfected elites’ type enemy, some kind of group of super-solider equivalents with overpowered weaponry and high end defenses and some serious skills, strategy, and tactics, to contrast the later ‘zerg’ type experience of the droid armies, they’d be more of an elite ‘protoss’ unit type enemy. Possibly something Set left behind and was working on inspired by Ranma’s effectiveness that Sideous figures out how to use quicker thanks to some skills passed down by Plageuis, even if he doesn’t have the skills to easily create more of them, and they might not survive long term due to side effects of some aspects of their weapons and armor that don’t work well with biological life forms, like personal shields and high end blasters that emit cancer causing radiation. Or maybe a group of old Sith ghosts bound to artifacts that Sideous somehow enslaves and binds to clone bodies and sends a bunch against Ranma’s group and/or Fay. 3. Definitely show some of the politics and world building. Perhaps not front and center actually showing the debates, but certainly bringing up some of the talking points and sides and opinions involved, showing at least Ranma or Shak’s opinions on such, and having them possibly contribute to developing the opinions of the Mandalorians or Padme regarding such or helping them recognize some key other perspectives or whatnot, but don’t focus over much on it, like showing more than a mid sized scene of the senate which wouldn’t even fully quote all the lines involved (similar to the recent scene with Palpatine is fine, possibly even a bit shorter, but perhaps containing a longer speech from Padme than anything Paplpatine says in that bit). Not enough to stop the war, but certainly enough to make things harder for Palpatine and not go quite as much the way he wants, although not enough for him to target Padme over it more directly at this point in time. 4. I like the inclusions over all, although I think the Nova guard individuals need more characterization, particularly the new groups that are under Ranma’s training and perhaps some of the leadership in contact with the Jedi. The Mandalorians need to have their presence be looked upon by the rest of the Galaxy a bit soon, perhaps you could have some character from another world looking at an essay on the New Mandalorian philosophy that won an award written by a youth character (perhaps a cameo of the one you didn’t use that I came up with for a potential student?) and admitting it seems decent and that some of the Mandalorians actually seem to understand it, but expressing their doubts about truly transforming the Mandalorian culture and making it last and work on a practical economic and military level. Maybe have that character looking at it be Fett talking with some of the clone trainers on Kamino about it? As far as poll splitting goes, maybe instead of a separate poll, give automatic bonus votes to stories that are within a certain number of vaguely planned chapters of finishing, like only 2 or 3 chapters away from finishing, perhaps giving them more votes for being 1 chapter from finishing than 2, and more votes for 2 chapters away from finishing than 3, but 4 or more chapters away from finishing they won’t get any bonus votes, doing this with part of your own votes. If you have the time to do extra though, a separate poll for close to completed fics for a while might be nice to try to finish some of them off.

Nick Finn

GDWHOM: 1. Honestly, this seems like the kind of thing Loki would do. Either that or the Dhampir who's name escapes me looses control of her Holy Gear that understands death/souls. She is maybe doing that to draw in people to kill her, as she sees that as the only way to escape her torment by her family. 2. I can see Rias breaking away, publically, because of gross betrayal. The Gremory Family has a strong reputation for treating it's servants well and looking after family. This seems more like a complete betrayal of family by her parents, so the Gremory family is ruined politically as publically known hypocrites. So long as she retains her status as a High Class devil, why would she want to stay under the control of such people. Which leads to the issue, it doesnt make sense on it's own, so there has to be more to the story 3. They seem attracted to eachother, but after the first time they have sex, they can realise that while fun, there is no 'spark' they are both looking for. 4. I don't mind about that, but maybe throw in minor scenes, rather than whole sections devoted to the backlash in devil society. 5. Not at all. Divine Dividing is overpoweringly broken already, since it can in theory work on concepts too.

Aaron Hardin

GDWHOM: I almost think the zombie apocalypse is something Azazel sets off by accident in collaboration with Ajuka more than something an enemy does intentionally. The most competent mad scientists in DxD are both allies, and laid back to the point of disorganization in Azazels case.

Matthew Hunter

GDWHOW: 2: I could see her wanting to be the head more as a "The family deserves better than you." thing. 3: Yeah, it is feeling a little forced. 4: Please feel free to skip politics in detail if maybe not in broad recapy "oh yeah here's the fall out of that thing that hapened" kinda way. 5: It may be OP, but would also make complete sense. No one they are encountering or hearing about in the three factions has any mention of Ki, so why would an ancient weapon work on it?

Joshua Longstreet

Unknown Naruto/DxD crossover: I don’t think I’ve ever read that one, but if no one names it, I might go digging for you. . In GDWHOM: 1. Zombie apocalypse: Are we talking accidentally or on purpose? Loki and Shalba strike me as the type to do it completely intentionally. Georg would do it as an intellectual exercise, but might have been prevented from completing it when Cao Cao realized that Great Red was a better target than zombies. However, the tools might be lying around. The Tepes may also be an interesting target. Accidentally . . . Hell, Le Fay could do it on accident. Pick a magic user. Any magic user. Seriously. 2. Gremory Heiress position. The issue here is that Rias is the only logical choice, as the only other candidate is Millicas, who is too closely connected to Sirzechs, being his son and all. Not to mention that it would cause extreme tension within the clan. The thing is, Rias might not give a damn about her parents, but she’d hesitate to put her nephew in that corner. That being said, it would be the ultimate bargaining card and weapon, especially if she played it right. By threatening to disown herself, her parents would fall over themselves to keep some form of control. Conversely, by offering it to Riser as a part of his victory (after all, they would be married in that situation), it would cause severe conflict between the Gremorys and Lord Phenex. In the end, it will be up to her to decide how that will affect her future. Though I can see her making it into a mockery on the surface though. A strong foundation, covered with enough farce to make her parents squirm. 3. Ranma x Rias. I can see both sides of this, but that is merely because you are making Rias into a somewhat non-canon version of herself. You see, canon Rias is like FILFY Rias. Classy, compassionate, and in control, despite the fact she is a major otaku. In this story, that Rias is a lie, made up by her parents. This Rias is realizing that she wants to be someone else. Needs to find her true personality. Right now, she’s in transition, becoming a girl that Ranma would be happy to add to his herd. 4. Politics? Gloss over the politics. Summarize it in a few paragraphs. If it affects the next few chapters, you need to at least mention whether it’s good or bad, how much so, and who is affected. Otherwise, we don’t need heavy details on devil politics, since Ranma probably hasn’t affected it too much. 5. Albion vs. Ki. Yes and no. Ki has been around for ages, and the White Dragon would know of it. That being said, Sacred Gears work under the logic of their users, so Valí might not be prepared for it now, if ever. For example, a glowing punch might get part of its energy drained, but it would either be the excess energy causing the glow, or the energy in the fist itself. A ki blast would be partially drained, but the drain could cause an imbalance, exploding right in front of him and causing sight damage at minimum. Basically, he’d only be able to drain the parts he understood, not the entire thing. FIlFy: 1. Kala. She’s at that stage where she can be molded, based on what you think Angel Kala was like. She’s trying to find her roots at this point by becoming a better person. It does introduce a bit of flexibility. As for her relationship with Akeno, it could be possible that she knows of her father. Not a close bond, but enough to complain about, and maybe some rumors about how he gets stone cold drunk or something on certain days of the year. Enough to hint that he’s a good father, but also plenty of complaints and rumors to bond with Akeno over. Akeno. Something I’ve noticed in DxD, and sometimes even in your story, is that Akeno has some character traits of a submissive. Yes, she is a sadist, but she has a guilt complex over her hybrid nature and a strong need for acceptance. She also seems to feel like she would cause Lily more harm than good, based on her own conflicting feelings over her parents and how her mother died. Maybe Kala has something for that last issue (see her section above), but all Harry has to do for the former is to take responsibility and not be too gentle. He is a werewolf after all, some form of domination instinct is to be expected. And no whips or chains are required. At least, not for a few years. 2. Ddraig. Issei is redeemable. Whether he will be redeemable enough to take on Boosted Gear again in the near future is unknown, but it is possible. Plus, a lack of Ddraig in his soul could cause some changes. After all, dragons are known for their obsessions, whether it be for power, battle, or gold. Think of a harem like a horde of oppai, and you might see how having a dragon bound to his soul might have affected his thought process as a child. Personally, I like a champion who can fight with his mind in the game. That being said, it is interesting to see a hero overcome heavy odds with sheer guts alone sometimes. 3. Koneko No to the love interest, at least at this stage. Especially no to a pairing with Gaspar. 4. Gaspar. Maybe not early in the next chapter, but I’m sure Rias would think of how Harry could help him soon. However, first we need to establish Miltelt as a background character, and move Kiba back there as well. I like the guy, but I don’t see him being a major part of this story until the holy swords come in. Gaspar, on the other hand, could very well become Harry’s latest adoptee. Poor guy needs another male role model. Plus, Lily would love another sibling who would enjoy playing dress up. Horse for the Force: 1. Set Harth Depends on what you want the outcome to be. If you want Sideous panicking his ass off, wipe them all out. If, however, you want him jumping in a certain direction, leave one survivor to give a half assed panicked report. 2. Sith artifact I have no opinion on this whatsoever. Sorry. 3. World building politics. Unlike with DxD, Ranma has had plenty of time to set up chaotic butterflies. This means you will have to show some of the political changes, and show that Padme is doing something. 4. What did everyone think of the inclusion of the Mandalorians and nova guard? Feel free to comment on anything here. I like them. Nice job. And now for some broader questions. Poll rebalancing. I will agree that there needs to be a reshuffling, and if you’d like some advice, I can sit down and suggest a few patterns. However, I would not suggest cutting your RanmaxDxD fic short. It doesn’t need to be a full fixer fic, but there are portions of it that NEED to be written, strictly because you’d be crazy not to think of it. We are most likely guaranteed, for example, to see Ranma vs. Kokabeil and possibly Ranma vs. Valí (together with Ranma causing chaos at the peace talks themselves), but what about Ranma meeting Odin? Or Ranma causing chaos at the young devils gathering as Rias’ special guest? Or Ranma going to Kyoto, only to find a small kitsune limpet? Ranma challenging Sairaorg Bael and coming off with a fight to remember? The odds of this going all the way to Trihexa are variable, depending on exactly what Ranma does and who it affects. And considering it’s directly affecting Rias and the Gremory clan? You can stretch that out quite a bit. But it all depends on what you want out of this. If you’d like to write it to a point where you can call either a hiatus or the end of the first saga? That’s fine, especially since you have two different Rias’ to restructure and develop at the exact same time, towards two extremely different points. But please don’t discount the fact that you could drive this storyline so far off the canon highway that it might as well be in outer space. And honestly, that’s what I like to see.

Joshua Longstreet

Further suggestion for incorporating Akeno: as Rias’s Queen, it stands to reason that she’s done more work in the rumor department than Rias has. After all, Rias is a busy girl, having to deal with numerous political situations. Once Rias and Akeno sit down with Lily, this experience would be quickly noted, allowing Rias to slowly back out. Combine this with Kala sharing some stories about how her parent’s romance was seen in the Grigori, and how her father has been rumored to be in a fit of depression, and this might make Akeno more willing to play at least the role of older sister to Lily. Koneko might complain, but honestly, Akeno has seniority rights over her, and can probably get a way with calling the kitten little sister as well.

cfp33pfc

Koneko seems firmly in daughter territory, not lover to me.

Jan

Before all else I'd say do what you think is right for your stories. That said I only read FIlFy so I'll comment on a couple of your questions there with my opinion.

Jan

1. Regarding Akeno and Kalawarner I'll start with Akeno. I generally like drama so having her and Rias both pursuing Harry and having conflict in those relationships is what I would prefer for them. I wouldn't want a conflict that lasted the whole story, only for there to be challenges to overcome for them all. It also will make the Akena and Rias relationship need more attention which I also would like. Regarding Kalawarner she clearly is seeking redemption at this point in the story and she won't be redeemed until she feels that she is. She has been a fallen for a long time and surely has a lot to atone for. I could see her trying to use Harry as a vehicle towards that as well as a love interest. I just don't think it makes much sense for Harry. Also not everyone can simply end up with Harry there are other boys in the story and they need girls too. I might introduce a wizard from Hogwarts like Ron, Neville, or Dean... someone like that as a vehicle to further blend the HP world into DxD, give context to how awesome Harry is among his own people, and have another boy for matchup purposes.

Jan

2. Regarding Ddraig since you've made the move to separate him from Issei I'd at the very least keep it from him for a long time or better yet find another wielder for him. I think it would be awesome to give Issei another avenue to power to make him even more different than he is in canon. It might also be cool to have Harry keep him in reserve for later. He could give Harry an edge over something like 666 or if he has to fight a super devil. Generally I prefer Harry keeps it or gives it to someone who isn't part of Rias' peerage.

vimesenthusiast

Said her own love interest not with Harry. The idea would make Harry cringe and run away.

vimesenthusiast

Akeno: I am NOT a fan of romantic type drama, however, in this instance the personalities of the characters have made it necessary, and will continue to do so. Akeno is...complicated. Even now that she has worked through a lot of her past issues, she still has her sexual mores, and I completely agree with the people who say it would be wholly out of character for this Harry Potter to enjoy such things. As for Kalawarner, yes she is seeking redemption that is not up for debate. She’ll be around for a long time, but pairing her with Harry just might not happen - from his perspective that ship has sailed, and they might not be able to build anew. And I have never and will never go the whole every girl gets with the main MC route. However I will not be introducing any more wizards from HP. Tonks and Teddy will show up at some point though

UrpsychoEX

Hey Vim, GDWHOM: 1. I can't really think of any villains from DxD that would fit beyond Hades or maybe another Death God 2. I don't think she should want the position personally. She has to many negative thoughts and experiences from being apart of it and dealing with her parents. Her brother and nephew are the only bright spots from that family. Leave the position to her nephew. 3. I believe it's just you but then again I am of the opinion that Rias has no true character beyond what you and other writers have given her. Cannon Rias is just a sex symbol as are most of the females from that series honestly. 4. Yeah I'm fine with that. Ranma wouldn't care about their politics. 5. It should not work on Ki. Dividing magic is fine as it is an energy used to do various things. Ki on the other hand is life energy and losing it can kill someone. Dividing enough of it would basically put Ranma in a coma. FILFy: 1. I don't see any issues at present. You're still really early in Rias and Harry's relationship and have plenty of time to move forward with the other two. Kala has more leeway as she is an adult and therefore is more acceptable as a choice for Harry at this moment. Akeno has time to grow and personally I think her love of pain shines more during battle than it would in the bedroom. A bit of pain in the bedroom would be different to Harry but I don't believe she would push so far as to drive him away. Maybe she tries to hard and use that as a way to mitigate it? 2. Please do not give Issei Ddraig. I personally can't stand his character and he's just so fucking overpowered with it. Also one dress break and Harry will kill him. I personally think given some of the other powers in DxD that even as a demigod Harry will need it. 3.She really doesn't need one. You can have everyone tease her about Gasper, and that would fit well, but she honestly doesn't need a pairing. 4. I think introducing him would be fine but we don't need much of Kiba at the moment and Mittelt is okay in the background for a chapter or two. HFTF: 1. Depends on the members, I've forgotten who they were, but I think so. Okay Durge and Bane can die and I won't care. I don't know who got sent from Talzin's group but honestly they can probably die as well. If Ventress or Komari are apart of it I would like to see them live. They can easily be worked in to the plot as adversaries for Ranma and Shaak Ti. Personally I think they could be turned to the light as well, or at least to the grey. 2. I would LOVE to see Celeste Morne brought into the story. However... the problem with doing so is that then you limit yourself to Horse for the Force for her, as it will probably be unpopular to bring her into Magic of the Force as well. I am torn as I think the story involving her would work better from the magic side as apposed to the ki side. Though it would be neat to see both stories. I'm just really excited to see her in one of your stories and at the same time very concerned about which she would do better in. 3.I think we'll get more of that from Magic of the Force as Padme is more central in that story. She barely appears in this story as Ranma and Shaak Ti are older and very much did not bond with her like Harry and Aayla have. Personally I think the politics you've limited yourself to are fine and would prefer more action in this story. 4. I do like the inclusion though I'm not sure how you'll deal with them in the combat to come. Will some of them die? If so will they go pick up replacements? If they won't die will they be regulated to a few being injured each mission? Like I said I enjoy their inclusion and it provides a good reason for Ranma to improve beyond his need to be the best and defend Shaak and himself, but will they just become a hindrance for your storytelling? Misc Question: 1. AGGC could be a shortish story and you wouldn't lose much as the plot for Sekerei is overly complex. I would honestly prefer to see Semblance be a bit longer but can understand if you see and end point earlier that wraps up all the story nicely. As for GDWHOM I think a full fixer would be preferable to me. 2. I'd go looking for good Reading Fic authors first. Maybe ask around to the Patreons and reviewers for recommendations and go from there. Not a fan of Reading fics personally so I have no other advice nor an opinion or if you should/shouldn't. That's all I got for now Vim. Later!

vimesenthusiast

Gdwhom1. I was actually thinking more one of those whisker twirler type Gillian’s who’d go ‘if I can’t heave the world no on will mwaaahhaaa’. Not so much one who has power over death. 2. Have to look up whether milicas is in the line of succession or not. Agree her turning her back on the position is possible. 3. Canon Rias and indeed all canon girls from DxD lack depth, something I try to correct.

vimesenthusiast

Answering on my phone, can’t start a new line. FIlFy: 1. Think you’re the only one to realize it is technically early days in their relationship. Yes the Rias and Harry relationship might be a whirlwind paced, but they both have hundreds of years to live so Kala and Akeno don’t have to forge that depth of connection as quickly. 2. You, me and a lot of reviewers over on fanfic. I have been trying to keep that dislike to a minimum so as to not negatively impact the story. 3. Teasing works just as much as actual romance for the lulz.

vimesenthusiast

Yeesssss. I am glad I am not the only one who is trying to think of which story to introduce Celeste into. And yes, I would prefer to use her in only one story, not both. Yes you will get more politics from Magic, and more Padme too. 4. More flexibility in combat, more skills - communication, hacking, aerial maneuvers, force projection. I refuse to say if they will die or not. As for the broad questions I am going to go full fixer in FIlFy, hence why I might not do so in GDWhom.

vimesenthusiast

Gdwhom1.was actually thinking more one of those whisker twirler type villains who’d go ‘if I can’t heave the world no on will mwaaahhaaa’. 2. Ooh I like the political play there, can have that going on while Ranma and gabby and Saeko have their more violent run ins elsewhere. 6. Also like your explanation here, pretty much precisely the kind of thing I was hoping to see in this thread.

vimesenthusiast

FIlFy: Agree wither what you said about Kalawarner, so skipping to Akeno. Not so much a submissive as a switch, can be both sub or dom. As for her interactions with Lily she is more just very uncomfortable about kids in general which comes both from her own horrible childhood-jealousy about the differences and the fact she has no idea how to treat them or any desire for her own in the next few hundred years. And there is a distinct difference between domination and liking pain. Agree Harry would be willing to dominate her if need be but there is a difference between that and say, smacking her rear to the point it’s red, or twisting her nips until they are in pain. And don’t forget she’s also into causing pain too. 2. The oppai thing is all issei there was actually a point where Ddraig had to have some counciling about being called the oppai dragon. Regardless of what happens to him, issei won’t be a main character anymore. As for the rest, might have to put in a scene with Gasper where they play dress up, that would be priceless.

vimesenthusiast

You mention plot points here and I can’t comment on them without spoiling things to come lol. But you mention the peace conference- who says that’s gonna happen in this fic? And I would say I’d stop the fic somewhere before trihexia - or perhaps shove that in a big three way battle between it, big red, and Ophis somehow

vimesenthusiast

2, ‘like that point, I’ll lead the family better walk the walk as well as talk it’ sort of thing.

vimesenthusiast

Lolololol. Can totally see that happening. Oh what’s this button do. It releases a toxin into the lower at,osphere that turn people exposed into flesh eating zombies. The carry over effect was the hardest part to get righ. Why? I just punched it. Oh, that’s nice, wait what?!

UrpsychoEX

I absolutely love Celeste, but I'm usually disappointed in her appearance in stories. The one that comes to mind is The Lord of Light by Darth Marrs. Though to be fair and honest I hated that story from the word go after I finished it the first time. It was just so... depressing is all that is coming to me at the moment. The ending was bullshit as well. I'm glad you'll keep her to just one and to be honest I would recommend Magic. She'll fit better considering she's not the only one that's out of place. Harry and Lily can sympathize. Thanks for taking the time to answer! P.S. Just saw the bit about the Naruto/DxD crossover and here were a two I found: Kaguya's Jinchuriki by AlernateReality A Devil's Bijuu by fg7dragon

Canadian Tick

GDWHOM 1. I don't know about the villains, but I could see one of Azazel's experimental Sacred Gears doing so in a roundabout fashion - maybe one that grants the user biokinetic abilities but no instinctive knowledge on how to do so? In such a case I could see someone trying to "heal" a friend and accidentally creating a corpse-puppet super-virus. 2, Honestly, I don't really see any reason for Rias to really want to become head to the Gremory clan, especially in the setting for your story - her values generally all revolve around her loved ones (peerage, family in canon), and being seen for who she is without the trappings of nobility obscuring her. I would say the happiest times of her life have been in the human world with her peerage and Sona. 3. I feel like Rias and Ranma could be very good friends, but yes I do feel as if the pairing, especially with Saeko there, feeling a bit forced. 4. I am interested in the politics, however I don't really mind at all if you decide not to bother going too deep into it this fic if you don't feel like it's your jam this time around. 5. No, I don't really think it's too OP, especially given the eventual power levels of individuals in this story even without special artifacts. If you're looking for an in-story reason for it to not work on ki, I would suggest that the Sacred Gear needs to have been on a user that understood the power sufficiently to do so: i.e. long ago there was a wielder that knew enough about magic to shut it down and that knowledge remained in the Gear as it passed through inheritors, same with things like devil power, holy light, etc. With none having encountered (fought with and survived) ki users before, Vali would have to do the research himself to do so, with that understanding passing on to future wielders of Divine Dividing. If anything, given how Vali is a combat junkie, I could see him being ecstatic that, with ki not getting automatically shut down by his Sacred Gear, he has no easy "Win" button for a fight against Ranma and ki users in general. FILFy 1. To be honest, I'm not too invested in the romance for this story, and beyond Harry trying to retain their friendship can't really offer much advice. Personally I was hoping he'd hook up with a yokai but don't really feel all that strongly about it regardless of who he ends up with. I enjoy the story anyways. 2. I liked how he was dealt with, and while the thought of Harry wielding dragon powers is a cool thought, hope he doesn't keep the Boosted Gear. For one, he's got the whole wolf-thing going on and think he should stick with that theme. For another, keeping a loose Sacred Gear around is just asking for dangerous people to show up (with his daughter nearby) to try and take it. I like the idea of Sairaorg being given it on the sly by Rias, perhaps in exchange for future help even if she doesn't need him to deal with Riser. I could just imagine someone busting their ass trying to take down Sairaorg and his ridiculous Touki mastery and then - just when they think they finally got him - he reveals he can keep doubling his power on top of all that. 3. I don't think Koneko needs her own love interest either. 4. I don't feel particularly strong about either of this questions. Maybe Gasper being introduced by Rias hoping Harry's magic could help him? Horse for the Force 1. I don't remember any of the team off the top of my head, but would find it entertaining if one or more survived, if only to fuel more rumours amongst those who don't know him personally (civilians, regular Jedi, Palpatine's minions, bounter hunters, Hutts, etc). 2. I don't mind that aspect not getting introduced. Maybe even include a section of the Jedi Masters conversing amongst themselves and remarking that the galaxy doesn't know how close it nearly came to destruction and wondering if Ranma attracts events like that himself or if he's drawn to them as they nearly come to fruition. 3. I like the world building and politics to be honest, and greatly enjoy it in ATP. 4. I liked the inclusion of both groups, and feel like there's probably potential for humourous shenanigans on the ship with two similar, and yet different, warrior cultures in an enclosed space.

Narsil

I don't feel qualified to offer an opinion on some of the questions, but for those I do: GDWHOM 2. I could see Rias going either way, but I'd come down on the side of her wanting a clean break. I can see her brother supporting her on it, too. 3. The Rias might not be forced, but it isn't really necessary to the story and, while I haven't read all that many DxD crossovers, perhaps a bit cliched? 4. I think we need to know of the politics, but don't need to see it in real time -- reports of the fall-out from friends and family caught in the middle while Rias and Sona and their peerages sit it out on Earth will do just fine. FIlFy 1. I'd keep Kalawarner in the growing harem, but to tell the truth I've never seen Akeno as that good a fit for the Harry of this story and can easily see her realizing that it simply isn't working and bowing out (much to Rias's relief, though by then she'll have other women to worry about). 2. Whether or not you choose to put Ddraig back with Issei, I vote for NOT leaving him in Harry's care. Harry's powerful enough as it is, and comparatively set in his ways. Ddraig might prefer someone that's still forming. 3. No, Koneko doesn't need her own love interest. Her budding "big sister" relationship with Lily is enough, I think. Horse for the Force 1. It shouldn't be a TPK, some survivors should scatter to the winds to spread the word of Ranma & co.'s magnificence, thus feeding their growing legend. 3. For the politics leading up to the declaration of war, I suppose it would depend on how central a character Padme (and any others involved) will be going forward. As well, I'm one of the lunatics that consider politics to be the greatest spectator blood sport ever invented so I don't find them boring.

Thomas Harold

Ranma & Rias doesn’t seem forced, not to me. I’m curious to see how Gabriel gets added to that three way

Wesley

1 On the subject of Dividing ki, I think that any wielder of Divine Dividing would have to first, think of lifeforce as something that can be divided and stolen. And second, believe that they have the right to take another's lifeforce. 2 I personally think that a character that thinks their wayinto and out of problems is more entertaining than someone like canon Issei and Luffy, The whole "I'm so stupid that I can pull off miracles" thing just doesn't do it for me. Though I'm always a fan of when characters take what powers they do have and munchkin them to hell and back. Like when you get that one telekinetic that munckined their power into allowing them to use it on the molecular level.

Caerival

I don't have much of an opinion on most of the questions, but in regards to the relationships, I'd say just let the story flow and decide where those stand once you get there. Let the characters speak through you instead of trying to put words in their mouths.

Thomas Edwards

GDWHOM: 1. I can see it being accidentally released by many villains, however if you are specifically after a character that intentionally causes it I can see Loki or maybe Trihexa doing so. 2. I think it depends on what would happen to her if she does make a clean break. For example would she still be considered a co-owner of Kuoh and if not how would that affect her and others. Would she be protected from some of the devils who see her as a way to get back at/ coerce Sirechs. I could see her taking a reprieve for a while to figure out whether they were her own desires or not but not a full break. 3. It is coming off as a little forced but mostly in the moments when she is trying to one up Saeko when they have been alone it hasn't seemed so. Though I think some part of it could be her doing so to distract herself from the changes her perceptions are currently going through. 4. I'd be fine with that so long as there was a brief blurb to show the aftermath from say Sirechs and Serafall maybe discussing such with each other or their peerage. 5. I would have to agree with some earlier posts about it; that it would depend on Vali's knowledge like it affecting some of the attacks used in different ways but not Ranma himself especially with Jusenkyo Curse. FIlFy: 1. I think one of the problems is that Rias and Harry have fit together so easily that having it hard for others to join them is understandable. At the end of the day you are the writer and if it seems off to you to pair them together then that's fine. For Akeno, personally I think they can be good for each other but it would depend on how far she is willing to push things and whether she is happy to be placed behind Lily in importance or not. I think with a bit more self-reflection then they can be a good fit together since Akeno can bring Harry's fun side out more than Rias. However, they still have many years ahead of them to figure this out and whether Harry is open to having more lovers as time goes by. For Kala, I can't see Harry trusting her enough to let her have his and Lily's hearts like that for quite a while. 2.I liked what you did there especially with Issei but I think that Harry would work well as a custodian until he finds someone that fits Ddraigs specifications for a good host. 3.I think the focus of her in the big sister role is working well, maybe some teasing when Gasper is introduced but she doesn't really need one yet. 4.Perhaps flesh out Mittelt a bit more but they are find so far. Introducing Gasper soon would be good now things are moving forward, love the image of Harry being exasperated at all these women aiding Gasper in dressing up after trying to have a moment of Male bonding with him. Horse For The Force: 1. I like the idea of having one or two survive to spread the image of how insane the chaos and team that is Ranma & co, is becoming. Such as "We thought it was bad enough one guy eliminating a whole Bounty Hunter Clan, now he has lots of Friends! Time to escape this Galaxy". 2.I could see this and Celeste Morne fitting better in Magic than here, especially if Sidious is in need of a distraction for Harry's faction so he can try to escalate a situation, either before or during the Clone Wars. 3. I think you need a slight overview to see more of the changes Ranma has caused before you can jump straight to the action but maybe show a few bits from Padmes' point of view to do this . But I enjoy both the action and the Worldbuilding you have been doing so far anyway. 4. I liked what you have done with them so far. Maybe begin fleshing out their expertise and how Ranma can both teach them in terms of using their skills more efficiently and how they can use those same skills as a group both in and out of battle.

Joseph Klos

GDWOM 1. I honestly think with a good few sacred gears showing capabilities of summoning/creating creatures, it'd probably be better to use an OC for that (since the ones I'm thinking of have themes already associated with their creations and not of zombification types) 2. Not sure, would have to check on if Millicas is in line for it or not first. 3. Eh~, it's at worst equal to some of the romance in the original DxD. Personally there's something there... 4. sure 5. Yes, it would be, because Touki is kinda DxD's analog to ki, and divine dividing has been known to divide physical prowess as well. Although making best use of that energy and power? I think we all know who would have the stacked deck in that case. FIlFy: 1. Honestly I don't quite see Harry, even your Harry in this story, feeling ready for that too soon (either the bdsm or multi-partners, though that second bit with the demi-godhood would change sooner). I can certainly imagine him being willing to try if he grew to love and was loved in turn by akeno for the pain part, but that would be some struggles on both their parts. Kalawarner...not sure. I could see it going either way, but it would depend all on Rias. And let's not forget Yasaka... 2. I'd say redeem Issei. He was a pervert but compared to his two compatriots and how he acts in DxD with each person he cares for, he has his redeeming traits...he is honest, but simply simple and too honest at times. Perhaps work along those angles first and see if him getting smarter or earning Ddraig's partnership is better. 3. I don't see Gasper, she likes him as a friend too much from what I see. However finding anyone else depends on how much her relationship with Harry and Lily helps her grow out of her self imposed stoicism. 4. I personally think Kiba at least needs some screen time, but as for Gasper, I'd say if you can figure out how someone could help him train his powers. Otherwise it might be a little premature. Horse for the Force: 4. I thought it was rather well done. And I liked the idea of them all cross training one another, that should make for some fun interlude writing between bigger scenes...

Tomon

GDWHOM 1) Really no idea which one would work best for this but I think there are several person capable of causing such. 2) That can go both ways. She may just give up on devil politics and schemes totally and just want to live the human life along with her friends. But she is strong enough to also go the other route and want to change how things are done... And both option are appealing so no help from me on this question at all :-D 3) For me the attraction works pretty well. I can see the issue with using Rias in both fics but well.. she is main character for a reason. I think it's too late to not include her. The story would need to be build differently. And I also truly like her and want to see her with Ranma ;) So you just being silly but don't worry. We shall forgive you :-D 4) I love getting details but in this instance I won't mind that much not getting every bit of information about how the aftermath affected everything. You can always point the important part later when it's needed and IF it's needed ;) 5) Honestly the Divine Diving is too op on it's own so if it couldn't target Ki it would be fun :) And for example if it can still affect his physical abilities it would be interesting fight to see Ranma being forced to rely on his Ki instead of using it just as a booster to his physical abilities and as a means of attack. It would sort of flip his style around but he is versatile enough to go with it I think... So my opinion is "go for it" ;) FIlFy: 1) I already addressed this in my review at least partially. But to take it further. Kala is in a weird position. I rooted for her but it's slowly falling down and her priority as Harry partner is not high enough on my list. There are others which I wish for more and given that Harry is at this moment struggling with idea of only two girls? Well I don't see the "harem" being overly big. And given how she damaged their relationship.. She can definitely get back to being his friends but from there it would be a long ride to get something more. Still she can be "there" so to speak slowly trying to win him back and join him more as a more than just a friend and who knows? It could actually work in end. Akeno is interesting. There wasn't the immediate connection as it happened with Rias (who is already the best mum Lily had). There was only attraction. And then the problems starting to show on both sides. Still while it may seems like they're not compatible enough it also seems more real. If they can work past this issues their bond will be truly strong. And after all if Akeno got some issues with Lily it should apply to Rias or any other partner even more. So she can do a little soul searching and found out for herself what her problem is. If she can accept that I have no doubt it could work. And there is one more issue. How exactly would the situation look like if it DIDN'T work? She would felt truly abandoned and the inner working or Rias's peerage would truly suffer. 2) Don't care about Issei. If his death couldn't make him think hard about his priorities and how the world works he is better of dead. Honestly I don't think he should have been resurrected without the sacred gear in his possession even if that seems to be cruel. OR he should be resurrected by Harry who might have enough power to do so for someone who just passed (very limited time, only for some kind of death etc) but would remain human. Now free to live his life without any supernatural influence. Ddraig should remain with Harry or be given to Rias. Currently Koneko is definitely the best candidate and I can even see her actively wanting it given the motivation of big sisters (if being grateful to Rias and wanting to protect her against Riser is not enough reason). Regarding your last question in this part: I don't like truly stupid one dimensional characters. But often having the bigger stick is a good option ;) 3) Not anytime soon. She needs family (whole set), truly accepts what happened. Ideally getting her sister back and understanding why it happened in the first place. When she is in a good place and in a few years then I can see her starting too look at boys :) And please no "heat" version or at least not to THAT extent. It can give her a nudge, not make her loose her personality. Regarding Gasper, I don't think he is able to handle this CAT :P Especially one who is taking care of her own puppy :-D 4) Well, one part of me want to say that Gasper is a male. But honestly... Does it even counts in his case? :-D Still we should be at least introduced to him if nothing else. But both Mittelt and especially Kiba are more interesting. It's nice to see Kiba having a good male influence in his life. And it's good for Harry to have some friend here as well. Kiba gains a more experienced male role model and Harry got at last one person who doesn't want to jump him and could potentially talk about such :-D Win-win scenario and I always enjoyed their interaction so far.

R Brown

GDWHOM: 1) No idea. 2) I could see Rias wanting the headship to protect her nephew. To use the authority to protect herself and her peerage. Or to simply remove that power from her parents control, especially if she doesn't want completely destroy her family name and history, as well as cause havoc for her brother. 3) Didn't really seem forced to me. I saw it as Ranma's Pavlovian training from Nerima affecting him, and Rias getting diverted by other concerns. Also, I think that any real development of a relationship would require some more interation between Rias and Saeko. 4) Showing the politics depends on if, or how much, they will affect the future chapters. If they will not have an effect, then they can be bypassed. Otherwise, they should at least have a small mention or scene. 5) I'm not familiar with the canon limits of Divine Dividing, but you could put some limits on how it can affect ki, rather then a flat yes or no. Such as only affecting ki outside the body. (i.e. strength/toughness/speed enhancement is unaffected, but a ki blast could be treated like any magic blast.) FiLFy: 1) The drama and conflict is interesting. It is avenue to provoke growth in Akeno. Kala also provides an opportunity to show that some romantic relationships just won't work out, as opposed to using a break with Akeno to do the same. Both will be interesting when Teddy is introduced, for different reasons. As well as, what your plans for Yubelluna are. 2) Ddraig. Give him to Sairaorg Bael. For the lulz. 3) No Koneko doesn't need a love interest, but don't let that stop you if you have an interesting idea. 4) With Rias interest in the applications of Wizarding magic, new ideas for uses of devil magic, new concepts of control based on aura and occlumency? Yes, I think it is appropriate to introduce Gasper. Not to mention, Rias wanting to know if Harry can help him. Even more so with her new anticipation for the confrontation with Riser. I don't think that I have read many fics with Mittelt as more than a barely above mook level character. It could be interesting. Kiba. *shrugs* Horse: 1) None of them stuck out to me as interesting enough to make an effort keep around, unless you have a plan to make use of them in place of another random villian. 2) It wouldn't be Ranma without some ancient artifact popping up. 3) I think the scenes from the wider galaxy should be limited to those that showcase the changes to people and events caused by the ripples of chaos. Especially, those changes that could foreshadow a major change in the future. Like the snippets about Jango Fett. 4) The different warrior mentalities should be a good source of contrast. Mandalorian vs Nova Guard vs Martial Artist. It will be very interesting to see how the wider population of Mandalorians react to the clones. More so, if those who were trainers with Jango Fett speak out. General: 1) That seems fine. I would says to divide the polls however best keeps your muse happy and productive.

pat fitzgerald

GDWHOM 1-no idea. 2-i don't see her disowning her parents but i can see her not caring, finding new priorities knowing she may end up leading the family at some point. 3-doesn't seem to be any depth to the attraction so i could see i fizzling out. 4-agreed but maybe a one paragraph summary in a later conversaton

MinotaurKing

GDWHOM 1) no idea. 2) I feel she should still want to be head just to spite them, but it could work either path. 3) The attraction does still feel a bit forced their interactions are good I just struggle to really see them working out given the already semi hostile rivalry with Saeko which in combo with Ranma's hangups seems like a deal breaker. 4) Depends on how the aftermath might affect the future if it is significantly impactful show if not the no biggie. 5)No, Ki is life force as in use it all up you die if Divine Dividing could affect something like that there would be whole groups solely dedicated to kill its wielders; do to the implications therein of.

MinotaurKing

FILFy 1) They could both still work but I just can't see Akeno and Harry getting over their respective hangups with each other; Kala on the other hand clearly wants it and given the fresh start I could definitely see them being a nice slow burn although there would be definitive bumps on the road. 2) I liked it a lot and Ddraig should definitely stay in Harry's care, both are good when done correctly. 3)No she really doesn't need one. 4) Wait more on Gasper as Rias still probably hasn't gotten strong enough to handle him; Kiba and Mittlet are interesting they way you have been doing them and it would be nice to see more but if its to akward don't sweat it.

MinotaurKing

Horse for the Force 1)Maybe Durge, but other than him I just can't see Ranma or Shaak letting them live; Durge is maybe cause I'm not entirely sure they could kill him. 2) I don't know enough about the artifact in question so just do what you want lol. 3) Definitely show the lead up and how Ranma and the changes he has brought have shifted things. 4) It makes sense and is generally interesting in just about everyway I can think of.

vimesenthusiast

3. That is sort of what’s feeding my own feelings on the subject. Then too, there is the fact there isn’t much in common there outside of anime - enough to form a friendship not a relationship. 5. Hmm...

vimesenthusiast

1. Whatever happens, Kala will be a slow burn. Akeno, I just cannot see this Harry indulging in her masochist/sadistic desires. 4. Don’t know I agre with that, though suppose you could say she’s been growing in abilities rather than raw strength.

vimesenthusiast

Celeste Morne and the sixth lord she is trapping in herself basically was what I was talking about there. Couldn’t remember her name until someone else mentioned it. Durge, there are a lot of ways I could kill him permanently if I wanted to, so that won’t be an issue. Lol

vimesenthusiast

Gdwhom:1. That is a good idea, I might go with that concept. FIlFy 1. Yubulluna will sort of become Harry and Rias’s Grayfia in many ways, but in no way an equal in the relationship nor any desire to be, so long as she is treated with respect and affection. 2. Would you believe I thought about doing just that lol! 3. Nah, it was just something a few people pied me about can’t see it myself. Though I will have fun with the time she goes into heat in canon. 4. Yeah I’ve decided to at least have Rias start talking to him and getting him to practice mental control, maybe not introduce him physically to Harry given her concerns about how a vampire might react to Harry now. Amused that Kba only gets a shrug from you lol. Horse 4. I imagine the reaction would be rage. The reborn have changed a lot and grown a lot, the clones might well be seen as deformed weaker, and artificially created replacements.

Duncan Evans

Lets see. GDWHOM first. 1) Ophis. With Big Red firmly in the Dimensional Gap, she accepts that she can't return, and decides to make this plane like the home she wants, Change a few humans to zombies, with a limited lifespan. Once all the people are gone, the zombies die off, and she gets the silence she craves. 2) I've always thought that giving up the Gremory name was an option for her to get out of being sold as a sex slave to the Phenix family. Have her threaten it, and Sirzechs give Mummy & Daddy Dearest a choice: loose their daughter, and their son (him), and the Gremory name would die if they couldn't produce another heir, or step down, give Rias the name and title of Lady Gremory, and go into quiet seclusion out of the public eye, which would suck for them, but save the name. 3) It doesn't seem forced to me. You might consider using the removal of the spell to make some noticeable changes in the personalities of Rias and Akeno. After all, who is to say how much of an effect that mind control spell had on them. This way, the situations could be resolved by actions that would otherwise be considered OOC. The only part that, to me, seems forced is the slow pace its taking. Have Rias recognize the fact that Ranma has no concept of the games girls play, and have her lay it out for him: "I like you, I want to try a relationship with you, and I want to have sex with you." He'll trip out a bit, but if she's straddling his lap when she says it, he won't throw her on the floor, so can't run. And straight up and direct is the best way to deal with Ranma, anyway. 4) That;s fine by me, as the politics aren't my favorite side, either. But I would love to see it pointed out, either by Ranma, Sirzechs, or Serafall, that the only difference between the Gremory's forcing her into a political marraige with someone she hates, and them selling her to Riser as a sex slave, is the label one puts on the package. All the particulars are the same for both transactions: Forced to stay in the situation, forced to have sex with the one controlling her, forced to bear his children, and the ones who arranged the transaction profit from it. 5) I wouldn't say that it was too OP. OP is a matter of perception. There are plenty of characters in DxD that count as OP. Keeping the main character weak is really only a writing device that gives the hero somewhere to grow. Having Divine Dividing be designed to have a built in weakness KEEPS it from being too OP. FILFy: 1) I think Harry and Kala would have a chance, but Akeno would require some character development on Harry's part. Harry is a Alpha werewolf, and has the potential for being VERY dominant. But except for combat situations, he's not letting it out. It reminds me of how Remus wouldn't acknowledge his wolf. I think that Rias should notice that he's forcing himself to be overly solicitous when they sleep together, and encourage him to let it out, He does, and spends the entire weekend driving her into the mattress. (He has the sex drive and stamina of a god!) He comes out more dominant, she comes out exhausted, scratched, bit, chafed, sore, and thinking of the others not as competition, but as tag team partners. He can also realize that the best way to treat a girl, is not the way HE wants to treat her, but the way SHE wants to be treated. He still gets the emotional connection he needs, and the girls gets what they need. The fact that Harry is currently struggling with two girls is actually easy to deal with. While he has his own societal morals in play, he knows he is in a different society, with different customs. He has his god abilities pushing him to have multiple girls, he has a new toy (Boosted Gear) that could be pushing him (see item 2 below), and he has his main girl pushing him to accept it (perhaps Rias realizes that godly stamina means she'll need help). With all that, convincing him that he should follow his new godly instincts shouldn't be too very difficult. 2) I love what you did with DDraig. I think you should do both: leave Boosted Gear with Harry, and redeem Issei. I've always hated Issei as a character, and was very dissatisfied with the series because of him. BUT now you have an opportunity for a real change. Scenario: Ddraig is the real letch here, and has been subconsciously influencing Issei his whole life. Issei has had to develop a very strong will and mind to keep from becoming Ddraig's complete thrall, so with it gone, Issei's personality can change drastically. He can become more forceful, clearer headed, and more dominant in his own right. I personally would love to see Akeno completely enthralled by the new Issei, and become a sub (or switch) under him. I wouldn't see Issei in this case being a sub - he's been controlled for his whole life, and he knows it. ( I would LOVE to see this relationship happen, and when Akeno starts teasing and running her mouth, have Issei scruff her - Run his fingers through her hair at the back of her neck, then make a gentle fist. As a dominant myself, if the woman has sub tendencies, she'll react just like a cat does. Very dominant and possessive move, and would be a personality defining moment for both of them.) Harry, in the other hand, is a battle-hardened veteran and an Alpha werewolf. The battle of wills is much less one-sided, and Harry ends up controlling the dragon, not the other way around. And with this scenario, Harry would really understand Issei, and become even more of a direct mentor to him, possibly training him in combat the way he taught the DA, and even more than he trains the others, since Issei no longer has Boosted Gear. 3) I would rather see Koneko with Harry and Rias, than Akeno. Rias would be much more comfortable with Harry having a pet kitten, than with Akeno. Akeno's habit of always pushing the boundaries, by the way, is very much a sub trait, and I would love to see a new and improved Issei reign her in. 4) Gasper. I don't think you have too many, but Gasper never really seemed to fit even in canon. It was like he was thrown in there to satisfy the SJWs who whined about there being no LGBT characters in the show. If I was writing it, Harry's new power would allow him to make Gasper happy, and actually turn him female. Gasper would be delighted, and would make a great pet sub for Issei. Horse for the Force. Not going to comment, as I'm not really into that story. Other questions: The only one I really have an opinion on was about a separate poll to include Semblance of Hope. I would be happy with that, as it's one of the ones I truly enjoy. Anyway, this has become way longer than I intended, so I'll leave it there. As always, thanks for writing, and for posting it where we can enjoy it. Duncan