Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Moment of truth: should Harry and Akeno break up?

  • Yes keep them together. 64
  • No, have Harry and Akeno break up. 191
  • 2018-10-03
  • 255 votes
{'title': 'Moment of truth: should Harry and Akeno break up?', 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes keep them together.', 'votes': 64}, {'text': 'No, have Harry and Akeno break up.', 'votes': 191}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2018, 10, 3, 22, 48, 40, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 255}

Content

Here are some more questions I would like everyone's opinion on. The first obviously has to do with the poll above, my thoughts of which you will find below. I also will thank everyone who took part in the last questions post, a lot of the stuff written about GDWHOM and this question was helpful, even if I can't quite make up my mind on it just yet. I also want to thank everyone who chimed in on the question for Horse for the Force, that helped a lot.

However, it is now time to make that decision and the decision of who will be in the harem entirely, which will be effected by Akeno's staying in, obviously. I have had reviews going both ways, and to be blunt few of the ones which were actually in depth and well written over on fanfic backed Akeno staying in the pairing. The ones who spoke in favor of her on were far better.

While Rias and Harry clicked pretty quickly after a semi-rocky start, I think they are by far and away one of the most natural pairings I've written. In contrast, I feel like I sort of forced Akeno and Harry together. Not attraction-wise, but going from that to beyond friendship. Harry is a war veteran, who has both been captured and tortured both physically and magically. I agree entirely with those who say it would be a stretch for him to like giving or receiving pain, regardless of his utterly insane healing factor. Akeno also is NOT ready to settle down, start a family, be a mother to Lily or anyone else. She is a decent big sister figure, the teasing somewhat taunting sort, but that is all she has been to Koneko before. And she is not ready to make the family the biggest part of her life, as Harry has. Further, Harry knows that, and might come to start comparing her and Rias in more ways than physically, which wouldn't be

However, given how much growth elsewhere Akeno has shown, would she be willing to forgo that aspect of their sexual relationship in order to remain with him? Am I making too much of the fact Akeno has had issues with being around children in general and the fact Harry spends so much time with them? Or is her inability to fully get over that, her jealousy and her need to feed her sadism going to force them to break up?

If they do, she will move on. I can see her getting with Issei possibly (yes going to redeem him, but not give him back Ddraig, think it could be interesting to try) or certainly Tonks when she shows up. If she wants to experiment in any way, Tonks would be the girl for that, and they could both use the fun. Akeno would then open up even more, her personality opening up in many ways, shattering her normal 'Yamato Nadeshiko' mask utterly.

If however, Akeno does stay with Harry, then Kalawarner will not get back with him. She will instead get paired with Issei, and have a hell of a time trying to be his one and only rather than let his inner pervert out to prey on other girls. Tonks will also not stay around, coming and going with the main point of being there to bring Teddy in and possibly create a short term rivalry between him and Milicas.

Akeno will however be unable to see any sadism in the bedroom, but Harry will compromise and attempt to play the submissive for her, with some very hard and certain rules. She will instead take out her inner sadist on Issei while training him, and anyone else that she needs to train in the future.

If Akeno leaves, I will get to play with Kalawarner, who otherwise would not be in the pairing, Harry has moved on, cannot be tempted back, and she instead will be the main driving force in getting Issei up to snuff. If she and Harry become involved once more, she will become Harry's Follower - think of her like an angel but for Harry instead of for god. This means new powers, new wings, and a whole bunch of other stuff I won't go into detail on. But I don't honestly see both Akeno staying in the relationship and Kalawarner coming into it. It just doesn't strike me as believable to have both.

Yasaka will remain in the sidelines for a bit, but will be seen as having more time with Harry after Rias's teleportation array is in place. I think she could join regardless of what happens with Akeno, but is more likely to join faster if Akeno and Harry break up.

Yubelluna is also most likely a lock, simply thanks to the way I intend to bring her in, and the way I intend to tie her to Harry. Think of her as sort of like Venelana, with a intensely flirty side to her when alone with Harry, and the next best thing to hero worship towards him and Rias. Can't tell you more for fear of spoilers.

Magic of the Force question and request:

I want to have one more politics talk scene, then from there push the politics into the back, constantly occurring but not the main thrust of the story, letting me have more character interaction time until right before the Clone Wars occurs. The question is, do I need to explain again what the armed neutrality party's goal is? Or have I done so enough and anymore would be disturbing?

I am also looking for a specific planet to use as a that diplomatic mission - I think it's an agriculture world, but I can't remember what it's name was. Yoda was sent to it in the Clone Wars to convince it to keep sending food to the Clones when it had stopped, or something like that along with a few young padawans, all of whom had seen war, and sort of resented him I think? Can't remember much of the plot. The leader of the planet was an extremely old sentient who was a friend of Yoda, but he essentially committed suicide to become a martyr by pulling a blaster on him. I saw it once in a comic, but I don't own it.

Is Zule Xiss too OC to use as a main character? Yes she is a canon character, but she was never fleshed out so I want to make certain she isn't coming across as too Mary Sueish.

Fairy tail question:

How old do you think Hisui is and NO, she is not a love interest possibility! More like Ranma would tease her unmercifully and troll the magic guards of her and her father something fierce. I would ask Justlovereadin' this, but I think it was never stated and thus becomes an opinion question. Could be wrong though, LOL.

Anything Goes Game Changer: I feel that the time has past where Tsukiumi could join Ranma/Akitsu/possibly don't call me Nabs. Unless of course it's an accident… What does everyone else think.

This is a general question: I've mentioned before that I think I need to take more time to edit and read through my work. So do you all think I should keep the present format, and have at least one, sometimes as many as three like this past month, chapters not being very well edited? Or one less chapter - the second small story - and have the chapters be better edited? Not, you'll note, as good as the ones Michael sees, but still better than they were this past month

Comments

Exar Kunn

About the political scene in magic,no you don't have to explain again what the pact is

Argenten

For Akeno and Harry, they click...but honestly they are just very different people with very different priorities and foci in life, so having them having tried and seeing that it doesn't work feels the most natural.

Tom smith

I reckon they should break up. I can see harry not being into snm from his time in the war and I can’t see Akeno being mature mentally enough to understand that he just can’t see a sexual side to pain. I’m up got kala joining and seeing her asa follower to him. Will he grow from being demigodly to more godly where that would affect more large scale? I can see isiee being more accepting of Akeno for his harem being more perverted and accepting of the devil hedonism side where harry is more loving large family guy. I’m up for what ever you desire for Tonks.

Chris

As much as I would like to see the growth of Akeno, I think it would be more interesting story wise to see Kalawarner try to fit in. I also like the thought of Tonks sticking around more. Maybe she wants the stability for her son and likes what harry has going on. For Magic, no further explanation needed I don't think. For Anything Goes Game Changer, I actually like Nabiki there the most just to see what kind of growth she will show. For Tsukiumi, don't mind that but honestly I would of thought the situation with Ranma\Akitsu and Nabiki would of been resolved first to make it stable. Still seems to be very much in flux.

Titan7

Why would you even pose such a question. While not perfect Akeno and Harry are great together please do not break them out!

Orchamus

When it comes down to it, I have to go with as much as Akeno has indeed grown from Harry's interaction with her and Rias, their personalities and interests are just too different for them to mesh any further than that of friends, while I can definitely see Kalawarner and Yasaka, with a bit more expansion on their interactions, fitting in well. As for Hisui...hehe, yeah, poking at her royal pride could be amusing, she should be around Wendy's age, right? And honestly, Ranma works best with Akitsu and Nabs, I can see too many personality clashes with Nabiki if you include Tsukiumi.

AR

Regarding Akeno and Harry, I think the story so far has really made a point of showing how different Akeno and Harry are, and not in an "opposites attract" kind of way. From Akeno's sadomasochism, to her desire for a "whirlwind" romance, to her lack of desire to associate with children... . She's physically attracted to him and his power, but I don't recall any indication she's attracted to his life. She comes across as wanting a fling, not a relationship. I just don't see Akeno as she is now in a positive, healthy relationship with Harry as he is now. And honestly the way you're written her and her interactions with Harry so far, I don't think you do either. :)

Alex McGregor

I'll be honest I consider Akeno a much better fit to things then Kalawarner

Halcyon

After the last chapter, I believe Harry and Akeno should break up. You've done a wonderful job of building chemistry between Harry and Rias, as so far the other possible romantic options seem a bit forced. It reminds me a lot of your previous story Wild Wolf, where it originally seemed like there would be multiple romantic partners for Ranma but as the story developed Dany took the center stage.

Dominyx Black

Akena gave it a try and I think she'll be a stronger friend to both Rias and Harry going forward, but pairing her with Tonks makes a LOT more sense and would fit her character better.

Marvin Morgan

Taken from the perspective of which course best serves the future health, well being, and development of the individual involves. With that in mind it seems remaining friend but not lover would serve both Akeno and Harry best. A healthy relationship requires a certain equality between the participants, not to be confused with similarity, which would take a immense effort at this time.

22

Fairy Tail: I'd say Hisui is about the same age as Sting.

Netveiwer

I am all in for Akeno to stay with Harry, but i think two scenes need to be added before she can commit fully to the relationship. First she has to see that her issues are splittinf them apart and she makes a desprite grab to salvage it by placing her alone with his daughter where she admits she jealous to her or something and pushs past it to truely bond. Second Harry has to find the root of why she feels like she has to have/give pain and either migrate it another way or have her acknowledge she can move past it completely to only her enemies deserve her sadistic streaks. I honestly cant see this Harry playing sub too long and not causing friction.

Zarra

I actually really like the akeno/tonk idea the relashionship with Harry feels forced and mostly physical.

Jacko Garcia

Yup, it feel forced and her actitud toward family and children should make Harry less interested than the S&M stuff she likes. Kalawarne also has her problems with Harry, but I would like to see that pairing because she is TRYING to change. About Yasaka... it sounds funny, she is the one that has more knowledge and experience than Harry and also has a daughter so with her she is the one that would take the reins in a relationship instead of the other way around like with the other pairings XD

Jacko Garcia

And yeah, Nabs is my favorite female character in that fiction, so if a fem. character cant be in the same rome with her, she is out, haha. (Hint: I love Uzume). And I think Hisui should be 7 years younger than Natsu and Gray before Island events.

Adam Ouellette

Have Akeno and Harry break up and I like the idea of Tonks and Akeno if it means more Tonks in the story, she is so under-used. No Zule is not too OC or Mary Sue. Go ahead and main character her. As for Tsukiumi, go accidents!!! Lol! As for the editing I would rather have the extra chapter personally.

Jaroslaw Jarmul

I don't really see Akeno and Harry as a pairing right now. At this point they are to different when it comes to interests and while some say that opposites attract, most of the time it ends up in a explosion if they are to different (matter and anti-matter). There would have to be to many compromises between them both and that would affect any harem dynamics. As for the Magic of the Force question I think that the armed neutrality party got fleshed out enough for now. There might be some place for reactions of the other players to it forming but I don't think you would have been able to add any more pertinent details by explaining their stance again.

Blitz

Kinda hard to have the mindset of keeping them together when the author has already set the mood of it not working (rly dont think the aspect of him being a Filf/Dilf is gonna take center stage) as for the ft question someone said sting and I'd agree just remember 7 years younger because of time skip.

Treant Balewood

I think the last chapter did a fair job of illustrating Akeno in that she is Not ready to settle down into such a serious relationship. Maybe if they had met 15-20 years down the line she would be ready for it and they'd of clicked but, as it is now no. Really Rias is the odd one here for being so ready and emotionally mature. Fairy Tail: I've always pegged her as alittle younger than the main cast at 16 or so(start of series) that said I'm not fully read into the series currently AGGC: I wouldn't it had passed the point and become unsalvageable yet. but if your asking do I care if we drop her I'd say go ahead I'm not invested in her at this point

Narsil

I'll add my vote to break up Harry and Akeno, their dreams and tastes are simply too different for them to be compatible and trying to force the issue feels like Author's Fiat. I personally think Kalawarner would work better -- and besides, inflicting Issei on her might be too heavy a punishment for even her centuries of sin.

Friendly Neighborhood Eldritch Horror

Akeno with Tonks sounds good to me. I could even see Tonks perhaps be willing to become somewhat into S&M for a partner into that if she gained a source of regeneration, perhaps by becoming one of Rias' peerage, largely due to being a relatively adventurous sort, but unlikely to want to risk lasting injuries without any regen due to them being likely to screw up her ability to use her metamorphmagus abilities as fully, due to likely retaining the injuries between forms. For Magic, I don't think you need too much more politics once the war actually starts, although it should still turn up occasionally when appropriate, especially for plots involving the Senate, the Counts, Padme, or Satine. I'd like better edited stuff over more stuff, as the quality has been bad enough that it can be hard to read at times in some of the fics.

Matthew Hunter

I can not see Harry as you have written him being able to ignore/go along with Akeno's sadism. He would also have a huge problem with the fact that she enjoys not just physical but mental and emotional pain, even of those "close" to her. That would cause him to have a hard stop in regards to trusting her around Lilly long term as a authority/mother figure. However I could totally see her and Tonks.

Zoma

During your earlier chapters I didn't mind Akeno in the pairing, but in your more recent ones, especially the latest, it was blatantly obvious that she just doesn't mesh with Harry. She'd need a lot of character development to change her into someone who would be part of a long term relationship with Harry.

Cereburn

I don't see the chemistry working for Harry and Akeno in any consistent basis - occasional playmate, maybe; but not close life mate material there. If you do keep them together, I get the feeling there will be strong feelings of obligation to try to make it work for Rias' sake vs the desire to actually be in a relationship. I can imagine Issei with Akeno - build up his feelings of guilt for his perversions and let Akeno work on "exorcising" those feelings with pain and pleasure. As for Kalawarner, I want to see her get the love she wants, but I'm not sure if Harry is the best fit with Rias also there. Luckily, while I enjoy it very much, I don't have to make it work, just partake of the fruits of your labors :P

Michael Duggan

I think they need to break up. Hopefully she realizes this before it happens. Otherwise the drama will get pretty...dramatic.

Slider

While I haven't fully finished this new chapter I've gotten far enough into it that I still feel comfortable stating that Akeno is not a decent match in this story for Harry. She has major, major issues with sharing him with LILY. Harry's daughter is always, always going to come first for him over everything and everyone else and I think it was clearly shown last chapter that he doesn't even give a damn about breaking the secrecy of their entire world wide open if it means he has the slightest chance of preventing harm to his child. Akeno...just doesn't get that. She pays lip service to working on it and I'm sure she genuinely means to try yet she shows zero growth with that front at all. They need to split up now before either gets seriously hurt when she finally, truly understands that Harry isn't going to put her above Lily ever. Kalla as a Follower sounds pretty cool! I'm hesitant about the Akeno/Tonks thing but that's partially because I kinda think it would be cool to have Tonks pairing off with Sona for a bit. It could also help to give Sona her own way of getting info about magic without hurting her pride. (I have this hilarious vision of Tonks sleeping with Leviathan as well in an unrelated note...) Yay for Yasaka! I really, really disproportionately like her based on the relatively smaller screentime she's had so far lol. I'd love to see her officially join up! As for the Hisui question: When I saw that portion of the show she always struck me as early 20s. Someone just barely older than most of the main cast.

Aaron Hardin

With the way Akeno is, I don’t see a relationship as sustainable. The character growth she can undergo after dealing with Barakiel May allow it to work, but frankly I find Kalawarner more intriguing than Akeno.

DarkPirateKing

Like many people above already mentioned, you've set it up to fail in the last chapter. I can't see it happening afterwards either, regardless of Akeno's character development in the future. things would have progressed to the point where she would either feel like a third wheel or just a n excuse to make the Harem bigger (assuming YAsaka joins, since two doesn't make a Harem after all). Just try to deal with this without TOO much teenage angst on her part. This is bit slow going fic for me in the first place. Mutual agreement on their part would be best.

DarkPirateKing

My knowledge of the SW Universe is fairly limited, so can't help you there.

DarkPirateKing

Never liked Tsukiumi's character, unless something fairly drastic is done about her. Tukiumi's super Tsundere/Androphobic/ignorant persoanlity makes her action/responses too predictable imo. But changing changing too much would just make her an OC pretty much.

DarkPirateKing

Hisui shoiuld be a 'little sister' type of character to Ranma. Older than Wendy though. Maybe maybe some sisterly riverly between the two when it comes to Ranma's attention?

DarkPirateKing

I honestly didn't see too much difference in these chapters, compared to the 'better edited' ones. At least, there wasn't anything obvious that jumps out to me. So, whatever works the best for you i guess? And damn, need to get used to the whole 'pressing enter' business on this site apparently. Just realized.

Vysirez

I have to admit that I'm not super familiar with DxD characters, so I'm mostly working with what you have in this story for Akeno. From what I have seen in the story, it makes more sense to me if Akeno and Harry break up. Beyond physical and power attraction, I don't actually see Akeno having much in common with Harry. There might be aspects to Akeno's personality that show up later in DxD that I'm not seeing, but as she has been presented so far I don't see a long term relationship working between Harry and Akeno. I also have to say that I'm a big fan of Tonks, so Akeno and Tonks seems like it would be fun to read and it would keep Tonks around. Then I also think the hints you just listed for Kalawarner sound very interesting. So all in all, I see far more positives for the story if Harry and Akeno split up.

Doraemax

You've said it. Akeno is not ready. But i think you are stressing over nothing. you forget all the players in question have long long long lifetime. Akeno is not ready now. Doesn't mean she will not be ready in the future. Harry's having a harem is not conditional on him having the harem now, all at the same time. He can start with Rias (there will be challenge there too, in terms of her family and politics). Each of the consequent pairing after that will have to come at them as a unit.

Meckruco

all your reason for Akeno not joining are valid. biggest deal breaker is her kink for pain. for game changer Ranma/Akitsu/possibly don't call me Nabs i fully support but no more. just cant see that many women willing to share and not be unhappy or at each others throats.

Thomas Edwards

FIFLY : - Personally I was all for Akeno staying until the latest chapter, the points made their about what they both want make too much sense to keep them together and it seems like the only real reason they are still making a try of it now is because of Rias. I can see them still trying until Tonks arrives at which point Akeno becomes a lot more interested in her given their personalities. As for your other points I like the idea of Kala becoming a follower and working her way back into the relationship and the interactions between Harry and Yasaka so far have definitely paved the way better and make more sense than Akeno. I also think that the Sadist part of Akeno is too ingrained in her and if she tries to change for Harry she would end up resenting him. There is nothing to stop her having her fun now and in a few decades deciding she wants to revisit things with Harry when she has matured etc. Magic of the Force: Maybe a very brief overview at one point from other perspectives either during the political talks or right before the start of the Clone wars but not other than that. To me I've enjoyed what you've made of Zule and she hasn't come across too Mary Sueish, would definitely enjoy reading her as a main character as well. Anything Goes : I can't really see Tsukiumi joining in at this point as anything other than a friend, I feel it would be a bit forced to have her join the others. General : Whatever works best for you really, in most cases the mistakes tend to all be minor and don't have an impact on my reading but if you would rather spend more time editing then do what you'd rather.

MinotaurKing

FILFY: break up I just cant see it working between them, also I want to see her sadism inflicted on Issei xD

MinotaurKing

Fairy Tail: Hisui is between 7-9 years old currently given she is only in her teens post the 7 year timeskip in canon. Game Changer: I concur far too late to bring in Tsukiumi at this point it would really disrupt the flow I feel. Magic of the Force: Touch on it briefly but otherwise pretty clear, I don't recall the planet in question either sorry, also she is fine.

UrpsychoEX

I have to say before moving forward that your timing for posting your stories almost killed me this month. I was so excited to see more of your work, but was completely side tracked when LiamG updated Naberius Heir. I had to completely reread his story, then go back to FILFY to reread the last chapter, on top of finally going back to re-read all of Stallion and most of Making Waves. Oh god you guys are killing my poor brain making me follow so many different plots and characters! But man I can't stop myself. MOVING ON! To FILFY: I'd have to say, while you might have overplayed Akeno's dislike of children a bit, that I have to voice my agreement that she and Harry can't continue as they are. I enjoy Akeno and I can see a pairing of her, Rias, and a man working if you have the right character. I can say however that this Harry won't work like that. The way he is written and the interactions they have just push them in different directions. Keeping Rias is a must at this point, I can take or leave Kala, am interested in where Yasaka is going, and am excited to see what you do with Yubelluna. Yubelluna is a very flat and unused character, like most of Riser's peerage, and I can't wait to see where you take her. The idea of Tonks and Akeno is interesting and I would honestly prefer it to pairing her with Issei. I don't want to let my dislike of him show, but the one pairing I did see in DxD that I liked was Issei and Asia. They were sweet and almost normal, baring the familiar forest bit. Issei just seemed more like a young man with sex on the brain but controlling himself with her rather than the sexual predator that he appears in the show/manga. Also I love the idea of Teddy and Milicas being rivals. Magic of the Force: I think you've done well enough in explaining the armed neutrality bit. I don't believe there would be anything wrong with a TLDR summary if you felt it was what the next chapter needed though. I looked for the planet and mission you spoke of but found nothing, sorry Vim. I like Zule period and point blank. I honestly am kinda hoping she moves closer to Harry and Ayala. Cannon characters that are not fleshed out are your bread and butter my friend. You do awesome things with them and I have no reason to complain so far. Do what you feel is best for her character. Honestly the relationships in Magic of the Force are what intrigues me the most right now. I want to see how Ayala and Harry's love evolves. I personally want to see what happens between them and Padme, Zule, and Shaak Ti. I don't currently believe you'll extend the relationship to all three ladies but I want to see where you go with it. As an aside, I will totally miss Alecto. Great interactions with Ayala and Harry and funny at times as well. Fairy Tail: I wouldn't expect Hisui to be a love interest. If this was a Naruto story, maybe, but not a Ranma story. I would say somewhere between 16-18 during the Grand Magic Games... so what like 9-11 years old at the start of the series? At her oldest I would say 24 and that would put her around 17 during the beginning of the series. Anything Goes Game Changer: I would honestly say I don't care either way about Tsukiumi joining them. I like the idea of Ranma/Akitsu/Nabiki. I can't really think of any other Sekirei that would fit them honestly. The problem is both series have the same plot, sort of. A guy with a lot of girls after him. Sekirei gets around the Ranma 1/2 problems by making them all okay with sharing, with only a few minor problems. Ranma however is a lot of girls trying to get with him, more or less, while fighting among themselves, fighting him, and at times trying to deny they want Ranma. You've already dodged the biggest problem in most Ranma stories by pairing him with Nabiki (Kasumi works too) and I feel Akitsu is an awesome straight man for the two of them. She won't even mean to do it most of the time. Including Tsukiumi would give you another character to play with and one that would also be able to play off the other three, but I would honestly call it at her. Adding a fourth, and second alien, would probably be where Nabiki calls it quits on her weird quota. General Question: I will ask you to slow down and do the better editing. I love reading your stories and having so much to read, when you post of little otherwise, would suck but some of the problems in the latest FILFY actually made me stop reading for a minute as I tried to puzzle out what you meant or was left out. I'll easily bow to your opinion Vim, they are your stories, but I would prefer a bit better editing.

MacArther

Tsukiumi with Ranma, because the martial artist is likely the only person to get through to the Dere side of her character with any consistency (the initial respect is also good). Also, the potential for here water based attacks along with Ranma's attacks seems a good blend. I'm putting Hisui around 23-25. She does seem older than Lucy for instance, and the few extra years would allow her to have conversations with Jude without being completely out of her element. That said, the manga (or anime, can't remember) basically says Hisui is extremely smart for her age (without giving the age T__T).

Aron Vanida

On the subject of FILFY I definitely have to vote for Akeno and Harry to break up. Their interactions and dialogues thus far have felt very stilted with Harry being a serious and intimate character whose flirtations are both heartfelt and caring whereas Akeno is kinda...immature?....shallow?....she doesn't feel as mature or committed in her conversations with Harry. I think if Akeno and them break it off it will allow Akeno to grow more as a character and force her to confront a lot of her issues if she doesn't have the opportunity to push them away by flirting with Harry. Additionally, by redeeming Issei and pairing him with Akeno you give allow Akeno to flourish as a dominant and allow Issei to keep and focus his perversions onto one person rather than have him lose them or be perverted outside of the relationship. On the subject of Kalawarner I love the idea of having her become some sort of valkyrie as the source of Harry's "godliness" derives from a god of death. If, in light of the whole Follower thing, Kalawarner enters into the relationship I feel she should be somewhat subordinate to both Rias and Harry as Kalawarner is in need of both redemption and a purpose and not necessarily a relationship. A relationship is what caused Kalawarner to fall in the first place and having a relationship be her redemption....is actually kinda poetic, but it shouldn't be the whole focus of her existence as right now she lacks a direction and purpose for her life.

Razgriz0x

Filfy: Akeno and Harry break up... voted for it. While I would love to see them work out, I believe that Rias and Akeno will both understand that it wouldn't work out as they'd hoped. Seeing Akeno eventually turn Issei into something other than a waste of space through sadism (which given his perverseness, he may enjoy) is an admirable idea... I'd only like to see snippets of this with most (not all) the growth happening off screen. As for Akeno and Tonks...… same problem with Harry. Tonks is a single parent who's first priority is their child.... only Tonks isn't as good at being a parent as Harry. Thus I believe that Tonks should find Harry to be the stabilizing influence in her life that she needs in order to truly be the parent Teddy wants and needs, as well as being the fun, lovable Metamorph we all know and love. (Sorry, kind of a Honks fan). I do not truly see Tonks enjoying sadism anymore than Harry would, and Harry is totally an Alpha through and through. Even an attempt to submit would go against his very nature. Kalawarner becoming Harry's follower/lover makes sense... I say go for it... this may allow Kala and Akeno to somewhat reconcile due to Kala no longer being a Fallen. Love that you've locked Yubelluna (she never gets enough love) and almost locked Yasaka as part of the group. Speaking of the group... since Harry seems to have such an aversion to the word/term Harem... maybe the women in his life could agree to form a/call themselves a Coven??? MotF: No need to explain the Armed Neutrality Party... the name says it all. No idea of planet's name. As for Zule...meh. Have her struggle enough and need help with techniques and some decision making but willing to adapt, adjust and overcome her weakness's will help ground her... and keep as a background character for the most part. This way she's not Mary Sue, nor is she comic relief always in need of rescue. Competent but still mortal and not omni in anyway. Fairy Tail: As of where you are in the canon story.... I'm gonna say put her at the same age (1-3 years older max) as Wendy. AGGC: No accidental winging. Tsukiumi would fight against it the whole way. I'd focus more on Nabiki and Akitsu and have that build to solid (sexual) point before having Tsukiumi request to join them and have Ranma as her Ashikabi. GQ: I'm still able to read the story even with the small mistakes... and I'm sure you've not had anyone point out big mistakes for some time because of your editors/proof-readers/Beta-readers. So please keep up the more stories... your works are amazing and worth reading.

Tomon

Akeno and Harry: Well, you know I was a staunch Akeno supporter and while I feel for, and like Kala, I preferred Akeno over her. But the recent chapter developments are starting to make me doubt the worth of Akeno and Harry relationship. To be honest, currently it's just not working and something needs to be done. I think you made a mistakes in the setup. You given Harry werewolves instinct and even added the god part with especially mentioned lust ("randy as god") being part of the legacy. But Harry is too much in control and with good enough reason to do so - his daughter. So his motivation about wanting a harem are waning at best at the moment. You also made Akeno desire for S&M too strong. While she definitely wants that, I never saw it as a integral part of her being. So if you didn't play on it so strongly, she could wish for it, but give up on it regardless, when compared to everything else she would gain from being with Harry. Hell she could even be so dominated in the bedroom by Harry and his doubly boosted stamina, that her desires would switch to being submissive. And while I can hardly see Harry doing something truly painful, I don't think he would have issues with bondage if Akeno wishes for it. I mean when she would be the one being tied up. Heh, with enough patience on her part she could get it a little further given time and some mild biting or firm gripping, on the edge of being painful, is definitely in the realm of possibilities. After all having such a woman at his mercy, pretty much begging for it, should call to Harry werewolf side somewhat fierce, at least. And far down the road when Harry really trust her? Yes, I can see even him being able to play the submissive or be tied up for a change just to experiment or if no other reason than just to make her happy (as long as he won't find it too bad). Still, back to Harry. His instinct so far made him only notice them and desire all the hot girls he got orbiting him. But even when he could, he chosen not to enjoy the physical aspect, and preferred to build a relationship. That's admirable but creates another issue. If Harry along with his new godly legacy get to the sex itself, it could "awaken" him and really make him want to have more or even crave it. Especially if his partner couldn't keep up all the way. Like this he is in amazing, but not overly fast developing, relationship with Rias. I truly love them together, but given that I definitely see Rias as the MAIN partner, his "queen" so to speak, no matter the addition of others in the future, it will also set pace for any other possible girls and make Rias have the final say, if they're even going to be given a chance. And given that Harry’s other big limiter and reason for a lot of his holding back, his daughter Lily is not going away. In fact, the issue is sort of multiplying by adding Asia, Koneko and now also Kunou? Yes, while that works flawlessly for Yasaka and I can’t wait to see more of her. Especially their interaction with Harry, Rias and others when they got some privacy to just enjoy their time together? Yeah, the same things works against Akeno in her current mindset. So, what to do? One route is definitely to let them break up. But imagine the fallout. Especially for Rias and her peerage. Honestly it might be part of the issue as Harry sometimes seems to be with Akeno because his girlfriend asked him to do it, and why not given how hot Akeno is anyway? So they both need to do some soul searching, Akeno more than a Harry. But back to the break up possibility. They will see each other daily regardless, unless Akeno goes away and WHERE she could even go? At this point having an okay break up with no hard feeling is unlikely, because at least Akeno would feel like she lost not only to Rias, who she will see blissfully happy in a position she just let get away, but also to a several little girls. If Kala sort of replaced her? Ouch, I can feel the pain of her feeling all the way here. It would destroy her safe heavens, left her nowhere to go, which would in fact affect everyone else. Especially Rias would be in such dreadful position that I don’t know how she could handle. Her being happy would pain her best girlfriend and sister in all bad name, her queen and integral part of her peerage and family. But the other option of not being happy and dragging down both Harry and Lily? Heh, almost the same effect in the end. Still, I admit that fear of a fallout is not exactly a good reason why to stay together if it doesn’t work. So… second option. Soul searching and some deep thoughts and decision necessary. I see, probably Rias, talking sternly to Akeno and force her to evaluate, what she wants from life. There are others characters who could do it. Maybe even a Kala who might be resented at first by Akeno, but in the end it would create a firm friendship, if it ends up well. Akeno truly needs to decide if she is too young to settle down and want to experience some “fun”, and date random boys, before she decides on a man. OR if she truly loves Harry and don’t want too lose him more, than any potential chance she might encounter by trying to enjoy being a young woman. It’s a hard decision, but time is running out for her and if she stay undecided she may loose the opportunity to choose herself. I think Akeno needs to find out for herself what she truly desires for a future family. Does the chance to being sister-wife with Rias appeal to her? Does she prefer monogamous relationship, since she is struggling with jealousy? Is Harry someone she truly doesn’t want to loose? There is no reason for her to be a mother figure. She can be the funny aunt, which is a role that she fits already pretty well, given her penchant for teasing. But what she needs to do is to accept not only Lily fully. But the fact that Harry is a family man. There is no going around this fact, and it’s up to her to either embrace it, and I know she can! She already did it with Rias and her peerage, this is a next step! Or… give up on this idea altogether. Honestly such talk, if done with Rias. Well, more like a second talk with Rias, because a lot of this stuff need to be done by Akeno alone, could be a step if not a final solution to their jealousy they both feel to some extent. Lay the card on the table, talk about their fears and desires. Take some time to organize their thoughts and then decide on what do to. Well, this was long, but I tried to cover a lot. So my FINAL vote is for Akeno to stay in the relationship. But only if she can truly let herself go and accept it for what it is. On the side note since they were both mentioned: Let Yamaka join soon as well! No need to make the poor horny foxxie wait :-D Regarding Yubelluna. I liked what I saw from her first interaction with Harry and they hit it of well. She definitely wants out which said something given the link to the king the peerage got. So I’m truly intrigued about what you have in mind 😊 Fairy tail question: 1) Hisui age, not an easy question and as far as I know it was never stated. Just who she knews creating some issue about just guessing it. But personally I think she is just a little older than Lucy, even if some says she is younger. My guess is two years older than Lucy at max (no time travel). Still I’m not sure it’s even that important 😊 2) Hmm, I think that Tsukiumi could in fact join them, IF she somehow found out how nice the Ashikabi bound can be. Heh, maybe accident like kissing and Ranma because he saved her or was just truly nice to her? Could be interesting. Especially as we still don’t know if Ranma in fact IS a Ashikabi. On the other hand it could create an unbalance and make it hard for Akitsu who wishes for nothing more. Guess they should really start to hard working on “curing” her 😉 But really as much as Tsundere she appears to be it could be fun to see Ranma stamping on it hard and her nicer/sweet side coming slowly but surely out more and more. Also from all the Sekirei, Tsukiumi seems like she on of the best chemistry with Ranma. 3) As much as it pains me to say so. Don’t burn yourself out. You are producing so much content and I really don’t want you to feel like you have to because of patreon fans who are sponsoring you. So if that means fewer story or taking a “lighter” month when you catch up on things and give us either just one story or not even that? I will be fine with it. So to answer your question? Do what is better FOR YOU 😊

Darth Bayes

I think Harry is too affection-starved and has too-strong trust and abuse issues to really get into any kind of BDSM. I don't think he is the right kind of person for Akeno, who, from personal inclination and her own at-this-point-mostly-resolved trust and authority issues, has developed strong preferences in that direction, probably quite integral to her character. However, I think Harry has the opportunity for personal growth in the direction of becoming more relaxed and confident in receiving affection, and this could be a step towards him becoming more comfortable with one-night stands or friends-with-benefits relationships with people he likes and trusts, and realizing that he doesn't want to be uptight and almost dursley-ish in condemning things consenting adults do to each other--and so, while not getting into it, becoming more accepting of BDSM. I also think that Tonks is not the kind of person who would make a great single parent, especially as young as she is. I think she'd make a great older sister or cool aunt, but she would eventually end up feeling stifled by responsibility beyond what someone her age and maturity should need to face. I don't think it's a bad thing, but I think she's going to be unhappy without Harry to share some of the load of raising Teddy, and is going to come to visit him, and he's going to wind up raising him nearly half of the time. I think she could be a good pair with Akeno as long-term friends with benefits and experimentation and additional partners, perhaps eventually including Harry if everyone else is okay with it. I don't think she would want to be a sub, but switch could fit, and co-dom in threesomes could make sense in my interpretation of her character. I think Akeno/Issei could work, but the dynamics that would appear in that relationship would involve BDSM and training and control and possibly mind magic to such an extent that you probably wouldn't want to write about it, and couldn't in an even-slightly-SFW way. I think keeping that part of Issei's character comedic, just in better taste and with more skill, is the way to go, and I think that means not Akeno. (Basically, I think writing about BDSM relationships in detail is problematic, and Akeno/Issei would result in BDSM becoming plot- and character-growth- relevant and thus necessary to write about in detail) I'm not a huge fan of Kala, but I think that she could fit well with harry, and that the situation with her is an interesting and valuable way to get Harry to think more about what it means to be a god, and relationships with strong power dynamics. I'm interested to see how her character changes. I think Tsukiumi's personality is surprisingly similar to Ranma's, and they will get along well, but not be happy with a relationship either feels to be forced, which both would likely feel reacting or winging is, at some level. I think a mutual mentorship role could work well for them, but eventually Tsukiumi would find herself liking Ranma but not wanting to interfere with his personal relationships--and eventually another friend of hers would push her into talking to Ranma about it, or go behind her back and talk to him, and they might eventually wind up together, and undergoing character growth about their neuroses towards relationships. I personally wind up going tons of rough planning and gratuitous amounts of worldbuilding whenever I write, so I have trouble imagining how you can function putting stuff out this fast. I'd say that what is most important is what you enjoy--and if your unhappiness with the quality of your work is not something you can talk yourself out of by pointing out your absurd speed, then try taking more time to plan and see whether you enjoy that enough to make it better in the long run. (I hate how patreon keeps turning 'enter' into 'submit' instead of 'newline'. I've had to edit this post like eight times.) (If you're looking for ideas on representing BDSM, the comic Sunstone might be a worthwhile read.)

R Brown

FiLFy: I'm not sure that Harry being sexual submissive for Akeno would fit his character. I could see him letting his partner lead, but not being submissive, even only sometimes and with limits. Especially, with the times that Akeno has tried to push her sadism. I think Kalawarner provides more opportunity for originality, and I'm interested to see where you take her character. While Tonks/Akeno would be an interesting experiment, I see a few of the same issues and Harry/Akeno cropping up. Mainly, her being a single mother and the related complications. I completely agree that both Kalawarner and Akeno both in the same relationship is a step too far. I have a hard time picturing Akeno in any sort relationship that involves another fallen. I'm also very interested in what you will do with Yubelluna and, to a lesser extent, Yasaka. Magic: I think that you explained the armed neutrality well enough. Don't know enough Star Wars EU to help with the rest. Fairy: Around the same age as Lucy after the time skip? Younger than Mirajane or Erza. Maybe the same age as Wendy currently. Don't really know. Anything Goes: I agree. I thought you had a good line when they parted one time and Tsukiumi's inner voice hinted at an opportunity lost. General: Whatever you think is best. You don't tend to have any of the truly jarring errors that degrade the reading experience for me. While I do appreciate the corrections being made, that is in part because you stories are so good that I often reread them.

JDZ

On the topic of akeno / kalawarner I’m ambivalent to both. Neither have shown that they would make sense as more than a friend. Akeno is probably not ready for a relationship with Harry and I would think that kala would need someone to actually be her one and only considering the backstory you’ve woven. She was jilted by a man with another. I can’t see a situation that lead to her fall being a relationship style she could cope with. Imo. Ok so with regards to magic of the force I agree with the others that you have explained armed neutrality enough. As for Zule I don’t really see her being a Mary Sue, and honestly she is no more or less an oc than Harry or Aayla. That isn’t a criticism just a statement. I believe you have created some very interesting and engaging characters. Carving one or two out as out of character would be silly to my mind. All your characters have been behaving internally consistently. As for anything goes, I almost think Tsukumi has a better fit with this Ranma than Nabs, but more than anything given Ranma’s terrible experience with multiple women I think you would need to do a really good job explaining why he would be open to that style of relationship.

R Brown

Don't forget, this Ranma just arrived at Nerima. He hasn't yet lived through the fiancee madness that we know as canon.

Joshua Longstreet

Harry/Akeno Had this been a few chapters ago, I’d have said that Harry and Akeno were almost perfect for each other. Akeno is a sadist, but in a way, she only recognizes the positive aspects of pain. Dealing pain to your enemies, and using pain to elicit a pleasurable response to her masochistic clients (and to herself). Harry, on the other hand, recognizes the negative aspects more than most, and has more of a realistic viewpoint of it. In other words, Akeno’s view is more immature. Had Akeno accompanied Harry on a hunt, and seen him use the Cruciatus or deal a fatal blow on someone, I’m pretty sure she’d see Harry’s viewpoint. However, we let it get too far for us to change things. I still consider Akeno to be a good thing, but I would like to see more Tonks and Teddy. As for Akeno and Lily, I think part of the problem may stem from Akeno’s childhood. She was a momma’s girl, through and through, and still loved her daddy. Then her momma died protecting her, and I think there still might be a bit of self hatred in her because of that. That emotional response reflects onto Lily, because she recognizes that Harry is the type of person who would sacrifice himself for his daughter. Thus, while Akeno doesn’t hate Lily, there is a part of her that wants to distance herself from the child because of that irrational belief. Given that it’s either Akeno/Harry, or Harry/Kala with Tonks and Teddy staying, I’d have to lean towards the second choice. Again, while I do like Akeno/Harry, and do think it might have worked, I would like to see more of our favorite metamorphs. And given where we are at in the story, and Tonks’ behavior, I do think that they’d be good for each other. In fact, it seems like Tonks may have a bit of a masochistic side to her as well, since she seems to keep punishing herself unintentionally. Maybe they’d allow each other to grow up a bit. And yes, I do recognize that Akeno would have similar problems with Teddy. However, Tonks is more likely to go for a non-serious relationship, which would ease Akeno into it, rather than trying to jump straight into a serious relationship. Also, Teddy seems to be a bit more grown up, since he's had to take care of himself while Tonks deals with her self-destructive habits. On top of that, Tonks is female, which might help Akeno ignore her daddy issues. Yeah . . . long rant for this section. To summarize, at this point I think Akeno/Tonks and Harry/Rias/Kala/Yubellena/Yasaka (maybe) would be a better fit at this point in the plot. Akeno has daddy issues, but dealing with a mommy who might be a bit masochistic (she loved a werewolf with issues, and seems to have issues herself) might be a better fit). Also, love your potential plan for Kala. Magic of the Force Given that politics seems to be a driving dramatic force here, I’d say it bears looking into. That being said, consider a decent wade through it, rather than a dive. We don’t need to make this into a political fiction, just a politically driven one. Part of the bonus of fanfiction is that we can take side characters, and elevate and characterize them as needed. It’s one of my favorite aspects. I like Zule, and if you think about adding her into Harry and Aayla’s harem, I would fully support it. Also, a Mary Sue would have been a Jedi knight without having to deal with stodgy politics. You gave a pretty good accounting of her doubts and feelings. Nothing sueish about her. Anything Goes Game Changer Go for it, but maybe consider getting Nabiki just a bit closer. I think they’d all work well, but Nabiki needs to be a bit more emotionally connected, since Ranma and two alien wives (submissive and tsundere) is a bit more of a leap than Ranma and one alien wife (submissive). That being said, I do like that thought of Nabiki pulling Tsukiumi to the side and making her blush luminescent red with plans and sexy schemes.

Your2ndGreatestFan

Harry and Akeno separating feels more natural, Harry is absolutely someone who would never delight in the inflicting/recieving of pain/humiliation after how he spent school years, to say nothing of his childhood with the Dursleys. Akeno is also too wedded to her belief that she deserves the pain, it is true that your Akeno is healthier, but she still thinks like that, at least in her current state, and Harry would not feel e tirely comfortable with that, it would pull at his “Saving People Thing” and cause him to approach deeper levels of a relationship with Akeno even more slowly, them drifting apart seems more natural at this stage, possibly if akeno had another few years to center herself, but now as she is now.

Micheal I Coyle

I'm not good with thoughts but I like the akeno tonks bit especially if it keeps tonks around

Alex McGregor

Huh, well, guess that's it for me for this story /shrug

NoobdockSaint

I don't know if it was done intentionally or not but they just don't... click, especially when compared to his relationship with Rias. Part of that may be on purpose, or just a difference in character but either way I don't see them together long term. If it is ended, I would vastly prefer Tonks though. The replaced pervert MC is the entire I stopped watching the series. Tonks on the other hand is a fantastic character. She has an great established character but enough blank space left over from cannon to make her fit a variety of roles

vimesenthusiast

If you're only reading it for the pairing that's rather harsh. especially since you never explained why you thought Akeno fit better than Kalawarner, who is still not set i nstone I'll note.

vimesenthusiast

It wasn't intentional, it was simply my attempts to keep Akeno and this Harry potter, in character. I am honestly surprised how much Harry/Rias click, even before htey started really understanding where those feelings were leading. But I am enjoying it, and that relationship is really driving a large part of my fun in this work. It's going to be a wrench to set it aside, but hey there's Harry/Jean/Emma/Ororo/Hela to look forward to in ATP. I'm looking forward to TOnks too. She is a very edgy sort of character in many ways, and can also free up Harry's time in a few ways to spend more time with the girls and experimenting with magic/learning from Tiamat.

Alex McGregor

It's less I'm only reading for the pairing and more the fact that I find the idea of Rias being with someone Akeno is not unbelievable, that and I honestly dislike Kalawarner. I also think Harry did sweet F A to actually try and build a relationship with Akeno, he went on what 2 dates? one of which was interrupted. I also think you did a fairly massive disservice to Akeno in regards to her personality, yes, she's a Sadist and a Masochist, but they are not the be all for her like this version of her seems to run on, I mean baseline her thing with Issei isn't hurting him or him hurting her, the part she found titillating is pretending they were having an affair, which wasn't the case, but roleplay seemed to be a bigger thing then and S/M play, she tended to only bring out the S by and large vs enemies from what I remember